Quantcast
Review: Kirby's Dream Collection - Destructoid
DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist
New? Take a tour   |   Suggestions   |   Themes:   Aah   Ohh   Foe

games originals community video shop xbox360 ps3 wii u pc 3ds psvita iphone android

Review: Kirby's Dream Collection

Jim Sterling, Reviews Editor
5:00 PM on 09.19.2012
Review: Kirby's Dream Collection photo


My love of Kirby is known far and wide. While the games themselves are incredibly simple, the sheer charm of the titular hero and his colorful world makes for endearing, unforgettable adventures. Kirby has also seen some of the most dramatic changes of any Nintendo franchise -- from the total visual overhaul in Epic Yarn to the ten-Kirby puzzling of Mass Attack, it's a series that's not afraid to be different.

The spherical warrior celebrates his 20th anniversary this year, and Nintendo has not forgotten. Kirby's Dream Collection is a lovingly crafted look back on the publisher's underdog hero, packed with games, memories, and even a cartoon or two. It's also better than anything Nintendo did for Mario's anniversary.

That was a surprise.

Kirby's Dream Collection (Wii)
Developer: HAL Laboratory, Nintendo
Publisher: Nintendo
Release: September 16, 2012
MSRP: $39.99

Kirby's Dream Collection contains six of the bigger titles in the series, culled from the its 20-year span. Kirby's Dream Land, Kirby's Adventure, Kirby's Dream Land 2, Kirby Super Star, Kirby's Dream Land 3, and Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards are brought together in one package, selectable from an easy-to-navigate but cheerfully animated menu screen. Each game is faithfully represented, so there are no enhancements to the experiences -- they are as they were.

The two Game Boy games are probably the most dated, but they still manage to be fun and are worth having as essential curios, the same being said of Kirby's Adventure. Though enjoyable, these don't quite hold up to today's standards. Most players will find themselves tiring of them fairly quickly, but they're worth at least dipping into now and again.

Kirby's Dream Land 3, however, is still great. While the ability to team up with weird characters to further enhance Kirby's powers debuted in Dream Land 2, the SNES sequel is where it really shines, with six odd creatures to recruit. Experimenting to see how Kirby's different copy abilities work when he's being rolled by a cat or carried by an owl is just as joyous as it ever was. Ultimately, it's a solid SNES game in which you can spend half your time wearing a living fish like a big bouncing suit. There is no more compelling an experience.

Kirby Super Star is something of a letdown, as Dream Collection uses the original SNES version and not the enhanced, superior version known as Kirby Super Star Ultra on Nintendo DS. While the original has historical worth, it's simply not as good as the portable remake and isn't worth playing if you already have the updated alternative. The Crystal Shards is a fun enough Nintendo 64 game, and probably the highlight of the collection based on its size in comparison to the other titles. It's also one of the weirder games in the series, featuring a range of creative boss fights against possessed creatures and the power to absorb two copy abilities to create all-new attacks -- something I wish had been made more of a series staple, since it's brilliant.

The six classic titles offer a nice look back at several highlights of Kirby's career, but I feel that Nintendo missed a trick by not including some of the more obscure spin-offs. Games like the golf-inspired Kirby's Dream Course, Kirby's Pinball Land, or even 2003's Air Ride would have been fine examples of just how varied and experimental the series has been over the years. The included games are all solid looks at more traditional platformers, but Kirby has had so many odd adventures in the past two decades that I'd have preferred to have seen a few more of his stranger outings.

In addition to the classic games, there is an all-new series of special challenge levels based on 2011's Return to Dream Land. These timed tests give Kirby one predetermined copy ability and challenge him to get to the end of the stage while killing enemies and destroying blocks to accrue as high a score as possible, and taking damage will naturally incur a points penalty. At the end of each series of challenges, players can take on Magalor in platform races inspired by Super Star's Gourmet Race courses.

While not a selling point on its own, the challenge mode is a very welcome addition. It's great to see some original content go into a collection like this; the designers didn't get lazy with it, ensuring the courses are quite inventive and uniquely tailored to challenge one's skill with each copy ability. It serves as the perfect distraction when playing through the classics becomes a bit tiring.

