Considering Torture, and the Rise of Harsh Bondage

Violet Blue: Erotic art prankster Midori's show "Taken" puts Amnesty International in the dungeon

Thursday, September 10, 2009


Print Comments 
Font | Size:

Conservatives and feminists love to freak out about BDSM practices and imagery. CIA doctors can perform human torture experiments in the name of national security, but show a few pics of the Folsom Street Fair on Fox News and you've got a nice hysterical anti-kink TV segment to make the uptight neocons and feministas all riled. All the same, it seems as though people who decry kink don't realize that it's made of elaborate fantasies about bad nurses, not actual doctors who waterboard, and that the participants are playful, consenting adults, not helpless prisoners.

Published in Best Sex Writing 2009, Morgana Maye wrote "An Open Letter to the Bush Administration" -- where she appeals to the administration then in power because they are doing her job better than she can, and it's hurting her as an American small business owner. Maye said, "Your administration has successfully organized what has to be the longest nonconsensual public edge-play scene in recent history. I look at your capacity to manufacture fear, degradation, torture and absolute powerlessness, and I can't top that."

Similarly, people who practice BDSM forget -- or blatantly do not want to acknowledge any relationship to -- the real events that inform dark fantasies. Author, sex educator, bondage expert and artist Midori tells me, "Lately I've noticed a definite increase in interest for harsh bondage imagery in porn, mainstream entertainment and personal sexual play that depicts harsh incarceration, kidnapping and interrogation. It's just not the Betty Page in fuzzy cuffs anymore. I am not sure why this is, but it's happening."

It's that very line of thinking that fueled Midori's most unforgettable art performance to date: The shocking stunt she pulled off at Art of Restraint, local gallery Femina Potens' amazing bondage-based art event series. Midori recounts, "I began to compose this piece 'Taken' several months back. Then the Iranian election revolt erupted, which further inspired me."

According to gallery witnesses, Midori (@planetmidori) was working on a bondage art demonstration with CCTV-style surveillance cameras rolling. Mid-demonstration, the SFPD burst in with a SWAT team and literally wrenched the gallery door open and hauled out a "dissident."

Gallery patrons were so shocked, one woman reeled, stumbled and fell stunned (she was okay.) It all happened in just under 30 seconds. Strangely, I was driving on Market Street by the gallery when this happened; I remember seeing a police car out front and thinking I should tweet what I had witnessed. From the street it looked like a gallery raid. When I got home I started checking the Twitter streams of friends I knew who were at the event, and texting them to see if everything was okay. Nothing.

Turns out, all was well and the supposed "SWAT" team had in fact worked in tandem with an SFPD escort, and when they pulled the "dissident" from the performance they dropped special Amnesty International flyers on the way out. The surveillance cams were just for Midori's performance. It was an action.

I asked Midori about the police -- were they really SFPD? She told me, "No, the 'uniformed men' who busted into the gallery to perform the 'Taken' performance are friends of mine acting the part. We rehearsed this many, many times to get it realistic with speed and safety. Their part of the performance action took 28 seconds! I called the SFPD in advance to notify them of the details of the performance. The last thing we needed were well-meaning citizens calling the police and SFPD arresting my performance group. It would have been a big bummer for my performers and waste of police time and tax dollars, right? I wanted to buy my performers beer, not bail. The SFPD were totally great. The two officers that showed up understood the nature and purpose of the performance; they were really nice and supportive. They took up a comfortable, out-of-sight location and made sure that it all went well. After the performance we signaled that it was over, they smiled, waved and went on their merry way."

Midori added, "Many of us in the crew are individuals whose citizenship status has changed for various reasons, experiencing the impermanence of national identity. We come from different political beliefs, original citizenships, income levels, ethnic identity, orientation and genders. We came together for this performance action believing in liberty being a good thing. That we could do this, as we did, and not face dire consequences, this alone is remarkable. We're actually quite grateful to our local police."

The "dissident" was present at the event all evening; I wondered if this person was an innocent bystander? Who was it? Midori explained, "'The Target' was intentionally chosen. He is a person likely to be profiled as potentially undesirable, by authorities in many of today's nations. This particular performer is someone who was granted political asylum based on being a persecuted minority -- he was brutalized at the hands of the authority in his country of origin for being queer."

