Department of Fine Arts, Okanagan University College
WORDS OF ART: THE A_LIST
WORDS OF ART: THE A_LIST
Compiled by Robert J. Belton
If you would like to see something removed, added or corrected, please feel free to contact
bbelton@okanagan.bc.ca.
ABACUS: See column.
ABSENCE: An instance in which uncertainty about
meaning prevails over the metaphysics of presence. See
deconstruction, différance, presence. The term
lurks behind the received opinion of David Salle's paintings
of the 1980s.
ABSOLUTE: 1. As a noun in general, anything free of
dependence upon factors external to itself. In metaphysical
idealism specifically, the totality of what in fact exists.
2. As an adjective in formal terminology, it has connotations
related to the former. For example, "absolute scale" (see
scale) means the actual size of an object, without reference
to the size it appears to be in a given context (cf
absolutism, relative, relativism).
ABSOLUTISM: 1. In aesthetics, the opposite of
relativism -- i.e., that there are, for example, eternal and
immutable standards for the evaluation of works of art. 2. In
politics, unrestricted political power. Postmodernism
generally rejects all forms of absolutism.
ABSTRACTION: Often used interchangeably with non-
objective; more precisely, imagery which departs from
representational accuracy (often to an extreme degree) for some
affective or other purpose unrelated to
verisimilitude. Compare, however, Wassily Kandinsky's
conception of abstraction with that of contemporary artists
like Peter Halley. Abstraction has been treated to a good deal of
revision by critics who practice a type of semiotics: Peter
Wollen, for instance, sees the move to abstraction as a gradual
separation of signifier and signified, until the
signified is suppressed altogether in favour of an art of pure
signifiers (Semiotic Counter-Strategies: Readings and
Writings [1982]). See also Craig Owens' "The Discourse of
Others" in Hal Foster's The Anti-Aesthetic (1983).
ABSURD: Generally, a state of irrationality or
meaninglessness. More specifically, absurdity is 1. a flaw in
logic (see reductio ad absurdum) or 2. a basic
premise of existentialism which asserts that the meaning of
the world does not precede the existence of beings capable of
formulating a conception of meaning.
ACANTHUS: See column.
ACCEPTABILITY: The idea of acceptable standards,
particularly of interpretation, is pretty much a
taboo in generally postmodernist times, but if a
criticism is tacitly an intelligent argument, then it
is measurable by such standards. Of course, artwriters then
have to agree on the criteria of acceptability, which they have not
yet done. In conventional informal logic, acceptability is
usually defined as sufficency, validity, and
defensible premises for a given audience, which is ideally
assumed to be a "universal" audience of reasonable people.
Postmodernism insists that universality is really a
Eurocentric and/or androcentric illusion
-- or a variant thereof, like fleshless academicism -- so
one can easily see why acceptability is such a problem. An
interesting recent attempt to define the parameters of the issue in
philosophical terms is Annette Barnes' On Interpretation: A
Critical Analysis.
ACCOMMODATION: Adaption or adjustment practiced by a
individual, an ethnic group, or the like seeking admission
or assimilation into a larger group, culture, or social body
of whatever sort. For a specific instance with visual
ramifications, see speech accommodation.
ACCULTURATION: This can describe both cross-cultural
(or intercultural) borrowing and the process by which persons
acquire knowledge of the culture in which they live.
Feminism and critiques of ethnocentrism make
use of the term with slight variations.
ACCUMULATED INTENTION: In The Principles of
Semantics, Stephen Ullmann argues that words gather meanings
unto themselves over time, producing not merely conventional
ambiguity, but also the power of symbolic expression in
general. Words and images thus function as accumulators of meaning.
The idea could serve as a practical explanation of some of the more
ephemeral results of deconstruction.
ACRYLIC: A plastic-based painting medium which, because it is water soluble, dries quickly and cleans up easily. Especially popular in the 1960s and 1970s for effects ranging from translucent watercolour-like washes to opaque hard-edges in bright colours, acrylic seems to have been declining in popularity since the new image movement of the early 1980s restored interest in oil as a medium.
ACTION PAINTING: Harold Rosenberg's 1952 term for those works within the orbit of American abstract expressionism which featured very energetically applied painting, apparently involving movements of the whole body -- or at least of its larger limbs, as opposed to minute movements of the fingers and wrist -- and a certain indifference to traditional niceties of execution, like the avoidance of drips and spatters. Rosenberg had the works of Willem de Kooning in mind, but because of the famous 1951 coverage in Life magazine of Jackson Pollock, in which Hans Namuth's photographs clearly show the artist dripping paint through the air onto a canvas on the floor, the phrase seems attached to this sort of quasi-theatrical activity. (Many artists followed this particular thread to its logical conclusion, a sort of painting as performance. Internationally, Georges Mathieu is a well-known example; in Canada, William Ronald was an early, if only occasional, practitioner.) There are many other variations of action painting, including French tachisme and Canadian automatisme. Although in varying degrees, they have in common Rosenberg's notion that the canvas is "an arena in which to act," rather than a distanced product of reflection and deliberation.
ACTUALITY (OF MEANING): See inexhaustibility by
contrast.
ACQUIRED DRIVE: See drive.
ADBUSTERS: See culture jamming.
ADD WOMEN AND STIR: An expression used by some feminists (see feminism) who feel that simply adding women to existing
canons of artistic greatness really does nothing to
challenge or change the processes of canon-formation, which
are inherently hierarchical and sexist.
AD HOMINEM: Traditionally considered a
fallacy, ad hominem is a usually pernicious type of
argument which attempts to discredit a counter-argument by
questioning the opponent, rather than the opponent's position:
such-and-such person's views should not be given credence because
his/her character is disreputable; s/he is not knowledgeable,
trustworthy, or unbiased; his/her credentials are not apparent or
are irrelevant; or there is no consensual agreement or resolution
on the part of other authorities. A recent example in the popular
press is Susan Faludi's dismissal of Camille Paglia's theories:
this is not done because of the quality (or lack thereof) of
Paglia's thought but because Paglia was filled with spite and a
desire for revenge on other feminists who failed to recognize her
talent, leading seven publishers to refuse her work (see
backlash, feminism, sexual personae). William
Blake's occasionally vicious marginalia in his copy of Joshua
Reynolds' Discourses -- e.g., "This Man was hired to depress
Art" -- are perhaps the most famous art historical examples.
