Department of Fine Arts,
Okanagan University College
WORDS OF ART: THE E_LIST
WORDS OF ART: THE E_LIST
Compiled by Robert J.
Belton
If you would like to see something removed, added or corrected, please feel free to
contact
bbelton@okanagan.bc.ca.
ECHO: See
visual rhyme.
ECLECTICISM: The
composition o something by
selecting details and stylistic features from a wide variety of
sources. Nineteenth-century architecture, for example, was eclectic
in its rather derivative adherence to the manners of bygone eras,
as in Classical Revival, Gothic Revival, and the like.
Postmodern architecture is more ironically eclectic, as in
Charles Moore's Piazza d'Italia in New Orleans.
ECONOMY: The organization,
structure or mode
of operation of a group; more specifically, the system of exchange
within an identifiable group, whether the exchange be of money
(economy in the widest sense) or of some more ephemeral thing, like
meaning (see
signifying economy). When some reference is intended to a
smaller, marginal or veiled system of exchange within a dominant
economy, it is often designated a sub-economy. See also
general economy.
(L')ÉCRITURE:
"Writing," but with
connotations taken over from the
death of the author to the effect that what is written is
an open-ended (see
open-endedness)
text, with multiple possibiities of
meaning beyond those intended by the
author. Some writers use the word "scription" to indicate
much the same idea.
(L')ÉCRITURE
FÉMININE: A type of
writing which rejects intellectual
paradigms of
logic and
logocentrism -- such as intellectual neutrality,
disinterestedness -- and so on, in favour of allusive,
divergent, and expressive associations -- like the body,
desire, and a sense of connectedness. Although
Hélène Cixous's "Laugh of the Medusa," Signs
(Summer 1976) is considered the key source, Chantal Chawaf put it
this way: "Isn't the final goal of writing to articulate the
body?... Language through writing has moved away from its original
sources: the body and the earth." See
language,
thinking as yet not thinkable. Cf
fleshless academicism.
EDITING: Go here
EFFECT: Something that invariably
follows a
cause (see
causality); the consequence of
inflection; and/or the overall emotional or dramatic impact
or tone of an
artwork. See also
meaning effect.
EFFECT OF THE REAL: In
art and literature, the creation of a fictive world that
appears to be seen through a transparent window, rather than as the
result of a particular individual's creative behaviour or the
processes of an
audience's enunciation. The basic challenge offered to this
position in
artwriting is described under the heading
perceptualism. The phrase itself derives from Roland
Barthes' essay by that name in the journal Communications (1968).
EGO: Generally, one's conception of
the self.
More specifically, in
psychoanalytical thought, one of three main divisions of
the
psyche. The ego makes distinctions between the self and the
not-self (i.e., the environment) and in the process mediates
between the primitive, infantile mind (
id) and the moral mind (
superego).
EGOCENTRIC: Considering the
ego as
central, as in simple selfishness or in developed
philosophies or ethics which give priority to
self-interest.
EIDETIC IMAGERY: Mental
images with
extraordinary vividness, as if actually perceptible.
EIDOS: Term for the
Platonic conception of the essential (see essentialism Forms or Ideas underlying all
experience.
EKPHRASIS: Synonym for
description.
ELABORATION: A
tactic in
rhetoric by which a theme is progressively argued by
gradual repetition with emendations, alterations, and the like.
Visual equivalents are easy enough to imagine. See also
secondary elaboration.
ELEGY: A solemn meditation on
death and the
like, particularly when presented in a gravely formal manner.
Antonio Canova's Tomb of the Archduchess Maria Christina
in Vienna's Augustinerkirche is notably elegaic.
ELEMENTAL: Pertaining to the
four basic
elements (air, earth, fire, and water) and, by analogy, anything
fundamental, rudimentary, or expressive of the basic forces of
nature.
ELISION: Omission of a
component, usually of
a word or a part thereof (as in contractions like can't). In
medieval imagery, illuminated texts frequently had elisions
signalled by a short line above the contraction.
ELITE CULTURE: See
high culture.
ELLIPSIS: The omission of one or
more words
whose sense can be easily supplied. For example, in "Bernini's
sculpture reached the zenith of Baroque exuberance, his painting
the nadir," the identity of the missing word in the second clause
is signalled by "reached" in the first. Discussion of the mechanics
of ellipsis might clarify how a specifically visual
trope works.
