Military    

  • email page
  • print page
  • send feedback
  • Rate this site.
  • get email updates
  • get feeds
Navy says speed of tanker sucked submarine up to surface

The Mogamigawa,  a 1,100-foot-long merchant ship displacing 300,000 tons.
The Mogamigawa, a 1,100-foot-long merchant ship displacing 300,000 tons. AP PHOTO/KAWASAKI KISEN KAISHA LTD.

By JACK DORSEY, The Virginian-Pilot
© January 10, 2007


NORFOLK - The submarine Newport News was submerged and leaving the Persian Gulf when a mammoth Japanese oil tanker passed overhead at a high speed, creating a sucking effect that made the sub rise and hit the ship, the Navy said Tuesday.

That is the preliminary finding of Monday's collision between the Norfolk-based submarine and the Mogamigawa, a 1,100-foot-long merchant ship displacing 300,000 tons.

Both were southbound, crossing the busy and narrow Strait of Hormuz while heading into the Arabian Sea.

"As the ship passed over the sub, it ended up sucking the submarine into it," said Lt. Cmdr. Chris Loundermon, a spokesman for Submarine Force in Norfolk.

"It is a principle called the venturi effect," he said.

The Mogamigawa, built in 2001, is a super tanker that displaces 300,000 tons of water - three times the amount of water of a modern aircraft carrier.

The Newport News, a Los Angeles-class submarine, displaces 6,900 tons of water.

"This was a very, very large ship moving at higher speed," Loundermon said.

No one was injured aboard either ship, the Navy said, and damage to both vessels is relatively minor.

The collision was the fifth involving a U.S. submarine in the past six years, according to news records.

Four of those incidents involved other surface ships. In one case, a submarine hit an undersea mountain.

The Newport News collided with the Mogamigawa while submerged in the Arabian Sea about 10:30 p.m. local time, the Navy said.

Afterward, it was going to Bahrain to check for further damage.

"She is headed to port right now," Cmdr. Kevin Aandahl, a spokesman for the U.S. Naval Forces Central Command in Bahrain, said late Tuesday from Bahrain.

Damage to the Norfolk-based Newport News appears to be confined to the bow, he said. The sail, or mast, and the sub's nuclear reactor were unharmed, he said.

Aand ahl said he could not discuss details such as the speed or depth of the submarine at the time of the impact.

Aandahl emphasized that the Newport News was not surfacing at the time, as was reported earlier by CNN.

The Strait of Hormuz separates the Arabian Gulf from the Gulf of Oman and the North Arabian Sea. It is about 40 miles wide - 34 miles wide at its narrowest point, according to globalsecurity.org.

The strait, which is the world's most important oil chokepoint, has channels for inbound and outbound tanker traffic that are 2 miles wide, as well as a buffer zone of 2 miles, according to the Web site.

The Newport News left Norfolk along with the aircraft carrier Eisenhower strike group in October for a six-month deployment to the Middle East.

The Mogamigawa was traveling from the Persian Gulf to Singapore with a crew of eight Japanese members and 16 Filipino members. The submarine has a crew of about 130.

The other four submarine collisions in the past six years are:

  • Sept. 5, 2005: The fast-attack submarine Philadelphia and the Turkish merchant ship Aysen met about 2 a.m., 30 miles off the coast of Bahrain, resulting in minor damage.

    The Aysen was attempting to overtake the submarine and approached the Philadelphia from the sub's port quarter.

    The ship damaged the sub's propeller, the sailplanes, a periscope and dented the Philadelphia's hull.

  • Jan. 9, 2005: The attack submarine San Francisco, traveling at a high speed near Guam, struck an undersea mountain, killing one crew man and injuring 24.

  • Nov. 2, 2002: The fast-attack submarine Oklahoma City struck a Norwegian merchant ship in the western Mediterranean Sea, damaging the sub's sail and periscope but causing no injuries.

    Its commanding officer was relieved of command.

  • Feb. 9, 2001: The attack submarine Greenville ran into the Japanese fishing and training vessel Ehime Maru off the coast of Hawaii while performing an emergency surfacing maneuver during a demonstration cruise for civilian visitors. Nine crew members on the Japanese ship died.

    The National Transportation Safety Board concluded that collision was caused by inadequate communication among senior members of the crew.

    The commanding officer was relieved of command and retired.

  • Reach Jack Dorsey at (757) 446-2284 or jack.dorsey@pilotonline.com.


    Los Angeles class attack sub USS Newport News. U.S. NAVY


    USER COMMENTS
    Comments solely reflect the views of and are the responsibility of users, not The Virginian-Pilot, PilotOnline.com or HamptonRoads.com. Readers may find some comments offensive or inaccurate. To comment, users agree to abide by rules of participation. If you believe a comment violates these rules, please notify us.
    Comments 1 - 10 of 28 View All Comments

    Traffic Separation Scheme (hide comment)
    Both ships were headed outbound (actual travel is NE then E then SE) in Traffic Separation Scheme (TSS) (similar to cars travelling a highway with opposing traffic). The shallowest point is ~200'. Sub transisted TSS at ~150' at
    - Ernie V. - Suffolk
     
    None of you know anything (hide comment)
    I dont mean to be rude, but none of you actually saw this boat after it hit the oil tanker. Unfortunately I got to bear witness. The navy only tells you what they want you to hear. The boat has not left Bahrain to this day. They are still flying people to it from this ship to fix it. The found propeller chunks in the main ballast tank for one. Secondly, the side of this boat looks like it was slashed by huge machettis. There are about 11 slash marks on the side where to propeller hit it. 3rd and most importatnly, everyone was very lucky, because the propeller hit about 1 ft infront of the "people tank" If it would have hit 1ft behind where it did hit, everyone would be dead. So maybe before you people spout your mouths off, you should stop and think about the stuff you will never hear ot see.
    - b powell - mad
     
