|
AFL and WADA - Your Questions Answered1 Jul 2005 - Matthew Finnis Much has been written and spoken about in relation to the AFL's policy on drugs in the last few days, as the AFL formally rejected the Federal Government's requirement for it to adopt a drugs policy compliant with the WADA Code. The following information is provided to to assist you in understanding the issues involved in this important matter.
Who is WADA and what is the WADA Code? The World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) was established in 1999 by the International Olympic Committee in an attempt to present a more united front in the global battle against performance enhancing drugs. The WADA Code was developed in 2003 and is basically a one-size-fits-all policy governing drug use in sport. WADA's goal is to have every world sporting code adopt the WADA Code as its anti-doping policy. The WADA Code was developed to respond drug use in Olympic sports such cycling, weightlifting and athletics and grew out of the anti-doping policy previously adopted by the IOC. Professional sporting leagues, non-Olympic sports and the athletes themselves have had little or no input into the development of the WADA Code. What are some of the AFL and AFLPA's concerns with the WADA Code? Putting aside the lack of consultation in developing the WADA Code, the AFL and AFLPA have a number of concerns with the specific content of the WADA Code. These include: 1. Banned List The WADA Code contains a list of prohibited substances and methods, which if used by an athlete will result in an anti-doping violation. The list of substances and methods is constantly reviewed and amended in light of developments in medical knowledge and scientific procedures. The AFL's anti-doping policy expressly incorporates all banned substances and methods on the WADA list with some limited exceptions. In order to comply with the WADA Code the AFL would be required to defer completely to the WADA list of banned substances and remove its current exceptions, notwithstanding that they have each been identified, reviewed and maintained on the basis of expert medical opinion applied to the context of AFL football. A particular concern is the treatment of cannabis under the WADA Code. The performance enhancing value of cannabinoid's for an AFL footballer must be questionable. At present, the AFL seeks to prohibit use of cannabinoid's by AFL players on a year-round basis via its Illicit Drugs Policy. Under the WADA Code, cannabis is only prohibited "in-competition" whilst under the AFL policy the drug is prohibited on a year-round basis. 2. Strict Liability One of the principal hallmarks of the WADA Code is its strict liability approach to anti-doping. Under the WADA Code an athlete is held responsible for the presence of any Prohibited Substance found to be in their bodily specimens. Full stop. The Code expressly states that "it is not necessary that intent, fault, negligence or knowing use on the athlete's part be demonstrated in order to establish an anti-doping violation…" Such a rule, particularly given the gravity of the consequences for a professional athlete, is contrary to principles of fairness and justice widely accepted as basic human rights throughout this country. The AFL Code differs from the WADA Code in that the AFL Code provides a defence for a player to prove that the presence of a prohibited substance in his sample arose through "exceptional circumstances." For example, a player who can demonstrate that his food or drink was "spiked" with a banned substance would most likely succeed in proving exceptional circumstances were the basis of the positive drug test. Hence, under the WADA Code, an AFL premiership player who tested positive to the presence of cannabis in his body on AFL grand final day would be stripped of his premiership medallion, even if it could be established that his previous day's lunch was tampered with and the presence of cannabis had no performance enhancing effect on the player. Further, risks of mistakes in the labelling, advertising, manufacturing and prescribing of medicines and food supplements may also give rise to "exceptional circumstances" which under the WADA Code would have no bearing on the ability of the grand final player to retain his premiership medallion. 