Quantcast
A Spotter's Guide to the Gaming Press - Destructoid
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist
New? Take a tour   |   Suggestions   |   Themes:   Aah   Ohh   Foe

games originals community video shop xbox360 ps3 wii u pc 3ds psvita iphone android

RSSSubscribe via RSS

A Spotter's Guide to the Gaming Press

Jim Sterling, Reviews Editor
5:40 PM on 05.26.2009
A Spotter's Guide to the Gaming Press photo


Chances are good that if you're reading this, you're a pretty hardcore gaming fan who often frequents gaming blogs, reads gaming magazines and watches gaming videos. Over the years, you will have become acquainted with the games media, sampling the many different takes on this crazy industry from a variety of equally crazy people. You may also have noticed that the games media can be easily categorized and pigeonholed, because everybody in the gaming press, including yours truly, conforms to a particular stereotype.

If you're confused as to what I mean, fear no longer. With this handy Spotter's Guide to the Gaming Press, you'll be able to accurately label every single writer, presenter, reviewer and columnist that the games media has to offer. From your bog-standard blogger to your artsy-fartsy thoroughbred game journalist, all will be discovered and covered by this, the Spotter's Guide to the Gaming Press. 

Read on and get spotting. 

Name: The Blogger
Appearance: Either incredibly thin or incredibly fat, wearing a "hilarious" game-themed T-shirt.
Quote: "Peter Molyneux says the PS3 is shit"

The Blogger is one of the most prolific and widespread members of the games media, due to the fact that the job requires no qualifications, skill, or more importantly, life. The nature of the Internet has made it so that anybody can run a Web site and be successful if they're persistent and obnoxious enough. Nobody knows this better than The Blogger, who has steadily made it his goal to ruin videogame journalism with every ill-conceived post he makes.

While real journalists strive for clarification and context, such things are a hindrance to The Blogger. Bloggers dislike research, not only because it's time-consuming, but because bothering to run a background check on a story might make the news less sensational and reactionary. It's all about the reaction for a Blogger, and he's not about to let a little something called "the truth" get in the way. 

Taking the majority of their cues from tabloid journalism, Bloggers love to focus on sound bites and quotes, removing them from their original source and turning them into something they're not. A Blogger is at his happiest when he's writing about some bullshit Aaron Greenberg said, and he draws an almost sexual pleasure from whipping fanboys up into a storm with his yellow journalism and overused, ridiculous sarcasm. A Blogger is accountable to nobody, and this is a power he wields without mercy or due care. 

A Blogger can most commonly be found hitting Ctrl+C over a number of press releases, discussing the latest murder case where a videogame was spuriously involved, and claiming to be better than the shitty writers of Destructoid/Kotaku/Joystiq (delete whichever site the Blogger currently works for).

Name: The Faux Journalist
Appearance: Similar to The Blogger, but usually more smug-looking.
Quote: "Pfft, Bloggers"

A Faux Journalist is an evolved form of The Blogger. While functionaly identical, the attitude of the Faux Journalist is something quite different, and easily distinguishable. The Faux Journalist has no qualifications and has access to the exact same sources and abilities as any other Blogger, with one key difference -- he's done a little bit of reading on Wikipedia, and he thinks that makes him better than everybody else. 

A Faux Journalist hates Bloggers with a passion, usually out of a desperate need to look superior. He will applaud his own ability to do "research," as if typing the name of a videogame into Google is some Herculean feat, and will criticize blogs for simply copy/pasting press releases, even though he has no inside track of his own and gets his news from the same places as other Bloggers. Faux Journalists believe that if they admit they're simply Bloggers, that somehow makes them a lesser human being. It's kind of like how repressed homosexuals act like violent homophobes. It's just easier than facing the truth about who and what they are. 

A Faux Journalist will take it too far, turning a simple and throwaway story into a crusade, just because it might prove them right and they can parade their intellectual victory in front of their three readers. Nobody else cares that they spent all afternoon learning minor details about a story that everybody had gotten bored about five hours prior. 

Name: The Games Journalist
Appearance: Smart, surrounded by people, incredibly quiet and introverted around people.
Quote: "This is why Games Journalism will never be taken seriously!"

