Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
GamesForumsCheatsStore
Amazon's 2009 bestsellers almost all Wii | Rock Band bags McCartney, Blink-182 | Lost Planet 2 screens | Borderlands Mad Moxxi's Underdome Riot out now | Dragon Age DLC coming Jan 5 | UK: Games outsell movies | C&C; eyes "new medium" | Sony goes multi-core for PS4? | ModNation Racers update | 25% off Telltale games | FIFA 10 World Cup due April? | GTA 5 info at E3? | 3D Realms: Strong resurgence coming for Duke | Merry Christmas and Happy New Year | PSN gets first premium avatars | Final Fantasy XIV screens show customisation, boobs | Gold PS3 "world's most expensive console" | Uncharted 2 Double Cash | Tekken movie poster | Pac-Man the most recognisable game character | LocoRoco festive wallpapers | Aliens vs. Predator: The story trailer | New comics for PSP | LittleBigPlanet Water levels out now | THQ signs eight-year WWE deal
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Download PC Games
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » PlayStation » Reviews
PreviousSAW PS3The Saboteur PS3Next

Demon's Souls Review

Dark, cruelly hard, brave action RPG offers pleasure from pain
The message written by another player in pulsing blood red lettering on a dark cobblestone: "I want to go home now", reflects your feelings exactly. It's just one of Demon's Souls multitude of innovative features: the ability for anyone to leave a message in the game world for others to draw comfort, inspiration or knowledge from.

"Watch out for the boulders", advises one message, ensuring that you gingerly hug the castle's cold wall before inching round a tight corner. "The real Demon's Souls starts here!" exclaims another directly after a particularly gruelling boss fight, an amusing, if disheartening reminder that Demon's' Souls challenge is anything but scaling.

These messages, automatically downloaded to your game at log in, are important because they offer one of the few moments of comfort in a game that is otherwise totally bereft of it. For pampered modern gamers, Demon's Souls is not so much a challenging game as an abusive one. Most players will be left reeling and disorientated from its first few hours, wondering why their gaming skill has deserted them.

It's not that the mission is complicated or unfamiliar - this is an action RPG all right. Depending on which character class you pick, you're given a sword and shield and a throng of tatty enemies to hack and slash your way through.

Neither is it that the game is particularly unfair. You're rarely overwhelmed by sheer numbers of enemies and they rarely outclass you. In those moments when you do stumble into a dragon's lair several score levels higher than your character, you'll be suitably warned by player's messages long before you wake it. Rather, the game punishes your mistakes in the extreme, allowing no compromise for the player who stabs at the attack button or neglects to keep their shield raised at all times.

In punishing every tiny mistake, it re-acclimatises you to its challenge while warning that no one who rushes in unprepared lives to tell the tale.Occasionally you'll stumble across a 'soul sign' in the castle, a symbol that indicates a stranger in your level range that wishes to join your game. Up to three people can play online co-operatively, although you've no choice over who enters. However, the brutal difficulty ensures that any stranger is considered a friend.

Death is something all Demon's Souls players grow accustomed to. While the game has the appearance of a Lord of the Rings-style epic, with is flickering torch lights, rumbling skies and foreboding turrets, it has more in common with high score arcade games. You are expected to fail as, each time you do, you'll be deposited back at the start of an area and made to do it again, inching forward with each attempt.

The need for care is heightened by the game's unique economy. Every killed enemy drops Soul Points, which can be spent in the game's infrequent shops on new equipment or on levelling up your characters base stats. However, when you die you drop all of your unspent Soul Points to the ground where they can be recovered only if you can make it back to the same spot. Dying is doubly frustrating as it also turns you into a ghoul, a weakened state from which you can only return by defeating the next boss or using a rare and valuable potion.

The relentless setbacks are eased by the spectacle of some of gaming's most memorable boss fights. From fighting monsters in the half light to battling a 30-foot silver knight with nothing but arrows and a prayer, the game's sky-high stakes ensure its rewards are also irresistible.

Demon's Souls is a rare creation in today's market of easy, anyone-can-succeed games. It rewards mastery over mere perseverance, and, while those rewards are hard won, they are also some of gaming's most intoxicating.

