• Filter the conversation
All posts Watched posts
ie8 fix
Click Here

Stay Connected with UrbanBaby:

Inside UrbanBaby

UrbanBabyBuzz

mom-inc.jpgThere has been some major talk this week about motherhood from TIME Magazine’s cover “Are You Mom Enough” to varied discussions related to the new book The Conflict: How Modern Motherhood Undermines the Status of Women by ... More »

UrbanBabyNewYork

Literacy QuiltHappy Mother’s Day! GoPirate SchoolAhoy, maties: This one-man family vaudeville show teaches kids how to be pirates with funny, zany details on how to stand, talk, sing and laugh like Buccaneers. A blend of clown theater, music and magic ... More »
  • [-]Thank you all who responded to my post about the 'process of seeing a fertility specialist. I am planning to make an apptment at cornell for consultation. I would to know, for those of you who had being through this,what should I expect to happen on that day, and what kind of questions should I be asking the doctor? Also, can anyone recommend a particular doctor or doctors at this facility? I was thinking about making an appointment with dr. Kang, has anyone ever dealt with her? Please help to make right choice. I consider myself and healthy 37 yr old so is my dh who is 42yr old. thanks so much

    11 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.11.12, 12:17 PM Flag ]
    • Davis is essentially the de facto head of the group as Rosenwaks is mostly for show nowadays. I thought Davis was great--very thorough and kind. First appointment was just talking, although he said he had time to take blood and do a pelvic exam if I had the time, or I could come back. Much easier to do it all at the same time, as I was eager the get the process started. It can take months to get an "intake" appointment with the more popular doctors, so don't wait to call and set it up. Also, be advised that all the major IVF clinics close around 4th of July and Christmas/New Years for about a week or two at a time for "cleaning". Also, you may need to come back for some blood tests as they need to be run on day 3 of your cycle, so the pro...

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.11.12, 12:23 PM Flag
    • I used Dr. Kang and loved her. She is very no-nonsense but also has a calm personality (I found this mix to be quite reassuring throughout the process). She also worked with us to find an approach that was the right degree of aggressive.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.11.12, 12:34 PM Flag
    • Dr chung is awesome. first appt will be history and plan of action - schedule day 3 bloodwork, hsg etc. it will be minimum 6 weeks before anything really happens after that appt. you could get your day 3 tests done now/before on day 3 of your next period. your gyn can schedule. I went in at 38 and took 3 ivfs for 1st child and 4 for 2nd with a slightly raised fsh (12).

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.11.12, 12:36 PM Flag
      • +1 on Dr. Chung being awesome!

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.11.12, 01:00 PM Flag
    • Have you been charting? / Do you know the exact dates of your period? Have you been using OPKs? Do you know exactly when you've had sex? If so, bring all that information, neatly written down so you can give doctor all the info you have. Basically yours and dh's medical history, be prepared for both of you to answer whether you've previously ever been pg, gotten anyone pg, any abortions, etc. If you've had any infertility testing done elsewhere, bring a copy. They will probably ask you after appointment to set up time to do HSG, blood draw, semen analysis, etc. First appointment is just info gathering, once they have all your test results in is when you can talk about what your options are. In the meantime you can ask them about basic outli...

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.11.12, 12:45 PM Flag
    • Spandorfer has his fans too. I don't think you can go wrong with any of the docs at Cornell. An in reality, you are going to see all of the docs for monitoring, testing and IVF, if necessary. You get whoever is on call, not your doctor, so it doesn't really matter in the end. Good luck!

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.11.12, 01:14 PM Flag
    • I have an appt with Spandorfer coming up. I have heard great things about both him and Pak Chung. It took me about 6-7 weeks to get an appt so agree with others, make it now. In the meantime I got my OB to run a bunch of tests. Depending on what your trouble is you may be able to as well. I did the recurrent pregnancy loss panel and found out I have a clotting disorder. I also got my progesterone tested, which came back fine. I am an (otherwise) healthy 33 y.o. GL!

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.11.12, 01:56 PM Flag
      • If the Cornell docs won't put you on Lovenox for the recurrent miscarrages, consider seeing Dr. Lewis Lipsey (hematologist). He has a open mind on this issue. This is my first pregnancy on Lovenox, and my first pregnancy to stick beyond the first trimester.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.11.12, 02:42 PM Flag
        • Thanks for the heads up. My docs at Cornell were fine putting my on Lovenox. I have heard others say they had issues, but I didn't have any trouble...perhaps my persistence has worn them all down :). Just started last week, fingers crossed that'll do the trick. GL with the rest of your pregnancy!

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.11.12, 08:48 PM Flag
          • NP I saw Dr. Chung and he sent me right away to a hematologist -- they put me on Lovenox. No issues, he was very pro it even though a second high-risk OBGYN I consulted with felt I did not need it. OP, also just bring any tests you've done already, any fertility history, they will ask how many pregnancies, any miscarriages, etc. They do a ton of tests and then you go from there. GL!

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.12.12, 04:02 AM Flag
  • [-]please I need some information regarding infertility care. what do doctors do first before going for invasive procedures like ivf? is there any good clinics out there in NYC for this care? any recommendations for a specific doctors /facility would greatly be appreciated.

