Self-Immolation Protests In Egypt Continue

Self Immolation

HAMZA HENDAWI   01/18/11 12:10 PM   AP

CAIRO — A 25-year-old unemployed man died in a hospital on Tuesday after setting himself on fire in the Egyptian port city of Alexandria, security officials said, amid a wave of self-immolation attempts possibly inspired by events in Tunisia.

Alexandria resident Ahmed Hashem el-Sayed had been unemployed for a year and suffered from depression and may have been mimicking the Tunisian man who set himself alight last month and set off a popular uprising that deposed the government there, said officials.

The death comes amid a rash of such attempts in Egypt. On Tuesday, two men attempted to set themselves on fire in downtown Cairo, just a day after another man soaked himself in gasoline and burned himself in front of parliament. All three survived, however.

El-Sayed, a construction worker, was on his roof in Alexandria when he slashed his wrists and set himself on fire Monday night, the officials added, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to brief the media. They said el-Sayed has suffered from depression since one of his brothers set himself on fire and died five years ago.

The incidents come as protesters in Mauritania and Algeria also set themselves alight in apparent attempts to copy Tunisian Mohammed Bouazizi, 26, whose self-immolation helped inspire the protests that toppled Tunisia's authoritarian president.

While isolated, the incidents in Egypt, Mauritania and Algeria reflect the growing despair among much of the Arab public which has no real means of expressing its dissatisfaction. They are deeply symbolic means of protest in a region that has little or no tolerance for dissent.

Ben Ali ruled with an iron fist for 23 years. Similarly authoritarian rulers across much of the Arab world have been in power as long or longer, like Libya's Moammar Gadhafi, in power since 1969; Egypt's Hosni Mubarak, in office since 1981; and Yemen's Ali Abdullah Saleh, who has ruled that impoverished nation since he seized power more than 30 years ago.

The stunning collapse of the Tunisian leader drew a litany of calls for change elsewhere in the Arab world, but activists faced the reality of vast security forces heavily vested in the status quo backing hard-line regimes ready to crack down on dissent.

Self-immolation as a method of protest is uncommon in the Arab world, where many associate it with protesters in the Far East or the Indian subcontinent. But Egyptian women in rural or poor urban areas have been known to set themselves on fire to protest violent husbands, abusive parents or an unwanted suitor.

Story continues below
Advertisement

Suicide is prohibited by Islam and on Tuesday, the Cairo-based Al-Azhar, Sunni Islam's premier institution of learning, issued a statement stating that the faith "unequivocally does not sanction suicide, regardless of whether it's an expression of hardship, protest or anger."

Frustration and despair does seem to have been the motivating factor in the Egyptian cases.

Lawyer Mohammed Farouq el-Sayed set himself alight outside the prime minister's office Tuesday, possibly, speculate police, because security forces have been unable to find his long missing teenage daughter. He was rushed to hospital with light burns.

A second man, identified as retired accountant Sayed Ali Sayed, 65, attempted to do the same thing outside the nearby parliament building but was stopped by guards. There was no word on his motive.

Their actions follow those of Abdu Abdel-Moneim Hamadah, who set himself on fire Monday, again outside the parliament, to protest the authorities' denying him cheap subsidized bread to resell to patrons of his small restaurant east of Cairo. He survived with burns to his neck, face and legs.

The four self-immolations in Egypt came at a time of tensions over the economic hardships endured by many Egyptians. Many see the ambitious economic reforms introduced by the government over the past decade to be only benefiting a small clique of rich businessmen linked to the Mubarak regime.

The events in Tunisia and the attempted self-immolations may be unnerving authorities in Egypt.

A front page article in Tuesday's Al-Ahram, the state-owned flagship daily, reminded readers that Mubarak, 82, was keen to lighten the burden on the country's poor and ensure that the benefits of reform reach everyone.

In the absence of any public comment from Mubarak on the Tunisian uprising, the Al-Ahram article appears to be an attempt to reassure Egyptians at a time when critics are drawing parallels between Ben Ali and the Egyptian leader.

Nearly half of Egypt's estimated 80 million people live below or just above the poverty line set by the United Nations at $2 a day. The widespread poverty presents a potential threat to stability, along with the absence of any meaningful political reform.

Bahey Eddin Hassan, head of the Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies, said the growing number of people setting themselves on fire was an indication that Egyptians were beginning to think they can emulate the Tunisian experience in their country.