AD IGNORANTIUM: Arguments from ignorance, as it were.
After the failure of a responsible attempt to find evidence
that a claim is true, conclude the claim is false, or vice versa:
there is no evidence of X (or -X). Therefore, -X (or X). For
example, there is little solid evidence that Vincent Van Gogh's
painting style was the direct result only of his state of mind, so
we can conclude that his style was not an expression of madness.
ADMISSIBLE: Capable of being admitted, allowed,
conceded, permitted, and the like. In legal contexts, a great deal
of attention is paid to what can and cannot be admitted as
evidence, but only rarely is such attention given to the
question in artwriting. This results in arguments and
interpretations which appear to be valid but are
constructed on flimsy or irrelevant grounds. See
hearsay for an application.
ADVERSARIAL: Occasionally used in place of the
adjective "adversary," meaning "having or involving antagonistic
parties or interests." It is a key component of the avant-
garde and of bohemianism, and some feel it has even
become mainstream culture. See for example, licensed rebels.
AEGIS: Term used in Norman Bryson's Tradition and
Desire to replace source analysis in traditional art
history with a conception of allusion as a trope.
Hypothetically, an artist uses an earlier artist's manner as
a source to take refuge in and to challenge its authority.
His principal example is the work of Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres,
but it can easily be applied to others. The concept ultimately
derives from Harold Bloom's Anxiety of Influence. See
anxiety of influence.
AESTHETIC DISTANCE: 1. The audience's awareness that
art and reality are not the same, entailing some
suspension of disbelief. Edward Bullough's famous essay
"Psychical Distance" (In the British Journal of Psychology,
1912) is the most extended discussion of the idea. Cf antinomy
of distance. The idea should be debated in discussions of
images that capitalize on shocking subject matter, ranging from
Géricault's Raft of the Medusa to Joel-Peter Witkin's
Pathological Reproduction: The Guernica Variations. 2. The
term is sometimes used to refer to the distance between a completed
art object and the circumstances of its production. Marxists (see Marxism) and non-partisan historians concerned with the
social and/or economic circumstances in which artworks were
produced would likely be indifferent or opposed to this idea.
AESTHETIC EMOTION: See unique aesthetic
emotion.
AESTHETICISM: See art for art's sake. The term
is often used to connote a certain decadence or preciousness.
AESTHETICS: Originally, that which pertains to the
beautiful, as conceived variously by artists and,
especially, philosophers with reference to noble aspects of
experience beyond superficial appearance or mere prettiness. The theme preoccupied philosophers in ancient Greece, but the term itself first appeared in the eighteenth-century writings of Alexander Baumgarten. Since
the adoption of the term of the term "esthetician" to describe
purveyors of cosmetics, "aesthetics" seems to have little
relevance, unless one thinks of it more generically as "pertaining to
the philosophy of art" -- i.e., its function, nature,
ontology, purpose, and so on. Even these have has largely
been supplanted by postmodernism's questions of meaning
and linguistically based investigations. The term is still
sometimes used to indicate a certain imprecise distinction between
art and life, or as a rough synonym for "artistic." See
art theory.
AFFECT: In an essay in Social Text (Fall
1982), Frederic Jameson characterized the move from modernism
to postmodernism as a move from affect to effect, from
emotional engagement to slick superficiality. Jeff Koons' works
could be so described. Cf simulacrum. Cf speech act
theory.
AFFECTIVE: Pertaining to emotional expression. Cf
affective fallacy, perlocutionary, speech act
theory.
AFFECTIVE FALLACY: Once of great value to all types of
expression theory and to Aristotelian
catharsis, the notion that a work's value resides in the
emotional affect it has on an audience has lost its lustre
both for formalism and for postmodernism in
general, though for very different reasons. Hence it is called a
fallacy. The question should be raised when discussing Romanticism
and much early modern art and theory, especially that of Wassily
Kandinsky and Kasimir Malevich, among others.
AFROCENTRIC: Characteristic of any of a number of
positions demanding greater representation of African
cultural heritage in post-secondary curricula in the humanities
(see canon). The range is very wide, from straightforward
demonstrations of black pride to claims that classic Greek
philosophy was plagiarized from lost black sources and that the
ancient Egyptians were actually black Africans. The term is most
closely associated with the academic books of Molefi Kete Asante,
but the issues should come up in discussions of the works of
artists like Romare Bearden, Faith Ringgold, Betye Saar, and
Henry Ossawa Tanner, among others.
AGEISM: On the model of racism and
sexism, a discriminatory attitude against people because of
their age. Are Ivan Albright's paintings ageist or sympathetic? See
the special issue of Art Journal 53.1 (Spring 1994) on art
and old age.
AGENDA: A list or outline of things to do, issues to
resolve, questions to be decided, and the like. In popular postmodern parlance (see
postmodernism), especially when preceded by "hidden,"
the word connotes premeditated cultural mechanisms of persuasion
and/or repression. Cf power.
AGGLUTINATING, INFLECTING, ISOLATING: August von
Schlegel's three categories of grammatical relations in comparative
linguistics. An agglutinating (or compounding) language is
one in which changes in relations are most frequently expressed by
an additive process of prefixes and roots. Turkish and German use
agglutination much more than English, but an English example in
"antidisestablishmentarianism." An inflecting language is one in
which changes in relations are most frequently expressed by changes
in the forms of the words themselves. In English, for example, the
plural noun "birds" calls for the verb formation "fly," whereas the
singular noun "bird" inflects the verb into the form "flies." An
isolating language (sometimes also called analytic) is one in which
the word forms are invariable and changes in relations are
signalled by word order and various other parts of speech, as in
Vietnamese. The typology suggests interesting parallels with visual
art, if art is genuinely understood to be a language.
