THE INTELLIGENT ENTERPRISE WEBLOG
What Makes a BPM Suite a Winner?
Blog Entries by Date
Oracle and SAP: Fur Flies as Executive Jumps Ship
Posted by Mark Smith It's been an interesting week for the two giants slugging it out in the business software marketplace. First Oracle filed suit against SAP for intellectual property intrusions into its Internet-based repository of product support information. Not to put too fine a point on it, Oracle accused SAP of wide-scale theft. Of course, this will play out over time, and ultimately, I expect, something like the true story will emerge. Continue reading "Oracle and SAP: Fur Flies as Executive Jumps Ship" Comments
Posted by Bruce Silver I'm in the process of updating my 2006 Business Process Management Suite (BPMS) Report series on BPMInstitute.org to the new-and-improved 2007 version. A major change from last year is a beefed-up evaluation scoring. I've discovered that many users (and most vendors) are happy to skip the 25-page walkthrough of the product and go straight to the scorecard at the end. Which product "won?" I haven't figured out the presentation - it will probably be some two-dimensional appoach, like the Forrester Wave or Gartner MQ - but I'm close to having a finished scoring methodology. It's probably asking for trouble, but I'm publishing it right here so that you can comment upon it. Continue reading "What Makes a BPM Suite a Winner?" Comments CIO Does Not Stand For 'Career Is Over'
Posted by Rajan Chandras …any more than, say, CEO stands for Capability Eludes Opportunity or CFO means Clever Financial Obfuscation -- okay, maybe there’s something in that last one. In a global economy that is more dependent than ever on information and technology, the CIO can only become more influential and in demand. Forrester Research reports that global spending on IT in 2007 will rise 6 percent to reach $2.02 trillion. How big is that? Well, consider that global military spending is estimated to be “only” slightly more than $1 trillion. Or one way to look at it: chief information officers have twice as much opportunity to do good as military officers have to do harm (ignoring, for the moment, the not inconsiderable IT spending on military). Continue reading "CIO Does Not Stand For 'Career Is Over'" Comments SaaS at AJAX World… Not!
Posted by David Linthicum I spoke about Rich Internet Applications (RIA) at Ajax World last week… great attendance, good speakers, good topics but no SaaS. Okay, a little SaaS. I think the SaaS players need to be serious about Ajax and RIA, else their customers make the call for them. Ajax is changing the Web. As true dynamic Web interfaces are taking the place of static, pump-and-pull HTML/HTTP, we are seeing a sea change in what users expect from Web sites and SaaS. Continue reading "SaaS at AJAX World… Not!" Comments Lawsuit Spotlights Loyalty As Well As Ethics
Posted by Cindi Howson The BI industry has long been rife with companies suing one another. Most recently, Hyperion and HyperRoll squabbled about patent infringements, finally agreeing to become partners. Business Objects and MicroStrategy kept counter suing each other over a period of five years, with both parties ultimately declaring victory and neither having to pay one another. Last week, Oracle joined the cacophony by filing claim against SAP. Continue reading "Lawsuit Spotlights Loyalty As Well As Ethics" Comments Prof. Davenport Misses the Point of Analytics
Posted by Mark Smith I recently sat in on a keynote presentation by Thomas Davenport of Babson College, who wrote a much-touted article on analytics in Harvard Business Review last year. He identified analytics as a competitive market advantage and illustrated his point with a number of case studies. It's certainly important to recognize the value of analytics and to broaden the discussion, but analytics alone are only a small part of what is currently missing in business. To effectively apply the results of analytics also requires appropriate management processes and an understanding of how to utilize metrics and other relevant information to change operating plans, create initiatives and make decisions collaboratively, all while keeping an eye on the goals that matter. Continue reading "Prof. Davenport Misses the Point of Analytics" Comments InfoWorld Follows (Readers') On-line Path
Posted by Seth Grimes InfoWorld has announced that their April 2 issue will be the last to appear in print. The magazine – the computing trade rag I'd most want to write for if I weren't part of the Intelligent Enterprise family – follows in IE's footsteps in going on-line only; IE's last print issue appeared in January. Like IE, InfoWorld cites the Web as "a more efficient delivery mechanism" and they also cite advertisers' desire for "more immediate gratification and measureable results than print can afford them." Yet there's another important factor to on-line delivery that InfoWorld does not explore: reader preferences. Continue reading "InfoWorld Follows (Readers') On-line Path" Comments Data Privacy: The Leading Roadblock to SaaS Adoption
Posted by David Linthicum As larger organizations move toward SaaS, a few organizations are pushing back on this new model citing data privacy concerns. So, is data privacy a real issue? Or are IT managers reacting more to the lack of control than to data privacy? Let's do a few reality checks. Continue reading "Data Privacy: The Leading Roadblock to SaaS Adoption" Comments Embed Rules Without Reinventing the Wheel
Posted by Product Maven Business rules show up in a lot of applications. Call centers employ rules for routing, exception-handling, escalation and approvals. Financial services set up transactional and administrative rules based on deal value, customer status and regulatory scrutiny. Security software embeds access security rules. And as always, rules are made to be broken, so software developers ideally want something that business users can change without having to go to IT to alter code. Continue reading "Embed Rules Without Reinventing the Wheel" Comments The Real Issues With XPDL, BPEL and BPMN
