By Thoreau
I’ve said more than enough over the past several months about why fear that a certain Senator who voted for a certain wiretap bill will probably fail to do much good as President. But who gives a damn about him, anyway? What about the nearly 64 million Americans who were willing to vote for a guy whose ethnic background would have made him a second-class citizen (both by law and social custom) not so long ago? A certain wiretap bill might not be change that I can believe in, but 64 million Americans voting contrary to the prejudices of the past, many of them constituting voting majorities in places where such an outcome would have once been unthinkable (and no, I’m not just talking about the South, there are more than enough examples of racism in lots of other places as well) is change that we just saw.
As a libertarian, I am skeptical that positive change can come from the state, but optimistic that positive change can come from individuals. 64 million individuals have demonstrated a change in our society, and that is what matters. Original Recipe Thoreau once wrote “The character inherent in the American people has done all that has been accomplished; and it would have done somewhat more, if the government had not sometimes got in its way.” Whatever should come of the Obama Administration, the shattering of a barrier in our society will have positive repercussions that will manifest in ways that go far beyond any sort of federal policy. And I am optimistic that these positive repercussions will accomplish something, even if they accomplish less than they might have accomplished had the Obama administration not sometimes got in its way. (Sorry!)
Yes, there are still racists. Ignorance and bigotry cannot be erased completely, but the influence of these vile things can waxe and wane over time, and clearly it is waning in the present moment. That is a change that I believe in. I don’t believe in any Senator or President, but I believe in the potential for good in the American people.
Some will say that I’m just part of the big hype and honeymoon for Obama, but I don’t really give a damn about him. I’m enough of a cynic to see hope in even a disappointing leader (and I’ve already outlined in many posts the reasons I fear that he’ll disappoint). In an ideal world, of course, change and hope and progress would come from the promotion of the most talented of each race, and all these talented people coming together to sing kumbaya around a campfire. In the real world, the sign of progress will often be that bigotry over ethnicity was no barrier to a disappointing person’s advancement–the double standard is gone! If Obama is a great President, well, great. If he’s just another mediocrity, it just means that he was held to the same standard as so many of his paler predecessors. See, cynics can find hope anywhere!
Finally, what do I think of the 56 million people who voted for McCain? Well, I won’t attribute to malice that which can be explained by really bad ideas about policy. Yes, there’s some malice in that group, but I think there are more than enough people who simply have bad ideas about policy.