Meteorite microbes aren't from outer space, NASA says

 

 
 
 
 
A meteorite filament is seen in a microscope image as part of a study published by the Journal of Cosmology that claims tiny fossilized bacteria had been found on three meteorites.
 

A meteorite filament is seen in a microscope image as part of a study published by the Journal of Cosmology that claims tiny fossilized bacteria had been found on three meteorites.

Photograph by: Handout photo, Reuters

Top NASA scientists said Monday there was no scientific evidence to support a colleague's claim that fossils of alien microbes born in outer space had been found in meteorites on Earth.

The U.S. space agency formally distanced itself from the paper by NASA scientist Richard Hoover, whose findings were published Friday in the peer-reviewed Journal of Cosmology, which is available free online.

"That is a claim that Mr. Hoover has been making for some years," said Carl Pilcher, director of NASA's Astrobiology Institute.

"I am not aware of any support from other meteorite researchers for this rather extraordinary claim that this evidence of microbes was present in the meteorite before the meteorite arrived on Earth and was not the result of contamination after the meteorite arrived on Earth," he said.

"The simplest explanation is that there are microbes in the meteorites; they are Earth microbes. In other words, they are contamination."

Pilcher said the meteorites that Hoover studied fell to Earth 100 to 200 years ago and have been heavily handled by humans, "so you would expect to find microbes in these meteorites."

Paul Hertz, chief scientist of NASA's Science Mission Directorate in Washington, also issued a statement saying NASA did not support Hoover's findings.

"While we value the free exchange of ideas, data and information as part of scientific and technical inquiry, NASA cannot stand behind or support a scientific claim unless it has been peer-reviewed or thoroughly examined by other qualified experts," Hertz said.

"NASA also was unaware of the recent submission of the paper to the Journal of Cosmology or of the paper's subsequent publication." He noted that the paper did not complete the peer-review process after being submitted in 2007 to the International Journal of Astrobiology.

According to the study, Hoover sliced open fragments of several types of carbonaceous chondrite meteorites, which can contain relatively high levels of water and organic materials, and looked inside with a powerful microscope, Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscopy.

He found bacteria-like creatures, calling them "indigenous fossils" that originated beyond Earth and were not introduced here after the meteorites landed. Hoover "concludes these fossilized bacteria are not Earthly contaminants but are the fossilized remains of living organisms which lived in the parent bodies of these meteors, e.g. comets, moons and other astral bodies," said the study.

"The implications are that life is everywhere, and that life on Earth may have come from other planets."

The journal's editor-in-chief, Rudy Schild of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, hailed Hoover as a "highly respected scientist and astrobiologist with a prestigious record of accomplishment at NASA."

The publication invited experts to weigh in on Hoover's claim, and both skeptics and supporters began publishing their commentaries on the journal's website Monday.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Location refreshed

More on This Story

 
 

Story Tools

 
 
Font:
 
Image:
 
 
 
 
 
A meteorite filament is seen in a microscope image as part of a study published by the Journal of Cosmology that claims tiny fossilized bacteria had been found on three meteorites.
 

A meteorite filament is seen in a microscope image as part of a study published by the Journal of Cosmology that claims tiny fossilized bacteria had been found on three meteorites.

Photograph by: Handout photo, Reuters

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

More Photo Galleries

vic mah.jpg

Gallery: Vic Mah

Edmonton restauranteur Vic Mah, owner of the Blue ...

 
band share day.jpg

Gallery: Band Share Day

Band Share Day is an annual event where students from...

 
Transcend

Gallery: Transcend opens downtown...

Transcend, a local coffee company, has opened its ...

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Breaking News Alert

 
Sign up to receive e-mail alerts on breaking news from The Edmonton Journal.