HPCwire: The 2012 Performance Per Watt Wars

Since 1986 - Covering the Fastest Computers
in the World and the People Who Run Them

Translation Disclaimer

Subscribe | Sign In

Tabor Communications
Corporate Video

Leading HPC
Solution Providers

July 26, 2012

The 2012 Performance Per Watt Wars

Robert Gelber

Exascale computing is going to require chipmakers to build extremely efficient microprocessors. This has been the focus of the Green500 list, which forgoes talking about the world’s fastest clusters in favor of those with the best performance per watt rating. In this brave new world of high performance computing, and increasingly, and any kind of computing, chip efficiency is now under intense scrutiny.

Yesterday, Real World Technologies posted an article detailing the computational efficiency of CPUs and GPUs, and how those designs have evolved over the last three years. In the analysis, author David Kanter looks at both the computational performance per watt as well as performance per physical die area. He also compares how the chip architectures have faired since 2009, when Kanter did his initial analysis. The evaluations were based on double precision floating point performance.

In 2009, the standout in performance per watt and physical space was AMD’s RV770 GPU. The processor was able to perform 1.6 gigaflops/watt. It was also capable of performing just under one gigaflop per mm². Intel’s Silverthorne processor was slightly less efficient than the RV770, but had far less density than AMD’s GPU. Subsequently renamed “Atom,” the chip was able to perform between 1.5 to 1.6 gigaflops/watt and was primarily tasked with powering mobile consumer devices.

While the R770 appeared to be the clear winner in 2009, GPUs were not widely accepted as compute engines and suffered a number of challenges. Many were unable to deliver double precision floating point calculations, and those that could, often did so with limited performance. Programming GPUs was also difficult, as APIs were in their early stages.

GPU technology has improved significantly over the past three years though. Almost all these “graphic” processors can perform double precision calculations and have become simpler to program, thanks to more mature programming frameworks like CUDA, and OpenCL. CPUs have also improved over the interval, including new vector extensions like x86 AVX.

So what does the landscape look like today? From Kanter's analysis:

IBM currently takes the energy efficiency crown with their Blue Gene/Q (BG/Q) processor, which just so happens to power the most powerful supercomputer in the world. The chip can perform roughly 3.75 gigaflops/watt and is represented in the top 20 systems on the current Green500 list. Not far behind in efficiency is NVIDIA’s Fermi GPU, which performs close to 3 gigaflops/watt. The K computer’s SPARC64 chip is just a little further behind at 2.2 gigaflops/watt. All other mainstream CPUs in use for HPC – Intel’s Sandy Bridge, AMD’s Interlagos and IBM’s POWER7 – are further back, below 1.5 gigaflops/watt.

Kanter says this divergence reflects a fundamental difference between traditional processors (x86 CPUs, POWER, and others) and throughput processors (GPUs and BG/Q). But, he notes, the difference in efficiency between the two groups has narrowed since 2009, and he expects them to eventually converge.

Probably not in the short-term though. Before the end of this year, Intel will release its first Many Integrated Core (MIC) coprocessor, now rebranded as Xeon Phi, which promises over 1 teraflop of absolute performance. It will directly compete with NVIDIA’s Kepler K20 GPU, also due out later this year. Both chips will probably best BG/Q silicon on performance/watt.

Further out, it should get even more interesting. Server-capable 64-bit ARM processors, low power x86 CPUs from Intel, heterogeneous CPU-GPU chips from (at least) AMD and NVIDIA, and whatever IBM is planning as sequel to BG/Q, are all in the pipeline for 2013-2014.

Full story at Real World Technologies

Share Options

Subscribe

Subscribe to HPCwire

Discussion

There are 0 discussion items posted.

Join the Discussion

Become a Registered User Today!

Registered Users Log in join the Discussion

RSS Feeds

Feeds by Topic

Feeds by Industry

Feeds by Content Type

Subscribe to All Content

All

July 27, 2012

July 26, 2012

July 25, 2012

July 24, 2012

July 23, 2012

July 20, 2012

July 19, 2012

July 18, 2012

July 17, 2012

Feature Articles

Australia Goes on Spending Spree in Supercomputing Market

While governments in much of the rest of the world are wringing their hands over stagnant or shrinking R&D budgets, Australia is buying up HPC machinery like there is no tomorrow. Just this week, Cray, IBM, and SGI announced supercomputing deals that would send the vendors' latest and greatest HPC equipment Down Under. In this case, the three systems are headed to various research facilities in New South Wales and Western Australia.
Read more...

Lack of Minority Representation in Science and Engineering Endangering US Economic Health

Rapid growth in certain segments of the nation’s population is pushing the country’s educational challenges to a crisis level, while too many of the “precious few” under-represented minority students pursuing science, technology, engineering, or mathematics (STEM) disciplines are dropping out or changing majors, according to Richard Tapia, an internationally known mathematician.
Read more...

NASA Builds Supercomputing Lab for Earth Scientists

This week, NASA announced it would soon be launching a new HPC and data facility that will give Earth scientists access to four decades of satellite imagery and other datasets. Known as the NASA Earth Exchange (NEX), the facility is being promoted as a "virtual laboratory" for researchers interested in applying supercomputing resources to studying areas like climate change, soil and vegetation patterns, and other environmental topics.
Read more...

Read more HPCwire features...

Michael Wolfe Webinar: PGI Accelerator with OpenACC

Join Michael for a look at the first PGI Accelerator Fortran and C compilers to include comprehensive support for OpenACC, the new open standard for programming accelerators using compiler directives.