Home Previews Reviews Top Media GT HD Gameplay Retrospectives User Movies Forums Community
Username:
Password:
Summer
Level 5
Stats
Blogs
User Movies
Friends
User Movies
Blogs
2067 views
5-1-2007 at 12:42am
942 views
9-15-2006 at 4:25pm
865 views
9-3-2006 at 1:11am
659 views
6-16-2006 at 3:49pm
594 views
8-24-2006 at 1:04pm
581 views
8-9-2006 at 2:30am
581 views
8-29-2006 at 2:28am
« Prev 1 2 ... of 6 Next »
Add User to Friends
Message this User
Report this User
"Here's another curse. May all your bacon burn!" Calcifer - Howl's Moving Castle
Eragon the Book vs Eragon the Movie
Posted May 1, 2007 12:42 am
[+39]
Get ready for a bloody review, which may include spoilers. So beware!

A friend of mine told me to read the book because he said it was good. I decided to do this before seeing the movie, which had been out on dvd for some time already. The book was cheap and on sale in the book store.

The book....was very slow paced. If you could not get through Lord of the Rings, then Eragon might not be the book for you. Although, one good thing it had was short chapters, between 2 to 10 pages at the most. If they had been Lord of the Rings sized chapters, it would have made it much harder to read. It is a "teen" book, but there are some graphic images in there that are actually kinda disturbing. For example (spoiler!) when Eragon and Brom went to Yazuac, there was a pile of bodies, killed by the Urgal, and on top was the body of a baby (there is more to this, but you get the idea).

Personally, when I was a teen (which was not that long ago) I don't ever remember reading anything like this at all! It is true that the writing level is teen for this book, but the graphic images are anything but. There were also some sexual references that surprised me when I read it.

Overall, I liked the book, but definitely not enough to read it again. I do plan on reading the second, but not at the moment. The character development was slow, and it took me awhile to get a sense of each character's personality. I really liked the idea of it and the history behind the characters is explained in full and was kept simple, which is really important for me. I easily forget who is related to who when there is a complex history involved.

Now onto the movie…………….and it sucked in comparison to the book. If I had not read the book, then I would have liked the movie. They took the story and butchered it, rearranged it, and sped it up a ton. I understand that there was a lot they had to cut out to make it into an hour and a half movie, but I don’t think they needed to alter the story so much! It was almost painful watching that movie.

They had a great story to use, but they messed it up terribly. Now they will have to mess the 2nd book around to get it to match the storyline of the movie, if there is a second movie. I wonder if they read ahead and saw if the characters they cut out from the first one appear in the second with greater importance, because they may have screwed themselves there. I can think of 4 characters so far, one in particular that they should have included, because all of their parts were bigger than Arya’s. It’s funny that they would make her an important character because she is the “love” interest.

So if you read the book, do not watch the movie and vice versa.


Showing all 8 Comments
[0]
Posted 5-1-2007 1:41am
that is the one thing i don't like about reading the book versions of a movie they seem to almost always kill one another but mainly the movie because they have to leave out parts and some times they take out some of the key important parts that later on they will need to continue the story for a sequel
[0]
Posted 5-1-2007 6:24am
I`ve read the Lord of the Rings 3 or 4 times now and wasn`t too happy with the movies.
Seems like Eragon is no exception.
I think I`m going with the book.

[0]
Posted 5-1-2007 12:47pm
I read and watched the movie, and I think the book is WAY better. It has more detail, and Brom and Eragon bond more and...it's just better lol
[0]
Posted 5-1-2007 6:29pm
Arya's the elf, if I can remember correctly. She's actually a pretty important character throughout the story so far (I'm including the second book), so it isn't entirely just the love interest.

I've read both the books, but it's been a while since I read them. I have Netflix, so for the hell of it, I think I'm ganna watch it myself, but thanks for the heads up. I've heard this from a lot of people, so I guess it's true. I love Eragon, the book, but I guess I shouldn't like the movie. :P

Thanks! -n_n-
[0]
Posted 5-2-2007 9:18am
I always find books better than films, even LOTR which was are some of the best films ever created are not a patch on the triology of novels.

Not seen Eragon or read book but i liked LOTR books even with the slow pace so maybe ill try it.
[0]
Posted 5-6-2007 9:40pm
I own, and have read both the books...but when I heard and saw trailers to the movie, I wanted to scream. The book had so much more to it than the movie does and the size of Saphira's egg is just not what it was represented as in the book. from a pebble, to a large rock? it's sad that they could destroy such a good book in about 90 minutes time...I'm not intending on watching the movie, but I still want to watch it...sad.
[0]
Posted 5-16-2007 11:41pm
Well, I talked awhile with a friend of mine who read the second book. Most of the stuff that I worried would had a great importance in the first, acutally has little importance in the second. Though there are a few things that they missed/altered that we are now curious to see how they are going to compensate for. I felt that they missed the essense of the book when they altered so much of it.
[0]
Posted 5-24-2007 7:42pm
ugh .... im afraid i agree with you there book is better then movie when compared to it ... ugh i wanted to die when i saw the movie it was so stupid...they left out some major roles like rorans gf which why it leads up why he was following erogon people who made the movies are idiots -_-
Info
Name: Summer
Join Date: Apr 27, 2006
Experience: 9,557
GTP: $16
Last Online: 4.8 hours ago
Contact Info
MSN: Angel_Fire1028@hotmail.com
Thumb Ratings
Total Score: 1,350
+ Thumbs Given: +118
- Thumbs Given: 0
Friends Online
None
Home Previews Reviews Top Media GT HD Gameplay Retrospectives User Movies Forums Community
About Us · FAQ · Advertise · Press · Affiliates · Podcasts · Related Sites · RSS · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy
Resident Evil 5 · Street Fighter IV · Killzone 2 · God of War III · Resident Evil Retrospective