    8 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.08.12, 03:15 PM Flag ]
    • You need to see a Reproductive Endocrinologist (RE). Go to a good clinic like Cornell or NYU. They first do a lot of blood tests on the woman to make sure all her hormonal levels are ok.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 03:28 PM Flag
      • ^^They also will do a test called and HSG to see that your plumbing is clear. They will test your husband's sperm to make sure that is ok. After all that, assuming all is otherwise ok and you have been trying for the required amount of time, they'll put you on Clomid pills for 3 to 6 months. Then 3 rounds of IUI. Then IVF.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 03:30 PM Flag
    • I just started the process at cornell and I could not be happier! I was with an RE for a year and no results and I was recommended to cornell. amazing.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 03:48 PM Flag
      • HI, thanks so much for responding to my question. please, can you give me more info about your experience so far at cornell.How is the care you're receiving at cornell differ that of your previous RE care?( I am not trying to be in your business,but am more concern about not getting adequate attention. I've read a lot from this website from other women's experiences. is there a particular doctor that you would recommend? Do they accept most insurances? am 38 yr old .

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 05:07 PM Flag
    • Definitely go to Cornell or NYU first. I wasted a lot of time with my OB-Gyn who kept reassuring me I didn't have a problem and then more time lost with Dr. Sami David. Finally, I went to Cornell and got clear diagnosis. I do have to do IVF and wish I knew earlier. So, please go somewhere reputable from the start. I'm with Dr. Chung at Cornell. If you don't need to do IVF right away, they may recommend you do IUI or surgery to correct any problems you might have. Good luck!

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 04:32 PM Flag
      • thank you so much for replying to my question. can you please tell me your experience so far with dr. Chung, and would you recommend him/ her? can you please give me his or her full name? thanks again

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 05:15 PM Flag
      • What did Cornell diagnose that the others missed?

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 05:17 PM Flag
      • i started with dr chung too two months ago, and think he is incredible. very professional, caring, really makes an effort to get to know you and make you feel as comfortable as possible in this miserable infertility mess you found yourself in. i haven't gotten pregnant yet, but we are moving forward and haven't had any setbacks. everybody in his practice, the nurses and admin people, are very nice. his full name is pak chung.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.09.12, 02:48 PM Flag
  • [-]Looking for suggestions for a great Obestrician in NYC!

    8 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.09.12, 09:30 AM Flag ]
    • Do you have a hospital preference? Where d you live?

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.09.12, 09:37 AM Flag
      • I live in Brooklyn, but I work in the city on the UWS. I prefer a hospital in the city because I am there most of the time, but I am more concerned about the doctor. Someone with integrity. See above post, pushed enter too soon lol

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.09.12, 09:38 AM Flag
        • Ah, ok. FWIW, I'm 34 and had 2 miscarriages when I was 32 and 33. The doctors did not check progesterone levels or anything of the kind. They assume it is a chromosomal issue. You may be better off going to an RE if you would like a workup and someone to monitor your pregnancy in the early stage.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.09.12, 09:42 AM Flag
          • ^Also, did you have a D&C? If so, you could have the embryo tested for chromosomal issues. I did this, and found it was trisomy 16, which is a fluke. I now have a 4-week old DB, so hang in there!

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.09.12, 09:43 AM Flag
          • What is an RE? in general, this one had bad bedside manner so that is why I am looking for suggestions in general. I have 6.5 year old, and my last OB was phenomenal. Unfortunately, she relocated to CT. What a bummer.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.09.12, 09:44 AM Flag
            • No D&C, it happened at home. I dont think I could have saved the tissue it was enough that it happened at home. When I was pg with my son at age 34, I got pg 2 months before and I had miscarriage as well. Hopefully, next one sticks.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.09.12, 09:46 AM Flag
            • RE = Reproductive Endocrinologist (fertility specialist). Dr. Drew Tortoriello does a lot more testing for miscarriages than the others. As far as OBs go, I use the Katrina Bradley / Amy Huang / Anna Rhee practice and I find them to be phenomenal. They are on the UWS and deliver at St. Luke's Roosevelt. I'm not sure they will do the type of proactive monitoring that you need/want, however.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.09.12, 09:47 AM Flag
  • [-]Anyone have their first baby at 37? I am 35 now, but have to prepare myself if it happens. I am postponing a fibroid surgery to give us a bit more time to try to conceive. But, if we don't, I would get the surgery at a time when I would be 37 if we get preggers. Thanks!

    12 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.03.12, 10:25 AM Flag ]
    • Does your dr. recommend the surgery now?

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.03.12, 10:29 AM Flag
      • Conflicting opinions. My ob/gyn thinks it is fine and a reproductive endo thinks if I get it removed it will help me get pregnant. Two other opinions think that it could possibly affect my ability, miscarriage rate, etc. But, not a lot. We only tried for about 5 months...so I am thinking to give it a few more months....

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.03.12, 09:11 PM Flag
    • 2 weeks shy of 38. Used TCOYF, which actually made me calm and feel like I was on top of (if not quite in control of) the process. Conceived @6mos after stopped pill, 3rd mo of TCOYF charting

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.03.12, 10:33 AM Flag
      • That is great! I was really stressed for most of our TTC time, so I was thinking that might have had an affect. For the first four of the five months. So, I want to try under a lot less stress and see, give it 4 months or so and then if nothing just go forward with the surgery.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.03.12, 09:12 PM Flag
    • I had my first at 41. natural conception, one try.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.03.12, 11:02 AM Flag
      • Wow, that is awesome! We have tried for 5 months, but I want to give it a few more months before going forward with the surgery since we didn't try for that long really.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.03.12, 09:13 PM Flag
    • Yep, me! Perfectly smooth pregnancy and delivery. Natural conception, second try

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.03.12, 11:04 AM Flag
    • I was 38 when I had my first. GL!

