CONTACT USSUBSCRIBEADVERTISEMARKETPLACEPM STORENEWSLETTERCOVERS
Search
Automotive News Automotive Clinic Online Home Journal News Science News Technology News Outdoors News Energy Family News 9-11 Myths PM News
January 17, 2007
Comair Pilot Called Deadly Airstrip 'Weird': Crash Update

Transcripts from last summer’s deadly crash of Comair Flight 5191, released today by the National Transportation Safety Board, show that at least co-pilot James Polehinke knew something wasn’t right. Polehinke, the lone survivor of the crash that killed 49 people on Aug. 27, noted the airstrip was “weird with no lights” shortly before the plane went down.

According to the federal investigation, pilot Jeffery Clay took off from the wrong runway—one that was too short for commercial flights—shortly before Polehinke took over the controls. The plane remained so low that it hit a fence and crash instantly.

The runway decision (or misunderstanding) was difficult enough to comprehend when we first examined the reasons behind the crash. But now, in light of Polehinke’s remarks, it becomes even harder to discern why two experienced pilots continued down an unlit airstrip that, according to the NTSB, was designated strictly for daytime use.

All parties involved have pointed fingers at each other—and the NTSB has stressed that the information released today contains no analysis of the crash, just factual findings. The investigation into Comair 5191 found that runways at Blue Grass Airport in Lexington, Ky., had been changed a week before the crash because of construction. Although the FAA had notified airlines, the maps and charts used by Comair’s pilots and those of several other airlines were not updated.

The antiquated airport navigation system may have been at least partially responsible for the crash. In use since the early days of aviation, the magnetic compass and paper diagram are a far cry from the Electronic Flight Bags (EFBs) that contain digital maps of airport terrain updated weekly, and Airport Moving Maps, which operate with EFBs to show a plane’s location on the runway.

Although EFBs might help prevent human error, the units aren’t available on many planes currently, and experts say EFBs won’t be available on most aircraft for at least 10 to 15 years. Experts cite the age of airline fleets and the cost of updating planes; the FAA typically does not require technology that airlines can’t afford. In the meantime, the NTSB has asked pilots to always check their runways before takeoff; the FAA has suggested airlines find a way to get the latest airport design maps to their pilots. —Erin McCarthy

Reader Comments
4. RE: Comair Pilot Called Deadly Airstrip 'Weird': Crash Update
It's true, due to the lobbying power of the airline industry, pilots work longer hours with less rest than truckers. The rules haven't changed for decades, and they won't until the NTSB forces the issue, which they really can't as they can only make recommendations.

What a sad loss of life, and comment #2 sums it up.

To understand this issue more fully, take a look at these two articles:

http://blogs.usatoday.com/oped/2006/07/fatigue_in_the_.html

But please be sure to read this NY Times article from October, 2001. The real irony is the quote from the then head of the NTSB, now head of the FAA: "Marion Blakey, the chairwoman of the board, said after the board voted that 'trying to predict the F.A.A.'s actions certainly is beyond my capacity.' " Looks like the politics of the job got to her; how many more will perish before the rules finally change?

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?sec=health=9903E2DA1431F937A15753C1A9679C8B63

3. RE: Comair Pilot Called Deadly Airstrip 'Weird': Crash Update
Most accidents are a culmination of many small events, this one is classic. Tired crew, tired controller, construction on airport, charts not up to date and on and on. I'm sure the crew will "eat" this one and that necessary steps to help prevent a recurrance will not be taken..

2. RE: Comair Pilot Called Deadly Airstrip 'Weird': Crash Update
In response to comment #1. Try working sixteen hour days. Being off work for only 8 hours and getting maybe six hours of sleep at best, day after day. Then get in a complex aircraft and make no mistakes. That's the life these pilots live. It's hard to understand until you're living it. It could happen again.

1. RE: Comair Pilot Called Deadly Airstrip 'Weird': Crash Update
I am simply a student pilot, and excuse me if I'm wrong but wouldn't you think the pilot would have wondered why there were no lights on his end of the runway?

Add Comment
Comment Title 
Your Name 
Email Address 
Website     make public
Comment 
Please enter the characters shown below:
 

 
  Make sure your comment is relevant to the topic discussed. Comments not relevant to the topic will be deleted. Neither you nor Popular Mechanics has the ability to make your e-mail address public in this Blog. However, we ask that yo submit your e-mail address to us just in case we need to contact you. Thank you for your understanding--The Editors.

Air & Space

Mission: Moon

NASA's new mandate is to return to the moon by 2020 and build a lasting lunar base. An in-depth preview of the spacecraft that will get us there—to stay.

Industry

Movies 2.0: Digital Magic

PM goes to Hollywood to explain the revolution in digital cinema. Plus, the top 10 F/X scenes ever, podcasts with industry insiders, video of hot new flicks and more.

Automotive

Buyers Guide: Find Your Perfect New Ride

PM's one-stop shop helps you with side-by-side comparisons and reviews from our experts on over 2000 cars and trucks.
ADVERTISEMENT

Jay's Green Garage

Welcome to the Green Garage!

Like most of us, Jay Leno has been looking hard at his footprint on the planet. In a long-term project with PM, he's upgrading with environmentally friendly equipment. WITH VIDEO!

Reviews


The Boy Mechanic

Culled from a half-century of Popular Mechanics issues (make that the first half of last century), The Boy Mechanic represents an age when imagination could conquer far more than the checkbook — when solving a problem was more satisfying than paying to have it go away.





Get a full year (12 issues) of Popular Mechanics for just 12.00 —
that's like getting 9 ISSUES FREE! We will bill you later.
First Name:  
Last Name:
Address:
 
City:
StateZip:  
Email:
 
Non-US Subscriptions Give as a Gift Privacy Policy
Hearst Men's Network