I had to know why Midori would stage a surprise mock abduction during a sexy bondage event. Surely this is the kind of association that most makes BDSM practitioners uncomfortable. She tells me:

My understanding is that the Art of Restraint isn't a sexy bondage event. It's about performance and visual art using the words, images and iconography of bondage as a departure point. If someone wants a sexy bondage event, there are plenty of fetish parties or nightclubs to go to. A person hooded, on the floor, naked and cuffed: If the only context or response that a person has to this image is a fun Saturday night of role-playing at the local kink party, are we starving our own humanity?

I'm not saying that we should not play with our dark fantasies and archetypes, but we shouldn't lose sight of the real-world human events that necessitate these narratives.

So many of us take for granted the enormous luxury of privacy and civil liberties. We assume that our homes and closed-door places of gathering will keep us safe. We speak and write our thoughts without fearing major consequences. We take for granted the notion of justice and individual rights. Yet for many around the world, as well as in our own back yard, these are ideas that are beyond their grasp, even as they struggle towards it.

People like us, those privileged with privacy and civil liberties read the headlines and watch the news. Subsets of this privileged citizenry are also those who enjoy the pleasures and luxury of adventurous sexual self-expression. Which is a fantastic luxury -- beloved so here in the cradle of the Sex Positive movement. We play with fantasies, innocent to intense, often borrowing themes and imagery from the darker sides of human behavior and history. Humans have always taken narrative from conflict and taboo, whether in forms of story telling, theatre or sexual fantasies -- that's nothing new. What's new is our near total separation of our places of perceived danger from places of personal safety.

Maybe it's a war-weary culture's subconscious search for a coping mechanism. Maybe it's over saturation of images and reports on violence by governments and power-holders. Maybe it's a desensitized culture seeking stimulation. Maybe it's just another sexuality trend, and this too will come and go. I don't know.

I am disturbed, though, that so many who enjoy consuming or acting out fantasy actions of detention and incarcerations don't seem to think of the reality of where these images come from. Arty kinkster hipsters chatter on about how bondage is freedom and art and so on, but so often it just feels like lip-service to transgressiveness when we've nothing to struggle against.

The parallel between fetish and freedom is so apparent and important, I have to wonder -- what if sites like Kink.com and Twisted Factory made vocal, visible and generous donations to Amnesty International?

Don't lose that handcuff key. Read Midori's post-"Taken" notes here (livejournal.com). Midori's new one-woman show "Plastics" at Femina Potens continues through October 1st, with a performance highlight opening on September 19th at 7:30 pm.


Violet Blue

Violet Blue is author and editor of nearly two dozen sexual health books and erotica collections. She is a professional sex educator, lecturer, podcaster, blogger, vlogger, porn/erotica reviewer and machine artist. She has written for outlets ranging from Forbes.com to O, The Oprah Magazine.

Violet is also a fetish model, an art machines expert, a Laughing Squid guest blogger, GETV reporter, SF Appeal staffer, sexy food blogger at BrokeAss Gourmet, fun to follow on Twitter, a San Francisco native and a Forbes Web Celeb. Her tech site is Techyum; her audio and e-books are at Digita Publications.

For more information and links to Web sites discussed in Open Source Sex, go to Violet Blue's Web site, tinynibbles.com.


Print

Comments


advertisement | your ad here

San Francisco Chronicle Real Estate

From
Pacific Union

SANTA ROSA

5 BR / 3 BA

$319,000.00

SONOMA

2 BR / 2 BA

$550,000.00

MILL VALLEY

3 BR / 2 BA

$6,000.00

SANTA ROSA

3 BR / 3 BA

$322,050.00

SAN RAFAEL

2 BR / 2 BA

$689,000.00

SAN FRANCISCO

2 BR / 2 BA

$1,480,000.00

SAN FRANCISCO

7 BR / 7 BA

$45,000,000.00

PALM SPRINGS

2 BR / 2 BA

$479,000.00

SAN FRANCISCO

4 BR / 3.5 BA

$1,950,000.00

LARKSPUR

2 BR / 2 BA

$969,000.00

Real Estate

Home prices' big role as crisis hit state hard

The bankruptcy of Lehman Bros. reverberated with particular fury in California, where it helped deepen...

Search Real Estate »


Cars

The new Bentley Mulsanne -- what recession?

So here is the 2011 Bentley Mulsanne, a new version of an historic marque. The Mulsanne is scheduled to be...

Search Cars »


Jobs

Unemployment rate doesn't tell the whole story

Yosha Bourgea earned $43,000 a year teaching school until he lost his job about a year ago and had to settle...

Search Jobs »

Advertisers