Quantcast
Review: Fate/EXTRA - Destructoid
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist
New? Take a tour   |   Suggestions   |   Themes:   Aah   Ohh   Foe

games originals community video shop xbox360 ps3 wii u pc 3ds psvita iphone android

Review: Fate/EXTRA

Wesley Ruscher
2:00 PM on 12.21.2011
Review: Fate/EXTRA photo


The PSP, along with the DS, has sort of been a last haven for Japanese RPGs. Companies like Atlus, XSEED, and Aksys Games have kept these handhelds, as well as the abovementioned genre, alive by continuing to feed American gamers with some its best experiences -- even in the wake of their demise.

Nintendo has moved on to the 3DS, and Sony's portable powerhouse, the Vita, is only a few short months away. It's an exciting time for gaming on-the-go, but as the anticipation climaxes, it doesn't mean we should forget about the systems that are still here; still breathing. Aksys Games hasn't forgotten and Fate/EXTRA, their latest endeavor, is an example of how these systems continue to pump out worthwhile experiences.

Fate/EXTRA (PlayStation Portable)
Developer: Type-Moon, ImageEpoch
Publisher: Aksys Games
Release date: November 1, 2011
MSRP: $29.99, ($39.99 Limited Edition)

The Fate universe has had a somewhat limited existence in the U.S. Personally, my familiarity extends to having watched the Fate/stay night anime series (which ironically enough is based off its visual novel) and casually knowing of the PSP fighter: Fate/unlimited codes. I thoroughly enjoyed the anime though, so the idea of playing a Fate influenced RPG, set in parallel universe from Image-Epoch no less, quickly intrigued me.

The world of Fate/EXTRA opens up amongst the confines of Tsukumihara Academy -- which serves as the games main hub. As a student, you attend class, converse with students, and even investigate (as a school reporter) rumors pertaining to the strange supernatural occurrences that have been happening on campus. It's in this introduction -- which is quite long --  that the realization is made that this game is more than your typical RPG and in fact, at times, actually more like a visual novel. Then again, from the warning message that proceeds the beginning of the game -- alerting players about the potential of dead ends -- I should have been ready for that twist.

Because of its ties to its visual novel past , Fate/EXTRA is a very text heavy endeavor. While the Japanese audio is left in (voiced by many of the original Fate/stay night's performers) not all of the dialog in the game is spoken. Luckily the game benefits from having one of the best written localizations I have read in quite some time -- which makes the semi-lethargic pace of the introduction tolerable. It's a strange and bewildering ride into the game's main narrative, but once the opening events unfold and set up the proceedings for the next Holy Grail War, Fate/EXTRA begins to shine as a unique RPG experience for the PSP. There's a very Persona 3-light feeling given off at first (in terms of aesthetics and some mechanics) but as the hours begin to melt away it becomes ever apparent that this is a beast all of its own.

Once the intro is complete, players will be given the chance to chose one of three different servants to use through the games adventure: Saber, Archer, and Caster as well as decide the protagonists gender. The Saber class is your typical up-close melee fighter, the Archer is best for ranged combat, and the Caster is best with magical abilities. I went with Saber in my play through -- as I wanted to make my experience as close to the anime as possible -- but choosing any of the other classes not only affects the games difficulty, but also the way the story unfolds. With each servant housing their own unique personality, I really appreciate the fact that not every player will experience the same journey to the end.

As the main narrative unfolds, you find yourself in a strange virtual world -- identically resembling Tsukumihara Academy -- and as part of the Holy Grail War. A tournament, to the death, for the fabled artifact of legend that will grant the winner their deepest desire. With no recollection of your past, winning the tournament is a must as failure results in death in the real world. It's a simple motivation to compel one to fight, but eventually the desire to know oneself -- a brilliant dissection of the human psyche by the writers of Fate/EXTRA -- serves as ample incentive to press on, even when the combat begins to fall mundane.