Realism, for example, might be understood as isolating:
since the forms of the representation are hypothetically true to
nature (but compare perceptualism), they remain constant and
meaning is principally produced through different
arrangements and accomodations. Expressionist art would likely be
inflecting, since its aesthetic impact is largely a matter
of deformation in a given context of something which would appear
"normal" in another context (compare paralinguistic). The
difficulty here is that spoken language usually has
denotations and connotations which expressionist art
probably does not have (see idiolect). A truly agglutinating
visual art is more difficult again to imagine, although one might
so consider Northwest Coast Indian totem poles, or certain
productions of the more mythically inclined Surrealists and early
Abstract Expressionists.
AGNOSIA: See interpretive agnosia.
AHA EXPERIENCE: The literature of psychology
describes the instant of insight and release in puzzle or problem
solving as the aha (sometimes ah-ah) experience. It would be useful
to consider whether the type of satisfaction afforded by a
particularly compelling interpretation corresponds to this
is any meaningful way, since it would seem to imply that an
artwork is principally something to "figure out," rather
than something to experience in an open-ended manner.
AHISTORICAL: Generally, that which is not concerned
with history or historical development. It is sometimes used as a
synonym for anachronism, particularly when the actions,
ideas, and/or motives of a given generation are attributed to an
earlier one.
AIR BRUSH: A device which sprays paint with compressed air to offer a broad range of applications, from wide patches of paint to thin mists enabling precise details. The principle is the same whether one uses an inexpensive contraption with one's breath or a rather expensive mechanical version of a device invented in the late nineteenth century by Charles Burdick. Air brush painting was particularly popular in 1960s and 1970s advertising and van painting, and its effect of photographic verisimilitude was adopted for use in pop art and photorealism.
ALBUMEN: See photography.
ALEATORIC: Composition based on chance,
usually, but sometimes also random accident and/or highly
improvisational execution. Hans Arp's so-called Collage Arranged According to the Laws of Chance is an early example. The composer John Cage is particularly noted for this technique, and traces of it can be found in the work of numerous artists within his circle (e.g., Robert Rauschenberg, Naim June Paik, Jim Dine, etc.).
ALETHEIA: Originally a Greek term meaning "truth" or
"the unconcealedness of things." Current writers often use the word
with the connotations supplied by Heidegger in The Origin of the
Work of Art, in which an artwork is useful to the extent that
it can open up a space in which existentially alienated beings (see alienation) can
discover the meaning of their existence, which is not synonymous
with "truth" in the conventional sense. See Dasein,
existentialism, existential phenomenology,
Open.
ALIENATION: Sometimes generally used to suggest
depersonalization, disenchantment, estrangement, or powerlessness,
alienation is actually a philosophical word with a lengthy history.
The most particular conceptions appear in Hegelianism,
Marxism and existentialism.Simply put, in Hegel, alienations were
various stages in the development of human consciousness: the
lowest was immediate perception of sense-data, the next a
consciousness of self, the next the abstraction of reason, and
finally the world of the spirit, manifest in religion and art.
Alienation is perhaps not the happiest translation of his
Entaüsserung, which was the dialectical (see dialectic) process by
which the mind moved from one of these stages to the next -- a move
which entailed the recognition of the illusion of the first stage
and a move beyond it, as if the mind became alien to itself, only
to return to itself later in a higher stage. In Marx alienation
meant the proletariats economic, psychological and other
senses of separation from the products of their labour, the forces
of production, and his own social formation (see also
species-being). In existentialism, generally, alienation is
the experience of the world as absurd (see authentic,
Dasein).
ALLEGORY: Traditionally, a type of figurative
expression, usually a narrative with one or more
personifications, and often with some moralizing conclusion.
More recently, it has been used in postmodernism to describe the relation of one text to another,
particularly where they purport to be about the same thing but
actually introduce unbidden levels of signification
alien to each other. See, for example, Gregory Ulmer's "The Object
of Post-Criticism" in Hal Foster, ed., The Anti-Aesthetic.
ALLUSION: Passing reference to an event, object or
person presumed to be familiar to the audience, most commonly to
increase affective potential without extensive digression.
As such, it is a less precise artistic borrowing than
appropriation or citation. The wailing mother with
the dead child in Picasso's Guernica, for example, may be
understood as an ironic (see irony) allusion to the typical Madonna and
child. Cf source analysis.
ALTAR: A structure on which sacrifices or other offerings were made to the gods. In Christian tradition, although the altar serves more to allude to the table at which the Last Supper took place, the celebration of the mystery of the Eucharist -- i.e., that bread and wine are the body and blood of Christ -- is still a sacrificial affair of sorts. Altars are a central part of many forms of religious life and are accordingly given special visual treatment with such things as altarpieces.
ALTARITY: Title of a 1987 book by a/theologian Mark
C. Taylor (see a/theology) describing religious existence in
terms deriving from deconstruction. The term plays on
alterity but is not synonymous with it. See also
disfiguring.
ALTARPIECE: Any of a varety of decorated panels, screens or shrines rising behind an altar to signify its importance and authority, to tell an associated legend, and so on. The most common type of altarpiece is a painting spread over several panels hung together like folding screens. A simple type consists of a central panel with two flanking half-sized doors to close over it (e.g., Bosch's Garden of Earthly Delights). A three-part painting of this sort is called a triptych. Paintings with more complicated arrangements, as in Van Eyck's celebrated Ghent Altarpiece, are called polyptychs. Altarpieces often have a decorated panel at the bottom called a predella. Some Baroque altarpieces are gloriously overblown flights of fancy, with painting, sculpture, and architectural accompaniments skillfuly interwoven for theatrical effect. Altarpieces are sometime called reredos or retables.
ALTERITY: Not to be confused with altarity, alterity is the condition of being radically different or
unlike some other being, state or thing. See other.
ALTERNATING FIGURES: Ambiguous diagrams (see ambiguity) serving in the psychology of perception to illustrate the way the
mind habitually tries to achieve a coherent Gestalt. An
example is the famous impossible trident, the bottom half of which
seems like a square "u," and the top half like three prongs. Op art
occasionally makes use of the phenomenon. One might speculate
whether there is a non-visual, cerebral equivalent which could be
useful in discussions of ambiguity or plurivocality.