    Subs are safer than cars, planes, and joggers (hide comment)
    The good news is there were no casualties. The bad news is that everyone who can read at a third grade level is suddenly an expert on things about which they know nothing. Trust me, it was due to the trained personnel on that sub that there were no human stats to cause sorrow/heartbreak. I have read the previous comments and agree that those who are part of the "Silent Service"know and appreciate the exigencies, demands on , and commitment of our men. I salute each and every one of them, and I honor the families and the American citizens who acknowledge their sacrifices on behalf of their country. God bless all military women and men in all the branches of the military, and God bless our military family members. America asks so much of them and of us, and we have not let her down ever!
    - patti hores - newport new
     
    Know it alls (hide comment)
    I was born and raised in the tidewater area, worked on that very ship when it was built, however, I really realized there were so many hydrodynamic engineers living in the area. I have no idea what happened or how. I think I can reasonably say that 90% or more of the commenters on this story don't know either. I do want to say to all the finger pointers is if you know so much about it..........enlist! If you are not willing to go through the training, the separation, the lonely cruises and crappy food, the shut the up. Because until you have the guts to stand the watch with them, you don't have the right to complain about the way they provide your freedom to open your mouth and show how truly ignorant you are!
    - Mike F. - Swansboro
     
    I Salute the Boat Crew & Officers (hide comment)
    The hit on the supertanker's bottom was 230 feet from her stern (or 870 feet from the bow). The tanker was reported to be traveling at 16 knots with a 70-foot draft. The boat was at 300 feet. Here are two scenarios: (1). If the boat was on the bottom it would have had only 13 seconds to register an ascent, order a counter action and effectuate a system response, or (2) If the boat was heading north and the Tanker south...the boat at 10 knots and the Tanker at 16 knots it would have been closing on each other with 13 to 19 seconds to impact (registering an ascent, order a counter action and effectuate a system response). Venturi/Surface Ship UNREP tests have shown that rudder maneuvers, engine twists can lessen the impact damage, but generally, cannot avoid an impact.
    - Bill K - Plano
     
    Venturi Principle (hide comment)
    Actually I learned of the Venturi Principle in high school auto shop--long before I was qualified on subs. It's the principle that makes carburetors work. Whether you believe it or not, it's real and it effects ships on the surface and submerged. Remember learning about the Cold War in high school history? Subs helped put an end to that "war" by deterring the USSR from attacking us with nuclear missles. You almost never hear about "boomers" because they are serving a different mission from the "fast attacks". There's a reason they call this the "silent service." You don't praise us for doing our jobs--please don't criticize us either.
    - Steven D. - Warrenville
     
    Dear Tom... (hide comment)
    Have you ever stood near a blower for a big AC Unit? I'm not talking about the ones at your house, but the ones at a school or other large building. We used to do something fun with them as kids. You see, when you are far away from the blower, you get blown. However, we would take flat sheets of paper an throw them at it from close range and guess what happened... They stuck... Because it is the same principle... as the wind is blowing around the edges of paper on the grill of the blower it zips past the edge and creates a vortex that pulls the object into it thus keeping the paper in on the grill. Now move away from the grill and the paper falls to the ground.
    - Michael Long - stafford
     
    Yes Plausable! (hide comment)
    I really think that our men and women of the military know in their hearts and minds that the C/O of the ship would not meaningfully put them in harms way. They are specially trained to be on this ship(sub), to no appereal would you put the blame game other than the C/O. He or she know pretty much about what would probably happen, if the depths for the clearance of the sub were not met, but took a chance, not knowing the capabilities of this huge merchant ships knots(speed). So if we don't know, we do know now that the C/O of the ship will be cited for not possibly remmembering the subs infructure. To be retrained for their command and knowledge of their ship(sub). So hopefully this will never happen again. THANK YOU?
    - michael w. - Suffolk
     
    Giving Thanks (hide comment)
    I am dissappointed in the posters here. We live in a community made up of Sailors, and their families, and everyone here seems to want to condemn these Sailors rather than give thanks they are all still alive. I am not a submariner, but I am sure it is the crew's skill that kept this from being a story about human loss. To respond to everyones bashing... things like this are not supposed to happen, the crews are trained to avoid these mishaps, and there will be an investigation to find what caused this. Now, for my opinion, 6 years, 5 mishaps - can the Navy give lessons to the air line industry? How about to those big rig drivers. Think about your own industry... if you're in a glass house, you know the rest.
    - Daniel Christian - Elizabeth City
     
    Movie to real life? (hide comment)
    They did it better in the movie, Down Periscope, with Kelsey Grammar as skipper LCDR Dodge.
    - John L. - Houston
     
    Comments 1 - 10 of 28 View All Comments

    Sorry, but comments are no longer being accepted for this story

    More Military Articles
    They were to capture the war in images. Instead they joined in - Jan. 10
    Audio and photos: Combat photographers awarded Bronze Star - Jan. 10
    Norfolk-based ships support action in Somalia - Jan. 9

    upTop of Page / Give us feedback / Get The Pilot / Sponsor this channel

  • -









    Big Deals

    WE NEED YOU! SALESPEOPLE
    Driver's World Of Va Beach

    Lead Teachers / Teacher Assistants
    Kimbi's Playworld

    Customer Service Specialist
    Capital Group

    Coordinator of Recreation / Activity Therapy
    The Pines Crawford Campus

    Engineering Technicians


    View All Jobs
    Place an Ad


    The most jobs, the best employers in Hampton Roads