Unlike Faux Journalists, who are just Bloggers with a haughty attitude, there are some who can lay claim to the title of being a proper Games Journalist. To these people, the term "Games Journalist" is not a silly and laughable title, but a real and important job description that must be taken seriously. Games Journalists are incredibly dry individuals who seem to have forgotten that videogames used to be about having fun. These are the people who constantly ask the question, "When will videogames have their Citizen Kane?" It is incredibly important to them that videogames be considered art, because that means they'll finally be able to tell their parents that they've spent the last five years writing about Super Mario Bros. for a living. 

Games Journalists tend to clique up at press events, sectioning themselves off from the proles so they can have long-winded and pretentious discussions about high art and feel morally and intellectually superior to everybody else. Their ability to get scoops, however, cannot be underestimated and they won't let you underestimate them. The Games Journalist has learned to adore things like Twitter, where he can make smug and teasing allusions to the exclusive and clandestine industry meeting he just had, and make himself look like some sort of God in front of his legions of adoring doe-eyed fans. 

A Games Journalist is in his element when he's writing huge assessments on the impact of videogames in modern society, comparing videogames to the obscure films he's watched, and getting some huge interview with Reggie Fils-Aime. Basically, a Games Journalist excels at everything except playing videogames. They forgot how to do that years ago.

Name: The Video Star
Appearance: Looks like a Frat Boy, but even dumber.
Quote: "FUCK ASS POO!"

As readers become lazier and lazier, videogame Web sites will increasingly begin to rely upon video content over the written word. A number of popular videos have popped up online in recent months, and with it comes the feeling among the Video Stars that they are better than everyone else, just because they're in front of a camera. Those games press who predominantly work with video labor under the impression that they have become huge TV stars, and will carry themselves with a sense of celebrity that they never really earned. 

The best example of a Video Star is someone who has a weekly or daily video podcast, and pretends that his poorly produced, often chaotic video content is better than some worthless blog. The funny thing is, the video is usually less informative and more obnoxious than any blog could even hope to be, but somehow the presence of a $400 camera makes this product more professional and valid.

A Video Star prefers the company of hot women, usually because it's the only way to get people to watch his shitty videos. 

Name: The Insider
Appearance: Impossible to tell. Usually anonymous and/or never leaves the house
Quote: "So I was just on the phone to Kaz Hirai ..."

The Insider is a curious member of the games press, usually because he isn't a member of any outlet, instead preferring a small and relatively obscure blog where his bullshit can fly under the radar without anybody considering it worth their time to refute or sue over. The Insider survives by making incredibly vague and nondescript references to shit he "knows" about the games industry, working hard to maintain the image of an all-knowledgeable, all-seeing industry seer. Very much like the Wizard of Oz, but instead of an Emerald City, he lives in a basement. 

A stopped clock tells the right time twice a day, and this is very much how The Insider operates. By generating vast quantities of unsubstantiated rumors and then focusing heavily on any that happen to come true, The Insider is able to mesmerize a small group of people and have them believe that he is a mystical soothsayer. In truth, most of the games industry has no idea who he is, and those that do tend to make a really strange, screwed-up face whenever they think about him. 

Name: The Retro
Appearance: Varies, but nearly always surrounded by Virtual Boys and NES Carts
Quote: "OMG THE DREAMCAST!"

Remember when games were simplified, short and looked like crap? The Retro doesn't, because he lives in a rose-tinted land of sunshine and gumdrops where poorly designed, graphically sickening garbage is king. The Retro is happy in his idyllic world of memories, and for that we cannot hold anything against him. Despite his happiness, however, he is disgusted at the thought of any and all FPS games, and insists that unless a game is so difficult it makes babies cry and kittens sick, it isn't worth his time. 

The Retro is putting Capcom's kids through college, throwing vast quantities of his money at the publisher's endless remakes and reimaginings, encouraging his readers to do the same. He will lose his mind about anything even vaguely 8-bit, and will write at great length about how how videogames were so much better when they had an hour's worth of content, made to appear longer thanks to how needlessly difficult and poorly designed they were. 

Yep, the games industry was so much better when we couldn't play the fucking things. 

Name: The One Wii Guy
Appearance: Nursing a sore elbow from too much Wii Sports
Quote: "PS3 and 360 games look so generic"

He thinks Wii Speak is "genius." Enough said. 

Name: The Girl Gamer
Appearance: Usually appears in very doctored photos, shot from a high angle
Quote: "Xbox Live is so sexist, actually. Brb, gonna play Halo with my Sexy_Diva69 Gamertag"

The Girl Gamer believes that she is a unique and fiercely independent woman, but her hot pink blog background and desperate need to plaster pictures of herself all over the Internet tend to say otherwise. Despite having absolutely zero talent in the field of writing, the Girl Gamer is guaranteed success in an industry full of 30-year-old overweight virgins who will give a female anything she wants if there's even the vaguest chance he might be able to smell her hair, once. 

