home / subscribe / donate / tower / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events / faq
What You're Missing in Our Subscriber-only CounterPunch Newsletter Blood Diamonds: the Inside Story An amazing expose by T.R. Naylor: How the "Blood" or "Conflict Diamonds" Myth peddled by NGOs Helped a Vicious Mining Company Shore Up Its Monopoly, Made a Pile of Money for A Washington Post Reporter and Leonardo di Caprio, Served As A Propaganda Myth in the "War on Terror" and had Nothing to Do With Osama Bin Laden. Pinochet is gone, and the world is a cleaner place. JoAnn Wypijewski recalls 1988 in Santiago, when Chile lost its fear. And yes, here they are in charge of Congress again, ready to facilitate a troop hike in Iraq. Alexander Cockburn re-introduces an old acquaintance: the Democrats--Party of War. Remember, we are funded solely by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this website by buying a subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation towards the cost of this online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now
Get CounterPunch By Email for Only $35 a Year
Today's Stories January 10, 2007 Robert Fantina January 9, 2007 R. T. Naylor Jonathan Cook Mike Ely and Linda Flores Joshua Frank Norman Solomon Sen. Russell
Feingold Joe Allen James T. Phillips Brian Concannon Leonard Peltier Website of the Day
January 8, 2007 Werther Jeff Leys Paul Craig Roberts Shulamit Aloni Dave Lindorff Sunsara Taylor Seth Sandronsky Dr. Susan Block Website of the Day
Alexander Cockburn Franklin C.
Spinney Paul Craig
Roberts Ralph Nader Walden Bello Marleen Martin Brian Cloughley Uri Avnery Saul Landau Ron Jacobs Joseph Nevins William S. Lind Gary Leupp Elisa Salasin George Ciccariello-Maher Beyond Chavistas and Anti-Chavistas: Deepening the Bolivarian Revolution Stefan Wray Michael Leonardi Richard Rhames Jeffrey St. Clair Barbara LaMorticella Website of the Weekend Song of the
Weekend
Jorge Mariscal John Walsh Christopher Brauchli Travis Sharpe Tom Barry Linda Schade
/ Kevin Zeese Tiffany Ten Eyck Mahmoud El-Yousseph Lucinda Marshall Website of
the Day
Patrick Cockburn Winslow T.
Wheeler M. Shahid Alam Raed Jarrar Bert Sacks Kathy Rentenbach Stephen Fleischman George Bisharat Peter Rost, MD Evelyn Pringle Website of the Day
January 3, 2007 Kathy Kelly Paul Craig
Roberts William Johnson Stan Cox Trita Parsi Declan McKenna Joe Bageant Nicola Nasser Missy Beattie Website of
the Day
Michael Watts Amina Mire James Brooks Alevtina Rea Al Krebs Peter Rost Niranjan Ramakrishnan John Stanton Website of the Day
January 1, 2007 Patrick Cockburn Uri Avnery Joshua Frank
December 30
/ 31, 2006 Alexander Cockburn Patrick Cockburn Manuel Garcia,
Jr. Tariq Ali Paul Craig Roberts Douglas Valentine Brian M. Downing Michael Donnelly Stephen Lendman Fred Gardner Bailly / Caudron / Lambert Ralph Nader Nick Dearden Elizabeth Weill-Greenberg Missy Beattie Ron Jacobs Dan La Botz Andrew Wimmer Dr. Carol Wolman, MD Martha Rosenberg Dick J. Reavis Jeffrey St.
Clair Poets' Basement Website of
the Weekend Music Video of the Weekend
Norman Finkelstein John Borowski Abid Mustafa Greg Moses Uri Cohen Bailly / Caudron
/ Lambert Website of
the Day
December 28, 2006 Norman Finkelstein Anthony Cowell John Ross Hilaria Cruz Greg Moses Brittany Bond Website of
the Day
December 27, 2006 Alexander Cockburn Faruq Ziada Christopher Brauchli Michael Ortiz
Hill Nikolas Kozloff Mark Schneider
Peter Stone
Brown Tito Tricot Gary Leupp John V. Walsh Reza Fiyouzat Ron Jacobs Website of
the Day
Saul Landau Lang / McGovern Michael Dickinson Website of
the Day
Marjorie Cohn Jeffrey L.