EMBLEM: A picture associated
with a motto,
usually moralizing in tone. An example is a popular print showing
King Midas, unable to eat because his touch turns everything to
gold, accompanied by the words "both rich and poor."
EMBOURGEOISEMENT: The suppression of
difference in class by attributing to all members of a society the
values of the middle class (the
bourgeoisie). See
hegemony,
ideological effect.
EMOTION: Psychological and/or
physical
reactions to stimuli subjectively experienced as feelings. See
betraying versus expressing emotion,
unique aesthetic emotion.
EMOTIVE: See
mind-set.
EMOTIVISM: Also known as
emotive theory,
emotivism holds that value judgements are neither good nor bad but
simply expressions of emotion, like laughing or fear. Where simple
subjectivism offers a statement like "Walter De Maria's
Earth Room is good art" when what is really meant is "I
like it/esteem it/approve of it," emotivism sees "Walter De Maria's
Earth Room is good art" as an honest (or dishonest) and
appropriate (or inappropriate, etc.) statement of the speaker's
feelings, but it cannot be either true or false. Ayer started the
idea in Language, Truth and Logic (see also
boo-hooray theory) and it was further developed by C. L.
Stevenson in Ethics and Language, where it was linked
with the
rhetorical desire to persuade with or without
valid
argument. Given that so much popular talk about art
includes often wooly value judgements, some consideration should be
given to these issues.
EMPATHY: Now loosely the
same as "sympathy" -
- i.e., identification with another's feelings -- but careful users
usually stipulate empathy as an imaginative projection of one's own
feelings into an event or object. One should perhaps be suspicious
of the latter, inasmuch as it can easily produce
meanings that are
read into an
artwork.
EMPHASIS: Any of several
means of drawing
special attention to some feature(s) of an
artwork for
aesthetic impact.
EMPIRICAL: Derived from
observation, whether
through anecdotes or through controlled experiment. See empiricism.
EMPIRICISM: Popularly
understood as the
philosophy that all understanding must derive from or be indebted
to actual experience. Empiricists assert that the mind is not
invested with a
priori
categories or
concepts (see
Kantian,
platonic) from birth but is instead a blank, receptive
surface, as it were. The prime movers were Berkeley (see
immaterialism), Hume (see
constant conjunction) and Locke (see
tabula rasa). Cf
logical positivism,
positivism.
EMPOWER: To enable; to give
recognition to;
to facilitate self-expression, particularly of
marginal groups within a dominant
culture.
EMULATION: Thus can mean
either "imitation"
or the "striving to equal or exceed." As a contemporary
technological term, it also means a device allowing a program
written for one computer to be run on another computer or a musical
instrument which records sounds digitally for playback,
manipulation, etc. See
sampling.
ENALLAGE: A
figure in which there is an exchange of grammatical forms,
as in instances when nouns are used as verbs -- e.g., "toe the
party line" -- or when past and present tenses are switched. The
application of the latter idea to visual imagery should be obvious
to those who have always found peculiar the representation of, say,
the Madonna and Child as if they belonged to the race and era of
the painter, rather than to history.
ENCLOSED RHYME: A
rhyme in the form "a.b.b.a." Rudolf Wittkower has pointed
out similar structures in Italian architecture.
ENANTIOMORPHS: Mirror
images, in effect, as
a left hand is to a right. As simple as the idea seems to be, it
has been used in such difficult
Kantian philosophical questions as "is space relative or
absolute?" Students of visual
art might care to examine a once-popular conception --
similar to some aspects of
information theory -- that whatever a
viewer experiences before an
artwork is the exactly reconstituted emotional expression
of the
artist.
ENCODING: In
information theory, the conversion of a message into a form
that can be transmitted along a
channel. In
postmodernist
artwriting, the idea is discussed more frequently from the
point of view of
code and
decoding.
ENCOMIUM: In Greek
literature, enthusiastic
praise, delivered in soberly formal terms, of anyone or anything
aside from the gods. Any decidedly glorifying treatment of a
subject's visual representation could be described as encomiastic.
Sometimes it backfires, as in the rather absurd sculptural cases of
Canova's Napoleon and Greenough's George
Washington.
ÉNONCÉ: See enunciation.