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.03.12, 01:10 PM Flag
    • after various fertility issues, ds born when I was 1 month shy of 37 (so conceived at 36), and then after multiple failed fertility treatments, got pregnant naturally at 39, with baby due this year on the week of my 40th birthday.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 10:26 AM Flag
      • That is great! Congratulations to you!!!

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 02:38 PM Flag
  • [-]Question for IVF veterans: NYU or Cornell? Everyone seems to recommend Cornell, but when I look at sart.org, NYU's are much higher. I know Cornell takes a lot of tough cases from around the country, but is there something else I'm missing?

    14 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.08.12, 12:00 PM Flag ]
    • OP: Sorry for the missing word -- NYU's NUMBERS are much higher.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 12:07 PM Flag
      • Yes, but Cornell takes on more cases per year - so the percentages are skewed.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 12:49 PM Flag
    • If I were you, I would do a consult with both clinics and decide after that. Meet the doctor(s) who will supervise your cycle, discuss the protocol options they would recommend, and ask any questions you have about the process. They are both exceptional clinics and have wonderful doctors, embryologists, nurses, etc. You might get a better 'vibe' at one or the other, and it's important that you are comfortable with both the doctors and the office as a whole. GL!

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 12:10 PM Flag
    • U have to take sart w a grain of salt. It really doesnt mean that much. Cornell doesnt turn patients away. They take patients that have failed at many other clinics, multiple times. They dont push donor eggs, unless u want them. Other clinics push patients out way before this, to keep their numbers up. Also, it's not a for profit clinic...it's research based. They also have the best lab. I don't know much about buy at all. I cycled at RMA, and 3 times at Cornell. Success on ivf4 at cornell. Nothing against nyu, but wanted to shed some light on sart. It's not the end all be all IMO.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 12:33 PM Flag
      • Nyu not buy. Autocorrect. Also, I think Cornell totally deserves its reputation, I'm forever grateful for what they did for me

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 12:35 PM Flag
        • Does Cornell work non-IVF miracles? Meaning, I have old eggs but don't want the expense of IVF or donor eggs.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.08.12, 12:46 PM Flag
          • np: I don't know what they can do if you're not willing to consider IVF. A medicated IUI, I suppose, but if you are a poor responder, that won't work (and if you are a good responder, the risk of high-order multiples is much, much greater with IUI).

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.08.12, 12:59 PM Flag
            • I've has 3 pregnancies in the past 9 months - 1 IUI and 2 on our own. None of them made it though - chromosonal defects.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.08.12, 01:09 PM Flag
              • ^^ just trying to figure out if I should switch REs or just stick with what we've got - I think it is me, not the RE clinic, and could Cornell really do anything more for me?

                [ Reply | More ]
                05.08.12, 01:11 PM Flag
                • If it's a chromosomal issue that is recurring, then Cornell can't do anything to PREVENT the same thing from happening again. What they could do -- but it's very $$$ -- is IVF with PGD (preimplantation genetic diagnosis). They take one cell from the embryo and test for chromosomal abnormalities. It's tough on the embryos (not all survive the process) and it doesn't test for everything, but it's the only way to guarantee that you are putting back a viable embryo. If it still doesn't implant, you might have lining issues or other issues that can then be addressed.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  05.08.12, 01:18 PM Flag
            • If u don't want to try Ivf, u can try Iui but that can't tell u anything about ur eggs without looking at them from retrieval. Dr Davis specializes in AMA using their own eggs, and he's great. But he take no insurance.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.08.12, 01:16 PM Flag
    • I had to pick too and went with Cornell. And although my first cycle did not work -- about to start second...I can tell you I was handled with the utmost professionalism during my cycle by not only all the Docs but the nurses too and I could not have asked for things to run better. It kind of shocked me. It is a well oiled machine. I also had asked people I knew who had done IVF and heard more than one story about how the "only place i got pregnant was Cornell" that along with my own research was what did it for me.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 12:46 PM Flag
      • That was the case for me too. Also, if u have mfi....Peter schlegel is the best uro in the country. Without his help, we would have never conceived.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.08.12, 01:18 PM Flag
    • I'm 11 weeks pregnant from IVF at NYU. On the whole I had a good experience there. Both are excellent, I would suggest going to the one with the most convenient location for you.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.08.12, 12:48 PM Flag
  • [-]How do people deal with their mother-in-laws during the whole ttc process? Mine's is passive aggressive and just plain mean. Most recently she said in front of my brother that she wanted to throw a baby shower for my cousin-in-law but that she knows I'll be jealous. I've never been jealous of my cousin-in-law, but that's the rumor she likes to spread to everyone b/c she's pregnant and I am not. She constantly grabs at my stomach - before, she used to do it coz she thought I was fat (size 0-2) - now she does it to see if I'm pregnant. I dread seeing her. I've given up on trying to make her like me and I definitely don't like her. But I do love my husband and want to keep the peace...

    38 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    05.06.12, 06:46 AM Flag ]
    • jesus she sounds like a bitch. I'm so sorry ttc is so stressful. She def doesn't help.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 06:48 AM Flag
      • thanks. i had nightmares yesterday coz we ran into her on the street and she pointedly looked at my stomach.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 06:53 AM Flag
      • ita. she sounds awful. She grabs your stomach??

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 07:46 AM Flag
    • I'm so sorry. Are you ttc your first?

