Music: Charting the number ones that somehow got away

You'd think it would be obvious which record sells best. No so, writes Spencer Leigh, who reveals that the books have sometimes been cooked

On Facebook
Life & Style blogs

Online House Hunter: Rising concerns

Fears about flooding are rising - but of more pressing concern is the ending of the government agree...

Online House Hunter: The UK’s health spots

Bear in mind access to health services when moving house - our Online House Hunter prescribes some l...

The future of the NHS

The ramifications of the NHS bill have rightly been hitting the news this last week. As the governme...

You've heard the question scores of times: "What was the Beatles' first number one?" Trouble is, you will also have heard the answer, the wrong answer: "From Me to You". Today we're going to celebrate - or, at least, I'm going to celebrate - the 35th anniversary of the Beatles' first number one: "Please Please Me".

Nowadays, we take our knowledge of past chart performances from The Guinness Book of British Hit Singles. From 1952 to 1960 the compilers used the weekly charts published in New Musical Express, after which they switched to Record Retailer. In 1969, a Top 50 was complied jointly for Record Retailer and the BBC by the British Market Research Bureau, and we have effectively had an official chart since that time. Before then, it did not exist.

In the Sixties weekly charts were published in New Musical Express, Melody Maker, Disc and Record Mirror, the last-named printing the one from the trade paper, Record Retailer. NME had the largest circulation and was regarded as the standard by music fans, although neither we, nor anyone else, had any idea which was most accurately compiled. Unlike TV viewing figures, however, there were only minor differences, so I suspect that there was little of the chart hyping that was to take place in the Seventies.

The most intriguing differences surround the number one position. By my reckoning, 14 records topped the NME chart and failed to make number one in Record Retailer, peaking at number two or three or, in the case of Tom Jones's "Help Yourself", at number five. Joe Brown is understandably miffed when reporters tell him that "A Picture of You" peaked at number two. "I hate that book," he says of the Guinness publication. "It has deprived me of my only number one, and I'm unlikely to get another."

The Allisons came second in the 1961 Eurovision Song Contest with "Are You Sure?" According to Guinness, the record also made number two, but they had the first missing number one, as they topped the NME chart for two weeks in April 1961. Are you sure? Yes, I'm absolutely positive.

Moving to 1962, Acker Bilk had a missing chart-topper with his TV theme, "Stranger on the Shore", and another trad musician, Kenny Ball, topped the NME chart with "The March of the Siamese Children" from The King and I. Chubby Checker's "Let's Twist Again" sounds like a number one in anyone's book, but it only reached number two in Record Retailer. This is because the two sides of the Record Retailer number one, "Can't Help Falling in Love", and "Rock a Hula Baby", were shown separately in the NME Top 10, thus causing Elvis to suffer from a slipped disc. I wonder how this can be; someone couldn't have bought "Can't Help Falling in Love" without buying "Rock a Hula Baby", and vice versa.

And so to 23 February 1963. According to Record Retailer, Frank Ifield was enjoying his third number one with "The Wayward Wind", but in NME he was shown at joint number one with the Beatles. The following week, Frank had dropped to number two and the Beatles had the top slot to themselves. Flash forward to June 1963, and Lennon and McCartney share in another missing number one, as they wrote Billy J Kramer's "Do You Want to Know a Secret?"

The Beatles' biggest rivals, the Rolling Stones, have a missing number one with "19th Nervous Breakdown", and the Hollies ("I Can't Let Go") and the Yardbirds ("For Your Love") also topped the NME chart but not the Record Retailer. The Everly Brothers' powerful "Price Of Love" and Len Barry's dance routine "1, 2, 3" are also missing number ones. The final missing number one is Paul Ryan's epic "Eloise".

Although the BMRB and then Gallup have compiled an official chart since 1969, it has been fiddled on at least one occasion. In 1977 Virgin Records released the Sex Pistols' attack on the Silver Jubilee, "God Save the Queen". It entered at number 10 and looked as though it would be number one during Jubilee week itself. This horrified the loyal compilers, and so for one week they decreed that shops which sold their own records could not have those records represented in the chart - hence, Virgin's sales of "God Save the Queen" were immediately barred from the statistics, letting the Pistols' detested rival, Rod Stewart, hold sway that week with "I Don't Want to Talk About it."

So, the answer to the question "What was the Beatles" first number one?" is: "Please, Please Me" - or is it? The Beatles' first single, "Love Me Do", made Number 17 in Record Retailer and number 27 in NME. However, in Liverpool, the record retailer Brian Epstein published his own shop's Top 10 and, in October 1962, "Love Me Do" was at number one in the chart in NEMS's window.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus

Day In a Page

How six would-be record-breakers ended up in seriously deep water

In deep water

Container ship saves crew cast adrift on life rafts after their Atlantic crossing turns into a scramble for survival
Police watchdog admitted system was ineffective

Police watchdog admitted system was ineffective

Revelation comes after Independent investigation into deaths in police custody
Stalemate at UN on resolution urging Assad to go

Stalemate at UN on resolution urging Assad to go

A defiant Russia resists intense pressure from the West and several Arab countries
Syria is used to the slings and arrows of friends and enemies

Syria is used to the slings and arrows of friends and enemies

Bashar al-Assad is clinging to power despite the slow growth of a civil war
QPR big spenders as Zamora and Cissé join

QPR big spenders as Zamora and Cissé join

...while Harry Redknapp is up to his old tricks again with day of movement at Tottenham
James Lawton: Time has come for the game to tear down its last taboo

James Lawton: Football's last taboo

A new documentary about the tragic death of Justin Fashanu is a powerful reminder of a prejudice that still shames British football
Graham Rowntree: 'Scotland will be licking their lips'

Graham Rowntree interview

The England coach says home side will be favourites on Saturday due to red rose side's 'unspeakable past'
Bed and breakfast – and yoga and cookery

Bed and breakfast – and yoga and cookery

The British B&B has undergone a transformation
Lakshadweep: All quiet on India's secret islands

All quiet on India's secret islands

Part of the same marine mountain range as the Maldives, the Lakshadweep archipelago offers idyllic scenery minus crowds
Around the world in 1,000 destinations

Around the world in 1,000 destinations

Plus the three locations that are the cream of the globe-trotting crop
The 10 Best travel DVDs

The 10 Best travel DVDs

From Mexico and motorcycles to the Mosquito Coast
Adventures with a lost Nick Drake recording

Lost Nick Drake record

And the lucky 167 people who heard it
Independent blogger rescued after boat overturns in Atlantic

Independent blogger capsizes

See the progress of the Sara G in pictures
Should we let children run wild?

Should we let children run wild?

Experiences and expectations of an ideal childhood
Get fit the Djokovic way (it is as hard as it sounds)

Get fit the Djokovic way (it is as hard as it sounds)

The unlikely secrets of the Serb's extraordinary stamina that helped him to victory in an epic Australian Open final