Quantcast
The ten best videogame detectives EVER! - Destructoid
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist
New? Take a tour   |   Suggestions   |   Themes:   Aah   Ohh   Foe

games originals community video deals xbox 360 ps3 wii u pc 3ds psvita iphone android

RSSSubscribe via RSS

The ten best videogame detectives EVER!

Chad Concelmo
4:00 PM on 09.12.2012
The ten best videogame detectives EVER! photo


This year marks the 25th anniversary of the Sam & Max series. It was 1987 when the very first Sam & Max comic was released, inspiring one of the greatest and most charming adventure game series ever.

Everyone is celebrating this exciting milestone! Telltale is celebrating with a major Steam sale on Sam & Max games this weekend! Original creator Steve Purcell is celebrating by continually being awesome! And now it’s time for Destructoid to join in the celebration. And what better way to celebrate the greatness of Sam & Max than with a themed top ten list?! THEMED TOP TEN LISTS ARE THE GREATEST GIFTS OF ALL!

Since Sam and Max are some of the most memorable detectives ever, there is no more logical choice than a list of the ten best videogame detectives of all time.

Enjoy this fine gift, Sam and Max. And, no, I don’t have the receipt.

There are two things I love in this world: dolphins and menu-based point-and-click adventure games on the NES. And the movie Babe. Oh, and Souplantation. Okay, there are many things I love in this world. But one of these things is definitely menu-based point-and-click adventure games on the NES. There may be only a few in existence, but they are all grand.

One of the best in the bunch is Déjà Vu, a surprisingly dark and challenging adventure that follows around Ace Harding as he tries to solve the mystery of who he is and why he is being accused of murder.

Players never get to see the main character since the game is entirely in first-person, but if the box art is any indication, Ace is one slick (and narcissistic!) detective.

Trench coat review: Very Carman Sandiego-esque. Love the bright color and sharp fedora! Grade: B+

 

One of the most underrated and sadly forgotten PC games of all time is Blade Runner. The game is gorgeous, moody, and a perfect extension of Ridley Scott's original science fiction universe.

In the graphic adventure game, you play as Roy McCoy, a gritty, hardened detective who, like Deckard in the film, is assigned to track down a group of potentially dangerous replicants.

If you haven't played Blade Runner, track it down. It's a real gem.

Trench coat review: Disappointing. You would think a trench coat from the future would have some glowing TRON lights on it or something. Or at least a less frumpy silhouette. Grade: C

 

Sissel is not technically a detective, as much as a [SPOILER] coming back to [SPOILER] his [SPOILER]. But I love him (and Ghost Trick!) so much that he had to make this list.

Plus, he is a phantom detective, which is inherently cooler than a regular detective.

Trench coat review: The stark red is unconventional and super fashion-forward. Grade: A

 

I love Hotel Dusk on the Nintendo DS. I really do. It is one of the most interesting and original games on the handheld. But, man, is it depressing. The sad story, gloomy environments, and morose characters, combined with the black and white art, make for one downer of an adventure. A pretty great adventure, don’t get me wrong, but one that takes itself very seriously.

Main character Kyle Hyde is just as serious. But he has a right to be! When he was a child, his father was killed. Years later, when he became a detective, his partner betrayed him and sold inside information to some bad people. So Kyle shot him. And then the body disappeared, leading Kyle to the mysterious Hotel Dusk, where some really crazy things happen.

He’s had a tough life. Time for someone to get a puppy!

Trench coat review: As disjointed and messy as the inner-workings of Kyle’s tormented mind. Grade: C+

 

Sonny Bonds, main character from the classic Police Quest series, starts off as a simple traffic cop, but eventually (and rather quickly) works his way up to narcotics detective,  tracking down a homicidal drug dealer and saving his girlfriend's life in the process.

He is also constantly ridiculed in the game by his superiors, called a "pig" by every rowdy citizen he meets, and dies -- yes, actually dies -- if he tries to walk out of the police station locker room naked.