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 06:49 AM Flag
      • yes, trying for our first. thx.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 06:53 AM Flag
    • Don't tell her! Why does anyone need to know you are TTC? The cat may be out of the bag now, but if you can, how about having DH tell her that you aren't TTC bc you're (you both) aren't ready for DCs yet. Then, surprise!, is you do get pregnant. You can even make a joke of telling people that to take he pressure off. We didn't tell anyone (not wen my own mother) until 12 weeks and I was 37 so people had to assume I was going to start TTC eventually but nobody felt like we were remotely open to prying.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 06:53 AM Flag
      • wow you are lucky no one asked. I'm 29 ttc #1 after a m/c. even people I just meet now who have no idea I was pg ask when I will have a dc...even people at work. You cant imagine what it takes for me not to cry. I hate people sometimes.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 06:58 AM Flag
        • i'm so sorry. i know how you feel - people ask me all the time or send me weird emails. i had a friend send me an article about breastfeeding. we had never even talked about ttc - so, wth?!

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.06.12, 07:04 AM Flag
          • jesus...why are people such assholes. Its none of your business whn or if I will have a baby. Wat if I can't ever why are you on my case.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.06.12, 07:06 AM Flag
      • i wish i could, but she's been on our case to have kids since we got married 2.5 years ago and asks every time we see her... and it's tough b/c not much changes week to week in that department. she used to be a nurse so you would think she'd know that.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 06:58 AM Flag
        • she seems like a dumb ass who only knows what she wants to know. what a bitch. what does dh say?

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.06.12, 07:05 AM Flag
          • dh is disappointed in his mother. he also realizes that she doesn't like me and that nothing i do will change that. (i'm a few years older than him and i think that has always bothered her.) i feel bad b/c he said something has shifted in the way he sees her.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.06.12, 07:14 AM Flag
            • np: she sounds truly awful. I'm not kidding when I say I would move to get away from her. LA is nice...

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.06.12, 07:52 AM Flag
              • I'd go to Timbuktu...seriously. Sounds like bad news.

                [ Reply | More ]
                05.06.12, 08:12 AM Flag
            • Nnp: why would feel bad? The woman is a bitch. If his view didn't shift you'd have a real problem. You really need to work on yourself. Your lack of confidence and self-regard are not healthy, and will make family life tougher for everyone than it needs to be. Your MIL should not give you nightmares. Get some help. There's more going on with you.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.06.12, 07:56 AM Flag
    • screeching, "ouch, what are you doing?! Stop grabbing at my stomach!!" is the tactic I'd try if she touches you again. Practice with a friend. You need to learn how to have an appropriate reaction. It will feel like overreaction, but it's called for here. You've been conditioned, as most of us have, to minimize drama when others act out. This only works with people who are civilized. As far as an overall strategy, I can only suggest avoidance.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 06:55 AM Flag
      • i might just have to try that! ty.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 07:00 AM Flag
      • This is a REALLY good suggestion. But the focus on her and her bad behavior, that she is doing something not normal.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 08:08 AM Flag
        • ^^^I meant PUT the focus on her

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.06.12, 08:08 AM Flag
      • I agree! "Get the fuck off" would work well too! I'm sure though that if someone actually did that to me I'd be stunned speechless...

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 01:45 PM Flag
    • What an awful woman! Your husband needs to be your champion here. He needs to tell his mom that if she wants grandkids and she needs to stop stressing you out by talking about it and touching you. He needs to make it super clear to her that if she's not on her absolute best behavior it will impact her access to future grandkids.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 06:57 AM Flag
      • he did have a talk w/ her after the cousin-in-law comment and she eased up the next time we saw her, but after running into her yesterday, she's acting weird again.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 07:03 AM Flag
        • np: When she grabs at your stomach, DH should be saying, "What are you doing? That's rude, mom. Would you want someone doing that to you?" This is in addition to you saying that, of course.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.06.12, 08:44 AM Flag
    • Try stretching her facial skin and tell her you just want to see what shed look like with a face lift.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 07:05 AM Flag
      • hahaha!

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 07:07 AM Flag
      • OMG! This!

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 07:07 AM Flag
      • haha love it lol

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 07:07 AM Flag
      • Or at least imagine doing that! : )

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 07:08 AM Flag
      • np: This is really fun to fantasize about but would be like launching the first nuke...

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 08:12 AM Flag
        • nnp: Not really. I don't know why people are so afraid of their in-laws. They have absolutely no power.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.06.12, 08:33 AM Flag
          • Well, she said she wanted to keep the peace w/ MIL. If she didn't care about that, then the above suggestion would be great.

            [ Reply | More ]
            05.06.12, 08:35 AM Flag
            • It's true that having DH on board is important. But I'd argue that, with some people, harsh, appropriate responses are the most effective in keeping the peace. She is treating OP this way because she can.

              [ Reply | More ]
              05.06.12, 08:40 AM Flag
    • Do you think your DH is more concerned about her wishes and feelings than he is about yours? Does he live his life to make her happy, or do you feel like he has transitioned that loyalty to you? (keeping a good relationship with his mother and being appropriately loyal to wife are not mutually exclusive. But she sounds like a difficult person. And if he wants to set up your lives to indulge her, you've got bigger problems than behavior around ttc.)

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 07:24 AM Flag
    • God, I have no idea. That sounds like an extremely unfun situation.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 08:04 AM Flag
    • Ack. Why why why did you tell her you were ttc? I can only imagine the pressure that adds to you. It's definitely not MILs in general here, just her. If I could get away with it I'd try to hide as much of my pg from her as possible-I have a feeling it'll only get worse when you DO get preg

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 11:41 AM Flag
    • I guess it's too late for OP, but others could take this as a cautionary tale: don't tell people you're TTC! We told absolutely no one. If family members asked, we said, "Sure, someday," and changed the subject. It only happened once or twice. I can't imagine having that family pressure on top of my own desire to get PG.

