ON TV.com: The Girls Next Door photos
GAMES:
GameSpot
GameFAQs
MUSIC:
Last.fm
MP3.com
MOVIES:
Metacritic
Movietome
TV:
TV.com

Netbooks

Computers keep getting smaller and smaller. In the past few years the world has largely abandoned desktop PCs for laptops. Just as that transition has neared completion, notebooks got poleaxed by netbooks. We've yet to see how far the trend will go, but there's no denying that netbooks have gained tremendous popularity in the past year. These minuscule computers don't pack much in terms of horsepower or storage, but they make up for it in price. Some netbooks cost as little as $200, making them almost throwaway items. You might not be happy if your laptop bag walked away with one of them in there, but you certainly wouldn't be shedding tears.

Eee PC 1000H       So shiny       Some ports      

It should go without saying that the netbook's small screen, tiny keyboard, and anemic processor don't make it the ideal gaming machine. But if you have one for typing on the go or browsing the Web in a cafe, the option to play games certainly doesn't hurt. A game like Crysis is out of bounds, but there are plenty of games on the market that don't need computing brawn to entertain you when you're stuck in a boring class. (Not that we’d ever recommend playing games in class, of course.)

Within the netbook category you'll find a few classes of hardware. Once we toss aside screen sizes and other miscellaneous features, netbooks fall into three broad categories. The weakest netbooks on the market feature a VIA processor and graphics chip. We didn't have one on hand; but after reviewing CNET's test results, we surmised that it wouldn't be worth the effort to see what kinds of games run on them. The VIA processor is considerably slower than the ubiquitous Atom, and the Atom doesn't exactly get the juices flowing to begin with. You can find the VIA processor in older-generation netbooks, most of which aren't sold anymore.

Asus N10J       Two colors make it classy       HDMI!      

The second, and largest, category of netbooks has the 1.6GHz Atom N270 or N280 processor paired with an Intel onboard graphics solution. The onboard graphics chip truly destroys any chance of modern 3D gaming. The Eee PC 1000H we had for testing falls into this category. You'll also find some netbooks with Intel's Celeron processor paired with its onboard video solution. These netbooks cost anywhere from $250 to $600.

The final category of netbooks is the most expensive ($600-plus) and also the most capable. They have the Atom paired with a GeForce 9300M graphics chip. They are far from ideal gaming machines, but the added GPU horsepower lets them do much more than the average netbook. In the near future you should be able to find netbooks with the GeForce 9400M--and at considerably lower price points. We used the Asus N10J to represent this category.

The one thing all netbooks share is the lack of a DVD drive, which makes installing disc-based games troublesome. You could lug around a USB DVD drive, but it's certainly not convenient. Outside of Web-based games, a digital download service will easily get games onto the hard drive without any extra hardware. We tested a pile of games from our Steam account and detailed the results on the following pages.

132 Comments

  • Jessman

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 10:29 am PT

    The basic netbooks that lack in the graphic card department are still decent machines for gaming. That being said, you games better be made before 1999 in order for you to play them properly. The other good thing is that they are running XP which gets rid of that annoying "Run as Admin" or "Run in Compatability Mode" that only allows the game to run "sometimes". Some good examples of games I have installed on my netbook (Toshiba N100) include: Final Fantasy VII, Diablo 2 and Expansion, Fallout 1 and 2, Peggle, Icewind Dale, Half-Life and expansion, Counterstrike and Condition Zero

  • Jvliet

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 10:03 am PT

    Netbooks are useful machines, you can have an idea of what can be done with computers. I wish I had one. Most of them use Intel GMA 950 as a GPU. I think the biggest disadvantage of it, is the lacking hardware T&L; engine when it comes to gaming. Instead, those T&L; calculations are made by the CPU (to make the chip Vista ready, i mean Aero capable) and it is mostly Atom N270. This is another bottleneck since its performance is only half of a Pentium M 730. Still, you can play some oldie but goldie games. But you can have another problem this way, most of the old games don't support widescreen resolutions. There is a game compatibility list for Intel GMA 950 here: http://support.intel.co.jp/support/graphics/intel945gm/sb/CS-021400.htm and another for MSI Wind here http://www.mymsiwind.com/2008/08/06/msi-wind-games-list.html also, you can have a look at http://www.widescreengamingforum.com for widescreen issues.

