Last night went to see All My Sons, whose all-star lineup did their valiant best to convert Arthur Miller's hot air into a mighty wind while crisscrossing and circumambulating the green patch of all-American backyard as if it were a soccer field. In the prologue a monstrous storm merging with the roar of a bombing campaign uproots a tree in the backyard planted in honor and memory of the missing pilot son, Larry. The tree's removal leaves a hole in the backyard, symbolizing the hole in the family's life left by Larry's loss. This symbolic hole was about as subtle as everything else in this huffing-puffing production, where the director Simon McBurney has neighbors and assorted Everymen and -women flanked at the side of the stage like a mute chorus, turning to face the audience like the risen dead; on the clapboard walls World War II footage of factory floors and ground combat is projected with a overlapping blur effect to conjure the Clouds of War. I can understand wanting to move away from the naturalist staging of Miller, where everyone seems to be wearing lead boots as they stand their Ibsenite ground, but I didn't anticipate anything this hokey. The cast? It was a pleasant surprise seeing how much Dianne Wiest has slimmed down since that HBO shrink show with Gabriel Byrne, where she looked beached in her own flesh; she had some inflections in act one that reminded me happily of Thelma Ritter, but by act three I was wishing it was Thelma Ritter in All About Eve I was watching. As the successful factory owner harboring a shameful secret at the core of his bluster, John Lithgow, joshing around in his bathrobe, had too much irrepressible buoyance to embody Patriarchal Enterprise. He's too vaudevillian for his character's Old Testament self-exonerating thunder. (I first saw Lithgow on stage in 1978, where he farced it up in Kaufman-Hart's Hollywood satire Once in a Lifetime. Time do fly.) Patrick Wilson seemed to be trying to psyche himself up to believe in what he was doing, though the four men sitting in front of me were most appreciative when Wilson came out shirtless in act two to perform tree-removal. Some of the actors in the smaller roles appeared encouraged to act peppy, and "pep" in an Arthur Miller play seems almost a violation against nature.
As the local bud of May loved first by Larry, then by his brother (Wilson), Katie Holmes raises the sails with her first entrance, a vision out of Irwin Shaw's classic story The Girls in their Summer Dresses. Holmes moves beautifully on stage and more than held her own with the old stage pros in the cast, her gestures and line deliveries executed with a clarity rare in Hollywood actors taking to the stage (they often sink into themselves, muffled and mumbly, letting their arms hang dead at their sides). I'd pay honest money to see Holmes essay a Broadway comedy or musical--she's got the gung-ho energy and stylized physical attack to deliver something wow from the diving board. That's the thing about TV and movies--they let you see only a small fraction of what an actor's capable of. It's only in the theater that you get the fullbodiment, though it sometimes entails having to put up with Arthur Miller's dialogue being hurled like boulders in a message drama whose hinges creak with arthritic age.