Posted by Bruce Silver Keith Swenson is one of the true superheroes of BPM, and a pioneer in the development of interoperability standards. Known for his stalwart defense of XPDL, he periodically feels called upon to insist that XPDL does not compete with BPEL… then usually adding that XPDL is actually better. But I've always felt that Keith obscures the real difference between XPDL and BPEL and their relationships to the "real" BPM standard, which is BPMN. The latest fracas started a couple days ago when Keith claimed victory in the non-war from the fact that eight of the 12 vendors in the top-three Quadrants of the Gartner MQ support XPDL. Even though a number of those vendors also support BPEL, at least as an interchange format for automated fragments of the process, it is fair to say that vendor support for XPDL is probably more widespread than vendor support for BPEL. So let's stipulate that - no problem. Continue reading "The Real Issues With XPDL, BPEL and BPMN" Comments In Defense of Hype
Posted by Doug Henschen As a writer and editor, I felt a twinge of guilt when I read Seth Grimes' blog on hyperbolic PR and "writers and editors who don't have the time, knowledge, and/or judgment to ask the right questions." Seth's last two blogs came about because a SaaS-model BI vendor served up what he felt was self-conscious PR overstating the market significance of the company's actual accomplishments. I guess I've read so many press releases -- and so few that tow the sober, responsible line that Seth puts forth -- that I've developed a permanent BS filter (and after rereading my own blog on said vendor, I don't feel guilty). Continue reading "In Defense of Hype" Comments On Products, the Press, Analysts and SaaS
Posted by Seth Grimes "How do companies with such a trivial product get such [extensive] press?" I had written in a recent blog entry about the claims and the coverage garnered by a BI software as a service (SaaS) company. Their products may be quite nice – their architecture and positioning seem sounds – but their grandiose self-depiction overstates their impact on the overall BI market. The person who sent me this question founded a company that creates BI solutions using open-source software, a rival of the company I wrote about. His question was half serious, half rhethorical – he surely had his own answer in mind – but it's worth a moment's thought. Consider the following as two minutes of PR 101 from someone on the receiving end of many press releases. Continue reading "On Products, the Press, Analysts and SaaS" Comments Study Finds Competency Centers Breed Success
Posted by The Brain Food Blogger Companies that develop formal practice areas around process management (sometimes described as a "BPM Center of Excellence") are far more likely to succeed than those that don't. That's one of the important conclusions of BP Trends' recent "Survey of Business Process Initiatives." "There is an undeniable correlation between BPM project success and the use of a dedicated process team or Establishment of a Center of Excellence," wrote report author Nathaniel Palmer of Transformation + Innovation, the research and consulting firm that conducted the survey. "BPM programs are not likely to succeed beyond the departmental level (if at all) without having in place an organized business process team of some kind." Continue reading "Study Finds Competency Centers Breed Success" Comments How BI Can Solve Airline and Passenger Woes
Posted by Cindi Howson Stranded travelers and lost luggage are daily news items of late. Outraged passengers, grounded on the tarmac for hours, are demanding a Passenger Bill of Rights. Airlines, BI can rescue you! As James May, head of ATA wrote in a USA Today editorial, the best punishment for airlines with bad service records is natural economic forces -- let customers fly better-managed airlines. In reality, customers don't know which airlines are better managed as we have so little information about airline performance and even less about things like lost baggage rates. Continue reading "How BI Can Solve Airline and Passenger Woes" Comments Build a Practical Intranet Development Plan
Posted by Tony Byrne Managing an intranet seems inherently an overwhelming task. First, there's the word, intranet. It sounds important, huge, nebulous, and boundless at the same time. In most enterprises, the opportunities for internal information sharing, collaboration, and process improvements are, well, limitless...but also very difficult to pull off. Continue reading "Build a Practical Intranet Development Plan" Comments Behind IBM's 'Dynamic Data Warehousing' Jargon
Posted by Doug Henschen You might get lost in buzzwords if you read this week's press release on IBM's "Dynamic Warehousing" strategy. Antone Gonsalves did a great job of boiling it all down, but here's a bit more insight gained in an interview with an IBM executive at the Gartner BI Summit. "Real-time" showed up at least a couple of times in the release, but just what does it mean? "It means supporting decisions while a salesperson or a customer service rep is on the phone with a customer or while you're processing a claim," says Marc Andrews, program director, data warehousing. Continue reading "Behind IBM's 'Dynamic Data Warehousing' Jargon" Comments The Business Bottleneck May Be Technology
