• Filter the conversation
All posts Watched posts
ie8 fix
Click Here
Click Here

Stay Connected with UrbanBaby:

Inside UrbanBaby

UrbanBabyBuzz

paperplanes.jpgLittle Paper Planes: 20 Artists Reinvent the Childhood Classic by Kelly Lynn Some of today’s most inspiring artists chime in on the classic paper airplane, and take the timeless craft to a whole new level. The book is printed on perfo ... More »

UrbanBabyNewYork

Governors Island Family FestivalGoGovernors Island Alliance Family FestivalKick off opening weekend with this 8th annual fest featuring music, dance, arts and crafts, face painting, bike helmut fittings and other outdoor activities. Bring a picnic lunch, and enjoy live ... More »
  • [-]Do any New York City private schools use Everyday Math? Which ones? Is it a strong program?

    32 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.20.12, 09:43 PM Flag ]
    • (apologize in advance for rant) - unfortunately, nearly all schools in entire Northeast, and especially NY area (private or public), use some variant on "constructivist" math (Everyday Math and its affiliated programs). NO- it is NOT a strong program. It is roughly the equivalent of the "Physics for Poets" taught in many liberal arts colleges- designed to give people a passing familiarity with topics without any real grounding, precision, or ability to do actual work in the area. It is also known as "Chicago" math because it was literally created at Univ Chicago, but their Education Dept, not their math dept, originally as a way to teach kids in Chicago housing projects enough basic familiarity that by high school graduation, they could w...

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.21.12, 01:16 AM Flag
      • This. My kid was a top student in elementary school, aced the EDM curriculum and all tests, and managed to learn very little that helped him once he got to a middle school that taught math properly. EDM is a terrible curriculum. It seems to be designed to "teach" kids who will be staffing the fast-food restaurants of the future.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 05:47 AM Flag
        • + 1. After 3 years of seeing my kid counting coins (K to 2nd grade), I feel a little bit desperate. But it's true that you need to have future generations ready to give back proper change, or instantly spot a quarter on the sidewalk from afar.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.21.12, 05:51 AM Flag
          • Especially since most people pay with credit cards.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.21.12, 07:21 AM Flag
          • Yes, the kids doing Singapore Math are doing advanced algebra in 2nd grade. NOT!

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.21.12, 07:50 AM Flag
            • Its not about doing advanced work, its about developing mastery and fluency in Math.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.21.12, 09:50 AM Flag
        • This. To be clear, as OR stated, it does NOT "seem" to be designed to teach kids who will work in fast-food restaurants as their "top" job after graduation, it IS specifically designed to teach such students.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.21.12, 07:55 AM Flag
      • ITA with you. FWIW, the same slow approach to teaching basic math is happening in France too, and with the same dismal results in the latest PISA results (both country have mediocre scores, to say the least). Some prominent scientists have tried to take a stand there, but with little results. So yes, heavy tutoring at home here. We intentionally didn't voice our concerns to the teacher, by fear that it would translate into more mind-numbing stupid homework. DC gets done with his school homework in 15 min max, and then the real work can start. He loves it.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 05:57 AM Flag
    • For all the hate Everyday Math gets, my 6 yo does seem to understand addition and subtraction, including with multiple-digit numbers, as well as bar graphs, using coins and dollar bills to make amounts of money, symmetry, shapes, etc. What else do you really want for a kid that age?

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.21.12, 04:32 AM Flag
      • The issue is not kindergarten math

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 04:40 AM Flag
        • He's first grade, actually, but since this is what the NYC schools use from K, maybe you want to specify what grade level your concern is about.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.21.12, 05:00 AM Flag
          • I have older kids and my career is science/engineering. I don't think EDM is the type of math program that gives a good foundation. This is my opinion. If you are happy then it works for what you expect of an arithmetic program