ÉNONCIATION: See enunciation.
ENTELECHY: The actuality or
truth of a thing,
rather than its potentiality. In
Aristotelian thought, entelechy was used to distinguish the
soul from the body (see
mind-body problem). In
vitalist thought, entelechy is an unobservable,
hypothetical agent that directs organic processes. Bear the idea in
mind while considering
holism,
possibilities, and
teleology.
ENTHYMEME: A
syllogism with a hidden premise. For example, in "Artists
should be seen and not heard. Be quiet, Pablo," the minor premise
that Pablo is an artist is suppressed but understood.
ENTROPY: Originally from the
study of
thermodynamics, entropy has been used in a variety of ways in other
disciplines. In certain
sociological circles, for example, the original definition
of entropy as the degree to which energy in a system is available
to do work becomes a description of how social progress slows and
finally stops because social change uses up energy which cannot
then be retrieved for reuse in further change. Related is the
psychoanalytical usage, in which
psychic energy cannot be transferred from the object in
which it is originally invested. A more straightforward application
of entropy as the tendency of ordered systems to degrade into a
state of inanimate uniformity can be seen in the writings of
artist Robert Smithson. Related to this is the usage in
information theory, where entropy is a measure of the
apparent disorder of a system, so that the more there is known
about it, the less entropy it seems to have. I.e., entropy is
understood as the number of
possibilities, which decreases as knowledge grows.
ENUNCIATION: In theories as
diverse as Lacan
and
speech-act theory, an
énoncé is the thing uttered (e.g., a statement),
whereas an
énonciation is the act of uttering it. In some
contexts, enunciation is construed as the
interpretation or
performance of a
text conceived of as a
discursive activity, rather than as the isolated act of a
single individual. Enunciation is neither the writer producing an
unequivocal
meaning nor a reader understanding an unequivocal
significance. It is the network of conceptual processes
involved in the production and reception of a text, including the
effects of contextual factors. The term is most clearly defined by
Tzvetan Todorov in Les Genres du discours: "A discourse is made not of
sentences, but of enunciated sentences, or more simply, of énoncés. Now the interpretation of this énoncé is determined on the one hand by the
sentences enunciated, and on the other, by the énonciation itself. This énonciation includes a speaker who enunciates, a
listener whom one addresses, a time and a place, a discourse that
precedes and follows; in brief, a context of enunciation." See also
reader-response.
EPAGOGE: Greek for
argument from
induction.
éPATER LE BOURGEOIS: To shock the
bourgeois
audience, to flout
conventional moral or
aesthetic norms, to startle through unconventional
behaviour. This is a basic component of
anti-art, but it has lost much of its force. See
avant-garde,
bohemianism,
dramatic conventions.
EPHEMERA: Published matter
intended to last
only for a very short time (from the Greek ephemeros, "lasting a
day"), like broadsheets, leaflets, pamphlets, and all manner of
cheaply produced visual materials.
Museologists and
art conservators rack their brains over how to preserve
visual
art produced without high technical standards, serving to
meet ephemeral needs, as in some Dada, say, or in preparatory
drawings.
EPIC: A long
narrative, usually in the form of a poem or film, in which
the
stories of a number of
characters are traced against a background of sweeping
historical importance, as in Leon Uris's novels. The term is only
rarely applied to the visual arts.
EPIDEICTIC: Now rarely used
Aristotelian term for the type of
rhetoric used chiefly to please an
audience, as in encomium. See also
deliberative,
forensic.
EPIGRAM: A concise
aphorism with moralizing overtones, which ensures that they
will have a rich history in visual illustration. A notable example
is Landseer's Man Proposes But God Disposes.
EPIGRAPH: The inscription of a
motto or similar on a coin, relief, titlepage and the like.
The study of such things collectively is called epigraphy.
EPIPHANY: A sudden
manifestation of divine
insight, as in Bellini's Ecstacy of St. Francis. When
the term is used
figuratively to indicate a sudden intuitive insight,
especially in popular
criticism, readers should cautiously note whether the
writer is seeking to persuade through emotional
rhetoric.
EPIPHENOMENALISM:
The doctrine that
consciousness is a product of neural activity in the
nervous system (i.e., an epiphenomenon of material existence). See
mind-body problem.