By far the highlight of the package is the interactive timeline. Spanning from 1992 to 2012, players can move Kirby along a path littered with trophies and games. Each year contains a window full of fun facts and historical tidbits, charting the election of Bill Clinton, the dates of each of the Olympic Games, and each of Nintendo's console releases. Every game in Kirby's library has its own specific page full of details, gameplay footage, and interactive box art. This is also where users can find three full episodes of the amusing (and incredibly silly) anime Kirby: Right Back At Ya! The theme tune is still far too catchy, and King Dedede still needs A MONSTAH TO CLOBBAH DAT DERE KIRBEH!

The Limited Edition also contains a soundtrack and a collectible book -- neither of which are mind-blowing enough to be worth it to the casual admirer but should certainly be enjoyed by fans. The book is particularly adorable and stuffed with all sorts of interesting information and concept art. The soundtrack takes 42 tunes from across Kirby's game library, and includes a further three bonus tunes, exclusively arranged by HAL Laboratory's sound staff. 

Presentation is everything, and it just wouldn't be right if a Kirby collection was full of drab, sparse menus. Everything is animated, brimming with life, and packed with music. From the timeline to the simple game selections, Dream Collection goes all out in making sure every inch of the screen is energetic. Any game that doesn't have a save feature can remember your progress upon quitting, and one can easily return to the main menu from any game by hitting the Home button and taking the reset option (which won't reset the entire collection). Too many collections overlook the ability to easily quit out of a game, so it's a very welcome feature.

As a hardcore lover of the Kirby series, I doubt any collection could find the right balance of mainstream and obscure titles to satisfy me, but Nintendo and HAL Laboratory have at least done a very admirable job of paying tribute to the pink puffball with genuine affection. The classic games aren't quite the selections I'd have made, but they're all worth checking out, and when combined with the extra content, they become one of the better anniversary packages out there. Kirby fans would be foolish to pass it up, while non-fans will get six good games and a lot of fun silliness for their dime. Can't argue with a deal like that!



THE VERDICT


8.0 /10
Great: Impressive efforts with a few noticeable problems holding it back. Won't astound everyone, but is worth your time and cash. Check out more reviews or the Destructoid score guide.





Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


I still need to play epic yarn
sterling is my pink fluffy ball who sucks things up

In this scenario Id be metaknight.
Well, when I was 16 I broke my arm when I fell off the roof of my house, beat that Mount Everest climbing kid!

Oh right Kirby....neat.
FINALLY a reason to play my wii...for once
When i do finally pick up a wii it will be for games like this. But they're still not cheap enough for my liking :P
oh please don't be a limited run T___T

will get this, but too many games still need to get :P

will check it out :)
My copy should be arriving next week. After spending most of my time on my Wii this year going through a JRPG sugar rush, it'll be nice to play some games where I don't have to worry about stats and leveling.
Its sad that Nintendo fail at compling a few of their old roms onto a disc, when tons of pirates could probably do a better job.
This is never coming to Europe, isn't it -_-
Figured it would get an 8. Not a bad score at all to me. Still gotta pick up Epic Yarn for the girlfriend and me.
"The classic games aren't quite the selections I'd have made"
What would be your selection?

The NES game is still very good I think, unlike the Game Boy games.
Jim I love you almost as much as I love Kirby. And I love a Kirby a whole freaking lot.

I agree with you on the obscure title point- even though I'm a fairly big Kirby dude, there's some games I've just not had the chance to play. They could've included Tilt 'n Tumble, for example, emulating the Gameboy with the Wii remote. I still plan to get this, though, because I'd like to play Kirby's Dream Land 3 with the Wii Remote on its side.

Actually, that's a good question- how are the controls mapped for the two SNES games? Switching between them and the other Kirby games is annoying and awkward because the VC controls are awkwardly mapped. It could be a problem with the original games themselves, but it'd be nice if they were brought more in line with the rest of the series to ease the transition.
i recently pulled out the GB kirby, and totally forgot it was the first one and you couldnt even absorb powers yet. and it was so damn easy just fly over everything.

then i went and started playing DL3 again. man i forgot how hard it was to figure out those stupid "heart" events. but they are still very easy.
I like this selection, as it's technically the first six non-spinoff entries in the series. Plus Kirby All-Star is amazing even outside of the DS package.

