Ed Gibbs

Ed Gibbs

Agrees with the Tomatometer 78% of the time.

Biography:
Ed Gibbs has been a film and music critic for over 15 years, both in London and Sydney. A film fanatic since childhood, he studied film in Scotland and the US (while running a cinema club, for good measure). As a magazine editor, events programmer and media consultant, he was instrumental in relaunching leading mastheads for the Australian market, including GQ, having cut his teeth in London across industry titles. Now a popular mainstay on the international festival circuit, he writes and broadcasts for The Sun-Herald and The Sunday Age (as their resident film critic); their daily counterparts The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age; film bible Empire; its musical cousin Rolling Stone; various news outlets in London (The Guardian, The Independent), as well as media in the Middle East and beyond. A regular voice on television and radio, he?s also currently working across a number of original features, shorts and documentary projects for TV and theatrical release.
Publications:
Empire Magazine , Empire Magazine Australasia , Guardian [UK] , Rotten Tomatoes , Sydney Morning Herald , The Age (Australia) , The National , The Sun Herald , The Sunday Age
Total Reviews:
226

Listing Of All Reviews & Articles

Showing 1 - 50 of 226
Previous | Next
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
3/5 74% Lee Daniels' The Butler (2013) " A self-conscious, would-be historical drama that's too distracted by star cameos and domestic strife to be truly effective. " — The Sunday Age
Posted Oct 27, 2013
7/10 86% Alan Partridge: Alpha Papa " It's all done with far more heart than one would expect. Perhaps Coogan, like Partridge, is now mellowing with age. Whatever next: grandkids? " — The Sun Herald
Posted Oct 20, 2013
5/5 95% Blancanieves (2013) " An absolute delight: a thrillingly unpredictable romp that entertains with joyful and mischievous abandon." — The Sunday Age
Posted Oct 20, 2013
8/10 81% Prisoners (2013) " Not since Erskineville Kings, in 1999, has Hugh Jackman appeared so emotionally exposed on screen. It is an exceptional, Oscar-worthy performance." — The Sun Herald
Posted Oct 13, 2013
4/5 64% 2 Guns (2013) " Kormakur and his merry cast blast their way through an absurdly silly and very funny comedy of errors, as one defence service inadvertently wages war on another." — The Sunday Age
Posted Oct 6, 2013
8/10 88% Rush (2013) " A thrilling, adrenalin-fuelled ride that recreates 1970s track-side action with aplomb." — The Sun Herald
Posted Sep 29, 2013
3.5/5 54% Lovelace (2013) " As good as it is, Lovelace oddly avoids further illuminating Boreman, beyond what we already know." — The Sunday Age
Posted Sep 22, 2013
6/10 91% The Turning " A tighter adaptation of Winton's book, helmed by one, possibly two filmmakers, would have sufficed. As a collective, it feels weighed down by its own remit. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Sep 22, 2013
2/5 7% Diana (2013) " Neither as dreadful as some would claim nor as poignant as it would like to be, Diana skirts the surface of a complex figure while trying to keep all parties at bay." — Sydney Morning Herald
Posted Sep 19, 2013
2/5 47% I'm So Excited! (2013) " The setting acts as a bland backdrop without substance or thought. Worst of all, the dialogue feels horribly contrived, even lazy. A misguided misfire." — The Sunday Age
Posted Sep 15, 2013
6/10 50% White House Down (2013) " Foxx and Tatum offer an effective buddy pairing lacking from the similarly preposterous Olympus Has Fallen." — The Sun Herald
Posted Sep 8, 2013
2/5 67% Mood Indigo " A surrealist pastiche that's too clever (or enthusiastic) for its own good." — The Sunday Age
Posted Sep 8, 2013
4/10 4% Paranoia (2013) " This boardroom blackmail romp feels as contrived and silly as anything Luketic has helmed in recent years." — The Sun Herald
Posted Sep 1, 2013
4/5 69% Stoker (2013) " Her elder co-stars may lead this psychological mind dance with ease, but it is Mia Wasikowska who astounds the most." — The Sunday Age
Posted Aug 25, 2013
8/10 75% You're Next (2013) " Sharni Vinson kicks some serious butt, in this very watchable horror romp from Adam Wingard. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Aug 25, 2013
4/5 100% The Rocket (2013) " A hugely enjoyable, thoroughly infectious feature debut." — The Sunday Age
Posted Aug 25, 2013
6/10 68% Elysium (2013) " Damon is, as ever, thoroughly watchable but given its predecessor's smarts, Elysium fails to capture District 9's spirit or sense of originality and wonder." — The Sun Herald
Posted Aug 18, 2013
4/5 100% Red Obsession (2013) " The film, which premiered at Robert De Niro's Tribeca Film Festival in New York, proves remarkably enlightening." — The Sunday Age
Posted Aug 11, 2013
8/10 90% Beyond The Hills (2013) " Mungiu has crafted an alarming and engaging real-life horror story, based on a 2005 case of exorcism. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Aug 11, 2013
2.5/5 60% The Bling Ring (2013) " The Bling Ring suggests Coppola still has the nose for a good story, but not the depth to sufficiently explore it." — The Sunday Age
Posted Aug 4, 2013
6/10 50% Pain & Gain (2013) " A fascinating yarn that could have provided for stunning story fodder. Thanks to spirited turns from his three leads, Michael Bay just about gets away with it. But only just." — The Sun Herald
Posted Aug 4, 2013
8/10 87% 100 Bloody Acres (2013) " A wickedly funny romp that heralds the arrival of some seriously fiendish talent." — The Sun Herald
Posted Jul 28, 2013
2.5/5 85% The Way Way Back (2013) " Aside from Carell's limited turn at doing nasty, it all feels terribly familiar, in a half-baked, Little Miss Sunshine-lite sort of way." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jul 28, 2013
