Corruption, Russophobia Weigh on Poland
28 January 2005 | Issue 3094
NEW YORK TIMES SERVICE
WARSAW -- From outside this country, Poland seems as if it ought to be a happy place, securely democratic after all those years of Communist dictatorship, enjoying a growing economy, membership in the European Union and a greater role than ever in world affairs.
But that is not the case. Objectively, as one commentator, Helena Luczywo, deputy editor of Gazeta Wyborcza, put it recently, Poland is better off than at any time since the 16th century.
Yet, as Luczywo readily allows, the mood is gloomy. Charges of high-level corruption dominate the news. The ruling coalition, led by the Alliance of Left Democrats, or SLD, is deeply unpopular. Far-right nationalist parties are threatening to flow into the vacuum. Why do the Poles feel bad when things are good?
"There are three reasons," said Leszek Jesien, a political scientist and former government adviser on Poland's entry into the European Union. "One reason is corruption."
Recently, parliamentary commissions have been holding televised hearings on suspected malfeasance in the sale of Polish state assets to private companies, and the sessions have been full of melodramatic accusations -- most notably of a secret and somehow sinister meeting between Poland's most famous captain of finance and the Russian intelligence service.
"Second, in 2001, there was the total decomposition of the right," Jesien continued, referring to the collapse of the government associated with the Solidarity democracy movement.
"Now, there's the total decomposition of the left, without any prospect that either of them can be recomposed," Jesien said.
"And third, before, we were the poor orphans of Europe. Now, we're an equal member of the all-powerful EU, but we are still poor."
In other words, there may be a touch of hypochondria to the Polish malaise. But that does not mean that the problems, especially of corruption, are imaginary. This is a country, after all, where the mayors of several towns -- and, in at least one case, almost the entirety of the municipal administration -- have been indicted or are already in prison after having been convicted of corruption of one sort or another.
Still, something seems a bit strange about the various corruption scandals and investigations. The corruption seems a bit on the petty scale, not quite worthy of a great political crisis.
In one high-level, high-visibility case, a film producer, Lew Rywin, reportedly a friend of a former prime minister, Leszek Miller, was found guilty of trying to solicit a bribe from Adam Michnik, the editor of Gazeta Wyborcza, to enable Gazeta to bid on the sale of a state-owned television station.
But, more generally, the investigations have revealed little in the way of a clear story of systematic corruption. Because of that, the investigations are beginning to take on an aspect of political theater: grand, made-for-TV gestures motivated more by the eagerness of party leaders to grab the spotlight than to use it to shed light.
"The parliament is a platform for political struggle," Jozef Gruszka, the head of one of the investigating commissions, acknowledged in an interview. "And it's hard to say that investigating commissions are completely free of political influence," Gruszka said.
The main corruption scandal has to do with the sale of Poland's biggest oil company, Orlen. This is the subject of the commission headed by Gruszka.
But he is not investigating whether bribes were paid or assets were sold off at ridiculous prices. The charge is that Orlen may have been sold to the oil giant , which comes from the country that the Poles love most to hate, Russia.
"The basic problem was that there were many conversations between the political establishment and the Russian government and parties," Roman Giertych, leader of the rightist League of Polish Families, said in a brief interview in the Polish Parliament. "It's important not only for the economy. It's a question of economic sovereignty."
The strange thing, however, is that Orlen was not actually sold to LUKoil or to any other Russian company. In other words, the biggest allegation of malfeasance in the privatization process involves an event that did not actually occur. The investigation concerns the possibility that, had it not been stopped, it might have occurred.
Here is where accounts of meetings between a Polish businessman and a supposed Russian agent come into the picture.
The businessman, Jan Kulczyk, generally referred to as Poland's richest man, met last year in Vienna with Vladimir Alganov, a Russian who is almost a household name in Poland. Alganov served in the Kremlin's embassy in Warsaw through most of the 1980s and early '90s, reportedly working for Russian intelligence.
The parliamentary commission that has been holding hearings on Orlen released a lurid Polish intelligence report on that meeting, which included unsubstantiated claims that Alganov complained to Kulczyk that Russia had not succeeded in buying Orlen even though millions of dollars in bribes were paid to Polish officials. After that, the head of Polish intelligence, Zbigniew Siemiatkowski, appeared before the commission and delivered a stark warning.
"I'm afraid that the Russian empire is being restored," he said. "Yesterday it was tanks. Today it is oil. The commissars are being replaced by politicians and businessmen."
Other prominent political figures in Poland -- former Treasury Minister Wieslaw Kaczmarek, for example -- have offered the opinion that if cash-rich Russia wants to invest in cash-poor Poland, Poland would be well advised to seize the opportunity. Ignoring that common sense, some hotter heads in Poland have been trying to stir up public anxiety about dark Russian dealings.