Gould Diane Christian William Loren
Katz Greg Moses M. Shahid Alam Fred Gardner Dave Lindorff Azmi Bishara Ralph Nader Seth Sandronsky William Hughes Ron Jacobs Jeffrey St.
Clair
December 22, 2006 David Rosen Christopher
Brauchli John Ross J.L. Chestnut,
Jr. Rahul Mahajan Arthur Neslen Peter Rost, MD Website of
the Day
Rosa Mariam
Elizalde Arundhati Roy Brian Cloughley Daniel White John V. Whitbeck Sam Smith Paris Reidhead Kevin Wehr Website of the Day
Gabriel Kolko Winslow T.
Wheeler Tariq Ali Saree Makdisi Bruce Jackson Dave Lindorff Leslie Radford Dave Jansson Johnny Barber Website of
the Day
Alexander Cockburn Jonathan Cook Greg Moses Sean Penn Dave Lindorff Ralph Nader Laura Carlsen Carlos Villarreal Website of
the Day
Luis J. Rodriguez Norman Solomon Uri Avnery Ron Jacobs Phil Gasper Behrooz Ghamari-Tabrizi William Blum Jim Goodman James Brooks Maria C. Khoury Website of the Day
Vijay Prashad Saul Landau Anthony Arnove Paul Cantor Annie Nocenti Nicole Colson Stephen Gowans Jordan Flaherty Fred Gardner P. Sainath Seth Sandronsky Nadia Hijab Deb Reich Susie Day Albert Wan Missy Beattie Martha Rosenberg Lee Ballinger Michael Dickinson Jeffrey St.
Clair Poets' Basement Website of
the Weekend
December 15, 2006 Eliza Ernshire Virginia Tilley Mike Ferner John Ross Fred Wilhelms Kevin Zeese David Severn Dave Lindorff Sunsara Taylor Website of
the Day
December 14, 2006 Jonathan Cook Riz Khan Jason Hribal Pennick / Gray Richard Levins Pat Williams Peter Rost, MD Website of
the Day
December 13, 2006 Patrick Cockburn Greg Moses Elizabeth Schulte Joshua Frank Debra Eschmeyer Leon Hadar Peter Rost, MD Margaret Knapke Reza Fiyouzat Fred Wilhelms Website of
the Day
Fernando A.
Torres Paul Craig
Roberts Stephen Soldz Uri Avnery William S. Lind Missy Beattie Dave Lindorff George Pyle Norman Solomon Website of
the Day
December 11, 2006 Virginia Tilley Roger Burbach Col. Douglas MacGregor Fawwas Traboulsi Ron Jacobs Gideon Levy Mary McGrane Bernardo Ruiz Website of the Day Video of the
Day
December 9
/ 10, 2006 Alexander Cockburn Sen. Gordon Smith Greg Grandin
Paul Craig Roberts Col. Dan Smith Ralph Nader Behrooz Ghamari Rev. Willliam Alberts James T. Phillips Bennis / Leaver Dave Lindorff Nikolas Kozloff Seth Sandronsky Lucinda Marshall Mike Whitney John V. Whitbeck Faisal Kutty Hugh Sansom Robert Gold Boots Riley Jeffrey St.
Clair Poets' Basement Website of
the Weekend
Patrick Cockburn Leutisha Stills Norman Finkelstein Will Youmans Peter Rost, MD Jonathan Demme Ray McGovern Lucinda Marshall Tariq Ali / Robin Blackburn Website of
the Day
December 7, 2006 Alex Friedman Maureen Webb Paul Craig Roberts Dave Lindorff Matt Vidal Yifat Susskind Rodriguez / Jones Website of
the Day
Robert Bryce
William S. Lind Zoe Blunt Corporate Crime Reporter Amira Hass Richard W. Behan Sophie McNeill
Virginia Tilley Sharon Smith Joe Bageant Ron Jacobs Norman Solomon Mike Whitney Derrick O'Keefe Julian Assange Missy Beattie Website of
the Day
December 4, 2006 Alexander Cockburn George Ciccariello-Maher Ray McGovern John Ross Walden Bello Peter Rost,
MD Stephen Lendman Gideon Levy Website of the Day
December 2
/ 3, 2006 Barucha Calamity
Peller Paul Craig
Roberts Ralph Nader Winslow T.