For the most part though the battle system is as much fun as it is a test of mental capacity. Each round, a new opponent is selected, and a week's preparation time is given before the fight. Preparation for each battle unfolds in two ways: gaining strength in the arena by fighting enemies; and by collecting tactical data on the opponent to figure out their true identity. If you are familiar with the Fate franchise, then you will know that every enemy servant in the series is actually a famous warrior -- real or mythological -- and thus contains the weaknesses of that person. This is definitely Fate/EXTRA's strong point, as the process of collecting data on each servant further showcases the excellent localization and helps move the story forward.

Acquiring as much information, as possible, may be the single most important aspect for a servant battle. The more one knows, the easier their attacks are to predict with the game's very simple rock-paper-scissor battle system. There are three basic moves: attack, block, and break ;which when planned accordingly will counter an enemy's move and negate any possible damage received. Outside of the servant battles, regular enemy fights move quite quickly once a foe's pattern is discovered. Combat is very enjoyable in Fate/Extra, but with only one character in your party and a very limited amount of adversaries per arena, they can become slightly tedious overtime. Thankfully, battles are not random -- allowing them to be dodged with a little skill -- but when you're making your third of fourth trip through an arena that looks practically identical to the last one, the game can begin to drag.

Unfortunately, a slow pace is Fate/EXTRA's biggest problem. While the game has a very eclectic and well written cast of characters, it finds itself basically repeating the same process over and over through the tournament: receive a new opponent, fight and level up in the arena, and collect enough information to have the tactical advantage. While some servants mix up the way you progress through the arena (setting poison traps or having treasure hunt missions) it all begins to feel the same after around the fourth round of competition, which is a shame considering how interesting the narrative is.

Visually though, the game looks very sharp. The characters models and art all look strikingly accurate and really capture the games anime essence, especially in combat. In fact combat, has some of the best looking visuals I've seen in a PSP game. Sadly the environments -- the arena and Tsukumihara Academy -- are fairly plain and devoid of any real presence. Fate/EXTRA's music is enjoyable, for the most part, but with the story revolving around the same few areas, the music finds itself essentially on repeat. It fits well, but like the rest of the game will make you feel like Bill Murray in Ground Hog's Day.

Aksys Games nailed the localization with Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors and they've done it again with the excellent writing in Fate/EXTRA. Unfortunately, a sea of monotony and repetitiveness plagues the game's potential for being one of the PSP's elite RPG's. While mechanically a solid experience from start to finish, it's a hard pill to swallow for anyone other than fans of the property or those looking for a little visual novel in their RPG. Regardless, if you are seeking an adventure that brings a little more to the table in the story department and don't mind the trek through 40 plus hours of gameplay, Fate/Extra, in the end, might just be what you are looking for.



THE VERDICT


7.0 /10
Good: A solid game that definitely has an audience. Might lack replay value, could be too short or there are some hard-to-ignore faults, but the experience is fun. Check out more reviews or the Destructoid score guide.





Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


Great review! Hmm I was thinking about getting this game seeing as how many people compared it to Persona 3 but my main concern was with it's battle system, it seemed so repeatative and it seems I was right. Still I may give it a shot should it ever drop in price.
I really do need to try the VN and this game. It looks interesting enough.
I'm enjoying playing this game a lot, but I'm a little worried about missing a clue; I had to try the first boss like four times even with all the information, and now I'm paranoid that if I miss a single clue I'm going to have to start the whole week over again. Which I guess could be worse with multiple saves, but given how long a week is and how many PSP games I have to play (PSP haz no games lol) is making me a little mental about making sure I get all of them.
Awesome review Wes! Need to get some action for me
I'm at the... fourth master(been a couple of weeks since I last played.)
I love it, but I know it isn't for everyone.
@Evk

Bosses can be a real pain if you miss any clues, but that's not even half as bad as trying to rush through the arena. In my haste there were a few times I got crushed by regular enemies because I forgot their patterns.

I really should give the game a go as a Caster though, heard that shi@t is hardcore.
I liked Fate/Stay Night, but I don't get why they keep milking this franchise.
Almost has that persona feel where you can choose to either train and level up or (in persona) create relationships to gain power / or (in fate) study clues to prepare and get ready ... may have to check this one out
30 bucks sounds like sweet price for this. Glad that's the msrp for the non LE.

