Associated Press

Housing tax credit a disappointment to builders

Thursday, February 12, 2009


Print Comments 
Font | Size:

(02-12) 14:12 PST WASHINGTON (AP) --

A new tax credit of up to $8,000 for first-time homebuyers that's being included in the economic stimulus package was far less than the homebuilding industry wanted, and analysts expect it will provide only a modest boost to the battered U.S. housing market.


More Realestate


The tax credit is part of the economic stimulus package expected to be signed by President Barack Obama on Monday. It was scaled back from a Senate proposal of $15,000 and limited to first-time buyers who act between the start of this year and the end of November.

The credit for 10 percent of the value of a home, up to $8,000 was estimated to cost the government $6.6 billion.

It starts phasing out for couples with incomes above $150,000 and single filers with incomes above $75,000. Buyers will have to repay the credit if they sell their homes within three years.

Struggling homebuilders, already looking ahead to the traditional spring selling season, had been counting on Congress to help spur pent-up sales after completing the worst year for new home sales since 1982.

Executives for one major builder, Beazer Homes USA Inc., noted earlier this week that they had seen an uptick in traffic over the weekend as many prospective buyers learned of the Senate's original incentive provision.

But with that proposal gone, Wall Street analysts said the homebuyer provision will have a negligible effect on homebuilders' fortunes.

"Congress, unambiguously, left the builders out in the cold," said Deutsche Bank analyst Nishu Sood. "It's a pretty big disappointment that they scaled it back."

Real estate agents were more optimistic. The National Association of Realtors projected the change will stimulate an additional 200,000 home sales.

"It'll make a big impact, I think on our market," said Paula Swayne, a real estate broker in Sacramento, Calif., an area flooded with foreclosures and sales of distressed properties. "Buyers will finally have to get off the fence in order to use it ... There are so many affordable houses."

The big unknown, however, was the state of the economy. With employers laying off thousands of workers, many potential homebuyers are nervous about making such a big financial commitment.

Mortgage rates remain low, falling this week to a national average of 5.16 percent for a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage, according to mortgage finance company Freddie Mac.

But credit remains tight and borrowers need a down payment of at least 3.5 percent to qualify for a loan backed by Federal Housing Administration, a popular option for many first-time buyers.

Many potential buyers haven't saved up enough money for a down payment. "If you don't have a way to get that, the tax credit doesn't do them much good," said James McCanless, an analyst who covers builders for FTN Midwest Securities .

But if the government can prod lenders to loosen credit standards and buy enough mortgage-backed securities to keep mortgage rates low, the tax credit could make a difference, said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Economy.com.

"I don't think it's enough to jolt the housing market back to life, but it's a plus," he said.

Last year, Congress enacted a $7,500 tax credit for first-time buyers, but that had to be paid back over 15 years and the impact on home sales was negligible. First-time buyers, in last year's law, were defined as those who haven't owned their own homes for three years.

When the new credit is signed into law, Chris Sipe, a loan officer with Mason Dixon Funding in Rockville, Md., plans to e-mail the more than 1,000 contacts in his database to let them know about the opportunity.

"The bulk of the market right now is first-time buyers," he said.

First-time homebuyers bought 2.2 million new and existing homes last year, according to the National Association of Realtors, making up about 41 percent of total U.S. home sales, up from 39 percent in 2007 and 36 percent in 2006.

Concerns about the bill's overall costs, plus criticism that a much larger credit would not benefit borrowers on the verge or foreclosure,and mainly help people with healthy enough incomes to buy a house helped sink plans for a much larger credit.

The homebuilding industry mounted an unsuccessful push for a credit for up to $20,000 for all buyers, flying builders in from around the country last month for a massive lobbying push that wound up falling short.

"What the builders wanted was massive relief — not targeted toward where the real problem was — paid for by everybody," said Thomas Lawler, a Northern Virginia housing economist. "That seemed to be pretty egregious."

Sales fell in the fourth quarter of last year around the country, except for six states where buyers have been able to snap up foreclosed homes at a bargain: Nevada, California, Arizona, Florida, Minnesota and Virginia, the National Association of Realtors said Thursday. Nationwide, the median sales price was $180,100, down 12 percent from a year ago.

Comments


Inside SFGate

Big Bird Plus a patient stylist, a baby gorilla and stormy weather. Through the Lens
Burris Was Asked To Help Ex-Guv Blagojevich's brother sought fundraising aid, senator admits.
Sing Your Praises Where are the best karaoke places in the bay? Vote here!

San Francisco Chronicle Real Estate

From
Morgan Lane

Napa

2 BR / 2 BA

$435,000

Greenbrae / Kentfield

2 BR / 2 BA

$509,000

Saint Helena

5 BR / 3 BA

$7,850,000

Glen Ellen

3 BR / 3.5 BA

$3,695,000

Napa

5 BR / 3.5 BA

$1,040,000

Napa

4 BR / 3.5 BA

$5,795,000

Mill Valley

4 BR / 4.5 BA

$4,500,000

Napa

4 BR / 3.5 BA

$15,000

Saint Helena

2 BR / 2 BA

$150,000

Napa

4 BR / 3.5 BA

$3,280,000

Homes

Search Homes »


Cars

Reader wonders how to get into stunt driving

Dear Tom and Ray: I want to know how to get a job, a very specific job. It seems like every car commercial on the networks now shows...

Search Cars »


Jobs

Despite stimulus, no quick turn for jobs, economy

No, the big stimulus plan won't "save or create 3.5 million jobs," as the president and congressional Democrats claim _ at least not this year. The economy will remain feeble...

Search Jobs »

Advertisers