Wheeler Amira Hass Maymanah Farhat Dave Lindorff Fred Gardner Col. Dan Smith Raed Jarrar Seth Sandronsky K.-Y. Taylor Yifat Susskind David Rosen Ron Jacobs Nikolas Kozloff Talli Nauman Alan Gregory Joe Allen St. Clair /
D'Antoni Poets' Basement Website of
the Day
December 1, 2006 Greg Grandin Linn Washington,
Jr. George Ciccariello-Maher Brian J. Foley Dave Zirin Joshua Frank Chris Floyd Ingmar Lee Manuel Garcia,
Jr. Website of the Day Video of the
Day
Subscribe Online
|
January 10, 2007 The Politics of Bad KarmaEverything New is Old AgainBy BEN TRIPP Humankind has never changed, and it never will. The essential misapprehension under which individuals labor --generation after generation-- is that we are on some endless collective journey that will take our species from weak-chinned, flint-chipping anthropoid misery to an exalted state wherein our lives will pass with the elegance of a new-age celebrity wedding in Tahiti. People imagine we're about three-fifths of the way along this evolutionary trek. They have always imagined this, and they have always been wrong. Nothing ever changes, and nothing ever will. Which is not to say that nothing ever changes. Change is the only constant in this universe. It's just that the changes that occur around us (and within us) have all happened before, but on a quantum scale. The human curse --and our greatest blessing-- is that man's intersection with the world (and most women's, excepting Marie Antoinette, who crops up in past-life regressions approximately six in ten times) is limited to one lifetime. Look at history, we surmise, and avoid the obvious mistakes recorded there, and progress will be made. All we have to do is internalize the idea that "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it". Clever-boots know that this statement is attributed to George Santayana, which shows they're very well informed and aren't likely to repeat the mistakes of the past. Except for always. George, now armed with such insight into the brevity of human existence as being dead provides, would probably agree that history is inescapable. We are all doomed to repeat it, regardless of what we learn of mankind's errant peregrination along its course. There are two obstacles to genuine progress: first, we are hard-wired to repeat behaviors; and second, history is rubbish. It would be nice to think that our species, which after all has come to rely on its brain power more than its physical prowess (I am living proof of this, or proof that inertia trumps both attributes), could innovate its collective way out of the situation. But it can't. History is primarily the glorification of murderers as told by liars to idiots. What we can learn from the past by studying history is much like what we can learn about a 1963 Chateau d'Yquem 1er Cru Superieur Bordeaux by studying chip vinegar. Even if history could be relied upon, it wouldn't change the human desire to do the same goddamn things, over and over and over again, because these things worked for our stoatish proto-ancestor Morganucodon Watsoni 225 million years ago, they worked for Siamopithecus back in the day, and in terms of DNA-swapping (which is the purpose of organic life) these behaviors still work for humans today. Ah, but Morganucodon Watsoni couldn't fly, you say (although Volaticotherium antiquus could glide pretty handily, 150 million years ago); we modern man types have made progress! Pother. The fossil record demonstrates that genus Homo was always on the go, cropping up in Africa first, then toddling off to Asia and points north the minute he got the hang of ambulating on his back legs. We started off walking, then figured out riding; when the wheel came along I'll bet everybody scoffed at their ancestors for dragging things around. Then they scoffed at their ancestors for relying on animal power, and scoffed again at steam, and anybody that isn't scoffing at internal combustion today should be taken out back of the woodshed and beaten soundly. The means of getting about has changed, but our desire to do so, on a species-wide scale, is absolutely constant. We simply mistake innovation for transformation. Despite twenty thousand technological solutions, the best mousetrap remains the cat. It makes no difference if hauling ourselves and our goods from place to place is destroying the ozone layer and ruining the landscape and causing the North Atlantic Current to reverse itself. We gotta keep moving. Another example might be our desire to live above-ground. Would it make sense for us to dig down, instead of building up? Of course it would. Manhattan could be two hundred stories deep, and Central Park could cover the entire island, and it would be just like in Popular