EPIPHENOMENON: An
accessory or accompaniment
to some
phenomenon, but considered incidental to it and not a
causal factor in its development. It might be worth
considering whether certain types of
art criticism really consider specific
artworks basically ignorable epiphenomena of the systems
under examination. For example, one of the commonly repeated
complaints regarding Serge Guilbaut's How New York Stole the
Idea of Modern Art was that it said virtually nothing about
art per se (cf
interpretive agnosia). In Grounds of Dispute,
John Tagg defends himself against Donald Kuspit's similar
objections by stating that criticism has lost its object -- i.e.,
that as criticism is socially
marginalized, it loses its institutional security and its
privileged methods and soon comes to realize that its object never
had an independent existence but was constituted by criticism
itself (see
constitutive). While this is certainly an important issue,
it places sole emphasis on
context and tends to treat the artwork as an epiphenomenon
instead of as
autoptic evidence. See also
insufficiency.
EPISODE: An incident which,
when taken as a
step in a sequential series of incidents -- regardless of the order
of the sequence -- constitutes a
narrative. The individual scenes in the
iconographic programs of medieval churches could be so
described. The word is also used as a loose synonym for
"installment," as in an episode of a sitcom.
EPISODIC: A literary term applied
to
structures of stringed episodes which do not necessarily follow a
logical pattern or even seem to develop the plot. The Fragonard Progress of Love
paintings in the Frick Gallery could
possibly be described as episodic.
EPISTEME: A
Foucauldian term, deriving from epistemology and "-eme" (the smallest
significantly
distinctive unit of a structure, like a morpheme, phoneme,
seme or
sememe), to mean something along the lines of "distinctive
units of the social institutions (e.g., relations of
power) which give shape to what we think of as knowledge."
Foucault himself wrote more allusively in The Order of Things: "what I am
attempting to bring to
light is the epistemological field, the episteme in which knowledge
... manifests a history ... of its conditions of possibility....
Such an enterprise is not so much a history ... as an
'archaeology'." John Tagg's Grounds of Dispute reads
much as a series of essays exploring one such episteme, the
discursive field (see
discursive practices) created by the intersection of
art history and
cultural politics. See
space.
EPISTEMOLOGICAL HEDONISM: In the first issue of Swift (1997), a newsletter of skepticism and debunking of claims of the paranormal, professional magician Jamy Ian Swiss characterized credulity and uncritical acceptance of unrepeatable and unprovable phenomena like astrology, spoon-bending, UFOs, etc., as "'epistemological hedonism,' i.e., if it feels good, believe it." Needless to say, this is anathema to skeptics.
EPISTEMOLOGY:
Philosophy concerned with
theories of knowledge -- i.e., what knowledge is, how it is
obtained, how reliable it is, and so on. The basic opposition is
between
rationalism and empiricism, but there are all sorts of intermediary
positions. Not the least of them is Kant's
synthetic a priori, which allowed for an account of
art, among other things. Cf
skepticism.
EPISTROPHE: See
palilogy.
EPITAPH: Inscriptions and the like
marking a
burial place.
EPITHET: A characterizing word or
phrase
appearing with or in place of a name or thing, as in Homer's "rosy-
fingered dawn." They need not be disparaging, although they often
are in
satire. See
transferred epithet.
EPITOME: A summary or typical
example of
something. Chartres Cathedral might be called the epitome of Gothic
church design, which would mean not that it represents the best of
what was available, but that it is typical of what was available.
ÉPOCHÉ: Suggestions anyone?
EPONYM: A name so closely
linked to a
characteristic, a place, or some other general thing that it comes
to stand for that. Examples are Machiavelli (deceit, treachery),
Romulus (Rome), Bowdler (bowdlerize), and so on. The principle
operates when
artists' names are used to characterize general tendencies
in the arts.
ERASURE: Suggestions anyone?
ERISTIC: Fond of wrangling, as in
people who
argue for the sake of
argument. The word is sometimes used in place of
polemics.
EROTIC: Pertaining to sexual love
or
desire. Although one commonly finds "erotic" ditsinguished
fundamentally from
pornography, the dividing line between the two is by no
means as clear as etymology would suggest (i.e., erotic from eros
[love], pornography from porne [sexual servitude]). As a result,
there is considerable debate regarding the definition and role of
the erotic in such things as
appetitive drive, the
critique of representation, the erotics of engagement, people who are
libidinally driven, and so on.