Posted by Mark Smith Too often, businesses get little information in return for the millions of dollars they spend on information technology. We have built silos of BI tools attached to ERP and CRM systems that aren't designed to communicate common objectives across business. Even data warehouse efforts have not automated information processes, instead creating poorly structured libraries of data that business users may not be able to find or access. Continue reading "The Business Bottleneck May Be Technology" Comments Views on BPEL (Re: Oracle, IBM, SAP and Microsoft)
Posted by Bruce Silver Sandy Kemsley calls attention to an excellent review of BPEL's history and current status from Oracle's Dave Shaffer and Manoj Das in (ironically) WebSphere Journal. Probably the best summary of the differences between the new BPEL 2.0 and the little-lamented BPEL 1.1 standard that I've seen yet in print. She also notes the seeming fakeness of BPEL4People, a joint SAP-IBM white paper that appeared 18 months ago that has achieved what I agree is the highest buzz-to-bang ratio in the history of BPM. My sources tell me that IBM and SAP have been meeting actively to put forth a BPEL4People spec later this spring, an activity that for some reason the companies' lawyers have shrouded in secrecy. If you recall my original post on this topic, the essence of the BPEL4People white paper is a new BPEL People activity that allows human task management to be integrated more directly with the BPEL logic than is possible with standard Invoke and an external task management service. That means BPEL4People "breaks" BPEL 2.0 engines, except for those with the foresight to implement the People activity. What, you don't have the specs for that? Oh, that's right… Continue reading "Views on BPEL (Re: Oracle, IBM, SAP and Microsoft)" Comments What's Your BI Competency Center Quotient?
Posted by Doug Henschen Competency centers -- a.k.a. councils or centers of excellence -- are making headway in the BI arena, and they grabbed a lot of attention at this week's Gartner Business Intelligence Summit. BI competency centers (BICCs) are typically cross-functional teams (architects, developers, support, analysts, line-of-business managers, etc.) that develop frameworks of metrics, goals and best practices that can then be shared with business units and departments throughout the organization. Ideally, they also ensure that goals are aligned with corporate strategy. Continue reading "What's Your BI Competency Center Quotient?" Comments Make the BI/Business Process Connection
Posted by Doug Henschen "Process-driven BI" has been a big theme at this week's Gartner BI Summit, so I sat in on a presentation by Gartner analyst Gareth Herschel on "Integrating Business Insight With Business Processes." Great presentation, overall, but those familiar with business process modeling and management might have been disappointed to hear little about the connection with those technologies. The performance management and process management camps share the whole idea of a "continuous circle of improvement," but perhaps Gartner knows that the BI crowd just doesn't get involved in the nuts and bolts of process management. Continue reading "Make the BI/Business Process Connection" Comments Microsoft Spotlights PerformancePoint
Posted by Doug Henschen Day Two at the Gartner Business Intelligence Summit was nonstop, with wall-to-wall sessions and appointments with industry's blue-chip and challengers. IBM, Microsoft, HP, SAS, SAP, Cognos and others weighed in the direction of their products, the direction of the industry and their take on customer wants and needs. You can visit our photo gallery to get a sense of the event, but I'll drill down on some of the bigger deals here in my blog… starting with Microsoft. Tuesday's "Driving Pervasive BI and Performance Management" offered Microsoft's vision of taking these technologies and applications enterprisewide. Reflecting on his 13 years at Microsoft and status as "employee one" in the company's BI group, Bill Baker, GM of Office Business Intelligence, said "we're at a tipping point." Continue reading "Microsoft Spotlights PerformancePoint" Comments New from the Hype Machine: BI as SaaS
Posted by Seth Grimes The launch of LucidEra, an "on-demand, reporting and analysis solution that focuses on simplicity," has generated quite a bit of attention. The company has been put forward as the poster child for software-as-a-service (SaaS) BI, a pacesetter for an emerging BI revolution. My take? The company appears to have spun the impact of a modest, narrowly focused (and perhaps quite nice) solution far out of proportion to its real import. Salesforce.com is a hosted customer-relationship-management (CRM) system. Fair enough; sounds like a solid foundation for a business. Babbi wrote in e-mail to me that "more applications are planned. Unfortunately we are not ready to share that roadmap at this time." Continue reading "New from the Hype Machine: BI as SaaS" Comments Gartner BI Market Assessment
Posted by Doug Henschen The Hyatt Regency Chicago is sold out and the ballrooms, breakout sessions and exhibit hall are seeing heavy, heavy traffic here on the first day of the Gartner BI Summit. I would say it's standing room only, but nor are there lots of empty seats available. This conference is clearly well past the hype cycle and rising on Gartner's proverbial "slope of enlightenment" phase of market maturity." If you read our "Summit Preview" there weren't a lot of surprises in Conference Chair Bill Hostmann's opening keynote, but he did share some new market analysis that he didn't talk about in that Q&A; interview. Hostmann said things like ETL, reporting, query and analysis and even data mining are well past the hype cycle and are moving up on the "plateau of productivity." Corporate performance management and business application data warehouses are just coming out of the "trough of disillusionment" whereas things like dashboards are just heading into the trough. Continue reading "Gartner BI Market Assessment" Comments Enterprise Architecture Modeling... On Demand?
