Mail&Guardian Online
 
  Make this your homepage
  RSS for your website, blog or reader
22 June 2007 12:59 Africa's first online newspaper. First with the news.

 SEARCH: M&G Online The web    Business directory  [Advanced Search]
Breaking News
Front Page
National
Africa
International
Business
Sport
And in other news ...
Photo galleries
News Insight
National
Africa
International
Comment & Analysis
Business
Columnists
Editorials
The Weekly Wrap
Monitor
Body Language
Obituaries
Supplements
Leisure
ARTS
M&G; Money
Motoring
Tech
Travel
Special reports
100 Young S Africans
Zuma special report
A new Zimbabwe
Aids, malaria & TB
Other reports
Regulars
Zapiro
Madam & Eve
Podcasts
Corrections
HIV/AIDS BAROMETER
Interact
Forums
Notes & Queries
Letters
Partner Sites
The Teacher
The Media Online
SA Good News
Find your match now!
I am a:
Looking for:
Age Range: to

Career search
Search South Africa's #1 job listings and career advice site.
Find me a job!

M&G; podcasts
The hottest news and views on our daily news podcasts and weekly podcasts with Tony Lankester
Read more ...

Mobile news
M&G; Online news, alerts and more on your cellphone.
Read more ...

FIND

- A job
- A date
- A destination
- An insurance quote
- Business search

MOBILE SERVICES

- News on your cellphone
- SMS news alerts
- M&G; Online mobizine

QUICK LINKS

- Get your free blog
- Notes & Queries

SERVICES

- Subscribe to M&G;
- Subscription queries
- Free news for your site
- Place an advert
Columnists
No Oscar for our populist hero
John Matshikiza: WITH THE LID OFF
05 February 2007 11:59
We of the “old establishment” are indeed terrified by the advent of Ronald Suresh Roberts on our shores, as he himself puts it. Here is a post-colonial liberator of impeccable credentials, and handsomely endowed features to boot, who, although, again as he says, we have never had a substantial conversation, takes us on as the major problem in his hitherto life of literary fame and glory in his forcibly adopted native land.

We do have to thank him, however, for bringing to our attention his comparison of himself with the late, great Irish author, playwright, and cynic, Oscar Wilde. It is something of a coming-out-of-the-closet, in the same way that Wilde, married with two children, succumbed, as he said in court, to temptations with another man.

Not that we are imputing anything to the dude’s sexual orientation. Just that it is interesting that Roberts chooses to place himself in the company of one of the greatest wits of the English language, and an anti-establishment radical of his times. What is he trying to tell us?

Wilde was an Irishman who rose to fame in the English literary establishment, got caught out by creaky English laws, spent time in jail for his sexual sins, and died in poverty some years later.

The only thing that the mighty Roberts has to tell us that likens him to Wilde is that “the duty we owe to history is to rewrite it”. And that, apparently, is what he is in this country to do.

His much anticipated biography of the state president will, presumably, tell us what the rewriting of history should be all about.

But who is he to compare himself to Wilde? What a waste of time. What a waste of good wit. Wilde was a master of off–the-cuff witticisms, written or spoken. Roberts is not. If we have not had a substantial conversation (in fact we have not had a conversation at all) it is because there would not have been anything to say.

But as I said, thanks, Mr Roberts, for reminding us that we should be revisiting some of the witty, intelligent, talented observations of Oscar Wilde, and making us wonder, yet again, what they have to say to us in the world we live in today.

“Only the shallow know themselves,” is one of the Irish wit’s pithy comments. Roberts is outstanding in declaring to what degree he knows himself, and how the rest of the world is wrong. He evades the comments of the judge who found his outrageous libel suit objectionable and ridiculous, and instead concentrates on the media (including myself) who simply commented on it: “The media is not the public,” says the Trinidadian Crusader. “The public knows a media-lynching when it sees one.” Here is the hero-figure confident in his knowledge of himself.

Not that I believe the media are omnipotent, universally intelligent, and incorruptible. As Wilde himself commented: “By giving us the opinions of the uneducated, journalism keeps us in touch with the ignorance of the community.”

Roberts might be associating himself with this sentiment in his comments on what he calls his own media lynching, although, as usual, he doesn’t say so with any precision or accurate English. But we should give him the benefit of the doubt nevertheless.

Oscar Wilde also said: “To love oneself is the beginning of a lifelong romance.” We shouldn’t deride Mr Roberts for being so in love with himself, and believing that, in spite of media comments to the contrary, the public is in love with him too. Sure, he provides no proof of this supposed public adulation, but that is neither here or there. He loves himself, ergo the universe is in love with him too. Fuck the press.