Science. But humans like to live above the root line. People that prefer subterranean dwellings are still considered weirdos. Ah, but didn't we once favor the cave as a desirable address? Sure, as long as it was on a slope. It's living below the horizon that bugs us. So we continue to pile up massive edifices that, from a historical perspective, are 100% guaranteed to collapse. The caves, it is worth noting, are still around. A thousand years ago, there was an industrial revolution no less impressive than the recent version that brought us the Eiffel Tower and World War One. Huge numbers of able-bodied men --belligerent, religion-crazed nitwits-- marched off to the crusades, leaving behind the cleverer fellows and a dearth of ready manpower (I'm paraphrasing a vast, complex stretch of history for my own purposes here, although the basic arc of the thing is correct, so keep a grain of salt handy). What was needed was a way to turn crops into portable food with a minimum of human effort. The main innovation was harnessing free energy-- wind, water, and so forth. With this power our forebears could turn grain into flour at a terrific clip, which meant that enormous amounts of food energy could be accumulated for later use. Which led to a revolution in agriculture, because now one could grind as much grain as one could grow-- so science came into play and brilliant new growing techniques were developed. This, combined in devious ways with advances in metallurgy, war-making, and the number of babies that survived past their first year, paved the way for explosive growth in urbanization and non-agricultural trades and industries. By the 14th Century people were worried about pollution and mineral rights, there were unions, strikes, miserable conditions in cloth factories, and the great cathedrals of Europe were being erected. Gosh, it sounds just like the 18th and 19th Centuries. But haven't we made progress? Not really. We're still operating sweatshops and mines as miserable as anything they had in the Dark Ages, although we've innovated transportation so much that we can use serfs in distant countries to do the grunt work. We've revolutionized pollution, but not in the better sense of the idea. We've only figured out how to make more of it that's more poisonous. Just as the people of medieval Europe eventually self-destructed, so are we doing. There are many more parallels throughout history to the sort of state we're in today: the rise and fall of superstition, the building up and tearing down of secular and religious states (ask the Greeks, ask the Romans), the ebb and flow of knowledge, art, and innovation. One could argue that improvements
in technology and advances in the human condition have allowed
us to go from maybe 200 million people on earth in the time of
that guy Christ, to 6.5 billion people today. Tell that to the
trilobites, for example, that kicked so much ass with their little
expodite legs they ran to 15,000 species before the inevitable
end came. Or the dimetrodons, critters that ran the show for
30 million years. You don't see them around any more. In fact,
ingenious as humans consider themselves (no trilobite ever figured
out how to build even the simplest four-stroke rotary engine)
we are on the same road to extinction that marks all highly successful
species, the terminus of which appears again and again in the
fossil record. It's tough titty for us, that's all. None of this
ought to be particularly upsetting, unless you take the vast
cycles of creation and destruction personally. Species come and
go, merely another manifestation of the transfer of energy (force
operating on matter), or in layman's terms: Our species has never changed, it is true. And never will, regardless of the guaranteed pan-fatal consequences. This being, however, the early 21st Century, a time when people require an uplifting coda at the end of any depressing narrative, just as the ancient Greeks required a god to descend from the heavens and thwack somebody at the end of their plays, I will provide an uplifting coda. A real one, at that. If mankind has a single talent above all others, it is a knack for acceleration. Paleontologists go back and forth about what adaptation let hominids, and especially our ancestors, take off like blazes up the evolutionary ladder. Anybody that has ever been menaced by a big dog on a lonely road knows the correct answer. It's not the opposable thumb, an upright stance, or a large brain. It's the simple ability to throw a rock with accuracy. Hitting a sabretooth cat on the head with a rock in hand might be good enough for some hominids; apparently not, though, because they're extinct. The throw is the thing. It doesn't matter if you have