Department of Fine Arts, Okanagan University College
WORDS OF ART: THE H_LIST
WORDS OF ART: THE H_LIST
Compiled by Robert J. Belton
If you would like to see something removed, added or corrected, please feel free to contact
bbelton@klo1.ouc.bc.ca.
HABITUS: A synonym for
social formation.
HAGIOGRAPHY: Writing about saints. Traditionally,
saints are not recognized as such until they have been officially
canonized (see
canon). By extension then, any type of
artwriting giving undue praise to an
artist or attempting principally to identify an important
contribution to an art-historical canon is implicitly a
hagiography. In official religious hagiography, certain criteria
must be met. The most well-known of these are miracles and
martyrdom. The straightforward analogies for these in
art history are
masterpieces and
bohemianism. See also
genius.
HAMARTIA: Frequently translated as "tragic flaw,"
hamartia is simply a mishap or human frailty which leads to
someone's reversal of fortune.
HAUTE BOURGEOISIE: See
bourgeois.
HEARSAY: A legal term denoting
evidence not based on a witness's personal knowledge, but
on information reported to him by someone else. As such, in many
legal systems, most hearsay is not
admissible as evidence without meeting a rigid set of
criteria. In some
art criticism, hearsay has become so entrenched in
interpretive history that facts about an artwork are sometimes
obscured (see
context [tertiary],
King Richard effect). This is a particular problem in
popularizing contexts. For instance, general books usually make
quite a to-do about Picasso's Demoiselles d'Avignon, but few
of them point out that the work was not publicly exhibited for at
least a decade after its completion. So assertions that the
painting was a direct influence on a host of young artists must be
revised to distinguish more clearly between those who had first-hand knowledge of the work and those who either did not know of it or had heard about it only through the grapevine.
HEBRAISM: The subordination of everything to
principles of obedient conduct. Matthew Arnold uses the term in Culture and Anarchy to signify "strictness of conscience,"
in contrast to Hellenism's "spontaneity of conscience." The contrast is
thus between duty and curiosity.
HEDONISM: Although it roots are genuinely
philosophical, hedonism is now taken to mean sensual gratification
as an end in itself. The term pops up in discussions of the work of
Henri Matisse, Claude Monet, and other artists who seem to have
made a point of avoiding troubling subject matter or politically
specific themes.
HEGELIANISM: Generally, anything pertaining to the
philosophy of G.W.F. Hegel. More specifically, the notion that
history has a rational end -- i.e., history is the manner in which
reason realizes itself in human experience. It follows the typical
dialectic of thesis/antithesis/synthesis. Followers of
Hegel disagreed as to what this meant, with the so-called Old
Hegelians claiming current political conditions were rational and
the Young Hegelians claiming the opposite. The latter preferred to
think of philosophy as essentially a call to revolution: one of
them, Ludwig Feuerbach, was of particular influence on Karl Marx
(see
Marxism). See also world-view. Hegel has had considerable influence on
art history, especially in his basic distinction between
form and
content. His idea was that these two could be reconciled in
a higher synthesis -- as they are in a different way in a
paralinguistic theory of art -- but his application of
thesis/antithesis/synthesis to the trio of symbolical (Oriental)
art, classical (Greek and Roman) art, and Romantic (Germano-Christian) art misses the mark by a wide margin. See also
idealism.
HEGEMONIC MASCULINITY: See
new masculinity.
HEGEMONY: Often linked to the writings of Antonio
Gramsci, but by no means exclusive to them, "hegemony" means
predominant influence, especially when it involves coercion, as in
colonialism. One reads frequently of the cultural hegemony
of the capital over the provinces, the economic hegemony of the
middle class over the working class (see
embourgeoisement), etc. The maintenance of hegemony is
dependent upon the
ideological effect, which makes the
power of the dominant class appear desirable and natural.
This in turn makes the
meanings chosen by the dominant group appear to be
universal. The hegemony of the mainstream
media is a case in point, creating
common sense beliefs that contradict statistical
observations: for example, people tend to think the majority of
crack cocaine addicts are black inner-city urbanites when in fact
they are white suburbanites, and the elderly are the most afraid of
experiencing violence even though they are statistically least likely to.