Not that I tried that or anything.

Trench coat review: What Sonny Bonds lacks in trench coat, he makes up for in one beautiful head of hair. Grade: N/A

 

Oh, Inspector Chelmey, you are such a bumbling, endearing detective. While you are trying to solve mysteries, Layton and Luke are rearranging matchsticks, sliding around blocks, untangling rope, and still end up beating you to the end goal.

PULL IT TOGETHER, CHELMEY!

Trench coat review: Surprisingly dapper. Also, bonus points for that bold purple tie! Grade: B+

 

Tex Murphy is a private investigator and star of a series of adventure games in the ‘80s and ‘90s. Well, “interactive movies” would be the better way to describe them, as they feature real-life actors playing the parts of all the characters. In fact, Chris Jones, the actual designer of the game, plays Tex Murphy himself. How awesome is that?!

I think this whole concept needs to make a comeback. Can you imagine Cliff Bleszinski as the star of Gears of War? Or Miyamoto with a flower on his head as the mysterious and feared Pikmin King? Classic.

If you are wondering why Tex Murphy is so great, just watch this hardboiled trailer for The Pandora Directive and bask in all its glory.

“Where the line blurs between loyalty ... and desire.”

Trench coat review: Well, it’s a trench coat! It also looks like something my dad wore to a Halloween party when I was a kid. Grade: D

 

If my parents named me Dick Gumshoe, I would ... well, first thing I would do would be to hug them for naming me something as awesome as Dick Gumshoe. But after that I would become a detective. I mean, what else is there to do with a name like Dick Gumshoe? Porn star? Candy store owner? Porn star/candy store owner? Nah, detective is the best option.

Fan favorite detective Dick Gumshoe from the Phoenix Wright games may not be the brightest bulb in the box, but he is such a loyal and lovable guy that you can't help but love him.

Trench coat review: Popped collar? Check. Loose fitting tie? Check. Is Dick Gumshoe a bro? Grade: C-

 

Pennington is a penguin detective from awesome GameCube RPG Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door. And he has a magnifying glass and a cute little hat.

Now, I am often accused of overusing hyperbolic, all-caps statements, but, seriously, HE IS A PENGUIN DETECTIVE! LOOK HOW ADORABLE HE IS!

Calm down, Chad. Breathe.

Trench coat review: His flippers wouldn’t fit through a trench coat, but look at that bow tie. And his little messenger bag! AND THAT HAT! MY GOD HERE I GO AGAIN! Grade: A+

 

To not put Sam and Max as the number one detectives on a list dedicated to them would just be cruel. Luckily, they actually earn this spot by being two of the most memorable videogame characters of all time.

Sam may be the one that does all the crime-solving, but Max is there to ... well, Max just likes to do terrible things to everyone he meets. But he is hilarious. And that makes everything okay.

Trench coat review: Simple, clean, and stylish. I also love the ... OMG MAX IS NAKED! Grade: (Sam) A-; (Max) N/A

 

-----

Since there are so many great videogame detectives (and almost all from adventure games, weirdly enough), here is a list of characters that almost made the final cut.

 

-----

What do you think? Do you agree with my picks for the best videogame detectives of all time? Are you a fan of the Sam & Max adventure games? And, seriously, what is up with all the trench coats? I understand they are detectives, but sheesh!





Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


No Naoto? Boo.
Wow, no Norman Jayden? PFFT!
NO COLE PHELPS?

I will nab your husband now
No Cole Phelps? No BATMAN?!
I love paper mario penquins
Norman Jayden and Naoto should have been there.
Just finished The Devil's Playhouse recently. Sam & Max are some of the funniest games I've ever played.
No Cole from LA Noire?
No Cole Phelps? Wow. I thought Cole would at least make number 10.
FBI Special Agent Francis York Morgan.
I see a distinct lack of Raidou Kuzunoha xIV, his games live and breath the detective noir shtick and he uses demons to help him solve cases.