The Girl Gamer may lack the ability to string together a coherent thought using the written form of communication, but she does have one important skill -- a complete lack of self-awareness. This allows her to flaunt and utilize her gender to get ahead, while simultaneously and constantly complaining about how nobody ever takes her seriously because she's a woman, and that she's more than just a set of tits. A set of tits that she has made us all well aware of before now. 

A Girl Gamer is at her best when she complains about there being no strong female roles in videogames, and about how male-centric the games industry is. She fails to note that if the industry wasn't so geared towards satisfying males, she'd never have gotten to the point where she's paid to write. 

Name: The Indie
Appearance: Wearing a scarf and cordoroy trousers, drinking wine and stroking chin
Quote: "Braid was so awesome"

The Indie hates every retail game ever produced, apart from Half-Life and Metal Gear Solid. Constantly talking about Braid and referencing Tim Schafer any chance he gets, The Indie won't pay attention to any game with a publisher, unless he's giving it a 2/10 review. Quite what The Indie wants or expects from videogames is anybody's guess, since his demands seem so unrealistic and/or abstract that it would literally be impossible for a videogame to cater to his needs without alienating 99.9% of the population. 

The Indie prefers games that are vague in their direction and need a 3,000-word essay in order to explain their meaning. If the gameplay consists of making a yellow circle rotate around a picture of the pig from Charlotte's Web while a MIDI version of "Cry Little Sister" plays, the Indie will likely declare it game of the year, and cast a sneer in the direction of anybody who just doesn't "get it," as if we're all supposed to understand a random collage of nonsensical items that only truly make sense inside the deranged head of the programmer. 

Name: The Fanboy
Appearance: Looks like every other 14-year-old
Quote: "Halo/Killzone is better than Killzone/Halo"

The Fanboy is incredibly similar to The Blogger, but whereas The Blogger will pledge allegiance to nobody and attack everything if it'll get a rise out of somebody, this particular writer has sworn undying loyalty to either the Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3. While Fanboys mostly appear in comments all over the Internet, a few of their species have evolved the ability to type ever so slightly coherently, and have been able to find gainful employment working for a gaming Web site. Empowered by their position of perceived authority, Fanboys become conduits of propaganda for their chosen God, spouting issuing forth their message across the land. 

Fanboys tend to cluster around console-specific Web sites, so they can dedicate their coverage of the industry to their favorite console. They usually try and hide their Fanboyism behind the mask of journalism, and are known often to say "I own every console" to make themselves look unbiased. However, it's very much like a racist saying "I have black friends" to justify the fact that he wishes Africans were all dead. 

The Fanboy is at his best when he's complaining about another Web site, usually criticizing their decision to rate a first-party game anything below a 9/10. They are also highly skilled spin doctors, able to provide comfort to their readers who may be worried about another console being more successful. They'll find some way to always claim that their preferred machine has the best games and is making the most money. The Fanboy is loved by games industry marketing executives, because they're basically doing their job for them.

And that's our Spotter's Guide to the Games Press! Hopefully you found it informative and useful. Next time you're on a media safari, hopefully you can recognize these beautiful creatures in their natural habitat. Take this pamphlet with you to E3 and see how many YOU can find!





Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


Wow man, this is an amazing article :-)

I laughed my ass off :-)

too bad I'm just a blogger :p ( and not even a frequent one either :p )
B-b-but what if we have Games Journalists who become Bloggers with growing credentials as Video Stars, but are constantly accused of being Fanboys?

It must be some kind of freakish abomination, never meant to exist on this earth, were publishers allowed to have their way.
Do I recognize the chin of the video guy? I think I recognize that chin.

Loved this article, and I appreciate that you can poke fun at yourself. I would posit that most Sterling haters won't quite get that.
Will they love him for it, or hate him for it?

It's anybody's guess!

Find out next week on As The Sterling Turns!
I'm sorry, but is it just me, or is the picture for the "Video Star" the man, the legend, THE Robert Summa?
But yeah, fantastic article Jim.
How long did you consider putting Anthony in "The Indie" header before dismissing the idea?
I really liked this (:
I know WAY too many people that fall under the Indie/Fanboy bracket..