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.21.12, 05:32 AM Flag
      • Everything that gets annoying after third grade. Because basically the curriculum is repeated every year.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 05:01 AM Flag
        • Eh, we had fractions and integers every single year from 4th through 7th grades when we were kids, too. This isn't exactly a new issue.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.21.12, 05:06 AM Flag
          • OR- your response is part of the problem, and this is largely the fault of the schools and the publishers. They know that it sort of resembles how we learned - it is not like they are specifically teaching incorrect information- 2 plus 2 is still 4. But they also KNOW (and if not, are idiots, which is certainly true for many math-phobic teachers/admins) that this is not a good curriculum, but hope to "trick" the parents into not noticing, and the ones that do care, will simply tutor at home or self-teach, so there will still be a core of high achievers that the teachers can use to rebut critics.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.21.12, 05:23 AM Flag
            • I don't know which math program my dc's use. It's a top tier coed and the math is amazing. We are both in finance and some nights we laugh about how challenging the dc's math is.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.21.12, 05:41 AM Flag
              • Please go check and tell us!

                [ Reply | More ]
                05.21.12, 05:58 AM Flag
                • Honestly don't know. It's Trinity. Dc in 4th grade and I think the math is excellent.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  05.21.12, 08:32 AM Flag
        • THIS! It is so f*ing annoying that every fall they have to spend the first 3 months or more reviewing basic concepts that were already pretty simple to get the first time around the year before. And there are no real math problems to actually challenge the kids.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.21.12, 06:00 AM Flag
      • Just wait, by the 4th grade when you realize that your dc hasn't learned anything new since, you'll hate it.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 07:14 AM Flag
    • It's a horrible program. No privates I know use it.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.21.12, 05:49 AM Flag
      • np. Don't be so sure. Most privates seem to use a blend of curricula, including many elements of EDM and TERC (which is even worse). We have dc at two TT SS schools and the LS and MS math is awful at both.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 06:27 AM Flag
      • MOST private use basically the same system.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 07:51 AM Flag
    • Everyday Math is being phased out of New York Public Schools! (not sure about private)

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.21.12, 06:57 AM Flag
      • How do you know this!! If its true, I will be so happy.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 07:25 AM Flag
    • The first OR really doesn't get it. Everyday Math is ELEMENTARY SCHOOL!!! It's utterly ridiculous that this is being blamed for poor math -- if your dc isn't learning what he or she needs, he isn't good at math!!! He is going to have problems learning math no matter what! Kids who weren't talented at math ALWAYS had issues when they get to algebra and advanced math -- yes, even those taught via the beloved Singapore. Geez, 70 kids come into NEST middle school, and are quite often BETTER than kids who have been there since K, despite learning via EM. Do you know why? Because they are good at math! Sure, pay millions for a new math curriculum, but there will always be issues.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.21.12, 07:49 AM Flag
      • OR - no, I get it completely. Fundamental lack of computational fluency and over-reliance on calculators create a permanent stumbling block to learning higher math, and certainly to fluency/speed. And NO, you do not "get it"- just because some gifted students still ultimately thrive in this system (and/or, as is more often the case, dedicated parents who help the child with tutoring and/or self-teaching), this is simply a testament to the students and their families, not a vindication of the system.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.21.12, 08:01 AM Flag
        • Are you kidding me? My dc almost NEVER used a calculator through elementary school using EM! What are you talking about? Posters like you do not seem to understand EM and I doubt you really have a kid who was taught via the system. Yes, the one disadvantage is that EM "spirals", so keeps introducing topics over and over, which arguably can be boring for fast learners. But your idea that kids don't learn is rather silly. EM gets kid to understand how numbers work instead of just teaching them rote ways of adding, subtracting, multiplying, etc. But some kids not as good in math need those rote ways of learning, I agree. EM works better for kids good at math.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.21.12, 08:26 AM Flag
          • You've just validated the whole argument for getting away from EDM. Most kids aren't naturally great at Math and do need the exercises and the drills. I have one DS who is a natural at Math, learned EDM with the worst 3rd grade teacher and still got a perfect score on the State test. My younger DS needs more time learning Math and EDM has been a disaster for him, and he has a good 3rd grade teacher. I'm nervous to see his results on the State test. I had to enroll him in a Math enrichment program just so he would be prepared for the exam and for 4th grade.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.21.12, 08:57 AM Flag
            • Perhaps, but then you'd have the same argument about the kill and drill math tests harming kids who ARE good at math and are forced to learn it one way only. (Everyday Math gives kids all kinds of ways to solve problems and they can pick what works best for them.) I'm not saying the EM doesn't have problems, but all programs do, and I don't know that it's so much worse than any other.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.21.12, 09:22 AM Flag
          • np. So in other words, EDM isn't good for kids who are weak in math, because there's not enough drilling and rote methodology. And it's not good for kids who ARE naturally good at math, because the repetitive, spiraling curriculum is too slow and boring. So, let's see... WHO, exactly, is it good for??? This is a perfect example of why we need to bring tracking back.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.25.12, 04:39 AM Flag
  • [-]My 7 year old son doesn't enjoy hanging out with his grandmother because they speak different languages. My mom is very hurt and I need to be able to leave him with my mom. Any advice?