EROTIC-FOR-MEN: See
erotic-for-women.
EROTIC-FOR-WOMEN:
Phrase coined by Joanna
Frueh to distinguish the conventionally erotic, which she sees as really erotic-for-men and
therefore an expression of
scopophilia. She argues that erotic-for-women has more to
do with the sense of touch because this is the primary way women
explore their sensuality, whereas men see the principle
sign of their sex. See her "Erotic as Social Security," Art
Journal 53.1 (Spring 1994).
EROTICS OF
ENGAGEMENT: Jane Gallop's term (in
Art in America, [November 1984]) to designate a
sexuality that resides not in the object -- e.g., within a nude
human figure -- but in an
intersubjective dynamic -- i.e., the encounter with that
object. She uses the notion to ask if
psychoanalytic criticism looks for sexual subject matter,
however deeply disguised, or if it finds all subject matter sexual.
Mainstream
Freudians describe the experience of the male child as a
move from dependency on the mother to detachment from her in the
recognition that she has been "castrated" (see
castration). Gallop describes psychoanalytical criticism as
an analogous rebellion against the object's power and assumption of
superiority over it due to its "lack" -- i.e., its need for
interpretation.
ESEMPLASTIC: Samuel
Taylor Coleridge invented
this word to indicate the faculty of the mind that can fuse
unrelated things into a poetically organic unity. It is a useful
idea, but
postmodernism is generally suspicious of the aesthetic (see
aesthetics)
holism it implies.
ESSENTIAL COPY: Norman
Bryson maintains that
artwriters who look only for realism in a painting overlook
historical and social dimensions in favour of the esential copy --
i.e., the empty
verisimilitude of the painting's ability to convince the
viewer that it "is" the thing, instead of "meaning" the
thing.
ESSENTIALISM: Any of a
variety of notions
concerning the primacy of essences -- i.e., permanent, unchanging,
"real" identities that lie "behind" appearances -- rather than the
temporary, changing, specific manifestations themselves. The most
common essentialisms are the
Platonic doctrine of universal types and the originally
Aristotelian doctrine that things in a particular category
all have at least one common characteristic without which they
could not be members of that category. Essentialism is frequently
attacked in
postmodern writings as a kind of wooly wishful thinking,
especially when it is thought to have been produced by unreflective
racists or sexists. A regrettably common example might be something
along the lines of an
art criticism which insists that women's work is
essentially feminine -- meaning that it is lacking in certain
supposed formal strengths and is preoccupied with "minor" subject
matter, like pastel-coloured flower paintings.
ETHICS: Popularly, the (moral)
standards
which a particular group sets to distinguish acceptable behaviour
from unacceptable behaviour. Philosophical ethics has a long and
complicated history. See
meta-ethical,
normative ethics.
ETHNIC: Deriving originally from
"ethnos"
(nation or people), ethnic once meant any social group bound by
race, customs, language, values, etc. Its current use to indicate
any visible minority in a Eurocentric (see Eurocentrism)
culture is often a thinly veiled reflection of an older use
meaning "heathen" (non-Christian, with a
spin meaning uncivilized). The word should be used with
care. Cf ethnocentrism.
ETHNIC
CHEERLEADING: Dinesh D'Souza (see
illiberal education) used this phrase to characterize the
worst aspects of required courses for the purposes of enforced
multiculturalism. In fairness to D'Souza, whose extreme
conservativism is easy to
caricature, it should be pointed out that he did not mean
every course in non-Wsetern culture, but only those which evoke a
kind of Romanticism instead of clear analysis of what makes a
particular culture truly worthy of study.
ETHNIC DOMAIN: Susanne
Langer's once
influential Feeling and Form (see also
presentational symbol), in asking what certain types of
art were for, proposed that the space created in an image
or in architecture was not real but "virtual." By extension,
architecture especially created an image of the world which was
actually an expression of the self and the relations of the self to
others in an ethnic domain of sorts, a system of functional
relations in which
signs play a less important role than the embodiment of
feeling -- " the symbol of humanity to be found in the strength and
interplay of forms." Ethnic, in this scheme, is not to be understood as
"heathen."
