Note: You are viewing the unstyled version of CBC.ca because you can not see our css files, or because you do not have a standards-compliant browser or you are a mobile user.

Welcome to CBC.ca


CBC News: the fifth estate - More about the fifth estatesubscribe to our e-mail newslettercontact us
The Steven Truscott Story: Moment of Truth
Originally aired:
March 20, 2000


Repeating:
Tuesday August 28 at
10pm ET/PT
on CBC Newsworld

WATCH the fifth estate ONLINE:

Runs 38:00
REPORTER: Linden MacIntyre
PRODUCER
: Theresa Burke
Video available in Windows Media Player.

WEB EXCLUSIVE:
Sgt. Kalichuk
the fifth estate uncovers evidence that a possible suspect was never investigated by the OPP. more
THE STEVEN TRUSCOTT STORY: MOMENT OF TRUTH

Lynne Harper
Twelve year-old Lynne Harper was found dead June 11, 1959.
On September 30, 1959, it took a jury less than six hours to decide that a 14 year-old boy had raped and then murdered a 12 year-old schoolmate.

A murder, almost 50 years ago
The girl was Lynne Harper. The boy was Steven Truscott. That verdict, and a judge's sentence of death by hanging, would propel Truscott into the history books; as the youngest person ever sentenced to hang in this country and, as many Canadians came to believe, the victim of a gross miscarriage of justice. The story of Lynn Harper's murder and Steven Truscott's trial would continue to haunt Canada long after his sentence was commuted and long after he left prison to lead a life of anonymity under an assumed name.

It was a hot, muggy evening on June 9, 1959 when Truscott gave his classmate, Lynne Harper, a lift on his bicycle near an air force base outside Clinton, Ontario. Two days later, searchers found the girl's body in a wooded grove near the base. The murder and the quick arrest, trial and sentencing of Truscott made the case immediately controversial.

book
Isabel LeBourdais's book was published in 1966.
A controversial case
He had his defenders, foremost among them Isabel LeBourdais who, in 1966, wrote The Trial of Steven Truscott, a book that attacked the police investigation and the 15-day trial. The book created a furious public debate and a Supreme Court review was ordered. But, the verdict was upheld and Truscott continued to serve his sentence behind bars.

A fresh start and new hope for a cleared name
In October, 1969, with a spotless ten-year prison record, he was released on parole. He took a new name and began life again in Guelph, Ontario where he worked as a millwright, married and raised three children. And there he lived, anonymously, until March, 2000 when the fifth estate broadcast a documentary about his case with new evidence showing that police case was incomplete, at best and that evidence and testimony that should have been heard at the trial, was not.

Since that documentary was broadcast, the public clamour to have Steven Truscott's name cleared, has grown. His case was taken up by the Association in Defence of the Wrongfully Convicted. In 2004, then Justice Minister Irwin Cotler, referred it to the Ontario Court of Appeal. And that's where the final chapter of the legal story of Steven Truscott will begin on January 31, 2007 and, sometime after that, the moment of truth will arrive.