Also, he as an awesome theme and a better battle theme:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vCzr-BSDqp8

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kfjqM7UqbA
I didn't know Adolf Hitler was a detective.
Sweet list, Chad! But I second Naoto Shirogane. How can you not love a 16 year old girl who pretends to be a boy... wait. That doesn't sound kosher.
@Everyone,
I like Cole Phelps and Norman Jayden, but they weren't super memorable to me as characters. Loved their games, though! :)
Cole Phelps would definitely be me #1. Surprised he didn't even make "Runner-ups."

My top 5 would be Cole Phelps, Sissel, Gumshoe, Chemley and Sam+Max. I'd put Batman on that list but he's a bit of a stretch.
Oh, Sherlock on top of that list. Not sure how I could forget that.
No Touch Detective?
Shame inspector Cabanela isn't on this list. At least he still has the best dance moves of any detective.
cant believe they missed that brah from ALan Wake
Shame inspector Cabanela isn't on this list. At least he still has the best dance moves of any detective.
Oh yeah, Cabanela is awesome! Definitely deserved a "Runner-up" spot for best dancing.

Guess you have to make some sacrifices though ;)
NO BATMAN?
No Nightshade?
No FBI Agent Ethan Thomas?!? Even with HALF of the S-word he went through he should be on this list! As always, a good read, but FOR SHAME! :P

Naoto and York both should be on this list. I don't think chad played either of those games though so that may be why he doesn't have them on it.
@Chadswick Chadington - I was being sarcastic and genuinely hope anyone else that mentioned Jayden was as well.

Despite not being an actual detective, I think Adam Jensen deserves more recognition than Cole Phelps considering his interrogation mechanics didnt cater to the mentally retarded.
Honestly, I haven't played a single game on this list (aside from Heavy Rain the runner's up, which I didn't like).
Dolphins out of ten
@D Sane,
Hopefully this will inspire you to play some of these games. They are all great! :)
You somehow mentioned Pikmin, Sam and Max, Paper Mario, and Hotel Dusk in one article. I love you.
Lovely list Chad. You never EVER disappoint.
Where the FUCK is FBI Special Agent Francis York Morgan????
@Sweaty Dungus,
I definitely thought about him, but I couldn't really decide if he was a detective or not. I consider him more of a, well, FBI agent. I agree that he is beyond amazing. :)
I'm chuffed that Tex made it onto the list. The FMV ones are a personal fave of mine. Trench coat and tennis shoes, what a style.
I've got one!

Christopher Walken as Detective Vince Magnotta in Ripper.

Man, this list reminded me of how badly I want to re-play the Paper Mario games.

I also agree with Cabanela, he was my favorite Ghost Trick character.

Not a bad list, though I would have added Gabriel Knight's Detective Mosely in the list (voiced by Mark Hamill). His character is quite memorable for me:
yay Sam & Max for being 25 years!!!!!!

lots of 25 years anniversaries!!!!!!!

so where's mah Save the World on PSN so i can buy all of them in one go??

Naoto, Raidou Kuzunoha, Francis York should also be on the list.

although he's not a detective, he actually looks fucking one and is freaking badass :P

No Detective Magnotta?
D'ya hear that Zach? This schmuck didn't put us on the list!
Sonny Bonds and Tex Murphy! :D I have the nostalgia.
What!? No Norman Jayden? Who the hell doesn't love a detective with a secret drug addiction and a cool pair futuristic shades?
No mention of the world's greatest detective?

Also, if permitted I would like to mention Inspector Tequila of Hard-Boiled/Stranglehold fame. Though he's more if a "shoot things until crimes are solved" kinda guy.
i guess layton and ace dont count, still a good list
Does an FBI investigator count as a detective? If so, than this list is missing a certain dual personality murder investigator, at least as an honorable mention. Also Naoto Shirogane.
Gabriel Knight? Cole Phelps? ...Happy for Sam n Max tho =-)
Chad you fabulous bitch, I totally called the penguin detective a mile away!
15 year old Japanese girl with a gun. Naoto must be mentioned.
yay for no phelps! He was a bellend. Batman should have made the list though imo.