    10 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.23.12, 10:54 AM Flag ]
    • he'll get over it, but your mom should be a little more understanding, patient and accepting considering he's just a child being left with an old adult that he can't communicate with.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.23.12, 10:56 AM Flag
    • do you speak that language? can you start teaching him some basic phrases?

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.23.12, 10:58 AM Flag
      • I do, and I do teach him the basics, but they can't have a real conversation. I feel extremely guilty for not having him taught that language from the beginning.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.23.12, 10:59 AM Flag
    • Can you start teaching your DS a language GM knows? Can she help with this?

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.23.12, 10:58 AM Flag
    • Can she get involved with a hobby he likes (card collecting? wii? football?). A common interest might help. He could try learning a bit of the language too? No?

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.23.12, 10:59 AM Flag
      • good idea. they both love doing art.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.23.12, 11:01 AM Flag
    • Get a translator.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.23.12, 11:00 AM Flag
    • Mine don't as much either due to the language barrier (my mom does speak some english, but it's not great). However, my mom has a big garden that they all love to work on and she takes them out to playgrounds.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.23.12, 11:00 AM Flag
    • Have your mom speak to him like he understands her in the other language. He'll pick it up. Have him speak in English. She'll understand him. I was very close to my grandparents and never spoke their language. Assure him that she understands him and help him understand her - practice by only speaking the other language to him at home.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.23.12, 11:21 AM Flag
  • [-]When is a good age to start reading harry potter?

    18 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.07.12, 07:09 PM Flag ]
    • never is always a good time for harry potter.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.07.12, 07:11 PM Flag
      • OK, fundie mom. I suggest LIAS for your blog-reading pleasure.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.07.12, 07:16 PM Flag
        • seriously. stuff is so bad it brings tears to my eyes.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.07.12, 07:20 PM Flag
          • Harry Potter stuff or Quiverfull stuff? Ooh, now there's a thread I think I just might start...

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.07.12, 07:35 PM Flag
    • Whenever your child is interested and capable.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.07.12, 07:13 PM Flag
    • depends on the kid, but I read it to ds at 8. He loved it, but understood more when he re-read to himself at 10

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.07.12, 07:14 PM Flag
      • we started reading the first book to our 5 year old, but it was too scary for her. will try again in a year or so.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.17.12, 04:38 PM Flag
    • my 2nd grader just finished all 7 books

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.07.12, 07:22 PM Flag
      • really - i think mine could "read" it but definitely wouldn't understand most of it. and then would never read it again so we are holding off

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.07.12, 07:23 PM Flag
        • She understood it all. I would not let her read it if it wasn't her level. I teach English and thus have raised both dcs in a very, very literature-rich environment. She reads for an hour a day. At lights out I always let dcs read with a flashlight (for fun) for another 20 minutes or so..