PSM3 Magazine
// Overview
Verdict
Overall A startling, yet satisfying experience - if you can handle it.
// Screenshots
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Read all 27 commentsPost a Comment
Really would like to see this get an official Euro release but thats looking more unlikely as time goes on.
lonewolf2002 on 30 Nov '09
I have to admit that after playing this for a few hours, I did begin to wonder if I had wasted £45 importing this. But after telling myself that it must have recieved all those good reviews for a reason, I persevered and did indeed realize what all the fuss was about.

Bloody hard but bloody good Surprised .
Jeffers15 on 30 Nov '09
I have to admit that after playing this for a few hours, I did begin to wonder if I had wasted £45 importing this. But after telling myself that it must have recieved all those good reviews for a reason, I persevered and did indeed realize what all the fuss was about.

Bloody hard but bloody good Surprised .

Same here, but I didnt persevere past those few hours. So I resold it on eBay and made a profit while I was at it, so something good came out of it at the end of the day.
zozobra on 30 Nov '09
This game above all others this year has got me excited, im getting it for christmas, cant wait to be punished by it Very Happy
beanhead81 on 30 Nov '09
It's mental this isn't gettin an EU release as it's F'ing awesome. The only reason its not hitting the 90's score wise is because there's too many pampered wussies out there used to plowing through hordes of enemies who dont bite back. The graphics and atmosphere have to be seen to be believed. Great.
NugNugs79 on 1 Dec '09
Demon's Souls sounds like my kind of game, but I'm holding out for a European release, only because there are tons of great games to play already.

Hopefully it gets a summer 2010 release date. That would probably be just about perfect.
Mark240473 on 1 Dec '09
this game scares me. Not in a fright kinda way but in a 'can my perseverance handle it' kind of a way. It does intrigue me but would i decide the stress of dying over and over mean I'd stop playing it completely? By the sounds of it there is enough to keep you playing
dannybuoy on 1 Dec '09
It turned up here yesterday, a present for my upcoming birthday from my sister.

I was tempted to open it and play it early, but i resisted.

I've heard a lot about the game so i hope it doesn't disappoint.
blagger on 1 Dec '09
This has always sounded brilliant and - if I had a PS3 - I'd have imported it by now.

So strange that there's still no confirmation on an EU release. Does anyone else think it's just a case of Sony knowing that it's being imported by those that want it anyway? - after all, it clearly isn't for everyone.

Smile
ParmaViolet on 1 Dec '09
getting it for christmas. Can't wait. It'll be good to have a proper challenge after borderlands.
WHERESMYMONKEY on 1 Dec '09
Picked up the deluxe edition a couple of weeks ago, it's not as hard as people say if you take your time and think about all your actions.

Don't get me wrong, i'm dying really often, but it's due to my own mistakes and over confidence.

The online side of this game is great, it's genuinely scary when a player invades your game and you've no idea where they are going to appear from.

I recomend this game to anyone who is after a challenge and doesn't mind a bit of level grinding and treading old ground. (some parts of levels are only open/unguarded once you've done something in another level)
vaynes on 1 Dec '09
Seriously not as difficult as people make. Trial and error is the name of the game here.
You may need to check an online guide for certain things (where to collect weapon upgrade stones) but in general its pretty manageable if you give it the time and patience it deserves cos if you don't it will punish you. But with this comes a high sense of pleasure and fulfillment the kind so rarely seen in games today.
wuntuwuntu on 1 Dec '09
i seriously need this game. where can i import it from ? it looks magnificent reminds me of my favourite rpg , vagrant story, in a way but looks superior. man thank goodness it's christmas.
splojgonxee on 1 Dec '09
This game is occupying me for 2 weeks now, so far I've lost like 90 hours in it and I'm not done with it (I want that platinum trophy). Meanwhile, Dragon Age: Origins, Assassin's Creed 2 and GoW Collection are sitting on my shelf. Unfortunately, they've arrived few days after Demon's Souls which has left my PS3 only for a few minutes while I checked out AC2, DASurprised and remastered GoW... and immediately went back to DS.

It's awesome. Last game that sucked my free time this much was Persona 4...
Vyvrtka on 2 Dec '09
ye this is the type of game were you're basically paying 40 odd quid for a stroke, sounds good!