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 11:43 AM Flag
      • sit down have a cuppa of tea and state how you feel. Focus on you do not blame her. Tell her you wanted her to now how you feel each time she does that.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.06.12, 11:46 AM Flag
    • Eeeek! This makes me thik of the Kevin Costner remake of Robin Hood where the old witch grabs Maid Marion's thigh and says "She's RIPE! She will give us a son!"

      [ Reply | More ]
      05.06.12, 01:44 PM Flag
  • [-]who are the best fertility doctors in nyc?

    56 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    11.02.08, 12:01 PM Flagged ]
    • Dr. Owen Davis at Cornell (most all of the Cornell doctors are amazing, but I felt Dr. Davis was truly extraordinary).

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.02.08, 12:42 PM Flagged
      • absolutely, that rep holds true all the way over here in Boston, women who fail at Boston clinics go to see him.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.02.08, 03:28 PM Flagged
      • ITA he has

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.02.08, 03:49 PM Flagged
      • ITA he has "the touch" i got pregnant naturally after going to see him, after being told by another re that i would NEVER get pregnant, not even thru ivf.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.02.08, 03:50 PM Flagged
        • Hi

          [ Reply | More ]
          12.02.08, 03:24 PM Flagged
        • I read your post concerning Davis and helping you get preg. Could you email me at ally26@aol.com so I could ask you some q's? I 've also seen him once.

          [ Reply | More ]
          12.02.08, 03:24 PM Flagged
      • I have amazing twins--and I credit Dr. Davis!!

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.29.09, 06:45 AM Flag
        • We loved Dr. Davis--but despite his best efforts, it never worked for us. They used many "novel" treatments, but we never got preg. They also never came up with a reason why...Cornell is the best, but nothing is a slam dunk!!

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.29.09, 06:48 AM Flag
          • did you ever end up having children?

            [ Reply | More ]
            10.08.10, 06:54 AM Flag
      • We have three Dr. Davis kids! Thank God for that man.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.24.11, 03:53 PM Flag
    • spandorfer at cornell, griffo at nyu

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.02.08, 04:03 PM Flagged
      • Licciardi at NYU. He got both myself and a friend pregnant on the first try.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.02.08, 04:23 PM Flagged
        • wow. half sibs!

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.08, 11:22 AM Flagged
      • Spandorfer is an amazing man...and really helped me through years of infertility (and I have two children now after his intervention!)

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.29.09, 06:46 AM Flag
      • i had spandorfer and would not recommend and cannot speak for all the docs at cornell but it's like cattle going through the clinic. i felt like just a number. he doesn't explain anything to me and if i ask a question, he gets defensive and doesn't explain anything except to say "it's your age! old eggs". note: i just tried iui a few times and unsuccessfully, not ivf yet and not likely with him. there were visits when he didn't even say "hi, how r u". finally, i should have known something was not right when he gave me a breast exam at my first appt. how does that relate to infertility??? moving on...

        [ Reply | More ]
        09.21.09, 11:27 AM Flag
        • wow, I couldn't disagree more with you about spandorfer. i had the total opposite experience. given that corness is a big clinic I never felt like jsut a number. i liked that i alwasy saw spandorfer. i can not rave enough about his bed side manne.

          [ Reply | More ]
          09.21.09, 11:34 AM Flag
        • I agree. Dr. Spandover doesn't care anymore and it's extremely in his apathetic attitude. This facility doesn't test for other factors eithe suck as natural killer cells, immunology issues etc (which is what I have). And yes, Spandover feels you up which made me uncomfortable and skeptical and was totally unnecessary.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.04.12, 08:38 AM Flag
      • I went to Grifo only once (was already pg but didn't know it), but thought he seemed like a great doctor - wonderful bedside manner. He got several people I know pregnant, which is why I went there.

        [ Reply | More ]
        09.21.09, 01:56 PM Flag
    • I've worked with RMA (Sinai), Roosevelt and Columbia. Columbia was HANDS DOWN the best.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.02.08, 06:13 PM Flagged
      • what is RMA?

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.08, 09:04 AM Flagged
        • Group associated with Mt. Sinai. I know a number of people who've gotten pregnant with them, and as of last year, their numbers were even better than Cornell's...

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.08, 10:14 AM Flagged
          • I go to RMA and I like it. They are matter-of-fact and efficient. I am seeing Dr. Grunfeld, so far he has been very good and I have confidence in him.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.08, 11:31 AM Flagged
            • ITTTA - i got prego at RMA. the doctors are not wan and fuzzy, but they will get you pregnant and the nurses are really great and responsive.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.08, 11:51 AM Flagged
              • i have two babies from RMA..but am now trying Zhang, and have to say, much more nurturing..

                [ Reply | More ]
                09.21.09, 11:41 AM Flag
        • Reproductive Medical Associates. Mt. Sinai. Very good, bit of a factory feel, but all of them are. I see Alan Copperman, who I really love to the point of crush hood. We've done 4 cycles with them, one ds, one mc, one blank. I'm 40 and will be giving them one more try. Have thought about switching to Cornell, but not sure it's worth it or would make a lick of difference.

          [ Reply | More ]
          05.01.09, 07:57 AM Flag
          • i saw him too. but his family situation gave me pause which likely isnt fair.