"The reality is that people see their rulers as the ones responsible for their economic setbacks. People think the Tunisian recipe could work in Egypt since they have tried everything else and nothing worked," he said.

_____

Associated Press reporter Maggie Michael contributed to this report.

Get HuffPost World On Twitter and Facebook!
CAIRO — A 25-year-old unemployed man died in a hospital on Tuesday after setting himself on fire in the Egyptian port city of Alexandria, security officials said, amid a wave of self-immolation ...
CAIRO — A 25-year-old unemployed man died in a hospital on Tuesday after setting himself on fire in the Egyptian port city of Alexandria, security officials said, amid a wave of self-immolation ...
.@marcusgilmer Have you heard the 1st single off Cake's new one? It's like a checklist of all their quirks over the years. Self-parody.
note to self: when rcving an award/recognition, don't say "oh idk if I deserve but thanks" say "FRIGYA and thanks"
31 minutes ago from web
An act of faith, desperation or protest: Self-immolations through time.
39 minutes ago from web
: Finance Minister dismisses self-immolating protesters, praises economy and "free and open" society.
Goldman's Self-Help: Eat, Pay, Trade
2 hours ago from web
Blog Post: Ocean Empire Super Yacht is Self-Sustainable, Costs $17 Million
True, except for purposes of making fun of the audience on Twitter. Which is what I was doing. (And including self in audience.)
When Self-Promotion Goes Too Far - authentic intros only happen once!
2011: Self-Assembling Dynamic Networks And Boundary-less Tribalism - published by Business Insider
Lieberman compares self to JFK in retirement presser. I had NO idea he got laid that frequently
3 hours ago from web
MT : RT : Conleezza Rice 2 'Cannot imagine self running 4 office'/Couldn't imagine terrorist attack w/ a memo
The world's saddest self-help book EVER: "How to Save Your Marriage Alone"
Link to BEST GREEN BLOGS comments section ripe for shameless self promotion... :)
I have great faith in fools - self-confidence, my friends call it. [Edgar Allan Poe]
The Middle East's desperate new trend! RT : Eighth Algerian sets self on fire: report
Oprah's Authentic Self What does it mean to be your authentic self? During their much-touted interview on Mo
"Journalism is important. It must never, however, be full of its own self-importance." More where that came from:
Self-promoting on behalf--needs his due. RT see 's wonderful biography of .
4 hours ago from web
Do you ever think of your "future self"? -Jenna
: solipsistic, adj. the theory that only the self exists; egoistic self-absorption
Filed by Cara Parks  |  Report Corrections
 
Comments
171
Pending Comments
13
View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »   (5 total)
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Hirnlego   1 hour ago (12:00 PM)
photo
isaidit   3 hours ago (10:11 AM)
Tunisia's revolt has fired up a lot of people. And we did not have to invade. Imaginetha­t.
photo
consequenceofsounds   14 hours ago (11:10 PM)
That photo is EXTREMELY disturbing­.
photo
bogey1   16 hours ago (9:22 PM)
to those so critical of this act, recall;

--- Norman Morrison, a 31-year-ol­d Quaker from Baltimore who, in 1965, handed his infant
daughter off to a bystander, doused himself with kerosene and set himself ablaze under [then U.S. Sec. of Defence] McNamara's window at the Pentagon..
One week later, another antiwar protester, Roger LaPorte, did the same thing in front of the United Nations building in New York..
McNamara would later describe Morrison's death as "a tragedy not only for his family but also for me and the country. It was an outcry against the killing that was destroying the lives of so many Vietnamese and American youth." ----

one could argue this act started real protest against the U.S. involvemen­t in the Vietnam War
holyghostie   14 hours ago (11:01 PM)
and it took another 10 years to get out of Vietnam.
SWhit   8 hours ago (4:58 AM)
Not to mention the Buddhist Monks in South Vietnam that did it to protest aganist the RVN regime.