Giertych is among those who have been most active in drumming up Russophobia. Of course, he happens to head a nationalist party that has been picking up influence as the mainstream parties have declined.
"It's true that Poland hasn't been in such good shape since the 16th century," Marek Beylin, a commentator for Gazeta Wyborcza, said when asked about Luczywo's comment. "But we are in a deep crisis," because the political parties are trying to destroy one another.
But that is not the case. Objectively, as one commentator, Helena Luczywo, deputy editor of Gazeta Wyborcza, put it recently, Poland is better off than at any time since the 16th century.
Yet, as Luczywo readily allows, the mood is gloomy. Charges of high-level corruption dominate the news. The ruling coalition, led by the Alliance of Left Democrats, or SLD, is deeply unpopular. Far-right nationalist parties are threatening to flow into the vacuum. Why do the Poles feel bad when things are good?
"There are three reasons," said Leszek Jesien, a political scientist and former government adviser on Poland's entry into the European Union. "One reason is corruption."
Recently, parliamentary commissions have been holding televised hearings on suspected malfeasance in the sale of Polish state assets to private companies, and the sessions have been full of melodramatic accusations -- most notably of a secret and somehow sinister meeting between Poland's most famous captain of finance and the Russian intelligence service.
"Second, in 2001, there was the total decomposition of the right," Jesien continued, referring to the collapse of the government associated with the Solidarity democracy movement.
"Now, there's the total decomposition of the left, without any prospect that either of them can be recomposed," Jesien said.
"And third, before, we were the poor orphans of Europe. Now, we're an equal member of the all-powerful EU, but we are still poor."
In other words, there may be a touch of hypochondria to the Polish malaise. But that does not mean that the problems, especially of corruption, are imaginary. This is a country, after all, where the mayors of several towns -- and, in at least one case, almost the entirety of the municipal administration -- have been indicted or are already in prison after having been convicted of corruption of one sort or another.
Still, something seems a bit strange about the various corruption scandals and investigations. The corruption seems a bit on the petty scale, not quite worthy of a great political crisis.
In one high-level, high-visibility case, a film producer, Lew Rywin, reportedly a friend of a former prime minister, Leszek Miller, was found guilty of trying to solicit a bribe from Adam Michnik, the editor of Gazeta Wyborcza, to enable Gazeta to bid on the sale of a state-owned television station.
But, more generally, the investigations have revealed little in the way of a clear story of systematic corruption. Because of that, the investigations are beginning to take on an aspect of political theater: grand, made-for-TV gestures motivated more by the eagerness of party leaders to grab the spotlight than to use it to shed light.
"The parliament is a platform for political struggle," Jozef Gruszka, the head of one of the investigating commissions, acknowledged in an interview. "And it's hard to say that investigating commissions are completely free of political influence," Gruszka said.
The main corruption scandal has to do with the sale of Poland's biggest oil company, Orlen. This is the subject of the commission headed by Gruszka.
But he is not investigating whether bribes were paid or assets were sold off at ridiculous prices. The charge is that Orlen may have been sold to the oil giant , which comes from the country that the Poles love most to hate, Russia.
"The basic problem was that there were many conversations between the political establishment and the Russian government and parties," Roman Giertych, leader of the rightist League of Polish Families, said in a brief interview in the Polish Parliament. "It's important not only for the economy. It's a question of economic sovereignty."
The strange thing, however, is that Orlen was not actually sold to LUKoil or to any other Russian company. In other words, the biggest allegation of malfeasance in the privatization process involves an event that did not actually occur. The investigation concerns the possibility that, had it not been stopped, it might have occurred.
Here is where accounts of meetings between a Polish businessman and a supposed Russian agent come into the picture.
The businessman, Jan Kulczyk, generally referred to as Poland's richest man, met last year in Vienna with Vladimir Alganov, a Russian who is almost a household name in Poland. Alganov served in the Kremlin's embassy in Warsaw through most of the 1980s and early '90s, reportedly working for Russian intelligence.
The parliamentary commission that has been holding hearings on Orlen released a lurid Polish intelligence report on that meeting, which included unsubstantiated claims that Alganov complained to Kulczyk that Russia had not succeeded in buying Orlen even though millions of dollars in bribes were paid to Polish officials. After that, the head of Polish intelligence, Zbigniew Siemiatkowski, appeared before the commission and delivered a stark warning.
"I'm afraid that the Russian empire is being restored," he said. "Yesterday it was tanks. Today it is oil. The commissars are being replaced by politicians and businessmen."