ETHNOCENTRISM: The
tendency to see one's own
ethnic group as the
norm and all others as
marginal.
ETHNICITY: Ethnic identity, or the
discourse which concerns it. See also
hyperethnicity.
ETHNOGRAPHY: Generally,
social or cultural
anthropology. Among studies of
art, the most overtly ethnographic are those which deal
with general patterns in non-Western
cultures, rather than with
artist and object-centered
interpretations, so that individuality and uniqueness are
less highly prized than epitome. See also ethnology.
ETHNOLOGY: Sometimes
synonymous with ethnography, ethnology is also sometimes
distinguished from
it by being less focussed on the data-gathering of field work and
participant observation and more concerned with the
historiography of
cultures.
ETHOLOGY: Originally a branch
of zoology,
ethology counters
behaviourism by arguing that certain types of human
behaviour are innate genetic developments that had survival value
in evolutionary terms. Some of these ideas are creeping into
aesthetics in the form of a supposedly universal "behaviour
of art," a kind of investment of value and meaning in what is
otherwise valueless and meaningless by means of
play and
ritual. This supposedly ensures the survival of the
organism by
making special. Ellen Dissanayake's What is Art
For? is the only lengthy study to attempt this approach.
ETHOS: The distinguishing
characteristic,
usually of a social group, particularly when it is a case of moral
values or beliefs. By extension, in Aristotle's Poetics, the character projected by a speaker, writer,
artist, etc. See also evidence,
implied author.
E-TOPIA: Title of a book by William J. Mitchell (not to be confused with W.J.T. Mitchell) describing the kinds of changes he anticipates will take place in urban spaces as a consequence of the digital revolution. Mitchell foresees the home as a space in which people both live and work, redefines "public" space as any of a variety of types of electronic "meeting" areas, anticipates decentralization of the production and distribution of goods, and do on.
ETYMOLOGY: The study of the
origins of words.
See
folk etymology.
EUPHEMISM: The opposite of
dysphemism; an expression of an disagreeable state of
affairs in mild or oblique terms calculated to avoid unpleasantness
or offense. E.g., "to pass on" is frequently used instead of "to
die." Inasmuch as
day-dreaming and
dream-work are supposedly palatable expressions of
something which cannot otherwise be tolerated, both are
euphemistic. Clearly, then, much Surrealist art could also be so
described.
EUROCENTRISM: The
tendency to see European
culture and history as the
norm and all others as
marginal. It is a frequent complaint of
postmodernism that what pretends to be
disinterested
objectivity in, for example, ethnography is actually the veiled self-interest of a
white, anglo-saxon
hegemony. It is clear, then, that first-year
art history
textbooks like Janson's History of Art and
Gardner's Art Through the Ages are generally
Eurocentric, despite recent valiant attempts to include more non-
Western material. See also
Foucauldian,
postmodern catechism,
power.
EVIDENCE: A legal term
indicating the facts
about a case that can be introduced as
premises to determine a reasonable
conclusion (see
argument,
circumstantial evidence). A great deal of published
art
criticism has glibly come to conclusions that are not based
on what the legal world would call
admissible evidence. See
hearsay. There are various types of evidence: autoptic (the
thing itself, like a murder weapon), character (pertaining to ethos, sometimes not admissible), exculpatory (tending to
prove innocence), exemplars (forensic and other materials, like
fingerprints), expert (reliance on
authority figures in a given field), inculpatory (tending
to prove guilt), material (objects, substances, measurable
data), oral (testimony of witnesses), rebuttal (arguing against the
relevance or reliability of another
interpretation), and so on. Most of these conceptions have
loose analogies in various types of
criticism, though they are rarely addressed as such, and
similar standards of acceptability, however flawed they might be,
have not been articulated.
EX-CENTRIC: Those who have
been pushed from
a
central position or
marginalized by a dominant ethnic group, institutional
practice, or
ideology. The
artwork of Black American women like Betye Saar and Faith
Ringgold and that of North American Native artists like Jane Ash
Poitras and James A. Luna is thus said to be ex-centric because it
is produced by voices that have been traditionally suppressed. It
is accordingly not to be confused with "eccentric," which means
"deviated from accepted conduct."