See closure.
ALTERSSTIL: German term referring to the style of an
artist in old age, especially when it has characteristics
distinguishing it from earlier parts of the artist's career.
Notable examples include late Michelangelo and Titian. See Hugo
Munsterberg's The Crown of Life (1983).
ALTHUSSERIAN: Pertaining to the ideas of philosopher
Louis Althusser. See autocritical, coupure
épistémologique, ideology, interpellation,
masquerade, overdetermination, problematic,
structuralist Marxism, theory of practice.
ALWAYS-ALREADY-READ: Frederic Jameson argues that no
text exists in a vacuum, for when it is read by a member of
an identifiable social group, its meaning is mediated (see
mediation) by his or her ideology. The material is
thus always already read, in a sense. See political unconscious. For visual art, there is no need to transform theterm to" always-already-seen," because the component "seen" implies a value-free physiological phenomenon which postmodernism
generally dismisses. See
perceptualism.
AMBIGUITY: Something which admits of
interpretation in two or more possible senses. In logical
and critical texts, ambiguity is usually something to be avoided
(however, see dissemination), but many creative works
capitalize on it quite effectively. There are, for instance,
ambiguities of drawing in Matisse's Le Luxe II and
ambiguities of content in Dorothea Tanning's Birthday. See
also double entendre, pun.
AMBIVALENCE: Often colloquially known as "mixed
feelings;" mildly conflicting emotions or contradictory attitudes.
AMBULATORY: An aisle surrounding the altar at the apse end of a church, or a covered passage around an open court, as in a cloister.
AMORPHOUS: Formless -- i.e., devoid of readily recognizable regularity in form, as in a standard shape like a rectangle or a triangle.
AMPHORA: A large storage jar with a fairly tall neck and two handles stretching from a wide mouth to a broader oval body. In Greek antiquity, such jars were for both practical and trophy purposes. Without their painted depictions of the Greek myths, we would have very little knowledge of ancient Greek pictorial practice.
ANACHRONISM: Chronological misplacement, usually
running backwards in time, as in asserting that Freud used a CD
player, or some such thing. Cf ahistorical. For a possible
instance, see camouflage.
ANALEPSIS: The recovery into consciousness of
unconscious, repressed or forgotten material. Clear examples are in
Max Ernst's descriptions of the discovery of frottage and
Salvador Dali's paranoiac-critical method.
ANALOGY: A comparison in which two things have
sufficient numbers of similar characteristics to conclude that they
will probably share others. It is commonly used when a familiar
thing is used to explain something less familiar and as such is a
basic component of symbolism. See argument from
analogy.
ANALYTIC: See synthetic a priori. (For a less
frequent sense, see agglutinating, inflecting, isolating.)
ANALYTICO-REFERENTIAL: See discursive
activity.
ANALYTIC PSYCHOLOGY: Jungian term for a
wholistic type of depth psychology which takes into
account not only the collective unconscious and the
personal unconscious as motivators of behaviour, but also
the conscious aspirations and goals of the subject. A hypothetical
criticism so inspired would differ fundamentally from
Freudian-based psychoanalytical criticism.
ANAMORPHOSIS: Mannered or distorted imagery that can
be optically corrected by examining it from an unconventional point
of view or through some optical device. Although the term usually
indicates a simple visual example of the phenomenon, as in Hans
Holbein's The Ambassadors, Donald Preziosi uses it in Rethinking Art History as a metaphor of the way
historical narrative (see metanarrative) deforms the object
of investigation. Jacques Lacan has also used the concept to
describe how his conception of a picture functions (see gaze and
glance).
ANCHORAGE AND RELAY: Roland Barthes' characterization
of the functions of captions in advertising, the former serving to
anchor (i.e., delimit) the meanings of the example, for
example, via identification, and the latter serving to proliferate
meaning via a process of referral to other, absent
significances.
ANCHORING GAZE: In You Just Don't Understand,
Deborah Tannen coined this term to indicate the principal line of
sight of people in conversation. She found that female speakers
tended to face one another and look directly into each others'
faces, whereas male speakers tended to sit at angles to each other
and find visual home bases elsewhere in the room. The idea gives
further support to her distinction between rapport-talk and
report-talk. The idea might be exploited to disrupt the
simple polarity of Bryson's gaze and glance.
ANDROCENTRIC: A specifically male
anthropocentrism. A typical, though simple example is the
use of the word "man" to refer to both genders. Imagine how it
might be used to discuss the canon of art history.
ANIMA: Originally the soul or life force, but now
universally construed as the Jungian archetype of the
female components within a male personality. Presumably, a male
projects his own female side -- whether it be creatively inspiring
(the muse) or protective and nurturing (the mother), etc. -- onto
those around him. Jung designated the reverse, the male components
within a female personality, as animus, but he did not
explore the concept to as great a depth. The notions have been much
abused in popular writings, opening them to charges of
essentialism.
ANIMUS: See anima.
ANOSAGNOSIA: A neurological term coined by Babinski,
a contemporary of Freud (see hysteria), designating certain
patients' inability to know they are suffering from a
cognitive deficit, particularly agnosia (see
interpretive agnosia). Such patients thus have a double
deficit, for they have even lost an awareness of their loss.
ANTAGONIST: In narrative analysis, the
adversary or opponent of the protagonist. The antagonist in
Artemesia Gentileschi's Judith and Holofernes, for example,
is the latter.
ANTHROPOCENTRISM: The mind-set that sees human
beings as central (i.e., essential and most significant) in the
universe. A more precise term that says the same specifically of
male centrality is androcentric.
ANTHROPOMORPHISM: The representation of non-
human beings, whether real or fictitious, in human form (e.g., the
gods); the ascription of human attributes, characteristics, and/or
preoccupations to non-human beings (e.g., the speaking animals in
Aesop's fables).
ANTI-AESTHETIC: The title of an influential postmodernist (see
postmodernism) anthology edited by Hal Foster (1983), in which
he expressly argues that "anti-aesthetic" does not mean a
reassertion of modernism's principle of aesthetic
negation, or anti-art, but rather a critique of the
very notion of the aesthetic (see aesthetics), especially in its modern
manifestations with supposedly pseudotranshistorical and determinate meanings (see
determinacy).