It's a similar situation, the RVN was just as oppressive aganist political dissent as some of these countries in the Mid East.
photo
TricksR4Kids   16 hours ago (8:57 PM)
Interestin­g the wording and lingo that's used when its a Muslim who acts violently within their country. In comparison to when it happens in the USA.
photo
TricksR4Kids   16 hours ago (8:56 PM)
It's one of the worst options. So uneducated that you don't know that most people survive.
photo
Level7   16 hours ago (8:55 PM)
If they are intent on self immolation­, isn't it more cruel to try to save them, causing them a lifetime of excruciati­ng pain, than letting them complete their horrible task?
photo
cvbnm67   18 hours ago (7:46 PM)
All well and good, setting yourself on fire, if you die. However, if you survive you are in a world of pain.
Half a century   11 hours ago (2:18 AM)
Can't imagine being on fire how painful it really is - yet still alive, which sets his crippling pain like almost forever. His family would suffer even more terribly to care for him when they have no income.
JackTheSkipper   18 hours ago (7:36 PM)
I nominate this guy for the Darwanian award.
photo
Manny Peddy   18 hours ago (7:28 PM)
Suicide is prohibited by Islam and on Tuesday, the Cairo-base­d Al-Azhar, Sunni Islam's premier institutio­n of learning, issued a statement stating that the faith "unequivoc­ally does not sanction suicide, regardless of whether it's an expression of hardship, protest or anger."
========
Or as a weapon against kuffars.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lostfan13   18 hours ago (7:17 PM)
Whatever happened to the strongly worded letter?

I'm all for freedom for political speech, but acts of self immolation and other attempts at suicide and/or martyrdom do nothing besides deplete your side of its more vociferous supporters­.
photo
cvbnm67   18 hours ago (7:45 PM)
It only takes one voice to change the course of history.
photo
CptFreakout   18 hours ago (7:11 PM)
Sometimes its the only way to be heard , in some places extreme is the only way for a protest to get the leaders attention or the medias attention on conditions .
photo
TYRANNASAURUS   3 hours ago (10:28 AM)
And their leaders still don't care.
photo
TYRANNASAURUS   19 hours ago (6:53 PM)
Self-Immol­ation Protests In Egypt Continue..­..

I see all bandaged up.......w­hy waste the time and money on them if that's what they want to do?

With 7,000,000,­000 people in the world and the medical expenses for them for the next 50 years.....­. it's a lose lose story.
BigSuede   19 hours ago (6:47 PM)
It is too bad the common people in these arab lands are not free to own guns- then a real rebellion would be possible
hottingers   18 hours ago (7:33 PM)
It is so much better in the Sudan where they have guns.
photo
Behind the Tweed Curtain   17 hours ago (7:56 PM)
Congo is also very excellent.
BigSuede   15 hours ago (10:49 PM)
I would rather live in an area where I had a chance to fight for my freedom, than to be stuck with so much despair that I would rather burn myself alive.

Say what you will- but i would rather live in Darfur than deal with the hopelessne­ss of being poor in egypt.
photo
RubalKhali   7 hours ago (6:39 AM)
Too bad you don't know much about these "arab lands" ( that would be Arab),
While their reported rates of civilian gun possession tend to be above the global average, the seven nations of North Africa record the lowest homicide rates on the continent.

Estimated civilian gun possession rates in North Africa range from Africa’s lowest, Tunisia (0.1 firearms per 100 people), to one of Africa’s highest, Libya (15.5). The remainder range from 3.5 in Egypt to 7.6 in Algeria – excluding Western Sahara, for which no figures are available.
http://www­.gunpolicy­.org/firea­rms/region­/united-st­ates

Homicide rates are highest in conflict-r­idden Sudan, which experience­d 4.6 direct conflict deaths per 100,000 people in 2007, and a homicide rate of 28.6 per 100,000 in 2004. The remaining North African states have estimated homicide rates ranging from as low as 1.1 in Morocco, to 9.6 in more heavily armed Algeria.In 2007 the U.S. had a homocide rate of 4.9 per 100,000- higher than in Sudan
BigSuede   0 minute ago (1:25 PM)
thank you for substantia­ting my argument! Least civilians with guns are tunsia and egypt- both area where citizens feel it was neccesary to light themselves on fire due to hopelessne­ss.

One could also argue that are the most oppressed people's in the region by its government­. Also interestin­g that libya having the highest number of civilian gun ownership (which is STILL SUPER LOW compared to the US) has been making SOME strides at correcting human rights abuses and becoming a member of the UN- very interestin­g!

Civilian gun rates DECREASE the amount of government oppression­!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lolawants1117   19 hours ago (6:45 PM)
Protesting does not always work. Taking it out on yourself is the wrong way to go about making a change.
http://ale­ttertothep­eople.blog­spot.com/2­011/01/dea­r-self-imm­olators.ht­ml

Twitter Edition