EXCESS: In psychological and
neurological
circles, an excess is the opposite of a
deficit. While a
cognitive deficit is an impairment of mental function
preventing the patient from forming a complete representation of
experience in consciousness and thus deriving
meaning from it, a cognitive excess is a superabundance of
meaning that originates with the patient, not in the outside world.
Paranoia is a good example: a car that just happens to be parked
down the street might be interpreted by the paranoiac as a sign of
his having been followed. Meanings
read into
artworks are equally a matter of excess. This observation
casts an interesting light on the connotations and use of excess in
writings on
base materialism,
indeterminacy,
metaphor and
polysemy.
EXCULPATORY: See evidence.
EXEGESIS:
Interpretation, understood chiefly as explanation,
originally of the Bible, but now of any
text.
EXEMPLARS: See evidence.
EXEMPLIFICATION: See
language.
EXEMPLUM VIRTUTIS:
Term used in Robert
Rosenblum's Transformations in Late Eighteenth Century
Art to describe
artworks whose themes are moral lessons or examples of
virtue which should be emulated. The theme is particularly common
in neoclassicism.
EXERGUE: A small space for an
inscription,
originally on coins and medallions, but now also on any other
object, visual or verbal. Jacques Derrida's Of
Grammatology (see
deconstruction,
grammatology,
quotation) has an introductory exergue of quoted material.
EXPERT: One who is supposed to
have special
authority, experience, knowledge, skills, and the like. See
also evidence,
subject presumed to know.
EXISTENTIAL
CRITICISM:
Criticism which downplays or undermines traditional themes
and conventional methods, especially those purporting to use
scientific
disinterestedness, in order to investigate more personal,
existential issues, as outlined under existentialism. Probably the most famous
proponent is Jean-
Paul Sartre.
EXISTENTIALISM:
Existentialism is a
heterogeneous cluster of philosophical ideas which have the common
element that existence precedes essence. This mean that there is no
overarching meaning in the universe beyond that which we choose to
create through our actions. Endowed with
consciousness, humans are confronted with the knowledge
that the world is basically
absurd -- i.e., it simply exists, with neither
justification nor organised structure which could yield to rational
analysis -- and this knowledge usually produces feelings of
alienation, discomfort, fear, loneliness, and the like.
Necessarily, the exploration of these feelings will be subjective,
peculiar to each individual who endeavours to live an authentic
existence (see
authenticity) through acts of self-definition. The names
most frequently associated with existentialist thought are Soren
Kierkegaard, Friedrich Nietzsche, Martin Heidegger, Karl Jaspers,
Jean-Paul Sartre, and Gabriel Marcel, but there are distinct
existential strands in the thought of currently influential
figures, like Jacques Derrida.
EXPANDED FIELD: Rosalind
Krauss (in
October 8 [1979]) argued that persistent attempts to
describe miminalism and earthworks according to the logic of
modernist monuments were misleading. Instead, she noted that
scultpure could be defined in terms of what is was not: "not-
landscape" and "not-architecture." Borrowing freely from
mathematics (Klein) and
structuralism (Piaget), she then expanded the field of
discourse by noting that "not-landscape" was really a way
of saying "architecture" and "not-architecture" was a way of saying
"landscape." (Such a relation is called a
deixis.) She argued that if sculpture could be situated
relative to "not-architecture" and "not-landscape," there was
reason to assume that there would another term situated in a
similar manner relative to both "architecture" and "landscape."
This she called "site-construction." Finally, she noted that if
"site-construction" could be both "architecture" and "landscape" --
and a sculpture could be neither -- then "architecture" had a
relation of contradiction, sometimes called a
schema, to "not-architecture," "landscape" to "not-
landscape," and so on. She used the term "marked sites" to
designate the position between "landscape" and "not-landscape" and
the term "axiomatic structures" between "architecture" and "not-
architecture." More important than simply inventing a useful new
terminology, Krauss's article was an early contribution to the
rejection of
historicism, which she saw as an endless attempt to
mitigate difference and diminish newness, in favour of a
postmodern celebration of difference.
EXPENDITURE: A
gift, loss, or payment through use of a resource. The idea
crops up frequently in
sociology, particularly where it concerns exchange rituals
like the famous potlatch of the Northwest Coast. Using the word
dépense, Georges Bataille added to this a
Nietzschean,
dionysian eruption into normal life of uncontrollable
forces giving expression to man's base nature (see
base materialism). Ejaculation and excretion, for example,
were just different kinds of expenditure and, as such, could be
understood as part of the same sorts of sociological structure.