Still, it would have been nice to throw in a few games they didn't have on the eShop -- like Tilt 'N Tumble, or maybe Star Stacker outside of Japan.
Sounds good.

Now, where's the Metroid anniversary collection, Nintendo.
It still isn't announced for the UK :/ I doubt we're getting it at all.
No Kirby's Air Ride?

BOOO -throws can-
It was nice of Nintendo to throw these classic Kirby games in with my Challenge rooms.
Not sure I can justify the purchase at the moment. Especially considering they omitted Kirby's Dream Course, which was probably my favorite Kirby game. Hope it does well, though.
I have loved Kirby since I first got kirbys pinball on my gameboy....yeah I played that before anything elese but this looks awesome!
@Marche100 The Wii already has a Metroid compilation, remember?
Ugh, my preorder still hasn't shipped from Amazon. I want to replay these games, Kirby's Adventure in particular, so bad. It's good to hear they put more effort into this than the Mario collection. I would have loved The Amazing Mirror to be present (especially with that interrupt save feature), but at least they covered all the core games.
If anyone was to review the Kirby Collection, it had to be Jim Sterling, the pink, fat, lovable bastard that he is.
This disc is literally the epitome of how an anniversary collection of ANYTHING should be done.
I've only given the time of day to epic yarn, so I look forward to getting my hands on this collection.
This collection is very cool. It has increased my interest and love of Kirby quite a bit. It definitely could have used a few more games, and i wouldn't have minded even paying more to have a couple more games packed in, but for what you get for $40, its a lovely little item to have.
The best Kirby Games:

1. Kirby 64
2. Kirby's Dreamland 3
3. Kirby's Dreamland 2

Plus, three more games. Can't go wrong with this.
Definitely getting this, though Epic Yarn was my favourite.
Also, please, PLEASE review Harry Potter for Kinect, Jim. ALL SENIOR EDITORS: MAKE JIM REVIEW HARRY POTTER FOR KINECT... please
@Salnax

Yeah, that's great, except that just compiled the Metroid Prime trilogy. That, and it was released 3 years ago. Far from the anniversary of Metroid. And it was discontinued. So, it's not at all what I'm talking about.

Zelda got Skyward Sword for its anniversary. Mario got a nice little Wii compilation for its anniversary. So did Kirby. Metroid didn't even get a passing glance.

Of course, it's all too late, now, but I'm still bitter about it. Nintendo just does not care for Metroid like it does any of its other franchises (barring some, like Star Fox and F-Zero and so on, but those aren't really big franchises in the first place), and it saddens me.
...wait, did you just blow off Kirby's Adventure as if it were a mere Game Boy game? Kirby's Adventure is amazing, thank you very much. *laughs*

But in all seriousness, I agree that it would have been nice to have some of the non-platformer Kirby games included just to show the diversity of what he's been in. Even small games like Kirby's Pinball Land and Kirby's Block Ball would have been nice.
Got this for 30 bucks at Fry's! Excellent value. I agree that another game or two (I have a soft spot for Pinball Land) would have been nice but it's hard to really complain, given all the great extras. Absolutely better than the Mario anniversary collection.
@Stealth is definitely an internet meta knight

Hey, this seems good. Great review
If only megaman received something like this on the 3ds or the vita....
It's just so laughable that Kirby is the only franchise that gets a decent anniversary release for its 20 years of existance, yet Mario and Zelda 25th anniversary only get a rom port of All-Star and... wait, did they do anything worthwile for Zelda besides the concerts?
(not a single one in my entire province, by the way. And I've been listening to video game soundtracks for years, so the whole "nostalgia" effect is lost on me, and should also be lost on most gamers since Nintendo releases every game at least twice.)
The original Kirby game was the second Game Boy game I played (after Tetris). Despite my Wii being on the other side of the country I will be looking at picking this up.
Seriously, why is there no release date for Europe?
Nintendo can crap out their piss poor mario anniversary thing worldwide but when they actually put effort into something like this they leave EU in the dark...
I think Kirby has a newer game on the Wii after Epic Yarn... no mention of that here. Why does everyone compare Dream Course to golf? It's more like pool (billiards for some).
Fingers crossed for a release in the UK; one Wii game for a while I would mind purchasing.
I really hope this doesn't end up being a limited release.
Nothing against this collection, but I think this might have been better on the Wii U as an HD collection, perhaps. As another launch title too.
@ Nicholas Patrick

Oh, you mean Kirby's Return to Dream Land?