Hegemony is, however, not a stable entity but what Gramsci called
a "moving equilibrium" in which positions are ceaselessly revised.
The seat of power is thus not the exclusive possession of a
particular class once and for all but a series of shifts of power,
sometimes across alliances. (A troublesome case in point is that well-meaning advertising can give the impression that women are far more likely to suffer violence at the hands of their spouses than men. Recent research indicates this is not true.) Hegemony thus needs continually to be
reconfigured and resymbolized.
HEIDEGGERIAN: Pertaining to the ideas of Martin
Heidegger. See
Dasein,
existentialism,
ontological difference,
open.
HELIOGRAPHY: See photography.
HELLENISM: The subordination of everything to the
intellect, even sensual beauty. See Hebraism for Matthew Arnold's application of the term.
HERESY OF PARAPHRASE: The notion that anything -- an
artwork,
text,
utterance, etc. -- means what it means only in its original
form, so that any abbreviation, paraphrase, translation, or other
form of representation introduces distortions, simplifications, and
misunderstandings. When Cleanth Brooks used the phrase in The Well Wrought Urn, he had no idea that the notion would
be turned on its head as part of
postmodern
orthodoxy in the form of
mediation. Brooks intended to give priority to the literary
work itself, but it is now understood that any act -- even
reading -- is a type of mediation, so there is no real "work"
without some sort of paraphrase. This realization gives rise to the
death of the author, on the one hand, and to
reader-response
criticism on the other.
HERMENEUTIC CIRCLE: In hermeneutics, the notion that one cannot understand the
meaning of a portion of a work until one understands the whole,
even though one cannot understand the whole until one understands
the parts. It is not simply a paradox, since it indicates that any
act of
interpretation occurs through time, with adjustments and
modifications being made to one's understanding of both the parts
and the whole in a circular manner, at least until some sort of
resolution is achieved (see
closure, sense 2). (There are some similarities to the
sorts of adjustments made in Pepper's conception of the
consummatory field.) The word "barked" cannot properly be
said to mean dog sounds if the sentence in which it appears is "the
child barked his shin when climbing the tree." Similarly, this
sense of the word "shin" does not operate in a sentence describing
the twenty-second letter of the Hebrew alphabet. Accordingly, a
reader will not understand the parts until s/he has read the whole,
and vice versa. Such examples are far too simple to characterize
what happens in full-blown hermeneutics, however. See
prejudice for a different type of example. Cf hermeneutic spiral for a related model which tries to
sidestep closure.
HERMENEUTIC SPIRAL: In theory, the traditional hermeneutic circle presumes to reach a definitive
conclusion as to the
meaning of an
utterance. Because it invokes
closure, it remains open to attack from
postmodern writers, who prefer
indeterminacy to
determinacy. In historical practice, no statement made
about a work of
art has ever been truly conclusive (cf
reception history), but rather than discard the hermeneutic
model, we can find ways to spring it open systematically. One such
is simply to acknowledge that something else can always be said,
however
invalid or
irrelevant it might be. The adjustments and modifications
one makes during the process of coming to understanding never cease
and a true closure is never evoked. But we might want to invent a
system which also enables us to create relevant and valid
responses, despite
open-endedness. One such is a hermeneutic spiral equation, which has two advantages:
first, it provides a hypothetical space for all future
contributions in structurally schematic form and it provides a
mechanism for testing their usefulness; and two, its structural holism assures the practitioner will not be subject to
interpretive agnosia.
HERMENEUTIC SPIRAL EQUATION: The use of a
formal language to produce a scheme of
interpetation which tends towards holism without invoking
closure and without excluding future interpretive
strategies or new evidence. In its
open-endedness, it avoids
interpetive agnosia. To create one such equation, let "F1"
and "F2" represent all primary and secondary aspects of
form respectively. Let "C1," "C2," and "C3" represent all
primary, secondary and tertiary aspects of
content. Let "X1," "X2," and "X3" represent all primary,
secondary and tertiary aspects of
context. Let the sign of multiplication represent the
action of
inflection or other forms of mutual influence or
interference. Let the sign of division represent the action of
tempering, corroborating, substantiating, or other testing. Let
"IC" represent
intellectual curiosity (thus, by implication, all future
contributions) and let "RSVP" represent "relevant, sufficient,
valid propositions" (see
informal logic). We can then produce the following:
(((F1F2C1)=C2)X1X2)/X3 = C3
_______________________
IC/RSVP
In this instance, primary and secondary form are first described as
inflecting the
literal content to produce a
figurative
meaning. As a simplistic illustration, the light (F1) and
composition (F2) of Edvard Munch's Puberty push the literal
scene of a young girl sitting on the edge of a bed to a figurative
scene of a threatened young girl on the threshold of something.