the biggest fangs or the sharpest claws if there's a dent in your forehead with brains leaking out of it and your quarry is still thirty feet away. That opposable thumb makes it easier to put a wicked topspin on the rock, walking upright frees the hands for hurling, and that big brain can do some lightning calculations that will get the missile from fingers to enemy cranium every time. It's all part of the throw. Problem is, other bands of us could throw, too. And then nobody has an advantage. So someone comes up with the throwing stick, which allows even a runty specimen to hurl a stone with formidable power over long distances. Someone else comes up with the spear, which allows a point to be thrown with accuracy; this is the difference between a bruise and a sucking chest wound. The next gink develops the bow and arrow, or in other words a miniature long-distance spear. This stuff is going faster and faster, accelerating. And the violence is accelerating. Twenty thousand years later the spear has become the ICBM and instead of arrows we're launching air-to-ground missiles from F-22 Raptor jet fighters. Faster and faster, accelerating. Repeating the same behavior again and again. So far this doesn't sound like good news. But it is good news. Even as the consequences of our actions come hurtling up at us (say the North Atlantic Current really does reverse itself-- Europe could be in for an ice age in 200 years) we are getting faster and faster at coming up with antidotes. Populations have figured out how to move fast. We've gotten better at insulating our dwellings. Hell, we can move stuff all over the world, including our lifestyles. Religious end-times fervor has gripped the United States again, and it looks like the government may finally drop its pro-democratic posture in favor of corporate fascism. But as fast as these things occur, new things rise up to take their places. Expect another age of enlightenment. Expect a chastened mankind (after a few decades of extremely shitty weather) to start taking environmentalism and conservation seriously. No matter how bad we make things, we're unlikely to have such an unsalutary effect as the volcanism that precipitated the Permian extinction (95% of species wiped out), or the K-T extinction that ended the age of large leathery non-mammal creatures. Imagining that the consequences of our unwillingness to change will somehow cause everything else to change is probably hubris. Things will change regardless. It's just that the changes in the world are now subject to man's accelerating influence. As I said, the human grasp of things extends not more than a lifetime; historians are trained to extend their grasp of time, but their heads are filled with nonsense made up by long-dead bullshitters, so it hardly matters. Our great-great-great-great grandchildren will look on our works and scoff, like everybody has scoffed through the ages. But they probably won't get upset that the jungles, elephants, polar bears, arctic ice, rhinos, low-lying coastal communities, sources of potable water, predictable winters, rivers, islands, and fish are all gone. We don't miss the mastodons, the woolly rhinoceroses, the Neanderthals, or being able to walk across a land bridge from China to Australia. Hell, we don't even miss ox carts. The faster things change, the more we have to remember that it is our short-sighted experience of change that makes us think things are getting worse-- or worser than usual, to coin a phrase. in fact things have always been getting worse, unless you're of a mind that they're getting better, in which case they've always been doing that; but in actuality things are moving through immense cycles we cannot comprehend, let alone have any impact upon, except to create a little turbulence at the very end of the Holocene epoch. That said, I will miss the elephants. Ben Tripp, author of Square
in the Nuts, is a hack in many mediums. He may be reached
at credel@earthlink.net.
|
CounterPunch Books / AK Press The Gang's All Here: Judy Miller, Bob Woodward, Kay Graham, Rupert Murdoch, Bill O'Reilly...End Times Leaves No Reputation Unstained! Buy End Times Now! Michael Neumann's Devastating Rebuttal of Alan Dershowitz Grand Theft Pentagon: Tales of Greed and Profiteering in the War on Terror by Jeffrey St. Clair Sick of sit-on-the-Fence speakers, tongue-tied and timid? CounterPunch Editors Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St Clair are available to speak forcefully on ALL the burning issues, as are other CounterPunchers seasoned in stump oratory. Call CounterPunch Speakers Bureau, 1-800-840-3683. Or email beckyg@counterpunch.org. The Occupation by Patrick Cockburn Bruce Springsteen On Tour By Dave Marsh |