2007 Darren Huckerby - Striker / Winger
2006 Gary Doherty - Defender
2005 Darren Huckerby - Striker / Winger
2004 Craig Fleming - Defender
2003 Adam Drury - Defender
2002 Gary Holt - Midfielder 
2001 Andy Marshall - Goalkeeper
2000 Iwan Roberts - Striker
1999 Iwan Roberts - Striker
1998 Matt Jackson - Defender
1997 Darren Eadie - Midfielder
1996 Spencer Prior - Defender
1995 Jon Newsome - Defender
1994 Chris Sutton - Striker
1993 Bryan Gunn - Goalkeeper
1992 Robert Fleck - Striker
1991 Ian Culverhouse - Defender
1990 Mark Bowen - Defender
1989 Dale Gordon - Midfielder
1988 Bryan Gunn - Goalkeeper
1987 Kevin Drinkell - Striker
1986 Kevin Drinkell - Striker
1985 Steve Bruce - Defender
1984 Chris Woods - Goalkeeper
1983 Dave Watson - Defender
1982 Greg Downs - Defender
1981 Joe Royle - Striker 
1980 Kevin Bond - Defender
1979 Tony Powell - Defender
1978 John Ryan - Winger
1977 Martin Peters - Midfielder
1976 Martin Peters - Midfielder
1975 Colin Suggett - Midfielder
1974 Kevin Keelan - Goalkeeper
1973 Kevin Keelan - Goalkeeper
1972 Dave Stringer - Defender
1971 Ken Foggo - Winger
1970 Duncan Forbes - Defender
1969 Ken Foggo - Winger
1968 Hugh Curran - Striker
1967 Terry Allcock - Defender