That in turn is inflected by circumstantial information -- for
example, the deaths of Munch's mother and sister (X1) and the
attitudes of his intellectual circle towards
gender (X2). These observations are then tested against
reflective awareness of our own critical expectations and those of
any
artwriters whose work may have affected our interpretations
(X3). In the case of Munch, for example, the shadow at the rear
right has been described as "phallic." We should at least ask
ourselves what expectations this reveals. (In other words, does
such a statement tell us more about the work or the tertiary
context in which the work is interpreted?) All of this produces a
final content (C3). If we were to leave it there, we would probably
have evoked closure. Instead, we acknowledge that something new can
and probably will always be said, signalling new interpretations as
a byproduct of intellectual curiosity. These, in turn, can be
tested by the principles of informal logic to distinguish
interpretations of substance from instances of
interpretatio excedens or
interpretatio predestinata.
HERMENEUTICS: Any of a series of systematic theories
of interpretation. Because it originally designated the
interpretation of religious texts -- a practice which
assumed that every aspect of a Biblical
text had to be meaningful because it was divinely inspired
-- hermeneutics carries a similar connotation that meaning is to be
derived from every conceivable feature of a
text that can be construed as a contribution to some sort
of organic whole (see holism). In spite of this, there are all sorts of
hermeneutic approaches. For Gadamer's special contribution to
hermeneutics, see
prejudice. Paul Ricoeur's The Conflict of
Interpretations distinguished between
linguistics, which he saw as a closed system of
intrasignificant
signs, and the
extralinguistic properties of hermeneutics. More recently,
the idea that a hermeneutic interpretation must apply in some way
to a total meaning has been revised by Peter Bürger in his Theory of the Avant-Garde (1984): formerly, the hermeneutic
interpretation had to resolve all traces of contradiction, but
Bürger calls for a revised approach replacing the necessary
agreement of parts with a stratification of sorts, in which various
layers might contradict one another and yet still contribute to the
meaning of the whole in their very contradictoriness. See hermeneutic circle, hermeneutic spiral, hermeneutic spiral equation. Cf
extralinguistic.
HERSTORY: A
neologism invented because of the false peception of
affinity (see
faux amis) between "history" and "his story." Despite the
etymological
fallacy, "herstory" is an economical way to describe
women's history and the
feminist project of dismantling a male-only
canon.
HETERODOXY: Ideas not in accordance with or critical
of established doctrine or received opinion. See also
doxa,
orthodoxy.
HETEROGENEITY: The state of being fundamentally
different in kind. See heterology.
HETEROGLOSSIA: "Different tongues" or "the speech of
others." Mikhail Bakhtin coined the word to describe multiple
voices in a
text (see
dialogism).
HETEROLOGICAL STATEMENTS: A statement which is not
true of itself. For example, "Italian," which not an Italian word.
See homological statements.
HETEROLOGY: James George Frazer's Golden
Bough characterized the primitive mind as incapable of
distinguishing between the sacred and the impure or filthy.
Building on this, Georges Bataille (see
Bataillean) drew from German sociology and theology the
sacred notion of the "wholly other" (see
ganz Andere). Seeking to fuse these notions, Bataille hit
upon the idea that that which is most "other" in the human body and
therefore most sacred is that which we have actually ingested but
cannot assimilate -- that is, the undigested material which passes
through the intestines. Excrement, then, is an example of the
completely other -- a heterogeneous "
foreign
body [Bataille's stress]...that can be seen as sacred,
divine, or marvelous." Moreover, excrement is a type of
expenditure, a basic conception in Emil Durkheim's theory
of social exchange. Bataille thus theorized that the surplus value
of the vile/sacred had some effect on the
social formation, as in such things as potlatches,
sacrifice and ritual mutilations. He proposed that the study of
such phenomena should be called "heterology." The idea has become
influential as a strategy for
disruption. The terminology of heterology -- e.g.,
bassesse -- have started to appear in discussions of
disturbing
artworks, like those of the Surrealists (Rosalind Krauss)
and Jana Sterbak.