ANTI-ART: Imprecise but once fashionable term to
describe works which sought to denounce or dismantle traditional
conceptions of art, whether through untraditional
techniques, materials, and display formats (e.g., automatism,
combine painting, installation) or through unusual
iconography and the like.
ANTI-AUTHORITARIAN: The essential characteristic of
any challenge to presumed authority.
ANTI-INTELLECTUALISM: Any position, whether
originating with an unreflective street tough or a philosophical
pragmatist, which eschews, fears, or mistrusts reason. Some hyper-
intellectual artwriting is, paradoxically, overtly anti-
intellectual. (See, for example, écriture féminine.) The
relation between it and once fashionable Romantic
bohemianism should be explored.
ANTINOMIANISM: Originally, the doctrine that moral
laws do not apply to Christ. By extension, the notion that certain
persons with privileged status do not have to obey their own
dictates, as in "Do as I say, not as I do." Many artists,
especially those of the middle class who feign distaste for
bourgeois values, have exhibited such characteristics. In
"Suspicious Art, Unsuspecting Texts" (In H. Smagula, ed., Re-
Visions), David Carrier uses the idea without identifying it as
such to point out the paradox of artwriters whose
"incredulity towards metanarrative" (see
postmodernism) is framed within yet another metanarrative.
ANTINOMY: A paradox or contradiction between two
conclusions, both of which were apparently arrived at by proper
reasoning. For specific applications, see antinomy of
distance, spontaneity.
ANTINOMY OF DISTANCE: Edward Bullough's conception of
aesthetic distance includes a paradox of sorts: an
artist's work will be most powerful when it is most
personal, but s/he can only formulate an effective artistic
expression by assuming a certain detachment from it.
Similarly, a viewer's experience of a work of art will be
augmented if s/he has experienced something similar, but if a
certain aesthetic distance is not maintained, the art is superseded
by the viewer's own emotional state. Bullough formulated the
principle in this way: "What is...most desirable is the utmost
decrease of [aesthetic] distance without its disappearance."
ANTIPHRASIS: A specific type of irony in which
a sign is used to signal its opposite.
ANTIQUARIANISM: Originally, the study of the
material culture of ancient societies, particularly those
whose current descendants exhibit markedly different customs, as in
Egypt. In certain circles, the term now has a connotation of
commercialism and commodity exchange for profit, rather than
for the expansion of the frontiers of knowledge.
ANTITHESIS: 1. A single figure with markedly
contrasting ideas. 2. The second component of the Hegelian dialectic (see Hegelianism).
ANTONOMASIA: A figure in which a general idea
is represented by a proper name, as when artists' names
signify their entire oeuvre or an unspecified single work.
This is everywhere in art criticism, art history,
etc.
ANXIETY OF INFLUENCE: The title of a book by literary
theorist Harold Bloom, who asserted that the ambiguous relationship
writers have with those who influence them is akin to the
psychological relationship of sons to fathers described in Freud's Totem and Taboo. It concerns alternating veneration and
vilification -- the mixed feelings of adoration and fear of the
artistic forefather, whose authority represents an implicit
castration threat, but whose position as father is nonetheless
worthy of some veneration. Its application to art history
appears in Norman Bryson's Tradition and Desire. See
aegis. An instance of the popularization of the term appears
in Stephen Eisenman's Nineteenth Century Art: A Critical
History, wherein the author casually and without explanation
describes Drouais' relationship with his master David as anxiety of
influence.
AORIST: Literally "without horizons," the term
designates a classical Greek tense presenting an occurrence without
limitation as to duration. It could be used as a rough synonym of
indeterminacy. Norman Bryson uses the term in Vision and
Painting as a rough antonym of deixis.
APHASIA: Impairment of the ability to use and/or
understand words. The term is still fairly rare in contemporary
theory, but it has crept in via Roman Jakobson and others (see
concatenation relation) and, from there, into a few writings
on contemporary art inasmuch as both artists and
aphasics find other ways to communicate (see communication).
For a related idea, see artist envy. Cf agnosia,
paralinguistic.
APHORISM: A concise statement of a principle or
something held by the speaker to be true or deeply felt. While
there is a strong philosophical tradition involved -- as in, e.g.,
Nietzsche's well-controlled aphorisms -- many artists' writings are
simply strings of unordered aphorisms, as in the cases of Brancusi
and Picabia.
APOPHASIS: The rhetorical figure in which one
states something while seeming to deny it. The phrases "not to
mention such and such" and "to make a long story short" are
apophases. To maintain, for example, that a depiction of cruelty
towards animals is a protest, rather than an indulgence, requires
some notion of apophasis. Compare indulgence or indictment.
APOPHATIC: A theological term meaning knowledge of
God obtained by negation (see negative theology). Much
modernism has been apophatic inasmuch as the autonomy
of art has been asserted chiefly by excluding what art is
not. Since what "art is not" is really what "art is thought not to
be," there is a similar dimension of faith involved.
APORIA: Formerly, a type of irony in which
certainty, say, about a person's character, masquerades as
deferential uncertainty. Now the term is more likely to mean the
point at which a text is most explicitly indeterminate (see
indeterminacy) or self-contradictory, as in
deconstruction.
APOSTROPHE: A figure in which something or
someone is addressed in their absence. For example, pictorial
appeals to the saints usually include some sign of the saints
within the picture's space, but instances in which no saints or
signs appear might be legitimately considered apostrophes.
APOTROPAIC: Having the power to avert evil or bad
fortune, as in a good luck charm or talisman. Magico-religious art and ex-votos could be said to have an
apotropaic dimension.
APPEAL TO PRECEDENT: X should be allowed (or not)
because some analogous Y has been allowed (or not). This structure
of informal logic is very widely used in writing about
art, especially in attributions and
interpretations, but it is rarely explicitly identified or
critiqued on the basis of its logicality. See
analogy, argument from analogy.