Posted by David Linthicum I'm seeing a number of software products "SaaSifying" as software as a service becomes an interesting way to deliver software and is more accepted in enterprises. One of the most innovative is the EA WebModeler from Agilense. You can find it at this site. As explained by Steve Hunter, Agilense CTO: "EA WebModeler is a business transformation enabling product. EA WebModeler helps organizations understand, cost, plan, and execute enterprise change by enabling organizations to build an actionable picture (model) of their current business and IT landscape, and develop models and plans of a future landscape." Continue reading "Enterprise Architecture Modeling... On Demand?" Comments Will BI Wax, Content Management Wane at EMC?
Posted by Doug Henschen I was surprised to read this week that Dave DeWalt, one-time EMC rising star and former Documentum CEO, is leaving EMC to take the reigns at McAfee as CEO and president. DeWalt headed Documentum during its most innovative and aggressive years, and he spearheaded the sale of the company to EMC in 2003. He subsequently spearheaded EMC's fast-growing software division, but last year he took a less visible role as President of Customer Operations. In the same vein, long-time Documentum marketing executive David Milam left EMC last fall to join Zantaz. Continue reading "Will BI Wax, Content Management Wane at EMC?" Comments Is Simulation Fake?
Posted by Bruce Silver [This is a re-post of something I wrote yesterday on the SAP Business Process Expert megablog, in case you don't follow that site.] At the recent Gartner BPM Summit, I was shocked to see how high a pedestal the Gartner analysts now place simulation analysis in their gallery of must-have BPM capabilities. Ever obedient, the BPMS and modeling tool vendors now universally throw it into the box. How else to get into that Magic Quadrant? But have these analysts ever really used these tools, or even scrutinized them closely? I'm not really sure. I haven't looked at all of them myself, but my sampling to date tells me this is a fake feature if ever there was one. Continue reading "Is Simulation Fake?" Comments BI On Demand: The List of Options Grows
Posted by Doug Henschen Business intelligence on demand for $3,000 per month for 100 users? That sounds pretty attractive, but LucidEra is not your typical BI suite that lets you build any application you want, now in a SaaS environment. It's specifically a BI-based forecast-to-billing application that includes data connectors (CRM, accounting, etc.), ETL, data cleansing, data warehousing, OLAP and a Web-based user interface. But isn't BI supposed to be an all-purpose suite? Continue reading "BI On Demand: The List of Options Grows" Comments How a CMS Can Help Your Web Analytics
Posted by Tony Byrne We continue to look closely at the intersection between Web content management and Web analytics. There are several important issues here, but one keeps reappearing. It revolves around the growing tendency to use page tags in lieu of (or in addition to) log files for data collection. Continue reading "How a CMS Can Help Your Web Analytics" Comments Could Mashups Be the Killer App for SaaS?