"In addition to the classic games, there is an all-new series of special challenge levels based on 2011's Return to Dream Land."

Yup, no mention of that game in this review. Except for that.
I just love that Jim's two favorite things in the world are the ever adorable Kirby, and violently cramming worms into Jonathan Holmes' butthole.
I'm so buying this when I get my Nintendo Wii. The NES ver. was my first Kirby romp, and I missed out on so many of them. I will save up my nostalgia tears for the first time I get the invincibility power up and hear that cock hardening music.




Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon has multiplayer?

Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon (formerly known as Luigi's Mansion 2) is almost here. True to the game's ghostly allure, details around the game's corporal existence remain shrouded in contiguity. Is this thing even...   more

Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon has multiplayer? photo

Capcom responds to Monster Hunter 4 Vita rumors

Monster Hunter 4 is no doubt going to be a massive win for the 3DS. The combination of traction Nintendo's handheld already has, along with the massive install base, and the incredible success of the Monster Hunter ...   more

Capcom responds to Monster Hunter 4 Vita rumors photo

Here's some BlayzBloo: Clone Phantasma footage

Some time ago, Jonathan Holmes reviewed BlayzBloo: Super Melee Brawlers Battle Royale. It was a pretty quaint release that was forgotten almost immediately. But now, it looks like a full sequel is upon us, ready to grace the...   more

Here's some BlayzBloo: Clone Phantasma footage photo

Interview: Disney Infinity's John Blackburn on toys

An hour after taking the stage to unveil Disney Infinity, "Disney's most ambitious video game initiative ever" (a press release states), I sat down with Avalanche Studios chief creative officer John Blackburn to discuss where...   more

Interview: Disney Infinity's John Blackburn on toys photo

Fire Emblem: Awakening demo now available for the 3DS

Yes, finally! I've been waiting quite some time for the US re-release of Kirby's Star Stacker (3DS eShop), and now it's finally upon us. As for everything else, it's not a whole lot this week. There's a free demo for Fire Emb...   more

Fire Emblem: Awakening demo now available for the 3DS photo

Nintendo's 2013 Wii U and 3DS release schedule

Want to know what's coming for your Wii U and/or 3DS? Nintendo has us covered with a list of first- and third-party releases for both systems as well as their respective eShop titles. Hell, they even threw in the kiddie DS ti...   more

Nintendo's 2013 Wii U and 3DS release schedule photo

Learn how to play Fire Emblem: Awakening with a new video

Nintendo has posted a new video for Fire Emblem: Awakening, and it's a great introduction for people who have never played the series before. It goes over the basics like the general story, troop placement, and general tips ...   more

Learn how to play Fire Emblem: Awakening with a new video photo

Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate now has a March 19 release date

It seems as the North American and European release date for the long-awaited Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate is finally upon us: March 19th and 22nd respectively. It'll launch in both 3DS and Wii U form (the latter of which is ca...   more

Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate now has a March 19 release date photo

Nintendo to restructure beginning next month

According to a Nikkei report, Nintendo plans to merge its console and handheld divisions next month. On February 16, the company is prepared to bring 130 console engineers and 150 handheld engineers together under a single ro...   more

Nintendo to restructure beginning next month photo

Iwata reminds us that the 3DS Miiverse is coming

In a recent interview, Nintendo President Satoru Iwata dove into some interesting topics, most notably the Miiverse and how it came about. Iwata also reiterates that the Wii U GamePad can transcend just a gaming audience with...   more

Iwata reminds us that the 3DS Miiverse is coming photo


Back to Top




Advertising on destructoid is available through Please contact them to learn more