HEURISTIC: Stimulating interest in order to make new
discoveries and formulations, and/or a teaching method to encourage
students to discover for themselves. The term is fairly common in
current
artwriting. For a specific application, see W. McAllister
Johnson, Art History: Its Uses and Abuses.
HIERARCHICAL: The defining characteristic of any
system of persons of things given different ranks or statuses, as
in a governmental hierarchy.
HIERATIC: Originally, "sacred" or "priestly." The
term is routinely used to designate a formal,
conventional, and
conceptual style like that in the
art of ancient Egypt or the Byzantine Empire. Potential
antonyms are
demotic and
perceptual.
HIERONYMY: Originally, "sacred naming." The term now
means the granting of special status to some thing by virtue of the
way it is named.
HIGH ART (CULTURE): Until recently, there has a
distinction between high art (also called "high culture,"
fine art, or beaux-arts) and low art (also called "mass culture").
Where the former supposedly consisted of the meticulous expression
in fine materials of refined or noble sentiment, the latter was the
shoddy manufacturing in inferior materials of superficial
kitsch. Moreover, the assumption always was that
appreciation of the former depended on such things as intelligence,
social standing, educated taste, and a willingness to be
challenged. In contrast, the latter simply catered to popular
taste, unreflective acceptance of
realism, and a certain "couch potato" mentality. Although
many earlier
artists took inspiration from popular and folk art -- e.g.,
Gustave Courbet's
appropriation of woodcuts -- the most systematic approaches
towards blurring the differences between high and low art were
taken by Cubism, Dada and Surrealism. Pop Art further weakened the
distinction, and artists as various as Jean-Michel Basquiat, Jeff
Koons and the Guerilla Girls, influenced strongly by the different
branches of
postmodern thought, seem have dealt it the final blow. We now find that formerly "high" artists are approaching mainstream celebrity status: for example, performance artist Laurie
Anderson's song O Superman reached the top ten of the pop
charts in England, video and camera artist William Wegman has
appeared on The Tonight Show to promote a book of photographs, and both have done segments on Saturday Night Live. In spite of this, one still wonders if
the distinction still exists, albeit in a slightly different form.
Few would seriously argue that the droves who follow televised
wrestling matches and afternoon soap operas have any genuine
interest in contemporary art. It is even less likely that the
millions who read supermarket tabloids or romance novels would ever
choose to read advanced
art criticism.
HIGHLIGHT: The point at which an object reflects the greatest light, or the representation of same in drawing, painting, photography, watercolour, etc. Works which follow the logic of perception tend to orient highlights in such a way that the direction of the light source can be deduced from them, but there is no shortage of examples which ignore this principle and use highlights in a rather more intuitive manner. See also reserve highlight.
HISTORICAL CRITICISM: Any criticism which attempts to describe, explain or recreate
the meaning a work had in its original context, rather than what it might mean to later
generations. See historical methodologies.
HISTORICAL MATERIALISM: The foundation of Marx's
(see
Marxism) materialist (see
materialism) theory of history: that the
consciousness of men does not determine the
social formation, but that the social formation --
particularly the economic structure of society -- determines
consciousness independent of the will of men.
HISTORICAL METHODOLOGIES: Those types of
criticism which
foreground
context, especially information of the environmental or
secondary sort. See especially
correlational social history,
Geistesgeschichte,
iconology,
Marxism,
new art history,
new historicism,
patronage, and
reception theory. The terms
macrohistory,
microhistory, and
quantohistory are also beginning to appear. Cf
perspectivism,
visuality.