I really love playing RPGs on the go and IMO PSP is the best place for it.
Umu! I played this non stop until corpse party came out.
The Fate/stay night anime was a terrible adaptation of the Visual Novel. You are missing pretty much all of the story and character development by only watching it. The original VN had three routes and the anime largely ignored the better two. Anyone who has an interest in Fate should read the VN before getting into all these adaptations, spin-offs, and sequels. Although the Fate/Zero anime is great so far.
You are so glad that there aren't a lot of type moon fans on this site or they would murder you. Other than that the game looks interesting since the caster run looks really hardcore.
It sounds very similar to Infinite Space to me...where the game is well written and enjoyable but it has kind of a blah rock-paper-scissors battle system. Probably pick this up some time soon.
another must have games on PSP.

does it have a PSN version????
Terrible horrible no-good very bad franchise with horrible characters and an awful, stupid story. This game deserves absolutely zero attention, you guys disappoint me. I seriously hate the blonde bitch on all the promotional stuff for the franchise, cannot stand that stupid whore.




Bethesda announces The Elder Scrolls Online beta signups

Bethesda has just let us know that beta signups are happening right now for The Elder Scrolls Online. All you have to do is go to www.ElderScrollsOnline.com, sign up, and you'll have a chance to get in. All of the detai...   more

Bethesda announces The Elder Scrolls Online beta signups photo

Here's 2,000 codes for the Defiance beta!

Our friends at Trion Worlds have hooked up Dtoid with 2,000 closed beta codes for their upcoming MMO shooter Defiance! If you recall, this game isn't just based on the upcoming Syfy TV series, it's part of it. Talk ...   more

Here's 2,000 codes for the Defiance beta! photo

The DTOID Show: Killer Is Dead, Revengeance & SimCity

Hey gang, The Destructoid Show wasn't live today, because our producer Zac has his fingers cut off for failing at his Yakuza duties. Er. He cut his hand by accident. Something, I forget.   Today, we discuss the possibili...   more

The DTOID Show: Killer Is Dead, Revengeance & SimCity photo

There will be a Survarium beta before the end of 2013

Despite my sadness that S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 may never happen, Vostok Games' MMOFPS Survarium might just fill that void. In a blog post today, the developers outlined the timeline they are aiming for and when players can get earl...   more

 There will be a Survarium beta before the end of 2013 photo

Warface closed beta opens ahead of full launch in spring

Trion Worlds and Crytek have kicked first-person shooter Warface into gear, announcing that the free-to-play game's servers are now operational for the closed beta. Amusingly, the "social entertainment platform" powering Warf...   more

Warface closed beta opens ahead of full launch in spring photo

CCP will roll out the Dust 514 open beta next week

After being available in closed beta for some time now on PlayStation 3, Dust 514 will be entering open beta on January 22, 2013, CCP Games announced today. And the timing couldn't be better. Arguably the most interesting asp...   more

CCP will roll out the Dust 514 open beta next week photo

Path of Exile opens its doors to the masses

Crowdfunded action-RPG Path of Exile is about to finish up its closed beta phase. Come January 23, it will be in open beta. On top of this, the third act of the game will also be unveiled, and will see players explore the doc...   more

Path of Exile opens its doors to the masses  photo

Sign up for the Final Fantasy XIV beta

Square Enix is nearing the re-release of Final Fantasy XIV and have opened up beta applications in preparations for the launch. Users can sign up for US or European accounts, and for either the PlayStation 3 or PC versions. ...   more

Sign up for the Final Fantasy XIV beta photo

Trion Worlds opens sign-ups for Defiance beta

Trion Worlds has a lot to prove with Defiance, its massively multiplayer online shooter which also happens to be an upcoming television show on SyFy. The studio will be running a brief "Advanced Mission Beta 1" this month, gi...   more

Trion Worlds opens sign-ups for Defiance beta photo

StarCraft II: Heart of the Swarm beta adds pre-purchasers

Ahead of the full release this March, StarCraft II: Heart of the Swarm has expanded its beta to include people who pre-purchased a digital copy of the expansion on Battle.net on or before December 18. If that describes you, b...   more

StarCraft II: Heart of the Swarm beta adds pre-purchasers photo


Back to Top




Advertising on destructoid is available through Please contact them to learn more