Creator: Shiro Amano
Publisher: TokyoPop
Age Rating: All Ages
Genre: Action
RRP: $5.99
Kingdom Hearts v1
Reviewed by Tom Rosin

A double whammy, in that if you've never played the game before, this is so badly constructed that you won't be able to follow a page of it, and if you have, this will prove the biggest disappointment since that love letter you found left tucked in your coat pocket turned out to be intended for your identically dressed best friend. Kingdom Hearts, the game, was a charming blend of Disney and Final Fantasy characters, full of light, colour, secrets, battles, and moments of "awww..." as well as "aaaarggh! (I've gone through the wrong door, the roof's now a floor and the fireplace is completely inaccessible! Plus I've just been smacked to death by a giant, unravelly thing that appears to be made out of yellow and blue baubles!)".

It was exciting, it was mysterious, and it gave you a considerable degree of freedom in what you chose to explore and when. On a great, big TV set. This... this is a miserable little, black, white and grey mess, barely readable through ill-judged layouts, completely without surprises for players (99%, I would suggest, of those picking it up now) and therefore utterly pointless. So why are we selling so many? Is it the comfort of the familiar? Are we really that unadventurous as a race now? There were so many pieces of beautiful animation - like the two young lovers holding out their arms to embrace, but floating straight through each other - that are completely buggered, drained of all emotional power.

"The door is opening..." Well, shut it, along with this book.

Comment on this review of Kingdom Hearts v1 on the Manga Life Forums.


6 October 2009
Naruto v46
We Were There v6



home | reviews | news | features | about us | advertise | privacy policy | contact us
All materials © Manga Life, 2005 - Site designed and hosted by Silver Bullet Hosting