APPETITIVE DRIVE: Any of the instinctual urges
thought to require some sort of satisfaction of a need, as in
hunger, sexuality, sleep, etc. For example, Friedrich Nietzsche and
many others (André
Masson, male Surrealists in general) have thought that sexual
appetite was the real drive behind works of art -- even the
high idealism of Raphael. More recently, Stephen Pepper used
the idea in The Work of Art to argue in favour of
determinacy: see consummatory field.
APOLLONIAN: Friedrich Nietzsche's designation for the
calm, conscious, orderly, and rational side of human nature. Cf
Dionysian.
A POSTERIORI: See synthetic a priori.
APPROPRIATION: More aggressive than allusion
or citation, appropriation is the excision of material from one
context and its reuse in another context, usually with
intent to expose some unrecognized irony in the original or
to undermine notions of authorial responsibility. The range
of possibilites extends from simple reuse, as in collage, to
Sherri Levine's rephotographed photos by Edward Weston (see
aura).
A PRIORI: See synthetic a priori.
APSE: Under construction.
ARBITER ELEGANTIARUM: A putative final
authority or judge in matters of taste. Clement Greenberg
might be so described, using other terms. Cf
connoisseurship.
ARCHAEOLOGY: The scientific study of the material
remains of past cultures. Michel Foucault used the term figuratively (see
figurative) to describe the history of the mechanisms which
appear to constitute knowledge. See episteme.
ARCHETYPAL CRITICISM: Usually Jungian, but any
criticism which seeks to discover the role of
archetypes in generating meaning. Cf matriarchal
aesthetic.
ARCHETYPE: An essentialist (see essentialism) term imported from
Jungian analysis, it means basic, unchanging images of a
primordially mythic character that reside in the
collective unconscious. The presumption is that these images
are universal, transcultural, and transhistorical. Jung
himself said the idea was not his invention and could be found in
previous writings by Adolf Bastian and Friedrich Nietzsche (Jung,
Psychology and Religion [1938]).
ARCHITECTURE: Under construction, if you will pardon the pun. For the moment, note that the word itself is made up of two components originally meaning "of a leading or distinguished sort" and "pertaining to construction," so that "archi-tecture" meant buildings of artistic, political, religious or social significance, as opposed to run-of-the-mill structures of little or no importance. This explains to a great extent why many classically trained architects of the nineteenth century were so strongly opposed to structures like the Eiffel Tower: designed by an engineer, it was thought by some as mere "building" -- somehow sub-architectural. Lately, however, we have used the word with fewer restrictions, although we sometimes still feel it necessary to use phrases like "vernacular architecture" to identify ordinary, average, everyday structures like domestic housing or commercial facilities. See column, order, vault, wall.
ARENA: Many writers are now concerned with how
speakers and listeners work with each other to ascertain the
meanings of the things they say (and, by extension, the
things they produce). Herbert Clark argues in an anthology entitled Arenas of Language Use that only analysis of the common
ground between speakers can determine their meanings. Each area of
common ground is an arena, which is thus a near synonym of what
other writers call the social formation.
ARGUMENT: In informal logic, a
propositional form in which premises (reasons) are given in
support of a claim (conclusion). While most art is not
propositional, and therefore cannot be construed as argument in
itself, much (if not all) art criticism is implicitly or
explicitly a matter of substantiating claims about a work. As such,
it admits of the kind of critical analysis applicable to logic. A
simple argument consists of one conclusion supported by one or more
premises. An extended argument consists of a main conclusion
supported by premises, some of which are, in turn, conclusions of
subsidiary arguments.
ARGUMENT FROM ANALOGY: If X is true, Y is likely to
be true if it similar in sufficient, relevant aspects, and if it is not relevantly dissimilar. See sufficiency, relevance.
ARISTOTELIAN: Pertaining to the thought of Aristotle
and his followers. See catharsis, mimesis,
techne.
ART: Any simple definition would be profoundly
pretentious and tendentious, but we can say that all the
definitions offered over the centuries include some notion of human
agency, whether through manual skills (as in the art of sailing or
painting or photography), intellectual manipulation (as in the art
of politics), or public or personal expression (as in the art of
conversation). As such, the word is etymologically related to
artificial -- i.e., produced by human beings. Since this embraces
many types of production that are not conventionally deemed to be
art, perhaps a better term would be culture. This would
explain why certain preindustrial cultures produce objects which
Eurocentric interests characterize as art, even though the
producing culture has no linguistic term to differentiate
these objects from utilitarian artifacts. For an interesting list
of the various definitions that have preoccupied writers over the
years, see definitions of art. Cf craft, high
art, low art.
ART APPRECIATION: The introduction of basic
principles of visual literacy -- especially the fundamentals
of formal analysis without reference to iconography
or historical context -- to general audiences for the
purpose of enhancing their enjoyment of works of art in non-
academic contexts. In some postmodernisms, the term has
a slightly pejorative tone indicating unreflective indulgence.
ART CONSERVATION: Principally, the technical study of
the best ways to preserve and protect artworks from physical
deterioration. However, some programmes in art conservation also
address related issues, such as the ethics of conservation, art
restoration, museology, and so on. The most
famous -- and hotly debated -- conservation issue in recent times
is the cleaning of the Sistine Chapel ceiling.
ART CRITICISM: See artwriting, critic,
criticism. Cf art history, art theory,
historical methodologies.
ART FOR ART'S SAKE: Any of a number of positions
related to the possibility of art being autonomous (see autonomy) or
autotelic. The term is usually used of artists and
artwriters of the second half of the nineteenth century: in
France the prime movers were Charles Baudelaire and Théophile
Gautier; in England, J. A. M. Whistler and Oscar Wilde; in the
United States, Edgar Allan Poe. In the twentieth century, the notion has been sharply critiqued by Walter Benjamin, among others. See, for example, aura.