It's a shame that I seem to fall under the "Blogger" bracket myself though...
Curse my desire to have a website and a podcast! >.<
I'm only 17, and trying to make "Gaming Journalist" (ironically, another one of those brackets) my career... *sadface*
Excellent article. I look forward to the follow up piece, A Spotter's Guide to Blog Commenters. You are working on something to that effect aren't you?
Yo, Gaming Journalist, I think you missed a spot - "Games jJurnalist"
Despite having absolutely zero talent in the field of writing, the Girl Gamer is guaranteed success in an industry full of 30-year-old overweight virgins who will give a female anything she wants if there's even the vaguest chance he might be able to smell her hair, once.

Haha I love it.

Also, like Dexter, I don't think the haters will recognize the satire.
LOL great article, Jim :)
BIAS!!!


great read Jim, this was hilariously spot-on
I love the surfergirl reference. Whatever happened to her anyway?
I wonder if Jim is going to get any shit for this one.








Wait, stupid question.


Nice work dude, I wish I could write like this.
Great guide though I think you missed one. Seldomly seen but there are some in the gaming press you feign an interest in gaming just because they want a paying job. The early writers of video games magazine were probably these. But I rarely see them around but I am sure there must be a few out there.
So where does Destructoid fit?
@Chronic
Read the first sub-section again. READ!
This was absolutely hilarious. Jim you are THE MAN!!!
Chad Warden didn't need any women in his videos. And look how well-known he managed to become on the interweb from one video. Besides that, it was an enjoyable read.

Also, how much longer before this article gets filled up with Jim haters?
Jonathan Holmes, "The One Wii Guy!" FTW!
Where are you in this list Jim?
I little bit too "estereotypical" to me, but a great read.
"the gameplay consists of making a yellow circle rotate around a picture of the pig from Charlotte's Web while MIDI version of "Cry Little Sister" plays"

Dead Movie Star, I believe this is your territory, is it not? Make it happen.
<3 <3 <3 ...also, Daedhead's idea would be hilarious.
But destructoid does do some interviews with game developers and publishers, and attend game press events I think like E3. Plus Destructoid does have a little of every stereotype here and there. So, does that put Destructoid in Faux Journalist/The Games Journalist/The Blogger?
"A set of tits that she has made us all well aware of before now."

This is so goddamn true.
The worst part is that, should I continue professionally with games, I see myself in one or two (or even three) of these categories. One of them is pretty damn douchy too ;__;
You forgot the most majestic of all, The Crecente.
El oooohhhh el, I found the girl gamer and insider particuarly funny.
Spot on Jim. Thank you for this even though I know you described many of your colleagues. Hopefully they can laugh at themselves.
Where is the "Sports Game Enthusiast"?
@Lemon
What sports game enthusiasts? Might as well have a section for "Unicorns
However, it's very much like a racist saying "I have black friends" to justify the fact that he wishes Africans were all dead.

I could only wish to use this analogy as perfect as you have.
Words cannot describe how happy I am from reading that.
I think you're forgetting the Troll. A subspecies of bloggers who only want attention. Typically fat and monocle wearing.
INB4 Kyousuke shits on a Jim article.
This was awesome.

Lol @ Surfer Girl and Summa
I plan on making a pamphlet and going Gaming Press watching when I'm at E3 this year. I will make a note on which breeds I see more than others.
Haha, everyone got called out, at least once
I guess I'm of the game journalist mentality (though I am not a game journalist). People don't watch Citizen Kane because it has some otherworldly value, they watch it because it is interesting, aka fun. Art is supposed to be fun. Its entertainment that is geared more towards people who have gotten bored with the regular explosions and princess rescues, and can't be excited by that anymore.
What one are you?
Well, at least Destructoid employs a full set! Loved the article, this cracked me up: "If the gameplay consists of making a yellow circle rotate around a picture of the pig from Charlotte's Web while a MIDI version of "Cry Little Sister" plays, the Indie will likely declare it game of the year..."
What???
I'm not in it???? Heresy!! :P
Is that last photo Husky?!!!
Hilarious hahaha..

NE1 wan play HALO3?!!!1
Add me on XBL!!111 WillHaveSex4Money69!!!
This guide is definitely missing the Otaku/Anime Game "Journalist". The guy that reviews all the JRPG's, knows the story like the back of his hand and know the correct pronunciation of Japanese game developers/designers etc. Oh, also he is studying on how to speak and read Japanese and will be sure to let you know in the comments, for example:
Normal gamer: "Does anyone have a translation of the newest Famitsu? I would like to know more about the latest Ninja Gaiden"
Otaku/Anime Game "Journalist": "Well Ive been taking a Japanese course at my local community college and I think it says: 'More boob physics'"
lol at the Cry Little Sister reference
Cry Little Sister is such an awesome song...