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.07.12, 07:32 PM Flag
          • ok - mine reads all the time too. that doesn't mean she can understand the complex content of the books. understanding the vocabulary is completely different from understanding the deeper issues.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.07.12, 07:38 PM Flag
            • Sure, there are different levels of understanding. Doesn't mean a young kid can't like it, then rediscover it later. My teenage cousins read them all at least twice at different stages.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.07.12, 08:23 PM Flag
          • :eyeroll: calm down, English teacher mom

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.07.12, 08:13 PM Flag
          • gross

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.08.12, 06:20 AM Flag
      • I don't know about girls but at least 1/2 of the boys in my DS's 2nd grade have read HP. They discuss the books and plot amongst themselves all the time. My ds loves to go back and re-read chapters of the books he already read.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 06:03 AM Flag
    • My first grader and I read the first two together. Holding off with more for now.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.07.12, 07:28 PM Flag
    • My 8 year old just listened to the audio book series and loved it, is listening to the whole thing again!

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 06:25 AM Flag
    • Why don’t you read some other book!?!

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.09.12, 02:52 AM Flag
  • [-]How many playdates does your preschooler have a week? My almost 3.5yo averages about one a week. He's happy and doesn't seem to want any more. But other parents tell me their kids have multiple playdates a week, and often standing playdates with certain friends. Is he missing out on a chance to grow socially? TIA!

    13 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    04.17.12, 07:45 AM Flag ]
    • Get a grip. He's 3. Let him be a happy 3YO and stop worrying about what other kids are doing.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 07:47 AM Flag
      • OP: My child is happy. Just looking for other people's thoughts here. Thanks.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.17.12, 07:48 AM Flag
    • none, he's my youngest and I busy with the older kids school schedules

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 07:47 AM Flag
    • You're fine. If he was understimulated or needed more socializing, you'd see that in his behavior.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 07:54 AM Flag
    • Whatever your kid wants is best. My 4yo is super social and would love a playdate every single day. But it's also fine to do none. A lot of 3year olds go home and nap after school.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 08:03 AM Flag
    • Isn't he in preschool? IMO, that's where the most important socializing takes place. We do playdates occasionally as well, but honestly, those tend to be more for me, and I think that's the case for most Moms.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 08:04 AM Flag
      • ^^^ also, even without a formal "playdate" kids that age often form impromptu friendships with whoever is at the playground, and I think that's probably an important aspect of socializing too, and one that is missed if your Mom is always scheduling who you are going to play with and when.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.17.12, 08:05 AM Flag
      • OP: He is in preschool for 3 hours a day, and is happy socializing with the kids there,although he doesn't have any one particular friend or buddy yet. He also doesn't yet join in on the group imaginary games the kids play (superheros, etc). He's young for his class, and most of the kids are 4-10 months older than him, so I assumed he was just a bit young to get the group socialization things yet. Teacher isn't worried- says that at 4yo there is often a dramatic change in their socialization skills. But I can't help but wonder if he "needs" more playdates, even though he doesn't want them. Thanks for your reassurances!

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.17.12, 08:13 AM Flag
    • My 2.5 YO has never had a playdate, unless you count the times that we get together with other couples who have kids.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 08:24 AM Flag
    • Why don't you just set up an additional playdate a week and see if he enjoys it? You might be surprised.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 10:23 AM Flag
      • OP: That's what I'm trying to figure out. Is this something that I Should do? Right now, we're happy as we are. But if its "better" for my child than letting him play with his toys at home, or at the playground/park in good weather, then I'll do it. Hmmm....

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.17.12, 10:24 AM Flag
        • I would have a 2-3 week trial and see if he likes it.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.17.12, 10:29 AM Flag
        • you might be overinterpreting the term "playdate." most playdates are exactly what you are describing--being in your house playign with your toys or going to the park, only with another kid there as well. it really is much more fun for the kids most of the time. see if you can arrange to meet another family at the park/playground. the kids can play together. when dd was younger, we had a standing playdate with a friend. what that meant was every sunday we were in the city and the weather was nice we would meet at the playground.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.30.12, 12:28 PM Flag
  • [-]Weston CT. Thinking of moving there. Thoughts.