8.8 because its not on the xbox CVG?? WinkCool
bunneyo on 2 Dec '09
For the people sayinh "im getting it for xmas" ...you should its a great game . Fully worth it
______________________________
(no spam)
Playstation/xbox/wii fans add me and check out my blog please http://luger992.wordpress.com/
RexLuger on 2 Dec '09
Just get it - after playing this it's hard to go back to the cotton-covered and hand-holding world of most other games. It is truly one of the best games around.

My advice is to stick with it - the beginning is the hardest bit and that is to teach you that this is different to other games - hack and slash doesn't work, nor does rushing in. You have to think.

The fact that you loose so much when you die makes you value your life and therefor gives you a genuine fear and excitement as you force yourself forward down dark castle corridors with strange noises ahead. It doesn't tell you what to do - you have to work it out. And that's the genius of the game - it's how it gives you such a sense of achievement where you sleep walk through so many other games.
DonnerKebab on 6 Dec '09
where can i get this then?
splojgonxee on 6 Dec '09
where can i get this then?

Ebay is only place Ive seen this.
NEOnburN9 on 6 Dec '09
where can i get this then?

Heres another :

http://www.renchi.com/renchi/PS3_Games_US_Demon_s_Souls.htm

Just pump it into google you should get a fair few hits.
lonewolf2002 on 7 Dec '09
You can get it from these guys too for £41.99:

http://www.movietyme.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=46260

I've ordered a couple of early BDs from them before and they're pretty good
Random Hangman on 8 Dec '09
http://www.gamesbasement.co.uk...

I imported this game from the above site. /First import for my PS3 and believe me, it is well worth it!!
wuntuwuntu on 8 Dec '09
Forget OTT prices on ebay, got mine from axelmusic.com for 38 quid, they have the deluxe version too for a few quid more, excellent game.
Oneohfour on 10 Dec '09
This game is not for the everyday gamer, no interest.
CatlinYantha on 12 Dec '09
Ordered this from Axelmusic.com for 38 quid, not holding out for a European release that's not going to happen probably. Should have the game this week. If you want to play this just import, it' not hard to do.
Nick_JD_ on 14 Dec '09
Beware buying on ebay, I got mine for about £42 from a Hong Kong ebay shop and it took nearly 2 months to arrive!!

Still on the tutorial which was fairly straightforward until I encountered the first boss and died seconds later, lol. Atmosphere, sound and gfx are brilliant.
zakrocz on 24 Dec '09
Well. What can I say. I played this twice. First time doing the tutorial. Second for an entire morning. I died twice during my morning long stint and really didn't get anywhere. Got a few rings and made it a bit further into the castle but the final straw was when my Internet connection dropped and I was signed out of the game and returned to the title screen. I wanted to smash the game up! At this point I decided I had made a terrible mistake buying this game. I no way have enough time to do this one justice. I mean come on. No pause button! My life demands that I play in dribs as drabs. I need checkpoints, not cos I'm a bad gamer, but just cos running your own business, being married and expecting a baby doesn't really suit this game. It was fun while it lasted but it's been on eBay and I actually made money on it. Silver lining. I'm now really enjoying pixel junk shooter. Sorted
dannybuoy on 31 Dec '09
Read all 27 commentsPost a Comment
// Screenshots
PreviousNext3 / 8 Screenshots
// Related Content
Reviews:
More Related
Demon's Soulsfrom £49.99
GameseekNo Information£49.99
PriceMinister UKIn Stock£75.00
// The Best ofCVG
Click here to subscribe to PC Gamer magazine.
Click here to subscribe to PC Zone magazine.
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Pro Evolution Soccer 6 | Metal Gear Solid 4 | Grand Theft Auto IV | LittleBigPlanet | Demon's Souls | Zone of the Enders 3
Rage | The Beatles: Rock Band | Battlefield 1943 | The Last Guardian | Project Trico
Top Reviews: Bayonetta Review | James Cameron's Avatar: The Game | The Saboteur | Demon's Souls | SAW | Assassins Creed 2
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 | Dragon Age: Origins | DJ Hero | Tekken 6 | Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
Copyright 2006 - 2009 Future Publishing Limited,
Beauford Court, 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, UK BA1 2BW
England and Wales company registration number 2008885