Per ABC News today: Twenty seven states currently in recession. Sixteen more very near. A mere seven states still showing economic expansion.
And only five were in recession just seven months ago. The pace of the economic decline is staggering.
So let’s review how voters in those states are responding, according to pollsters. At this point in the campaign, if the most reliably accurate pollsters - like SUSA and Rasmussen - indicate an 8% margin, I consider that definite.
Kerry and Bush states that have crossed over or have swung to tossups are noted in red or blue, respectively.
.
The States in Recession Already
In recession, definitely will give electoral votes to Obama: CA, OR, WI, IA, IL, MI, PA, NJ, DE, RI
In recession, likely or leans to giving electoral votes to Obama: NV, MO, ME
In recession, definitely will give electoral votes to McCain: ID, AZ, KY, TN, AR, MS, AL, GA, SC, WV
In recession, likely or leans to giving electoral votes to McCain: IN
In recession, within 3 pts in polls so rates as a tossup: FL, OH, NC
.
The States NEARLY in Recession
Nearly in recession, definitely will give electoral votes to Obama: HI, WA, NY, CT, VT, MD, DC
Nearly in recession, likely or leans to giving electoral votes to Obama: MN, VA
Nearly in recession, definitely will give electoral votes to McCain: UT, WY, SD, NE, KS, OK, LA
Nearly in recession, likely or leans to giving electoral votes to McCain: None.
Nearly in recession, within 3 pts in polls so rates as a tossup: ND
.
The SEVEN States Expanding still
Expanding still, definitely will give electoral votes to Obama: NM MA, NH
Expanding still, likely or leans to giving electoral votes to Obama: CO
Expanding still, definitely will give electoral votes to McCain: AK, TX
Expanding still, likely or leans to giving electoral votes to McCain: MT.
Expanding still, within 3 pts in polls so rates as a tossup: None.
.
Conclusion
1) McCain has already LOST the Bush states of IA and NM, which puts Obama 5 electoral votes from a win.
2) Not a single Kerry state has swung to Mccain and none lean his way. And none are even tossups.
3) Only two Bush states lean McCain’s way, IN and MT. Which means both remain vulnerable to Obama, though they currently rank as longshots for him. MT has an expanding economy, which makes it the longer longshot of the two.
4) Extremely important, none of the tossup states were Kerry states. FL, OH, NC were Bush states and are already in recession. ND was a Bush state and is near being in recession. McCain has to defend all but ND in this group to eke out a win by 4 EVs.
5) Most important, Bush states now leaning pretty strong for Obama include NV and MO (both already in recession), VA (nearly in recession) and CO (still expanding). So in addition to the three MUST DEFEND states in #4 (above), McCain HAS TO defend all 4 in these Obama leaners.
6) So Obama has to play offense in 7 states to pick up one, but has none to defend. And McCain has to play defense in all 7 and can’t afford to lose even one. Even more dire for McCain, in CO, NV and MO, he defends 3 states where he’s down by 5% to 7% in the polls, which makes all three longshots despite being must-wins for him.
7) If he had the luxury of playing offense in any, ME and MN would be the Kerry-won states he’s closest in. Yet they are as great a longshot as his defense of CO, NV and MO, meaning he’s 5% to 7% down.
8) The McCain campaign is presenting a public face that it MUST PRESENT now. Not only do they claim to be defending states like CO, but they claim they’ve found a way to victory WITHOUT Colorado. And today’s analysis says the only LONGSHOT way to do that is to pursue MN and ME. And there’s no indication they’re pursuing ME at all. Their campaign shows minimal life in MN now and they keep making the dubious claim they can pull an upset in PA, even though the polls suggest that’s virtually impossible.
I believe that claim can only mean one of two things:
a) they’ve focus-grouped a robocall method that can make some inroads within certain PA demographic groups (maybe the Appalachia voters?), or;
b) by presenting a confident face, they keep fundraising and GOTV efforts going despite the recognition they’re going to lose.
The bottom line: were they still seriously trying to win, you’d see ALL of them constantly campaigning in FL, OH, NC, NV, MO, CO and VA, and occasionally in MN, ME and maybe IN. Instead, they’re wasting time in PA, likely for PR purposes to prevent further erosion.
Maybe they haven’t accepted losing, but they clearly have reached desperation shoals. Without a big economic upturn reported in the next 9 days, all they have left is to throw every negative claim they can at Obama, hoping that something sticks.
The reality is they can’t swing the economy, the negative ad game is backfiring, and numerous well-regarded Republicans have been abandoning ship in a growing tide of pragmatic rodentry.
Barring some catastrophic event beyond my imagination, I stand by my assessment of three weeks ago. McCain has lost. And while we can’t be complacent before the Mountain Time polls close, our principal focus should be on turning the Senate as strongly democratic as we can.
(thx for the current polling aggregates, as always, goes to Nate Silver.)