ART HISTORY: Misleading presentations of a unified,
homogeneous art history have eroded the reputation of the field as
a serious intellectual endeavour. In much of Norman Bryson's
writing, for instance, it is equated exclusively with
perceptualism, while Nicolas Hadjinicolau (Art History
and Class Struggle) assumes it is hagiography
unconcerned with social context. Reductive characterizations
like these should be baffling to postmodernists (see postmodernism) and students
of traditional historiography alike. While it is true that
certain approaches achieved predominance in institutional contexts
in the 1960s -- especially connoisseurship and
formalism
-- simplifying characterizations do not recognize the rich variety
of interpretive approaches that have succeeded one another over the
history of art history. The real culprit is not the field itself
but textbooks -- written for general service courses at the
university level, but strongly influenced by the commercial success
of coffee table books. Since textbooks reduce everything
complicated to a simple taxonomy, often with a
teleological bent, the onus is on innovative instructors to
generate enough intellectual curiosity that students won't forget
to see the trees for the forest. (No responsible student of
psychology or biology would assume that their field is perfectly
characterized by a first year textbook designed for specialists and
dabblers alike.) See art criticism, art theory,
criticism, hagiography, historical
methodologies, perceptualism, taxonomy,
teleology.
ART MEDAL: See medal.
ARTIST: A maker of art. See also
author.
ARTIST ENVY: Donald Kuspit's term (in Artforum
[November 1987]) for the envy psychoanalysts -- and by implication, practitioners of
psychoanalytical criticism -- have for artists, whom
they feel can establish a pre-verbal closeness (empathy,
identification. etc.) with the audience. This closeness is
of the sort that psychoanalysts work so hard to achieve with their
patients.
(L')ART POUR L'ART: See art for art's sake.
ART RESTORATION: The rectification of damage to
artworks. Cf art conservation.
ART THEORY: The general study of aesthetics
and art, with a particular view to elucidating the nature
(see ontology) and purpose (see function) of works of
art. Art theory has been written by practising artists,
critics, historians, and professional philosophers. It is
impossible to see a work of art without theory: even the
most unreflective, untrained viewer -- protesting, e.g., that even
a child could draw such and such -- is encountering visual phenomena through a tacit theory (in this case, one which
foregrounds illusionism and traditional conceptions
of talent as technically based). Although art theory sometimes
deals with history and ideology, historical
methodologies and postmodernism in general
are more directly concerned with and responsive to them.
ARTICULATIVE RESPONSE: See illustrement.
ARTISTIC BIOGRAPHY: The interpretive mode which seeks
to produce an accurate account of an artist's life and/or
foregrounds data about an artist's life in the discussion
and evaluation of the artwork. Vasari's Lives is a prime
example, and the model continues to this day. As in the case of
Vincent Van Gogh, sometimes biographical accounts become so
distorted in popular consciousness that readers fail to recognize
the merits of disinterested scholarship. Cf biographical
fallacy.
ARTS JOURNALISM: The production of descriptive
reviews of arts activities (including dance, drama, music, theatre,
visual arts, etc.) for publication in the mass media.
Because it is usually directed towards a general audience, much
arts journalism has not been very critically acute. Except in some
larger centres, popular writing about the arts has even fallen
under the rubric of entertainment or lifestyle journalism, and in
such cases it is often written by columnists without particular
qualifications.
ARTWORK: A work of art. Sometimes, like
oeuvre, it can also signify an entire body of works.
ARTWORLD: Not simply an art world (sic) -- i.e., an
institutional framework in which art is commodified,
discussed, insured, researched, etc. -- "artworld" is Arthur
Danto's term The Journal of Philosophy [1964]) for the
knowledge of theory and art history that is necessary
to understand how a single artifact can be non-art in one situation
and art in another. More bluntly, theory is not a parasite of art
but is constitutive of it. Cf "is" of artistic
identification.
ARTWRITER: A practitioner of artwriting.
ARTWRITING: David Carrier's book Artwriting is
a thought-provoking analysis of practices in both art
criticism and art history, based in part on Arthur
Danto's theory of interpretation (see also artworld).
It traces the interrelations of three conceptual points: "the need
to properly identify an artwork [i.e., to distinguish it as
an artwork, rather than a non-artwork]; the possibility of
conflicting interpretations; and the use of rhetoric in
intepretation." Accordingly, the term "artwriting" is more or less
a conception of art criticism and art history as essentially
rhetorical, rather than scientific -- i.e., the primary
characteristic of both is persuasive instrumental value, not
truth value.
ASIDE: A term used mostly in theatre and film
criticism to describe the dramatic convention in which an
actor directly addresses the audience without the other
actors' knowledge. It could easily be applied to paintings like
Manet's Déjeuner sur l'herbe.
ATAVISM: Reversion to an earlier type or to the
characteristics of a remote ancestor, as in some varieties of
primitivism. Joan Miro's pictograph-like images and
Henry Moore's allusions to Precolumbian artifacts might be
so described. The word was frequently used by Salvador Dali to
indicate something closer in meaning to analepsis.
A/THEOLOGY: A unique brand of postmodern (see postmodernism)
theology in which the Bible, God, the self and the Word of
traditional theology are mutually interpretable in terms deriving
from deconstruction. The term, first proposed in Mark C.
Taylor's 1984 book Erring, would have no currency in
art discourse were it not for the same author's
Disfiguring: Art, Architecture, Religion (1992), in which
the disfiguring of artists and architects like Michael
Heizer, Anselm Kiefer, Robert Venturi and James Stirling is
discussed.
ATTRIBUTE: An object familiarly associated with an
office, person, or personification, as in the sceptre of a
king, the tablets of Moses, or the scales of Justice. See
metonymy.
ATTRIBUTION: The act of giving credit for an unsigned
work to an artist on the basis of similarity of
style, iconography, or some other material
evidence.
AUDIENCE: Originally, a group of listeners; now, any
reader(s), spectator(s), or viewer(s). The traditional distinction
between active artists and passive audience is being revised
substantially, with much more of the responsibility for meaning
going to the latter. See authorial responsibility,
reader-response.
AURA: Walter Benjamin's famous essay "The Work of Art
in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction" defines "aura" as the unique
existence of a work of art -- its originality and authenticity.