8/10 95% Behind the Candelabra (2013) " Its raison d'etre is a terrifically spirited performance from Hollywood's most heterosexual of Lotharios, Michael Douglas, aided and abetted by Damon and Lowe." — The Sun Herald
Posted Jul 21, 2013
4/5 40% Only God Forgives (2013) " Outrageous and shocking to its core, the film, perhaps aptly, feels like some wayward younger sibling to its more accessible and commercial predecessor." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jul 13, 2013
7/10 84% Much Ado About Nothing (2013) " A self-contained, astutely executed project, with Whedon's old guard giving their all for the sheer joy of performance. Great fun." — The Sun Herald
Posted Jul 7, 2013
3/5 79% Reality (2013) " Garrone has confounded expectations with this light, Fellini-esque send-up of reality television and the celebrity it has spawned." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jul 7, 2013
8/10 93% We Steal Secrets: The Story Of Wikileaks (2013) " Alex Gibney's film is an absorbing examination of the world's most infamous information portal." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jun 30, 2013
2/5 44% To The Wonder (2013) " Terrence Malick's vague, sweeping ode to love lost and found is anything but wondrous." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jun 30, 2013
6/10 56% The Look of Love (2013) " Far from the swinging '60s or sleazy '70s so often portrayed with glee on screen, the London of Paul Raymond's world feels grim, dark and, ultimately, devoid of passion." — The Sun Herald
Posted Jun 23, 2013
3.5/5 —— Satellite Boy " McKenzie does well to emphasise the cultural impact of modern Australia on the lives of its original settlers, while wisely avoiding political grandstanding. " — The Sunday Age
Posted Jun 16, 2013
5/10 78% Monsters University (2013) " The Pixar themes may be present and correct, but its values are sorely lacking. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Jun 16, 2013
3/5 35% The Internship (2013) " Wilson elicits a stronger turn from Vaughn than we've seen for some time. The results are surprisingly engaging and endearing." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jun 9, 2013
1/5 10% A Haunted House (2013) " A painfully unfunny, overly familiar send-up of recent horror franchises." — The Sun Herald
Posted Jun 2, 2013
3/5 63% Sinister (2012) " Hawke brings a gravitas to the role of parent and home protector that is of far greater interest than the film itself." — The Sunday Age
Posted Jun 2, 2013
2/5 49% The Great Gatsby (2013) " Luhrmann understandably wants his Gatsby to be great, but he has inadvertently reminded us that the Great American Novel belongs precisely where it was born: on the page." — The Age (Australia)
Posted May 23, 2013
6/10 58% Stuck in Love (2013) " A sweet tale of love, loss and life with solid performances from a first-rate cast." — The Sunday Age
Posted May 19, 2013
2.5/5 33% The Odd Life of Timothy Green (2012) " As odd as the title suggests, this is a strange and dreadfully overwrought family yarn." — The Sunday Age
Posted May 19, 2013
5/10 44% The Call (2013) " A tense psychological chiller that ratchets up the tension before collapsing with a predictable finale." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 12, 2013
4/5 83% The Place Beyond The Pines (2013) " Gosling delivers his most assured performance yet, in an ambitious, near-operatic drama-thriller that boldly unfolds across two distinctly different hours." — The Sunday Age
Posted May 5, 2013
8/10 66% Spring Breakers (2013) " Parents will look on with dismay; others will leave feeling bemused but thoroughly entertained." — The Sun Herald
Posted May 5, 2013
8/10 79% Iron Man 3 (2013) " An outrageously entertaining, CGI-soaked tale of foreboding that transforms into a good-natured send-up of everything that proceeded it, replete with gags galore." — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 28, 2013
3.5/5 64% Unfinished Song (2013) " Terence Stamp is terrific as the grumpy Arthur, while Vanessa Redgrave embodies the ailing figure of Marion with a gravitas one would expect." — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 21, 2013
7/10 68% Haute Cuisine (2013) " A whimsical view of the woman who fuelled the corridors of power in France with culinary common sense." — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 21, 2013
3/5 54% Oblivion (2013) " Joseph Kosinski's ode to classic 1970s sci-fi lacks serious tension, but does offer visual flair and elegance, with a typically arresting performance from Andrea Riseborough." — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 14, 2013
6/10 81% Warm Bodies (2013) " An occasionally funny romantic zombie comedy (or rom-zom-com) that offers a fresh twist on Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet." — The Sun Herald
Posted Apr 7, 2013
3/5 52% Thérèse (2013) " A respectable swansong for the late Claude Miller, who passed away just weeks before it premiered at Cannes. " — The Sunday Age
Posted Apr 7, 2013
6/10 69% Trance (2013) " A hugely entertaining but dreadfully convoluted crime romp, in which logic flies out the door as wandering illusions of the mind take hold. " — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 31, 2013
4/5 98% Mea Maxima Culpa: Silence In The House Of God (2012) " A heartbreaking, brilliantly executed exposé, in which four deaf victims bring the church to account. Their testimonies are chilling. " — The Sunday Age
Posted Mar 24, 2013
7/10 70% The Loneliest Planet (2012) " Scoring a popular hit on the film festival circuit, director Julia Loktev elicits superb performances from a minimal cast." — The Sun Herald
Posted Mar 24, 2013
Showing 1 - 50 of 226
Previous | Next
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | Press | API | Licensing | Mobile