  • trodeback

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 9:17 am PT

    It's not cost effective to buy a gaming laptop. You could get yourself the same components in a desktop for \$500-1000 less. A laptop's primary function should be business/school oriented and anything requiring major processing power needs to be in a desktop. Enough Said.

  • Maverick4Ever

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 9:11 am PT

    netbooks are a joke. I personally don't see why any person in their right mind would buy one. If you need a small form factor, buy a tablet. If you need power on the go, buy a good laptop. If you only need internet and email (which is pretty much all you will get with any quality in a netbook), then buy a blackberry or iphone.

  • klugenbeel

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 9:00 am PT

    The fact that some of these games even ran on a Asus EEE surprises the crap out of me...makes me wonder what tests and games i can run on the HP Mini-Note that i won while on vacation can run....hmm....time to bust out the old library of PC games! lol

  • lukedeutsch

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 7:56 am PT

    Laptops + Gaming = do not want

  • juztrax

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 7:43 am PT

    Ohh , yeeah lets play some games on the lil netbook. Yeeah! How awesome my netbook....and games, YEEAH!!!

  • Kiriyama12

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 7:19 am PT

    these netbooks are only for work and everyday computing, try alienware instead

  • The_Fat_Zebra

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 7:19 am PT

    why pay 650USD for a netbook that may run some recent games when 750USD will get you a laptop that will run GTA 4 at 25 fps. (HP Dv5's will do that) The plus is that the mini-screen won't blow out your eyes after a few hours. And gamespot, the 'you wont shed tears if someone steals your netbook' argument is ridiculous. If someone steals my laptop I couldn't care less about the laptop in comparison to the data that I would lose. (regardless of regular backups) In these days intellectual property is often much more valuable than physical property, as is the time wasted trying to recover from the theft of your workspace!

  • draking84

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 6:27 am PT

    I play wow on mine and diablo 2 LOL

  • GSgirl

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 5:33 am PT

    I just want them for work

  • userzero

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 3:22 am PT

    I need to try some gaming on my netbook. Though I think only very old games will work.

  • Fatal_Byte

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 3:21 am PT

    Looks like some life has been breathed back in Lords of Magic and Carnivores! If you want to go back to that I suppose. What about Half Life: Opposing Force? How well does it work on here?

  • shabulia

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 1:20 am PT

    I bouthg a netbook that I wish I could tell all that it was capable of. It's an Acer One and I absolutely love it. It has the Atom processor and 1Gb of RAM along with a nice harddrive. But I'm not sure how it performs with newer gaming. I guess I'll have to just check it out and see.

  • Maxor127

    Posted Mar 16, 2009 12:46 am PT

    I don't see the point in playing games on a POS netbook in the first place. If you're gonna pay ~\$400-500 then you may as well buy a game console or a cheap desktop computer. Unless you're really set on internet-on-the-go, then I think wasting your money on a netbook is retarded. Especially if you're buying it as a handheld gaming replacement.

  • Machineboyyy

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 11:20 pm PT

    I was considering buying a PSP for a portable gaming/media device but I changed my mind when seeing what the Asus EEE PC 900HA could do.

    It can play most pre-2005 games like GTA: San Andreas, UT2004, Half-Life 2 (with the right settings) and many more. Considering it's a fully functional PC that comes with WinXP and you can fill it up with older games much too your nostalgic delight. It only costs a bit more than a PSP and has MUCH more value.