3. Mandatory Penalties - Illicit Drugs The AFL has already conformed to a major extent with WADA's desire for the implementation of uniform mandatory penalties to apply to athletes committing doping offences regardless of the sport in which they are involved. The current average AFL career spans approximately four years. It follows that a two year mandatory prohibition for a first doping offence is likely to have a more significant impact on the career of an AFL footballer than an individual athlete pursuing a career in rowing or archery which may span over two decades and four Olympic Games. Further, the individual sport athlete is able to continue to train as usual during his period of ineligibility whilst an AFL footballer would be excluded from all team based training activities at all levels of the sport. Under the AFL's Illicit Drugs Policy, positive tests for illicit drugs result in reprimands and formal medical counselling in the first two instances, and match suspensions for third and subsequent offences of up to 12 matches. This approach was agreed between the AFL and AFLPA in January 2005 in anticipation of WADA taking a tougher stance on illicit drugs notwithstanding their lack of performance enhancing effect. The AFL and AFLPA undertook detailed research and analysis when determining how it would deal with cannabinoid's, narcotics and stimulants under its Illicit Drugs Policy and sought the best possible information from around the sporting and medical world. We were consistently advised that the best way to deal with any illicit drug problem is confidential counselling, rehabilitation and education (ie. the emphasis should be on prevention and intervention) with punishment used only as a last resort. The AFL policy currently goes further than the WADA Code in providing that AFL players can be tested for illicit drugs "out of competition". In our view, the AFL has taken a more responsible approach to tackling illicit drug use as a legitimate social and health issue than WADA's simplistic and very public "three strikes and your out for life" policy. Why should AFL players be treated differently to Australian swimmers, rowers or cyclists? AFL Players are subject to the same standards, testing and penalties as other Australian athletes in relation to performance enhancing drugs. However, when it comes to illicit drugs, AFL players are subject to more testing on a year-round basis. Olympic athletes are not tested for cannabis use outside of competition - AFL players are. The AFL conducts more testing for illicit drugs than any other sporting body in Australia and probably the world. the world. As such, it is appropriate that if the AFL is going to take a harder line on drug testing for illicit drugs that it should have a comprehensive rehabilitation and treatment program in place to respond to positive tests, rather than simple mandatory bans for positive tests occurring during competition. Conclusion Unfortunately one size does not fit all when it comes to sport. For the AFL industry to set its own agenda on drugs is not to be soft on drugs. Rather it represents a more considered and perhaps enduring commitment to the issue which reflects the principles of justice, fair-play and sportsmanship which underpin the entire anti-doping campaign. Matthew Finnis is the AFL Players' Association Manager of Player Relations.
AFLPA past player golf day a great success 2008 Mike Fitzpatrick Scholarship applications now open AFLPA holds Player Development Manager Forum Vale Peter Allen NAIDOC Week - 50 years: Looking Forward, Looking Blak Round 2 Education & Training Grant Applications now closed Round 3 Next Goal Program applications now closed Feature News AFL players ask 8 key questions AFLPA moves office Lizzie Corrie - AFL Footy's Mother of the Year Three charities to share in $30,000 of player raised funds The Long Walk - Saturday 26 May, 2007 AFLPA / AFL / beyondblue team up to Tackle Depression AFLPA Dreamteam 2007 - online now A message from AFLPA President Joel Bowden AFLPA announce Executive changes AFLPA holds Next Goal Breakfast Are you a past VFL / AFL Player? Then join the AFLPA AFLPA launches third annual AFL Player Mother of the Year Competition AFLPA new player Induction Camp a success HealthKICK - a landmark health support program for current and past players AFLPA holds annual Executive & Delegates Conference Nine AFLPA Mike Fitzpatrick scholarship selected in AFL draft AFLPA & GPA reiterate support for International Rules Series AFLPA Indigenous Camp a success $6m to help AFL Players Kick Goals with Homeless Young People Chris Judd receives Leigh Matthews Trophy for Most Valuable Player AFLPA announces MVP award category