But we have to wonder, finally, what Mr Roberts’ role really is in South Africa, and how we define South Africa.

Reverting to Wilde, as Mr Roberts so graciously encouraged us to do, we have to look at another of Wilde’s witty comments: “America is the only country that went from barbarism to decadence without civilisation in between.”

For “America” substitute “South Africa Today” and we have a fine metaphor indeed. JM Coetzee (now self-exiled in the Antipodes) characterised white (read: colonial, Mr Roberts) South Africa as being a threatened territory waiting for the invasion of the encroaching barbarians (read “darkies in general, including you”, Mr Roberts.)

The country whose history Mr Roberts has now been commissioned to rewrite can indeed be seen, from many angles, as one that has moved from white barbarism to the kind of BEE decadence that this same Mr Roberts so eloquently speaks for and fronts -- although God knows by whose mandate.

The civilisation phase that Wilde noted was missing in the nature of modern America is still sadly wanting here on our own shores -- see the comments by the government saying that crime, for example, will not be seen to be out of control until the majority of the population actually says that it is. The media is at fault, once again.

Mr Roberts is happy to speak in the first person about “our Constitution”. Well, whoever he is, let us remind ourselves of another Oscar Wilde off-the-cuff aphorism: “Democracy means simply the bludgeoning of the people by the people for the people.”

Let’s just hope we’re not there yet. Although, sometimes you wonder -- especially when you see who is supposedly speaking for “the people”, as in the case of the venerable Mr Roberts.
Get M&G; Online news on your cellphone
SMS mg to 32368 (R1 one-off) or find out more here.

Blogs linking to: M&G; Online | | What's this about?

Save this page: on del.icio.us |

Hot news and views on the weekly and daily M&G; Online podcasts

Add M&G; Online news to your website or blog

Get M&G; Online news in your RSS reader

For more news, go to the M&G; Online home page
ADVERTISING LINKS
Looking for a reliable IT supplier? Shop at PCMall.co.za for the best prices on all PC and technology equipment, notebooks, etc
Dating Buzz Find your match now!
Brabys.com Finding a company or service is simple and easy on our business directory
Private Property listings List your property with us or search for a property. No estate agent's commission
Your gadgets, cheaper, on Bid or Buy Do your shopping via online auction and get your goods for great prices
Newsflash Get news on your desktop!
Advertise your business here
Contact Author: E-mail the author of this article
Talkback: Have your say about this article
Blog: Blog this story in M&G Online's blogspot

News on your desktop: Download & install M&G Online NewsFlash
Daily cellphone alerts: Get news headlines by SMS
Daily Newsletter: Get the news by email
Columnists | HOMEPAGE

 Get news by e-mail
HTML Text   
   
[ More about this ]
Article tools
E-mail this story
Print this story
Bookmark page
Most read stories
RSS feed
JavaScript feed
Your M&G; Online
» ON YOUR PHONE
» ON YOUR DESKTOP
» VIA PODCAST
» ON YOUR WEBSITE
» VIA RSS FEED
» IN DIGITAL PDF
» VIA EMAIL

Online services
» FIND A JOB
» WIN EURO LOTTO
» WIN NOW. FOR REAL
» ONLINE IT STORE
» PROPERTY
» HOLIDAY RENTALS
» MAP SEARCH
» INSURANCE QUOTE
» HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION
» FIND A DATE
» ONLINE AUCTIONS
» HOLIDAY FINDER
» ONLINE SHOPPING
» INSURANCE
» SUBSCRIBE TO M&G;
» PLACE AN ADVERT

Fri Jun 22 2007 12:32:30
SA Exchange Rates
R/$ 7.1458
R/£ 14.2543
R/€ 9.5902
IN THIS SECTION
Go, Ivy, go! Communications gets cracking
Prepare for the African writing revolution
For your viewing pleasure
A fool and his Guide aren't easily parted
The hamster has landed

Current: R16,000.00
Panasonic FP 7835 Copier

[ see more advertisers ]

[ see more advertisers ]

CONTACT US  |  ABOUT US  |  M&G HISTORY  |  SUBSCRIPTIONS  |  M&G CSI  |  FREE NEWS FEED  |  ADVERTISING

All material copyright Mail&Guardian.
Material may not be published or reproduced in any form without prior written permission.
Read the Mail&Guardian's privacy policy
RSS feed JavaScript feed