    3 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    04.29.12, 01:20 PM Flag ]
    • Weston is a quiet and beautiful town. Good schools. Did I say quiet?

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.29.12, 01:34 PM Flag
    • nothing in weston in terms of retail - need to drive far if you need anything. (ok so there is a small town center grocery store but expensive!!!) if you like country though you will like it

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.29.12, 01:38 PM Flag
      • this is what i hate about the country, though other things are good. also, dining options. ugh.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.29.12, 01:50 PM Flag
  • [-]Preschool teacher told me that I should get evaluation for My 3-year-old DS for ADHD. She is also concerned about his hitting other kids. He is doing OK at home except for mildly/occasionally hitting us or his younger btother. The teacher is new and has been at the school for a week. I understand that staying concentrated at the circle time is very important but I do not want to put too much restrictions on him. Will he be a menace to the society, should I see the doctor and even direclty evaluators from the Early Intervation Program? Any insights or opinion highly appreciated!

    14 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    04.25.12, 12:38 PM Flag ]
    • What?! He's THREE.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:40 PM Flag
    • 3 is WAY too young to be starting this conversation. Model appropriate behavior, remind him constantly, redirect/reward. I'd run as fast as you can away from this school FWIW! Yikes.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:45 PM Flag
    • I think she is probably overreacting. he is a little kid. one of my ds' was a hitter, the other one is a biter. both outgrew it and are fine.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:46 PM Flag
    • What is wrong with this world. No way should a preschool teacher be suggesting a 3 yo get an ADHD evaluation.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:48 PM Flag
    • A 3 yo misbehaving is more about discipline than ADHD. 3 yo boys are just nuts and it takes a fine balance to reign him in without quashing his spirit. I would NOT seek medical evaluation.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:50 PM Flag
    • That is very strange. I've taught in 3's classes and no way would I rec evaluation after one week

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:54 PM Flag
      • Same. I worked with preschool special ed and some kids DID have attentional issues as part of many other developmental problems, but after one week it'd be impossible to tell. In one week the class isn't even adjusted to the teacher and her routine and rules. Hitting is a concern, but could be happening for many reasons besides ADHD.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.25.12, 02:29 PM Flag
    • Is the teacher a physician? Is she even a teacher? Seems unethical for her to say this to you after being around DS for only one week

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:56 PM Flag
    • No real doctor would ever ever ever diagnose a 3YO (or 4, or 5YO for that matter) w/ ADHD. Not even a 6YO - although that seems to be fairly common lately (super sad). Ignore the teacher's comment and teach your son that hitting is absolutely unacceptable. How does she handle it in the classroom?

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 12:56 PM Flag
    • You should factor in that the teacher is new. It's an adjustment for your DS. She needs to get a grip and do her job.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 01:01 PM Flag
    • When you say teacher, what do you mean? Is she a daycare provider (which can mean virtually no education) or does she have an early educ degree? Either way she is wrong.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 01:07 PM Flag
      • Thank you all for the comments, much appreciated. OP here. The teacher has early education degree and has just started at Preschool of America. In her class there is a boy who has a helper from a private agency for his being a bit autistic (he looks normal to me), and she thought the similar help may be beneficial for DS. My DS loved the class two teachers ago. She and the sub-teacher were fantastic. No hitting during the time. He started hitting after they left the school. The new teacher also does not like guy-play. I am totally anti-gun and understand it's a no no more than from the perspective of political correctedness, but I think this could be the only time boys can play fantasy guns. The scary part is that the young direct...

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.25.12, 01:53 PM Flag
    • I just shuddered when I read this- my DS hits and pushes, seemingly more to get a rise than genuine agression but a hit is a hit. Many boys his age can't sit still and do annoying things to each other (one poured sand over the teacher's head!)...while there's nothing wrong with getting an evaluation, I can't imagine this is a big deal at this point

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 01:17 PM Flag
Refresh » New Post »