Anywho, great article as always, and a very true one at that. Kinda makes me want to change my college major from journalism to something that's...not journalism. I often forget how viciously elitist some of the other writers out there can get when they have that title of 'journalist' attached to their resume.
This is so true. Awesome article.
OMG THE DREAMCAST!




HAWP: Oh Ash, your diplomacy is so thick and hard

This is... well... umm... you know what? I'm not even going to explain it. The latest Hey Ash, Whatcha Playin'? is brilliance, plain and simple. Go watch it and have a good laugh or two. Hey Ash, Whatcha Playin'? - Civilization V [GameTrailers]   more

HAWP: Oh Ash, your diplomacy is so thick and hard photo

Goodbye, Destructoid

As some of you may or may not have heard, this is officially my last day with Destructoid. Man ... I can barely type that without getting upset. I am starting a new job next week at GolinHarris as a writer for Nintendo. It is...   more

Goodbye, Destructoid photo

Games journalism came: Polydong.com

You'll know that you've made it when Destructoid makes a dick joke about you. By now, you've surely heard of Polygon, the new gaming portal by the people that ruined Engadget. Congratulations to Chris, Brian, and the whole cr...   more

Games journalism came: Polydong.com photo

The DTOID Show: Assassin's Creed DLC, Star Wars, & Porno

On today's completely professional, mature, and otherwise not stupid or embarrassing Destructoid Show, we discuss some very serious topics. First, a season pass is announced for Assassin's Creed III, and the first DLC will b...   more

The DTOID Show: Assassin's Creed DLC, Star Wars, & Porno photo

YouPorn 'now on' Xbox, welcomes 'Xbox Masturbators'

Sometimes this job is boring, and sometimes YouPorn sends Destructoid a press release, excitedly telling us that its streaming sex video services is coming to Xbox Live. Of course, what it actually means is that, with Interne...   more

YouPorn 'now on' Xbox, welcomes 'Xbox Masturbators'  photo

Destructoid Community Meetup Photos!

Yeah we're a web site, but we are also a collective of fleshy sacks of meat and blood that play video games together and drink sometimes!  In an effort to centralize our random adventures and always have a place to show ...   more

Destructoid Community Meetup Photos! photo


Destructoid Community Meetup Photos! photo
Destructoid Community Meetup Photos! photo
Destructoid Community Meetup Photos! photo
Destructoid Community Meetup Photos! photo
Destructoid Community Meetup Photos! photo
Destructoid Community Meetup Photos! photo



Swordfight will get your joystick hard

I stand corrected. This is the weirdest story of the weekend! If you read Joseph Leray's "Nordic New Wave" feature from the other week, you ought to be familiar with Johann Sebastian Joust, a game using accelerometer-powered ...   more

Swordfight will get your joystick hard photo


Swordfight will get your joystick hard photo
Swordfight will get your joystick hard photo
Swordfight will get your joystick hard photo
Swordfight will get your joystick hard photo
Swordfight will get your joystick hard photo
Swordfight will get your joystick hard photo



Namco Bandai pulls penis-flavored SoulCalibur V ad

[Update: So apparently it is not real. Stupid sexy Voldo!] Namco Bandai recently pulled an advert for SoulCalibur V after fans complained that it was too offensive. No, it wasn't the magazine page featuring ginormous breasts....   more

Namco Bandai pulls penis-flavored SoulCalibur V ad photo

The DTOID Show: Our Top Gaming Moments Of 2011!

Merry Christmas, everybody! I'm gonna keep this short because idiot thought it was a good idea to put a small tree in my house and then leave a bunch of presents sitting under it, so I need to go get rid of that crap before a...   more

The DTOID Show: Our Top Gaming Moments Of 2011! photo

Review: Saints Row: The Third Dildo Baseball Bat

While we're all waiting for that hotly anticipated Saints Row: The Third review, it's easy to forget that Volition Inc. has something else coming to market -- the official Saints Row: The Third Dildo Baseball Bat.  Fortu...   more

Review: Saints Row: The Third Dildo Baseball Bat photo


Back to Top




Advertising on destructoid is available through Please contact them to learn more