Sam and max are worthy champions though :D Still gotta get round to doing the second season... and hope they bring the 3rd to xbox. I've got a perfectly good pc but i like them chieves :D




The DTOID Show: Skyrim: Dragonborn, GTA, DmC, Wii U & THQ

Hey gang! It's my birthday! Go birthday! Also, Tara's out sick, so Anthony Carboni guest-hosted. Or substitute-hosted, I suppose. Go Anthony! Big news today is Skyrim's Dragonborn DLC, which looks really friggin' cool. Grand ...   more

The DTOID Show: Skyrim: Dragonborn, GTA, DmC, Wii U & THQ photo

You can pre-order Grand Theft Auto V right now

If pre-ordering games months in advance is your thing, you can now go out and drop $5 to $60 on Grand Theft Auto V at your favorite retailer. Rockstar officially is listing themselves, GameStop, Amazon, Best Buy and Walmart (...   more

You can pre-order Grand Theft Auto V right now photo

Oh look, more Grand Theft Auto V promo items leaked

Retailers will be taking pre-orders for Grand Theft Auto V starting on November 5, and Rockstar will be giving out little collectible Los Santos Photo Viewers as a bonus incentive to put some cash down early. How do...   more

Oh look, more Grand Theft Auto V promo items leaked photo

The DTOID Show's Halloween Special! Gaming News! OoOoO!

Happy Halloween everyone! On today's SPOOKTACULAR episode of The Destructoid Show, we talk about some festively spooky video game stuff. Because we didn't report on it enough this week, Grand Theft Auto V is coming out t...   more

The DTOID Show's Halloween Special! Gaming News! OoOoO! photo

Borderlands 2 ships 5M copies, XCOM deemed a success

Take-Two Interactive has disclosed its financial report for its second quarter fiscal 2013, which saw GAAP net revenue of $273.1 million, up from last year's $107 million for the same period. This was attributed to Borderland...   more

Borderlands 2 ships 5M copies, XCOM deemed a success photo

Grand Theft Auto V to release Spring 2013

Rockstar has made clear their intentions to marry your daughter release Grand Theft Auto V in spring of 2013. Awesome. I'm sure we'll all be well and caught up on everything else coming out in the first quarter. I mean, ...   more

Grand Theft Auto V to release Spring 2013 photo

The DTOID Show: GTA V, Assassin's Creed III, & Cliffy B!

Well hello there, jewels. How are you doing this fine evening? Staying dry, I hope? Wha-OKAY ENOUGH SMALL TALK. On today's Destructoid Show, we're treated to a launch trailer for Assassin's Creed III, a live-action trai...   more

The DTOID Show: GTA V, Assassin's Creed III, & Cliffy B! photo

Grand Theft Auto: Vice City coming to iOS and Android

Grand Theft Auto: Vice City is preparing to enjoy its 10th anniversary, and Rockstar is celebrating by porting the 80s-themed classic to iOS and Android devices. I'm up for that! Although a date is yet to be revealed, it seem...   more

Grand Theft Auto: Vice City coming to iOS and Android photo

Grand Theft Auto controversy orchestrated by PR guru

Grand Theft Auto is one of the most controversial game franchises of all time. Every new release is greeted by an outpouring of outrage, as its violent content and morally dubious scenarios are eviscerated by moral guardians ...   more

Grand Theft Auto controversy orchestrated by PR guru photo

A massive Rockstar Games Collection is on the way

[Update: Rockstar has just officially confirmed this collection, coming out on November 6 for $59.99.] Retailers Buy.com and CDUniverse.com have outed a Rockstar Games Collection which is set to include Grand Theft Auto: Epis...   more

A massive Rockstar Games Collection is on the way photo


Back to Top




Advertising on destructoid is available through Please contact them to learn more