            [ Reply | More ]
            09.21.09, 11:47 AM Flag
            • what's his family situation?

              [ Reply | More ]
              10.08.10, 06:02 AM Flag
            • Someone has referenced his "family situation" twice now, without explaining. Either explain, or stop alluding to some issue with his family situation.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.11, 08:11 AM Flag
      • Really? I thought Columbia was disorganized. I liked the doctors but the support staff seemed clueless. I would not have gone there except that they take my insurance. For someone who is self-funding (ie not insurance) I would recommend Cornell or NYU.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.08, 09:24 AM Flagged
        • np: ditto; same experience at Columbia. I selected it because it was best location for my commute.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.08, 10:20 AM Flagged
      • columbia stats are no where near as good as cornell - and I did a round at columbia

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.08, 11:49 AM Flagged
      • Anyone knows the best stats of RMA,Columbia,Cornell/NYU? I met terrable staff at Columbia..(doctors seem nice,though)Or anyone knows the best Dr at columbia?I wonder if I should continue at Columbia...

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.29.09, 06:41 AM Flag
        • www.sart.org. This gives all stats. But beware. The better clinincs (cornell&nyu but especially cornell) success rates tend to be understated because they get and take the tougher cases- women who due to their multiple failures elsewhere have lower odds of getting pregnant. Some of the clinics with really high success rates screen out patients early on to avoid a drop in their success rates.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.29.09, 07:17 AM Flag
      • I think Columbia is just horrible, no standard of care at all and everyone gets pushed through the system like a piece of meat. Good luck talking to your doctor beyond the initial visit, usually they dump you on a nurse when you have questions.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.01.09, 07:50 AM Flag
    • Any RE is only as good as his or her clinic.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.08, 10:19 AM Flagged
      • i disagree. there are many doctors at the same clinic, and they aren't all great.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.08, 11:38 AM Flagged
    • I went to Dr. Fred Licciardi. Nice guy, and it worked.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.08, 11:33 AM Flagged
    • Dr Nicole Noyes at NYU - after 4 years got pg at first IVF

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.08, 11:47 AM Flagged
      • I second Dr Noyes. She was incredible to me throughout a difficult process and I ultimately had IVF twins.

        [ Reply | More ]
        10.08.10, 06:14 AM Flag
    • any heard anything about Dr. Mark Sauer at Columbia-Presbyterian?

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.15.09, 07:31 AM Flag
    • Ask SJP

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.29.09, 04:03 PM Flag
      • so witty. she would say cornell and some out of state place that did surrogacy procedure.

        [ Reply | More ]
        05.01.09, 07:51 AM Flag
        • Didn't she do donor egg?

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.11, 08:53 AM Flag
    • Steven Spandorfer Cornell. Agree 100% with above poster. I went to him to get pg w #1 and #2. Not only is he one of the top fertility drs he has an amazing bedside manner. He is easy to talk to and you can tell he really cares. My dh and I both felt so comfortable with him. I can not speak highly enough about him.

      [ Reply | More ]
      09.21.09, 11:32 AM Flag
    • Dr. Alan Berkeley at NYU... no nonsense, professional yet warm. DH and I were healthy but had "unexplained infertility" through 6 months of TTC naturally and 3 rounds of clomid/IUI. Two rounds of IVF (at age 38 & 41) = 3 kids for us. Couldn't recommend Berkeley or NYU more highly.

      [ Reply | More ]
      09.21.09, 11:49 AM Flag
      • Has anyone with PCOS seen Dr. Kang or Davis at Weill Cornell or Dr. Choi at Columbia? What has your experience been like?

        [ Reply | More ]
        10.07.10, 06:52 PM Flag
        • Choi is a hack, don't waste your precious time with her.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.24.11, 05:13 PM Flag
    • NYU. NYU. NYU. Dr. Licciardi is da bomb diggity and he's good looking. Also, after being with an IVF clinic with an awful, hair pulling, bunny boiling long wait time, NYU's wait time is very short.

      [ Reply | More ]
      10.08.10, 01:04 PM Flag
    • I have loved RMA so far, although very crowded, the nurses and doctors are great.. I just hope my IVF works..

      [ Reply | More ]
      10.18.10, 07:39 PM Flag
    • I went to a RSofNY in Brooklyn and they have screwed up my system. I was incredibly regular, a 28 day cycle and ovulated always on the 12th day. It has now been 40 days since my last period and I've called the office numerous time to ask what I should do, no reply. I have appointments at the following, Dr Chung at Cornell - Dr Grundfeld at RMA and Dr Park at Columbia. Can anyone tell me if they have any experience with any of these doctors? It's not just trying to get pregnant, it's also the stress of finding the right doctor and receiving the best care - ugh

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.11.11, 02:18 AM Flag
    • Has anyone been to Dr. Kang at Cornell? Thoughts?

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.11, 05:52 AM Flag
    • Cornell. Rosenwaks is responsible for my twins, IVF #1 after failure elsewhere.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.11, 08:31 PM Flag
      • DO NOT go to Columbia. They are terrible... rude, disorganized, and told me I needed a surgical procedue that was totally uncessary. Go to RMA - Dr. Eric Flisser is great.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.16.11, 04:56 PM Flag
        • ITA, Columbia is a dump, run don't walk to any other clinic, and GL!

