.
Handwritten

The Gaslight Anthem

Handwritten

Mercury
Rolling Stone: star rating
5 3.5
Community: star rating
July 19, 2012

"Have you seen my heart?" asks Brian Fallon on the Gaslight Anthem's fourth album. "Have you seen how it bleeds?" Have we ever. There is no shortage of earnest anthemic rock in the 21st century, but no one wears their bleeding hearts on their sleeves quite like Fallon and his mates. Gaslight aren't regal like Coldplay or Arcade Fire; on their major-label debut they remain proudly provincial New Jersey punks, who sing about deep feelings with a sincerity that could make Bono blush.

Handwritten is Gaslight's biggest-sounding, most straightforward album. The hints of Motown and dub are gone, but superproducer Brendan O'Brien supplies bite and gleam. With his newsboy caps, sleeves of tattoos and wiry intensity, Fallon can come off like a barista getting high on his own supply. But he's a ferocious vocalist, and his way with a hook and Springsteen-schooled sense of drama make these songs more cathartic than cornball. Listen to "Handwritten," where he growls over lashing guitars, "What's your favorite song?/That's mine, I've been crying to it since I was young." Then there's "Too Much Blood," the power-ballad centerpiece. "Are you scared this sounds familiar?" he cries. Fallon isn't scared of anything: not of sounding familiar, not of coming off heavy-handed. That fearlessness serves him well. 

Listen to "45":  

Related
Video: The Gaslight Anthem Revisit Jersey on '45'

prev
Album Review Main Next

ADD A COMMENT

Community Guidelines »
loading comments

loading comments...

COMMENTS

Sort by:
    Read More

    Music Reviews

    more Reviews »
    Stay Connected

    Sign up to get Rolling Stone's daily newsletter.

    Song Stories

    “Fearless Love”

    Melissa Etheridge | 2010

    Melissa Etheridge held nothing back when she released this song, which was also the title track of her 2010 album. "It was the first time I kissed a girl," she recalled of her inspiration for writing the song. "I try to put my own experiences in my songs, of course, and yet have them remain universal." Etheridge added that she hoped the tune inspired her fans to make a love choice instead of a choice based on fear.

    More Song Stories entries »