nominees AFLPA announces Mike Fitzpatrick Scholarships Supreme Court verdict confirms player rights over public curiosity AFLPA signs new Total Player Payments deal AFLPA statement on AFL X-Men campaign AFLPA Business Ownership Program Mike Fitzpatrick Scholarships now open Libby Wakelin - AFL Players' Mother of the Year Statement from the AFL Players' Association Total Player Payments Update Drake Training begins exciting new partnership with the AFLPA Peter Bell re-elected unopposed as AFLPA President AFLPA sets the record straight AFLPA / AFL SportsReady 'Next Goal' Breakfast AFLPA / AFL SportsReady launch AFL Player Apprenticeship Program AFLPA Player Motor Vehicle Insurance Program Round 1 Education & Training Grant Applications due Fri 17 Feb Trisha Broadbridge - Young Australian of the Year 2006 Congratulations Trish Broadbridge - Young Australian of the Year 2006 AFLPA Response to 2007 – 2011 TV Rights AFLPA / AFL to hold new player induction camp AFLPA / AFL Level 2 Coaching Course AFLPA holds 2005 Executive & Delegates Conference Ten AFLPA / Mike Fitzpatrick Scholarship holders drafted AFLPA response to 2006 AFL fixture AFLPA awards Life Membership to Peter Allen Ben Cousins wins AFLPA Leigh Matthews Trophy for Most Valuable Player AFL players donate $250,000 to The Broadbridge Fund AFLPA announces MVP nominations 2005 Education & Training Excellence Award AFLPA Most Valuable Player Function AFLPA announces 2006 Mike Fitzpatrick Scholarships Special dial up & broadband rates for players from Pacific Internet Accredited Agent has no case to answer Call for Grant Hattam Trophy Entries - Entries close 31 August AFL names Indigenous Team of the Century AFLPA response to AFL's WADA decision AFLPA remains vigilant on gambling Support for the AFLPA in the press AFLPA launches 2006 Mike Fitzpatrick scholarships AFL Drug Code Deserves Respect Total Player Payments to increase Pacific Internet Hoax Email Warning Footy's greats collect retrospective Leigh Matthews Trophy's Mike Fitzpatrick Scholarships open Anti-Doping - It's not all Black & White Guy Rigoni takes on a 'Cat' Excitement building as retrospective MVP awards night approaches Player email blitz Discount net rates for AFLPA members with Pacific Internet AFLPA launches Professional Development Program - Cert II & IV Maree Selwood - AFLPA Mother of the Year AFLPA support of past VFL/AFL players AFLPA to celebrate former MVP's with retrospective awards night AFL players meet the Challenge Nominations called for AFL Players' Association Mother of the Year Tax Deductibility of Player Agent Fees Update Players aware of responsibilities Harassment Policy statement AFLPA TV rights statement AFLPA & AFL SportsReady launch 2005 Next Goal program Jarrod McCracken / NRL negligence case AFL Players to honour Troy Broadbridge & Tsunami victims AFLPA Email changes Surplus Education & Training Grants to be distributed Illicit drugs policy announced AFLPA / AFL Induction camp a great success Improved Email service for AFLPA members Leigh Colbert appointed Kangaroos AFLPA Delegate AFLPA commited to playing its part to end violence against women Brett Burton joins AFLPA Executive Taxation Update AFL Players donate $20,000 to Royal Flying Doctor Service Surplus 2004 Education & Training Funds Available - applications close Friday 14 January 2005 Players encouraged to contribute to AFLPA Strategic Plan AFLPA Welcomes AFL Tribunal Reforms Key 2004 AFL Pre-Season and Rookie Draft dates announced Brendon Gale named AFL Players' Association CEO AFL X-Men announce health service for ex AFL players AFLPA CEO to resign Nick Riewoldt wins AFLPA MVP Mike Fitzpatrick Scholarships announced 2004 AFLPA / Herald-Sun Survey Results Released AFLPA helps aspiring footballers achieve goals Overhaul melee rule: AFLPA AFLPA closely monitoring melee outcome Brendon Gale to join AFLPA AFLPA seeks feedback on drug code Long-serving AFLPA delegate retires from footy Update: AFLPA position on tribunal telecasts unchanged $20,000 a heavy penalty: AFLPA New faces on AFLPA committee New players attend induction camp Arbitration may help: AFLPA Voss the players’ choice, again Annual Leave and the Christmas break Helping young footballers achieve their dream |
Privacy Policy | Contact Us | © AFL Players' Association 2003 ABN 25 695 729 819
Association Reg: A00252292 All images from Getty Images except where otherwise specified. Last modified Friday 31 August 2007 14:39 |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||