Skip navigation
Alerts  Newsletters  RSS  Help  
MSN HomeHotmail
MSNBC News
Tech / Science
Science
Space News
Tech News/Reviews
Security
BlackBerry Battle
Wireless
Innovation
Games
Digital Life
News Video
U.S. News
World News
Sports
Business
Entertainment
Tech / Science
Health
Weather
Travel
Blogs Etc.
Local News
Newsweek
Multimedia
Most Popular
NBC NEWS
MSNBC TV
Today Show
Nightly News
Meet the Press
Dateline NBC
MSNBC ClassifiedsShoppingJobsPersonals with Perfectmatch.comAutosReal Estate with HomePages.com
Advertisement
MSNBC Home » Technology & Science » Wireless World » BlackBerry Battle Sponsored by 
BlackBerry blues

RIM says U.K. patent court rules in its favor

Claims by patent holding company InPro Licensing deemed invalid

Updated: 11:30 a.m. ET Feb. 2, 2006

OTTAWA - Research In Motion Ltd. said Thursday that a federal patent court in England has ruled in favor of the maker of BlackBerry e-mail device and against patent holding company InPro Licensing.

RIM said the English court decided that all claims in InPro's United Kingdom patent were invalid. InPro has the right to appeal the decision, RIM added.

Last week, a German court decided all claims in InPro's equivalent German-designated patent were invalid.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement

The decision comes one day after the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office sided with RIM, and issued a preliminary rejection of a fifth patent in a heated court battle with patent holding company NTP Inc.

RIM is preparing for a Feb. 24 hearing in a U.S. district court, which could be the final legal step before a judge decides whether to impose an injunction on RIM.

RIM is trying to fend off a 2003 patent infringement ruling that NTP won against the company.

Separately Wednesday, the U.S. Justice Department urged a U.S. federal judge to refrain from any plans to shut down BlackBerry service until the government gets more assurances its users will be exempted.

Copyright 2006 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
   Rate this story    Low  Rate it 0.5Rate it 1Rate it 1.5Rate it 2Rate it 2.5Rate it 3Rate it 3.5Rate it 4Rate it 4.5Rate it 5 High
     • View Top Rated stories

 
advertisement

advertisement
Shopping on MSN