    I don't see these netbooks as desktop replacements but as really great portable media/internet devices with decent gaming ability considering the price. The Asus N10J (that features the dedicated Nvidia graphics) is DOUBLE the price of the Asus EEE 900HA plus it's bigger and heavier. Don't get me wrong the Asus N10J is a great little device but I don't consider it a "proper" netbook being at almost \$700, netbooks are supposed to be cheap.

    P.S: I'd like to openly apologize to Gamespot for my previous post in this feature, didn't know I would breach terms of use. It won't happen again.

  • wmc540

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 10:45 pm PT

    ElPadilla they are reviewing netbooks not notebooks smart one.

  • vickersfan

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 10:32 pm PT

    the acer kills the asus btw.

  • vickersfan

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 10:28 pm PT

    i have an aspire one and i play WoW, quake 3, unreal tournament, and halo on it. they all run very well except halo can slow down a bit during really inense parts.

  • _Margulis_

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 9:55 pm PT

    You can share your desktop's DVD drive over a network like you would share a folder or hard drive. Also, I guess theoretically you could use VPN (Virtual Private Network) to connect to your home network and use that DVD drive (or hard drive if you don't mind really slow transfer speeds) if your on the go, which would be useful if the game requires the disk to play, but it's really just simpler to use a USB drive.

    Also, you can plug a full size desktop keyboard, mouse and monitor into them.

    Oh yeah, World of Warcraft will run on a toaster.

  • BVCX

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 9:11 pm PT

    LOL Crysis and this = a bomb.

  • k0r3aN_pR1d3

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 8:55 pm PT

    Yes, but will it blend?

  • fel_rossi

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 8:36 pm PT

    lol!

  • MediaMessiah

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 8:21 pm PT

    Now the question is can it run Sims 3

  • Evil-Assassinz

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 8:20 pm PT

    I just got a laptop, Dell XPS M1530 and it is really good. I only have 2 games (Fallout 3 and Crysis). My laptop can play Fallout 3 on high settings and Crysis on Medium/High settings.

  • cytheh

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 8:13 pm PT

    you know what's the biggest problem with netbook gaming? 1st, without DVD , it's hard to install a game. 2nd and most important, as the keyboard is smaller than usual keyboard, it's not easy to play. If any gamers want a laptop for game but not expensive one (since having a good desktop at home) I'd suggest you to buy a laptop like mine. Compaq. AthlonX2 (1.9Ghz) with a 8200M. It cost me 550~600 Canadian Dollar, So I guess it must be even cheaper in usa. I bought that at a Futureshop(which is a sub company of Bestbuy) so it's not like i got a cheap computer cuz it was from blackmarket or something.

    I didn't test most of the games , but Company of heroes / Opposing front works pretty well on this laptop.

  • dkdk999

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 7:49 pm PT

    like pirates the game? ya that games pretty awsome.

  • West_Side_LOgic

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 7:35 pm PT

    Im surprised that a netbook was able to run the Wrath of the Lich King expansion =O

    cool article btw.

  • lucas182

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 7:34 pm PT

    ahhhh.... Pirates!
    ...good times good times...

    whos ever gonna make a sequel to that game? one of the best ive ever played...

  • dkdk999

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 7:11 pm PT

    i dunno. psp is much smaller and you can still play emulated games for ps1,snes,genesis etc. I personally like it .

  • a_mop265

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 5:50 pm PT

    ya
    this is kinda pointless
    really i mean
    the only netbook on here that is any good for gaming cost like \$650 (the N10J)
    and for that price you can get a laptop that will work a lot better on the games if u just be smart and look around a bit
    plus
    you get a optical disc drive
    so really the cheep netbooks i get
    the other one not so much

  • enix165

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 4:23 pm PT

    Uhh...ElPadilla...they're not talking about laptops, they're talking about netbooks. The really small, cheap ones. XD But...the article's still about as informative as an 8 year old Mario-obsessed fanboy.