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.24.11, 05:11 PM Flag
    • Dr. Sami David for IUI.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.24.11, 11:20 AM Flag
    • Has anyone been to Dr. Zimmerman at Columbia? I just started this process, but feel like CU is kind of a factory and I have not been able to talk to the doctor after I got some blood test results back. I am thinking of switching. Any ideas?

      [ Reply | More ]
      12.03.11, 08:31 AM Flag
  • [-]Conflicting opinions from different Dr's about fibroid affecting ability to get pregnant. Any advice? I have only one 7.5 cm intramural fibroid, at the back of uterus, small submucosal component. Ob/Gyn says she doesn't think it is a problem to get pregnant and stay pregnant. Fertility dr says she thinks I should get it removed and fibroid surgeon thinks it is decreasing my chances of getting preg 50%. Have been researching a lot. Am 35, TTC.

    16 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    04.25.12, 05:37 AM Flag ]
    • What's the downside of just getting it removed? Given what you said (and zero knowledge on my part beyond that), I'd probably just get it removed. At 35, if I'd been trying for 6+ months, I think I wouldn't want to waste another year+ trying.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 05:45 AM Flag
      • I know, that is how I feel. The reasons I am hesitating are: having to have surgery-getting cut, possible complications, the small chance that something could go wrong; potential scarring on the uterus that could affect pregnancy; and probably having to have a c-section if I get pregnant. Also, the chance that they could grow back anyway. Ideally, we want two kids. So, I am thinking about one surgery and two c-sections. Dr said I should get my fallopian tubes checked first to make sure something isn't being blocked, before having surgery. But, that would change my surgery date (I scheduled it for May 9).

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.25.12, 05:54 AM Flag
        • And my ob/gyn was adamant about thinking it wasn't affecting my chances of getting pregnant, so that makes me want to wait and see for a while. If I was younger, I would wait a year and see what happens. It is my age and being ready that makes me unsure.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.25.12, 05:56 AM Flag
          • How long have you been trying?

            [ Reply | More ]
            04.25.12, 05:57 AM Flag
            • approximately 5 months. some of it under some stress though.

              [ Reply | More ]
              04.25.12, 06:18 AM Flag
    • Both myself and my sister had fibroids. We heard from our obgyn that it wasn't a small surgery to get them fixed. We both conceived easily and carried to term. She needed a C section because a fibroid was blocking the canal. I ended up needing one due to Pre Eclampsia. But other than that, no issues. How long have you been trying? Are you using an ovulation predictor kit? Anyone over 30 should be using one of those. People tend to think they 'know' when they're ovulating and in my experience, my friends have been way off. They wasted 6 to 9 months guessing at dates and then as soon as they knew their cycles were pregnant immediately. Granted, that's just a few people, but I wouldn't 'wing it.'

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 05:59 AM Flag
      • We have been trying October-February. So, 5 months. March and April we stopped trying because I wasn't sure if I was getting the surgery, etc. and the Dr's made me think my chances of miscarriage were high. I have been using the OPK's, and am very regular. Also, I was very stressed, first NYC solo show in January. All my hormone levels are ok. I might try to get yet another opinion before the surgery, from another ob/gyn. If I get them removed, it is with Da Vinci, a robotic assisted myomectomy.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.25.12, 06:12 AM Flag
    • Have you gotten an opinion from a fertility center like Cornell. The MDs there are excellent. They would tell you what to do right away. If you need to have surgery have it with Glenn Schattman. Hes an absolutely amazing surgeon.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 06:12 AM Flag
      • Thank you for your recommendation. One thing my ob/gyn said is that almost all IVF dr's would say to get it removed, but maybe that is if I am doing IVF. I am thinking I should get another opinion. I also have a dr appointment with Lealani Rodriguez on Monday for another opinion. I have almost 2 weeks till my scheduled surgery to see if I want to go through with it.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.25.12, 06:18 AM Flag
    • My mom started TTC at 36 and couldn't get pregnant for a year. Doctor found a fibroid, removed it and within two months got pregnant with my older sib. No problem with getting pg year and a half later. I'd have it removed so you don't waste a lot of time ttc.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 06:25 AM Flag
      • Thanks for sharing your experience. Do you happen to know where hers was or how large, also how she got it removed? If not, no problem. It is really helpful to hear other people's experiences.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.25.12, 06:30 AM Flag
        • I don't know, sorry. She said it was pretty large though. Doesn't help, I'm afraid.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.25.12, 07:02 AM Flag
          • that is ok, thank you so much for your responses!

            [ Reply | More ]
            04.25.12, 07:31 AM Flag
    • I had a 6 cm fibroid subserosal/submucosal (they couldn't tell exactly), but my OB told me he recommends surgery only for fibroids 8 cm or larger. I got pregnant easily at 32, but had a very difficult pregnancy because the fibroid grew and degenerated. My OB said I had to get it removed before getting pregnant again or I would have the same issues. I didn't and had a very easy second pregnancy at 35. So I think OBs cannot predict with any certainty which fibroids will cause a problem. That's why you got three different opinions and why the decision is so difficult. What convinced me not to have surgery is that in 50% of cases the fibroids come back (you're supposed to get pregnant within 6 months after the surgery) and that the surgery brin...

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.25.12, 06:25 PM Flag
      • ^^brings its own risks, including infertility.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.25.12, 06:27 PM Flag
        • Thank you for sharing your experience. I am thinking now to postpone the surgery, since we really only tried for 5 months. I might get the test where they make sure your fallopian tubes are open, HSG I think. And will try to relax more, when we were trying I was quite stressed on a fairly consistent basis (first solo art show in nyc, etc). It isn't the end of the world if I get pregnant at 36 or 36 and a half...having a kid at 37. Anyway, thanks again!