Reproduction withers the aura, detaching the object from the domain
of tradition and "liquidating the traditional value of the cultural
heritage." Photography, which renders absurd the notion of the
"authentic" print, replaces the ritual roots of authentic
traditional art with a basis in politics. Discussions of
contemporary appropriation, especially that of Sherri
Levine, Richard Prince, Sarah Charlesworth and others, often make
explicit reference to the idea. See also negative theology.
AUTEUR THEORY: The still fashionable theory that a
single filmmaker, almost always the director, is fully and finally
responsible for the creative processes that make the finished
product. Essentially Romantic at heart, auteur theory often
capitulates to modernism's, rather than to postmodernism's,
definition of the artist as a singular genius. The
contributions of a host of putatively lesser talents -- writers,
supervising photographers, editors, sound personnel, etc. -- are
supposedly superceded by those of the auteur. Films by Hitchcock,
Kubrick, Truffaut, Vigo and a host of others are generally so
treated. Analogies to artists with large workshops and/or numerous assistants (e.g., Rubens, Bernini, David, Warhol, etc.) are inevitable. Some important artists of the 1980s are forcing the issue by becoming film directors themselves (e.g., David Salle, Robert Longo, and Julian Schnabel).
AUTHENTIC MARXISM: See vulgar (sense 3).
AUTHENTICITY: Generally, the condition of that which
is reliable, trustworthy, real, original, unique. In this sense,
see the more specific term aura and cf simulacrum. In
existentialism,art sometimes plays a primary
role in establishing a sense of unique identity in the face of an
absurd, basically meaningless world. The resultant freedom to
choose -- to fashion a meaning for oneself, instead of simply
reacting passively to external circumstances -- is considered
authentic. Cf Dasein, existentialism,
inauthentic.
AUTHOR: "Artist" can refer generically to
practitioners of any number of art forms. Similarly, in some
contexts "author" no longer means strictly an editor or writer, but
any creator. The doctrine called the death of the author,
however, has become one of the more powerful contributions to the
growing body of reader-response theories. For this reason,
translations of certain thinkers, notably Julia Kristeva, use
"writer." See also auteur theory, authorial
ignorance, authorial irrelevance, authorial
responsibility, authority.
AUTHORIAL IGNORANCE: The notion, at least as old as
Plato, that authors do not fully understand what their own works
are about. Cf authorial irrelevance.
AUTHORIAL IRRELEVANCE: The rejection of an author's
biography, social context, and/or stated intentions in the
interpretation of a work. Postmodernism generally takes the
idea as a given. In contrast, E. D. Hirsch argues against the
concept in Validity in Interpretation. Cf artistic
biography, authorial responsibility, intentional
fallacy.
AUTHORIAL RESPONSIBILITY: Like the auteur
theory in film studies, the notion that artists have
conscious, determinate (see determinacy) intentions and thus are solely
and fully responsible for their work's success or failure,
regardless of the audience. The notion is largely out of
fashion in postmodernism. See appropriation,
intentional fallacy. Cf reader-response.
AUTHORITY: The power to act, command or judge;
expertise; mastery; or one who wields such power. As might be expected in a period of postmodernism and multidisciplinary pursuits, the notion is
challenged as an instance of political power, rather than
true knowledge. An interesting example is Jan Gallop's
"Psychoanalytic Criticism: Some Intimate Questions," in Art in
America (November 1984).
AUTISTIC CERTAINTY: A narrow example of the type of circular logic called begging the question, in which an individual maintains an illogical certainty about some matter by saying "It is because I believe in it," or "It cannot be so because I believe it cannot be so." Unverified or unverifiable statements like "I don't think it, I know it" are even narrower instances of the same phenomenon. Obviously, this raises a number of issues concerning such matters as faith or belief in the paranormal.
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL ART: Art produced
specifically to exploit, illustrate, or record events in the life
of the artist, and/or art produced to give expression
to personal thoughts or to vent feelings peculiar to the artist
responsible. Autobiographical art is usually indifferent to public
themes, but there are recent instances (particularly among feminist
artists) in which the personal becomes political, as it were. Mary
Kelly's Post Partum Document is a recent important example.
AUTOCRITICAL: In general, self-critical. A specific
application is in the autocritical essays of Althusser, in which he
revised his earlier opinion that philosophy was about science to a
conviction that philosophy was the theoretical expression of
politics (see Althusserian).
AUTONOMY: A state of self-government or freedom from
restraint; by extension, the supposedly pure, independent realm
which art occupies after the removal of all those things
which are not "essential" characteristics of art, like
iconography and social context. The latter
implications are said to derive from Immanuel Kant, who argued that
pure art was not limited by function, knowledge, morality, or
necessity. The idea is clearly a cornerstone of absolutism,
abstraction, apophatic, essentialism,
formalism, modernism, non-objectivity, etc.
Not surprisingly, postmodernism disputes the idea virtually
everywhere. Cf autotelic, homological statements.
AUTOPTIC: A thing itself used as evidence.
AUTOTELIC: Art which has no goal outside of
itself, unlike didactic or moralizing work. Audiences
incapable of tolerating the portrayal of moral excesses or criminal
activities in a work of art have refused to acknowledge the
possibility of its autotelic status. Autotelic differs from
autonomy in that the latter ideally refers to nothing but
itself, whereas the former depicts, say, emotionally trying
circumstances, without pretending to be an account of an actual
series of events and without having an ulterior motive.
AUTRE: French for other.
AUTRUI: French for other people or others in general.
The term is occasionally used for alterity. See
other.
AVAILABILITY BIAS: Go here
AVANT-GARDE: Originally a French military expression
meaning "advance guard," and one which still carries distinct
connotations of a group of courageous adventurers who take
the lead, but now in cultural matters. It once had the very real
sense of being ahead of -- or at least outside of -- the mainstream
(i.e., the bourgeoisie, who were alienated [see alienation] by it),
but it is now replaced with the debased illusion of "advanced"
creative endeavour. And, of course, its productions -- once
genuinely outside the mainstream market -- are now supported by
public institutions with only the occasional flutter of public
discontent. See also bohemianism.
© Copyright 1996 Robert J. Belton
Back to Words of Art Index
Back to Fine Arts Page
Back to OUC Arts and Education Home Page
Back to OUC Home Page