HISTORICISM: Any of a variety of approaches which
give priority to history, specifically with the implications that
all of life and reality are historically conditioned and that each
historical phenomenon must be interpreted according to its own
terms. Historicism appears in many guises in
aesthetics and
criticism, including the following:
Hegelian
idealism (that
culture in general must be understood in terms of a
transcendental progression of historical change);
positivism (that a particular
artwork must be interpreted in the light of the unique,
verifiable circumstances in which it was created);
new historicism (the revitalized historicism of the
postmodern period, emphasizing economic and ideological
circumstances), and
perspectivism and/or
relativism (that no one point of view is
central).
HISTORICITY: The historical actuality of a thing, as
opposed to putative
timelessness.
HISTORIOGRAPHIC METAFICTION: See
metafiction.
HISTORIOGRAPHY: The theory and practice of
historical writing, especially history about history. In
artwriting this usually takes the form of extended
historical commentaries on the writings of key art historians, as
in Michael Podro's Critical Historians of Art, Michael
Baxandall's Patterns of Intention, Mark Roskill's The
Interpretation of Pictures, and so on. Most of these feature
case-studies of an historiographic nature. For
postmodern applications, see Linda Hutcheon, The Poetics
of Postmodernism.
HISTORY: For "history" as a category of
content in
art, see
genre. For various aspects of "history" as a branch of
knowledge or an account that records, analyses and explains past
events, see
art history,
herstory,
historical criticism,
historical methodologies,
historicism,
historiographic metafiction,
historiography,
metafiction,
metanarrative,
new historicism,
postmodernism.
HISTORY PAINTING: See
genre.
HOLISM: The philosophical notion that the structure
and behaviour of a system or an organism in its entirety cannot be
explained solely as the sum of the operations of its parts.
HOLOTROPE: Gerald Visner? Suggestions anyone?
HOMAGE: Reverence or tribute, as a serf might give
to his lord, or an apostle to his master.
artists throughout history have paid homage in various ways
to those who
influence them, as in Odilon Redon's À Edgar
Poe.
HOMEOSTASIS: The tendency to maintain constant
functioning of organic processes or to attempt to restore constancy
when one of the processes is disturbed. For a specific application,
see
jouissance.
HOMO DUPLEX: Man conceived as having two distinct
natures, the body and the mind (see
Cartesian interactionism,
mind-body problem). George Mauner understood édouard
Manet's Bar at the Folies-Bergère, with its impossible
mirror reflection of a male viewer, to be a meditation on this
theme.
HOMOLOGICAL STATEMENTS: Statements which are true of
themselves, as "English" is an English word (compare heterological statements). One of the basic tenets of
formalism is that what an
artwork symbolizes is external to the work itself and might
just as well be discarded in any serious
critique of it. In Ways
of World-Making, Nelson Goodman uses the notion of
homological and heterological statements to undo this assumption.
He maintains that what a symbol symbolizes is not necessarily
extraneous to itself, since, for example, "word" is a word which
applies to itself and to other words, "short" applies to itself
among other things, and "having seven syllables" has seven
syllables, as do many other phrases. Formalists, he concludes,
implicitly and erroneously maintain that the most important
characteristic of
art is it heterologicality.
HOMOLOGY: A correspondence, relation, or similarity
between structures. In sociological writings, the term is likely to
refer to a metaphorical match between the values of a group and its
lifestyle. Paul Willis's Profane Culture (1978), for
example, shows how the hippie
subculture's anarchic reputation was a misconception, for
the group's values and lifestyle were highly organized along
homologous lines. That is, hippies' espousal of certain values like
bohemianism agreed with (found a correspondence with,
matched, paralleled) their taste in music and recreational drugs.
Dick Hebdige's Subculture (1979) does much the same for the
punk phenomenon. Similar homologies can be found for most art
movements, especially those in which a marked taste for
expressionism is also manifest in an artist's rather
freewheeling lifestyle (e.g., Jackson Pollock).
HOMOPHOBIC: Irrational fear and/or persecution of
homosexuals.
HORIZON: The limit or range of perception,
knowledge, etc. See
fusion of horizons, horizon of expectations.
HORIZON OF EXPECTATIONS: The range of values --
aesthetic, economic, moral, religious, social, symbolic, etc. -- a
given
audience anticipates it will encounter in an
artwork. The work functions either by meeting those
expectations or by challenging them. The idea is central to
reception-theory.