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.27.12, 11:52 PM Flag
  • [-]Cornell versus SIRM?

    4 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    04.26.12, 11:13 AM Flag ]
    • Each has their fans. I finally got pregnant at Cornell after 1.5 years at RMA. If Cornell failed 3 rounds, my last hope was to try SIRM, just for a change of pace, not because I thought they were better.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.26.12, 11:26 AM Flag
      • Thanks. I'm at Cornell right now. First IVF - BFN. First FET - chemical pregnancy. My RE thinks it's a case of bad luck. I hope so. Congrats on your success at Cornell!

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.26.12, 11:46 AM Flag
        • I'm 40 and had had 2 chemical pregnancies at RMA. One fresh, one FET. There is no right answer here. Maybe give Cornell another shot with a fresh then re-evaluate. Good luck.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.26.12, 11:50 AM Flag
    • Penn or Brown.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.26.12, 11:31 AM Flag
  • [-]Conflicting opinions from reproductive endicronologists...

    6 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    04.20.09, 11:25 AM Flag ]
    • I could use some advice. I saw Dr. Noyes at NYU and she recommended surgery on an intramural (in the muscle, but not cavity) fibroid. Then I saw Dr. Spandorfer at Cornell who completely disagreed with her. How am I supposed to decide what to do? Anyone else deal with this? I've been TTC for 8 months and no one can seem to figure out why...

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.20.09, 11:26 AM Flag
      • I found Dr. Noyes to have NO bedside manner whatsoever. She recommended an exploratory laproscopy many years ago and when I called her to ask some questions, she was so short with me that I ended up not having the surgery. I was asking completely reasonable questions like, how long recovery time, etc. I never went back to her and would not recommend her to anyone.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.20.09, 11:31 AM Flag
      • I have no experience with this but if it was me I would want to know why each doctor gave you the answer they did and then get a 3rd opinion and make my choice that way. Sorry to hear your havig trouble ttc.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.20.09, 11:40 AM Flag
      • how old are you?

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.20.09, 11:41 AM Flag
        • 37. all my tests came back normal. i have a daughter who's 2 and who was small (5 lb 13 oz) possibly because of the fibroid, but possibly not. it's just so bizarre to hear such conflicting reports. dr noyes said not only could it be preventing pregnancy, but it could lead to a late term miscarriage. dr spandorfer said both are not true. i have appointments with dr pak chung and dr husami (at cornell...my ob/gyn recommended him) later this week for a 3rd/4th opinions, but it's definitely disconcerting that doctors feel so differently over what i thought would be a relatively non-complex issue.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.20.09, 11:49 AM Flag
          • Hi, not sure if you are still on urban baby, but I have a kind of similar issue. My ob/gyn says my fibroid (7.5 cm, intramural with small submucosal component at the back of my uterus) isn't causing issues ttc (we have been ttc for 6 months and I am 35, 36 in august). Dr Noyes and Dr Ascher Walsh think getting it removed would help my fertility. Everything else is normal so far. I have a surgery scheduled for May 9 with Ascher Walsh, but I am having second thoughts. I would be doing it to increase my chances of getting pregnant.

            [ Reply | More ]
            04.25.12, 05:47 AM Flag
  • [-]Am I crazy for TTC at age 42 (43 in June)? Already have 2 kids, ages 7 and 5. Thought this was my last hurrah in trying for a third. Is this too old? Be honest!!

    16 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    04.10.12, 05:12 PM Flag ]
    • Well, I kind of think so. But if you really really really want a baby...

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.10.12, 05:14 PM Flag
      • why do you think it is old?

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.10.12, 05:15 PM Flag
      • too old?

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.10.12, 05:15 PM Flag
      • I think that's a lousy reason honestly. they are babies for a short time and it's fleeting. Then you have a kid.

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.10.12, 05:16 PM Flag
        • i tend to agree. the whole thing goes by so fast. my son turned 7 in a flash. and i have come to see that family is the most important thing.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.10.12, 05:17 PM Flag
    • friend had twins at 44. if you have 2 you know what you re getting in to. It is hard on your body though (signed, mom at 40)

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.10.12, 05:15 PM Flag
      • did you just feel more exhausted and worn out?

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.10.12, 05:16 PM Flag
    • Not at all...I was a few months shy of 43 when I had my dd who is 4 now....do it.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.10.12, 05:21 PM Flag
      • maybe a silly question.... but did you feel judged by others? as though you were doing something that was "off" or out of the box?

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.10.12, 05:25 PM Flag
        • np: I know lots of older moms. It's not off anymore.

          [ Reply | More ]
          04.10.12, 06:07 PM Flag
    • Not to old go for it.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.10.12, 05:21 PM Flag
    • Its not the little baby, what about the teen when you are SIXTY!!!!Too old.Our health doesn't get better, it gets worse. Not fair to them.Sometimes we are just too old, this is one of them.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.10.12, 05:38 PM Flag
      • ouch. you are angry and must have old rents

        [ Reply | More ]
        04.10.12, 05:44 PM Flag
    • Had DD just short of 46, no regrets. I have more energy and spunk than lots of younger people.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 01:07 PM Flag
    • For me, yes, it would be too old. I'd also worry about premature labor and other problems. But at the same time, I'd never want to have 3 kids, so it's hard to imagine myself having the desire you have.

      [ Reply | More ]
      04.17.12, 01:14 PM Flag
Refresh » New Post »