(See the Bataille anthology Visions of Excess.)
Something of the idea of expenditure also plays a role in
deconstruction inasmuch as potentially new meanings of
texts can always be produced: the illusion of a stable,
determinate meaning is thus expended.
EXPRESSING: See
betraying versus expressing emotion.
EXPRESSION: See
language.
EXPRESSION THEORY:
Probably the most popular
and long-standing notion of
art is that it is the expression of the
artist's emotion. Although such a simple expression theory
stretches back as far as Plato, the first person to make the idea
a criterion of systematic
aesthetic inquiry was Eugène Véron, who wrote
in L'Esthétique (1878) that "art is the
manifestation of emotion...by expressive arrangements of line,
form, or colour...[and/or] by a series of gestures, sounds, or
words governed by a particular rhythmical cadence." While Leo
Tolstoy, Benedeto Croce and many others have made significant
contributions, the most thorough development of expression theory
is generally agreed to be that of R. G. Collingwood. Collingwood
distinguished very carefully between art and
craft on the grounds that true art involved the genuine
expression of an emotion and its recreation in the spectator. He
also argued that true expression was not a simple matter of having
an emotion and showing it (see
betraying versus expressing emotion), because expression
meant a coming to self-awareness. One of the implications of this
line of reasoning is that art lies in the mind rather than in the
object. Despite substantial differences in other regards,
principally regarding how much Romanticism is acceptable (see
bohemianism), a wide variety of aesthetic attitudes has
held this to be a truism for many years.
EXPRESSIONISM: Any of
various styles and/or
movements in
art giving priority to the expression of inner experience,
particularly where the manifestation is conspicuously deformed or
paralinguistically altered (see
paralinguistic).
EXPRESSIVE: Vague, overused
adjective
indicating vivid or especially apt descriptions, depictions,
performances, and the like, of personal moods or sentiments.
EXPRESSIVE THEORY:
More or less a synonym for
expression theory, used in the literary criticism
of M. H.
Abrams.
EXPRESSIVITY: Dictionaries
define this as the
quality of being expressive (in addition to an obscure genetic
reference). Paul Ricoeur, however, has used it in "The Problem of
Double Meaning" in The Conflict of Interpretations to describe not the
expression of a particular emotion, but the fact that language says
anything at all. Following A. J. Greimas and others, he says that
there is no mystery in language -- i.e., the structural rules for determining
meaning are accessible to all -- but there is a mystery of language: "namely, that
language speaks, says something,
says something about being. If there is an enigma of symbolism, it
resides wholly on the level of manifestation, where the
equivocalness of being is spoken in the equivocalness of
discourse." He concludes by asserting that philosophy's task is to
reopen discourse to the expressivity of being. See also extralinguistic.
EXTENSIONAL
DEFINITIONS: Definitions which
identify members of the class of things named by that term ( for
example, visual arts means
painting,
photography,
printmaking,
sculpture, etc.). Such definitions link our experience to
the world. Without them, all words would be circular.
EXTRALINGUISTIC: Paul
Ricoeur uses this word
to refer to the expressivity of being: "while
linguistics moves inside the enclosure of a self-sufficient
universe and encounters only intrasignificant relations...,
hermeneutics is ruled by the open state of the universe of
signs." The term is thus not to be confused with
paralinguistic.
EXTRINSIC: External;
extraneous; not forming
part of or belonging to a thing. In some
artwriting,
contextual information is characterized as extrinsic. For
instance, information concerning the social circumstances under
which a given
artwork was produced might be dismissed or downplayed by a
critic or
art historian who exploited only
artistic biography and who intended to demonstrate his
subject's
genius. Obviously, methods which emphasize social
circumstances (e.g.,
Marxism,
feminism) would argue that such "external" conditions are
not really external at all but
constitutive of the work of
art. Cf epiphenomenon,
intrinsic.
EXTROVERSION: See
personality types.
EX-VOTO: Under construction.
© Copyright 1996 Robert J.
Belton
Back to Words of
Art Index
Back to Fine Arts
Page
Back to OUC Arts and Education
Home Page
Back to OUC Home Page