Other prominent political figures in Poland -- former Treasury Minister Wieslaw Kaczmarek, for example -- have offered the opinion that if cash-rich Russia wants to invest in cash-poor Poland, Poland would be well advised to seize the opportunity. Ignoring that common sense, some hotter heads in Poland have been trying to stir up public anxiety about dark Russian dealings.
Giertych is among those who have been most active in drumming up Russophobia. Of course, he happens to head a nationalist party that has been picking up influence as the mainstream parties have declined.
"It's true that Poland hasn't been in such good shape since the 16th century," Marek Beylin, a commentator for Gazeta Wyborcza, said when asked about Luczywo's comment. "But we are in a deep crisis," because the political parties are trying to destroy one another.
From the Web
comments powered by Disqus
Most Read
1.
Action Star Seagal Plays Down Olympic Terrorist Threat
Action hero Steven Seagal has played down security fears ahead of the Sochi Olympics, equating the threat of terrorism with that of going out to buy a bag of sugar and getting hit by a car.
2.
A Week Before Games, Sochi Still Lacking Final Touches
With a week to go before the opening ceremony of the Sochi Winter Games, one would expect the Olympic Park to be filled with the bustle and buzz of arriving athletes, journalists and spectators.
3.
Sochi's Neighbor Abkhazia Shut Out of Olympics
When celebratory fireworks shoot across the dark Caucasian sky above Sochi on Feb. 7 for the opening ceremony of the 2014 Winter Olympics, people in the neighboring breakaway republic of Abkhazia will be able to see the glow.
4.
Obama Confident that Sochi Winter Olympics Will Be Safe
Americans hoping to go to the Winter Olympics in Sochi should not refrain from doing so out of concern for their safety, U.S. President Barack Obama said.
5.
It's Been a Bad Week for the Ruble
It has been a punishing week for the ruble, and for many, the ghosts of previous crises feel all too near. Despite the Central Bank pouring more than $1 billion a day into propping it up, the Russian currency fell 3 percent against the dollar and reached an all-time low against the euro.
1.
Action Star Seagal Plays Down Olympic Terrorist Threat
Action hero Steven Seagal has played down security fears ahead of the Sochi Olympics, equating the threat of terrorism with that of going out to buy a bag of sugar and getting hit by a car.
2.
'Peace Doves' Attacked During Pope's Ukraine Gesture
Two doves — released by the Pope in a call for peace in Ukraine — have been attacked by two larger birds, in what many interpreted as an ominous sign for the country.
3.
Yanukovych's Unlimited Stupidity
Former German Chancellor Konrad Adenauer once said, "In view of the fact that God limited the intelligence of man, it seems unfair that He did not also limit his stupidity." Every one of Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych's recent actions provides living proof of this statement.
4.
Sochi Concedes Defeat to Vancouver in Merchandise Sales
With the opening ceremony of the Sochi Games less than two weeks away, millions of licensed Olympic products have popped up on grocery store shelves, toy stores and special retail outlets across the country.
5.
Navalny Publishes Sochi Corruption Report
Whistleblower and opposition leader Alexei Navalny on Monday published an investigation into the construction of Olympic facilities in Sochi that said contracts had been repeatedly altered to inflate their cost, allowing officials to embezzle billions.
1.
What to Expect From The Year of The Horse
Many Russians love to honor the animal that symbolizes the coming year, based on the Chinese astrological calendar, believing, half-jokingly but many would insist, that it brings them luck for the next 12 months.
2.
52 Russians Shortlisted For One-Way Mission to Mars
A non-profit organization preparing a one-way manned mission to Mars has shortlisted 52 Russians among the aspiring astronauts who want to become the first settlers to live and die on the red planet.
3.
Action Star Seagal Plays Down Olympic Terrorist Threat
Action hero Steven Seagal has played down security fears ahead of the Sochi Olympics, equating the threat of terrorism with that of going out to buy a bag of sugar and getting hit by a car.
4.
Abramovich's Girlfriend Apologizes for Posing on 'Black Woman' Chair
The founder of the Garage contemporary art center, Dasha Zhukova, has stirred up controversy after being photographed sitting on a chair designed to look like a half-naked black woman.
5.
Why Russia Is No. 1 in Anti-Americanism
According to state-controlled television programs, the CIA supports Russian fascists and terrorists from the North Caucasus, and U.S. military cargo planes fly tons of heroin in to Russia from Afghanistan to turn millions of Russians into HIV-infected drug addicts, while NASA last year tried to send a meteorite to destroy the city of Chelyabinsk.
It's interesting
advertising
Moscow Directory