HORROR VACUI: A tendency, sometimes characterized as
medieval or primitive, to fill all the available pictorial space
with decorative or other motifs, as if "afraid of a vacuum."
HUBRIS: Arrogance, insolence, or pride that leads to
misfortune.
HUMANISM: Any attitude that gives priority to human
endeavours, rather than to those of the gods, the spirits, the
animals, or any other non-human thing. The term is frequently
qualified, as in "Renaissance humanism," which is characterized by
a love of the achievements of the Greco-Roman world, an optimism
that humans are inherently endowed with the skills necessary to
reshape the world according to their own needs, and a belief in
inherent human dignity. While the Renaissance humanists did not see
their enlightened self-interest as a contradiction of their
Christianity, a few recent
demagogues identify "secular humanism" as a tacitly
atheistic preoccupation with human affairs.
HUSSERLIAN: Pertaining to the ideas of Edmund
Husserl. See
existentialism,
phenomenology.
HYMEN: The mucous membrane partially enclosing the
vagina in a virgin. Jacques Derrida (see
Derridean) used this image in "La Double séance," in
his La
Dissémination as a
metaphor to invent a hypothetical space for the operation
of
différance in a
text. He chose a female image to counter the notion of the
phallus as the
privileged signifier.
HYPERBOLE: Exaggeration, whether used simply for
effect or because of
linguistic inflation. Some Baroque ceiling paintings are
extravagantly hyperbolic, as in Pozzo's Allegory of the
Missionary Work of the Jesuits on the vault of S. Ignazio,
Rome. Compare
bathos,
litotes,
meiosis.
HYPERETHNICITY: A serious preoccupation with
ethnicity. The word should be used with care, since some
opponents of
political correctness use it in a thinly-veiled
contemptuous manner.
HYPHENATION: A common
postmodern technique to draw attention to hidden political
and other
agendas in supposedly apolitical words. Examples include
"dis-possessed" (Mary Daly, Gyn/Ecology), "photo-graphed" (Jacques Lacan, "What is a
Picture?" Four Fundamental Concepts of Psycho-Analysis),
etc. Sometimes it is not really necessary, as in "re-vision" or
"re-presentation."
HYPOCRISY: Pretending to be what one is not or to
believe what one does not. The idea should be discussed with
reference to traditional
myths about artistic
bohemianism and
genius, as well as to new ones like
anti-intellectualism and
political correctness.
HYPOTAXIS: The grammatical arrangement of words in
dependent or subordinate relationships of causality, logic, space
and time, usually taken as a characteristic of mature, formal or
disciplined speech. It is opposed to "parataxis," the grammatical
arrangement of words in coordinate relationships where subordinate
ones are called for. For example, the statement "You should try and get some sleep"
is incorrect because "You should try to get some sleep" properly indicates that the
second verb is dependent upon the first. The statement "Although Seurat's intention was
to render the canvas more luminous, he failed because the optical
mixture was too evenly distributed" is properly hypotactic because
the failure is in spite of the stated intention. The statement
"Seurat tried to render the canvas more luminous and he failed..."
is paratactic because the causal relationship is obscured by "and,"
which uses coordination. There is an understandable temptation to
interpret
art paratactically because images appear to be presented in
terms of coordination. I.e., Arnolfini and His Bride
could be described in a paratactic sequence: "a man and a woman are
standing in a room with a bed, and a dog stands at their feet, and
there are shoes set to one side, and there is a chandelier with one
candle, and there is a convex mirror, etc." As soon as we start to
speak of
figurative
meaning, however, we must use causally subordinating
relationships: "The wedding vows are understood to be holy because
there are shoes set to one side, which is a
conventional act of respect when standing on holy ground."
Theorizing a set of criteria for visual hypotaxis and parataxis
might provide some useful weapons for the fight against
perceptualism. On another level entirely, hypotaxis has
occasionally popped up as a
metaphor in discussions of
political correctness, with white male language construed
as a hypotactic grammar of
power (i.e., an instrument designed to subordinate those
who have not mastered its niceties of expression). This is the ground for the recent debate about Ebonics in California.
© Copyright 1996 Robert J. Belton
Back to Words of Art Index
Back to Fine Arts Page
Back to OUC Arts and Education Home Page
Back to OUC Home Page