Posted by David Linthicum There are mashups and then there are mashups, as I'm finding out. However, if you're looking for a clean definition of a mashup, here's WikiPedia's: "A mashup is a Web site or application that combines content from more than one source into an integrated experience." What has occurred is that public Web APIs, such as those stood up by the likes of Google, are allowing savvy developers to take content and behavior from one SaaS and mash it together with another, thus forming a new application custom-made to solve the business problems of the end user. Since there is plenty written about mashups I won't dwell on them here. However, the number and level of sophistication of mashups have grown exponentially in the last several months, and this trend will only continue. This could be the next great thing that happens to the world of SaaS, and a new way to sell the value of SaaS. Here's why. Continue reading "Could Mashups Be the Killer App for SaaS?" Comments Straight Dope About Open-Source BI
Posted by Seth Grimes Open-source business intelligence has changed nothing, yet it is making all the difference in the world. Continue reading "Straight Dope About Open-Source BI" Comments Hear More on the Oracle/Hyperion Deal
Posted by The Brain Food Blogger Can't get enough insight on Oracle's planned acquisition of Hyperion? Ventana Research analysts Mark Smith, Robert Kugel and David Stodder - that's right, David Stodder - hold an analysts' roundtable discussion and Q&A; session on the planned Oracle/Hyperion deal, Tuesday, March 6 at 9 AM PT/12 PM ET. Continue reading "Hear More on the Oracle/Hyperion Deal" Comments The Upside of BI Market Consolidation
Posted by Neil Raden Other analysts are preoccupied with the Oracle/Hyperion deal, but I'm not. There are so many important things to keep on top of that the financial doings of the industry are only secondary interests for me. After all, Hyperion itself is composed of three major companies – Arbor, Hyperion Software and Brio, some of which made major acquisitions of their own, including Brio's purchase of Scribe (SQR). This is just another step in an endless process. Some worry about consolidation of the market. I don't. There are dozens of companies waiting in the wings to become the next Hyperion. Continue reading "The Upside of BI Market Consolidation" Comments Score One for Oracle: Can SAP Stay in the Game?
Posted by Mark Smith It has been clear for a while that Oracle needed to make a strategic acquisition to elevate its standing with corporate finance organizations, so few were surprised when the Redwood Shores database giant announced today it plans to acquire Hyperion Solutions Corp. When it comes to finance, Hyperion is, after all, the biggest kid on the block from customer, revenue and product-line perspectives. The intention to acquire Hyperion is further proof that market consolidation is still the name of the game. It also is validation of the increasing importance of the CFO and the finance organization. The ownership and leverage of ERP has been waning for many years now and is just an IT maintenance function mostly and not a strategic finance conversation. This is a critical point that is now much more obvious to Oracle and SAP. The CFO relationship for influencing the management of budgets and many key strategic elements of decisions on technology is not to be under estimated. How Hyperion will get along within Oracle remains to be seen. The finance components of Hyperion's offerings will be a good, complementary fit to Oracle Financials, but integrating its BI line may not be quite as simple. After all, Oracle has made its strategic bet clear with the release of Oracle BI Enterprise Edition, a product that came courtesy of the earlier acquisition of Siebel. Hyperion BI will provide a starting point from which to build a future migration path. But what happens to Hyperion's BI customers in the meanwhile? Continue reading "Score One for Oracle: Can SAP Stay in the Game?" Comments Hyperion Deal Puts Pressure on SAP and IBM
Posted by Doug Henschen Every BI and performance management vendor has come out of the woodwork to offer an opinion on the Oracle/Hyperion deal. I'm gathering those comments and will share a few soon enough, but the companies I'm really anxious to hear from are SAP and IBM (and maybe HP belongs on that list as well). Consolidation happens in every technology market. It only goes one way, and every big, stand-alone vendor ultimately has a price. Continue reading "Hyperion Deal Puts Pressure on SAP and IBM" Comments Oracle to Buy Hyperion: A Look Behind the Scenes
Posted by Cindi Howson So much for rumors! This morning, Oracle announced its intent to acquire Hyperion Solutions … not Business Objects as the rumor mill previously suggested. With performance management and BI slowly converging and arch competitor Microsoft about to release a complete product set, it's a smart but aggressive move on Oracle's part. For Hyperion, I only hope that the best people and products don't get lost in the shuffle. Continue reading "Oracle to Buy Hyperion: A Look Behind the Scenes" Comments
|
Blog Channels
Cindi Howson on Business Intelligence The Brain Food Blogger Tony Byrne on Content Management SQL Puzzlers by Joe Celko Rajan Chandras on IT & Information Management Seth Grimes on Analytics In Context by Doug Henschen Phil Kemelor on Web Analytics Sandy Kemsley's Column Two Nelson King on Enterprise App Development David Linthicum on Software as a Service Natural Insight, By Mark Madsen Alan Pelz-Sharpe on Content Management Mark Smith on Performance Management Neil Raden on Business Intelligence Bruce Silver on Business Process Management Product Maven Subscribe to RSS Archives
|
|