  • VenomRitual

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 4:18 pm PT

    they are called netbooks for a reason GS. they're not meant to play high powered games, they are meant for surfing the web, typing a word document, and playing a few media files. at the price for a top notch netbook you're already paying as much for a mid range notebook to play these games.

  • ElPadilla posted Mar 15, 2009 4:05 pm PT (does not meet display criteria. login to show)

    ElPadilla

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 4:05 pm PT (hide)

    Of all the gaming laptops they could have chosen to write about why netbooks? They aren't even close to the top of the line. If you're looking for a reasonably priced gaming laptop get the Asus G50VT notebook. It has the 9800M in it. I can run Crysis and Crysis Warhead at high settings without any problems. I also have Fallout 3, Call of Duty 4, Empire Total War, Stalker Shadows of Chernobyl, Half Life 2, Medieval II Total War Gold, and Left 4 Dead all running at their highest settings. Netbooks for gaming =fail. I got it on sale at Best Buy for \\$1200 at Christmas time. Now you can get it for about \$1000. http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=9050279&type;=product&id;=1218012519873

  • angreepirate

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 3:59 pm PT

    Wii sux

  • nickisom

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 3:42 pm PT

    My laptop is not a mini but is a cheapie! I bought from Wal-Mart for like 350 bucks before taxes. I can play lots of mmorpg's on it such as City of Heroes, WOW, Shaiya, Fiesta, Mabinogi, Megaten, Perfect World, Ethersaga online,. But i do have to turn graphics way down but still 32 bit online and with the lcd screen itself makes look pretty smooth. Equal to the wii or better since wii isn't high def.

  • leonard88

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 3:31 pm PT

    nice i want one now

  • maartenvc

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 3:22 pm PT

    laptops/netbooks/... are not made for gaming.
    some are, but most are not. (or they are very very expensive)

  • tsugantino

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 3:21 pm PT

    This was a good write up. I have to say that it's about time the new computer to have is something like a netbook. Sure you could buy a fully functional gaming rig (at 2500 dollars and up) but these are at most 400 dollar machines that let you do everything a 1500 dollar laptop will do. Sure it's without an optical drive, but like the article said there's Steam I'm sure there are others. If it were any smaller it could be an ipod killer.

  • x_Xarion_x

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 3:17 pm PT

    why bother?

  • angreepirate

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 2:45 pm PT

    the only thing notebooks are good for is being able to take them into the bathroom with you so you dont have to sign off WOW.

  • PS2to-the-end

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 2:36 pm PT

    its a waste of money. like a halfway computer. y not just get a fully loaded real thing?

  • kemar7856

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 2:35 pm PT

    these are using intergrated chips right

  • Resbang

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 2:12 pm PT

    " MrFinalFantasy"
    I guess people will never be smart enough to check the facts before posting. I am yet to see Crysis being played at 60+ fps on a desktop. Besides, is it even a big deal to have ALL the settings on ALL games maxed? What the hell has happened to gaming?

    Besides, you don't seem to know anything about laptops. It IS possible to change components. Memory is possible, CPU can be changed with knowledge and GPU can be too. Ive seen it done in many cases.

    I wish people will actually become "intellect" creatures one day.

  • Soilworker1234

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 1:58 pm PT

    definitely would not use any of these for gaming..

  • Baraq

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 1:54 pm PT

    I got the 9800M GT is mine asus and I can run crysis on high no problem.

  • MrFinalFantasy

    Posted Mar 15, 2009 1:43 pm PT

    Yeah..smaller PC's are good enough to play games that are not really new. though. try playing FPS on the move on the laptop. that'll be very difficult. well. i am sure desktop PC is still good enough. i mean. cmon. no laptops could hold a candle to Desktop PC's. try running Crysis on your laptop. if it works, then try MAX setttings. if it don't work. change your graphic cards and processors. oh yeah! i forget. you can't on a laptop.

Feature Navigation

advertisement